BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Donnie Darko (Spoilers)

 
  

Page: 1 ... 23456(7)8910

 
 
Rage
12:57 / 29.03.03
This movie keeps getting better and better. My first viewing and I was like "what an overrated piece of asscrap." Honest. I can now consider it one of my favorite movies of all time.
 
 
Sunny
17:55 / 29.03.03
I got the dvd for 6.99 used, hurrah.
 
 
PatrickMM
20:52 / 30.03.03
I just rewatched it yesterday, and I really loved the movie, much more than the first time seeing it. I think reading The Invisibles, then seeing the movie gave it a lot more depth, and made it much easier to understand, particularly the time travel paradox stuff. Stuff like the Timeworm, and Donnie hitting the barrier of reality exactly like Six did was really odd to see.

The oddest thing about watching the movie though was the fact that the day before I watched it, I had downloaded Under the Milky Way by The Church, after seeing it mentioned on the Lith music board. Then, to hear it in the movie was completely odd, and felt right in tune with the movie itself.
 
 
PatrickMM
21:59 / 30.03.03
I just read through the whole thread, and I've got a couple of things that haven't been covered yet.

This may be the influence of The Invisibles a bit, but I saw the entire movie as an exercise to bring the turbine into the real world. All the characters were subconsciously, or consciously, moving events forward to the point where the plane would explode, and the turbine would be flung out of time.

Frank and Gretchen are the only characters who are "outside the game," in that they, particularly Frank, are actively manipulating Donnie to ensure that he does the things that are needed to bring the plane down. When Frank makes Donnie flood the school, he allows Donnie to make his major connection with Gretchen, by saving her from getting tormented from the other people from the school. When Frank shows Donnie the nature of time, and the portals and such, he shows Donnie the ultimate nature of the sacrifice he has to make will be, and prepares him for it. When Frank makes Donnie burn down Cunningham's house, he exposes Cunningham's crimes, which ensures that Donnie's mother will be on the plane. By this point, Donnie knows what he has to do, and is prepared to make the sacrifice.

So, Frank is comprable to John a Dreams in Invis, in that he exists outside the game. He manipulates Donnie to ensure that their world will end, and Donnie can do nothing to manipulate him. When Donnie is hitting at the wall, he is at the barrier between his world, and Frank, who can do whatever he wants.

The tougher thing for me to figure out is Gretchen as someone outside the game, but I think I've got it down. Gretchen's point in the movie in the movie is to ensure that Donnie kills Frank, and takes Frank outside the game, so he can make Donnie bring down the plane. To do this, she plays the role of girlfriend, and generally goes along with exactly what Donnie wants.

And, I don't think that the website is needed to understand the movie. I figured out the idea of the tangent universe, without calling it that, without using the website at all. The website is just a supplementary bonus, that you can use if you like.

Also, again like Invis, the intellectual stuff is what you talk about, but it was scenes like the party sequence where Donnie realizes his destiny, set to excellent music, the real emotion that made the movie work.
 
 
Foust is SO authentic
21:27 / 15.04.03
Question. What's the song that's playing over the party scene, just before Donnie head's off to the old woman's house? I've looked at the soundtrack, and there's no obvious title tracks.
 
 
Jack Fear
22:06 / 15.04.03
Well, the film soundtrack CD only features the instrumental score, not the eighties pop songs: I'd have to check the DVD to see what's playing just before Donnie leaves, but the two songs I remember from the party scene are "Under The Milky Way" by the Church (acoustic guitars, spacy "aaaah" background vocals, bagpipe solo), and "Love Will Tear Us Apart" by Joy Division (quick, pattering drums, high synthesizer melody, deep, slightly off-key vocals with slight electronic distortion on them).
 
 
dlotemp
22:50 / 15.04.03
It's the Church song, as mentioned by Jack Fear.
 
 
Foust is SO authentic
01:15 / 16.04.03
Cool, thanks.
 
 
Jack Fear
12:31 / 16.04.03
Foust: If you have any trouble finding "Under the Milky Way," PM me and I'll bung an MP3 up on my webspace.
 
 
Jack Fear
16:33 / 16.04.03
(By the way, I blather on a bit about The Church hither.)
 
 
jcoriha
21:07 / 16.04.03
I just wanted to post a message saying that I love this movie, but the commentary on the DVD really let down the movie for me. I had already watched the movie a couple of times and was really impressed. I thought Requiem for a Dream, and this in the same year. WOW

But then I heard the director explaining his meaning for the story on the DVD. Granted, everything he said was right, but somehow I feel like the movie he was trying to make was WAY below the standards of the movie he made. He really explains it like it's any other sci-fi Final Destination type movie, and the vibe I got was very differant. More Lynchesque then anything.
 
 
that
09:52 / 08.05.03
I don't know if someone has already said this, but I watched it on video last night for the first time and I do agree that it's Lynch-esque, but basically its 'Back to the Future' with a bunny rabbit. It was ok, but not worth the hype. Disappointed, really...
 
 
nihraguk
13:00 / 08.05.03
Well, I personally think comparing Darko to Lynch-anything would be a little more than insulting to the body of work that Lynch has crafted over the years. Watched the movie, found Frank pretty spiffy and freaky at the same time, and thought the entire tone and mood of the movie was pretty interesting, almost surreal at times. Perhaps it was a well-executed idea, perhaps. But I thought intellectually the thematic appeal of the movie was kinda shallow: to have it all boil down to the tried-and-tested theme of .time.travel. was, to me, a total let down. I thought so much more could've been done with the edgy feel of the movie, and that offering up time travel as the ultimate... premise of the movie was a retreat into somewhere warm, safe and harmless, as opposed to something more in line with the freaky, macabre nature of Frank's mask/head. Alice in Wonderland should have shaped this, what with the rabbit. Not, as Cholister mentioned, "Back to the Future".
 
 
kfggcbs
15:30 / 26.05.03
Sorry if this was covered earlier, but does anyone else have trouble reading the Philosophy of Time Travel pages in the DVD extras?

The words are sort of digitally blurred and I want to know if I should get a another copy or that's just the way it is.

Thanks
 
 
Hieronymus
16:06 / 26.05.03
They were a bit blurry when I read them, kfg, but maybe this can help.
 
 
kfggcbs
16:33 / 26.05.03
Very helpful. Thanks.
Now that I know its not just me, I'll keep my copy.
 
 
Quireboy
19:03 / 26.05.03
Great film - had a look at the website - but on one level one of the best portrayals of schizophrenia I've seen - far better than that godawful crap A Beautiful Mind.
 
 
waxy dan
11:00 / 28.05.03
but on one level one of the best portrayals of schizophrenia. That's exactly what I thought coming out of it. I had thought it was a well-crafted and horrific portrayal of a tragic mental condition.

Haven't seen the DVD, but I'm really surprised/disappointed to hear that it's just a time-travel movie. Or was intended as such.
 
 
that
11:21 / 28.05.03
Actually, I think I was being a bit thick when I watched it. What I said was probably somewhat unfair...and based on a less-than-full appreciation of the thing... but there we go.
 
 
sleazenation
11:21 / 28.05.03
The funny thing is the director isn't at all keen on the mental illness angle of Donnie Darko - indeed one of the deleted scenes reveals that donnie's drugs are placebos...
 
 
waxy dan
11:40 / 28.05.03
Fantastic thread by the way. Thanks to everyone who posted anything!

indeed one of the deleted scenes reveals that donnie's drugs are placebos... Was that implied somewhere in the final cut? I remember presuming they were, but I haven't seen the DVD, so...??
 
 
Mourne Kransky
14:29 / 08.06.03
No idea what Donnie's "drugs" are, froze the dvd and there's no indication on the label. There is perhaps an indication in his stiffened facial muscles and zombie-esque gait at points of Chlorpromazine side effects which would be congruent with 80's US psychiatry. Have to disagree that it succeeds as a presentation of classical paranoid schizophrenia but I don't think that detracts at all from the film.

Further to sleazenation’s and dlotemp’s remarks about the name "Sparrow", this may be entirely tangential (although perhaps not, given the many Christian references in the film) but I’ve encountered this famous sparrow metaphor in several other places.

In The Venerable Bede’s The Ecclesiastical History of the English (c. 700 C.E.), he recounts the use of the sparrow as a metaphor for a human life, bound by Eternity, as part of the successful move to christianise King Edwin of Northumbria and his kingdom:

"Your majesty, when we compare the present life of man on earth with that time of which we have no knowledge, it seems to me like a swift flight of a single sparrow through the banqueting-hall where you are sitting at dinner on a winter's day with your thanes and counsellors. In the midst there is a comforting fire to warm the hall; outside, the storms of winter rain and snow are raging. The sparrow flies swiftly in through one door of the hall, and out through another. While he is inside, he is safe from the winter storms; but after a few moments of comfort, he vanishes from sight into the wintry world from which he came. Even so, man appears on earth for a little while; but of what went before this life or what follows, we know nothing."

There’s another (possibly relevant) biblical sparrow in Matthew:
10:29: Are not two sparrows sold for a farthing? and one of them shall not fall on the ground without your Father.
10:30 But the very hairs of your head are all numbered.
10:31 Fear ye not therefore, ye are of more value than many sparrows.


Then there’s Psalm 102:
1 Hear my prayer, O LORD, and let my cry come unto thee.
2 Hide not thy face from me in the day when I am in trouble; incline thine ear unto me: in the day when I call answer me speedily….

7 I watch, and am as a sparrow alone upon the house top.
8 Mine enemies reproach me all the day; and they that are mad against me are sworn against me.
9 For I have eaten ashes like bread, and mingled my drink with weeping,
cont.

Don’t know how relevant they may be but they all came to mind when “Grandma Death” was doddering recklessly around in the middle of the road.

Enjoyable film. Irritating bloody website. Looking forward to seeing what Kelly will come up with next.
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
09:08 / 26.06.03
Taking the "mental illness" angle, okay, I'm no professional, so accuracy is not really an issue I can judge. But I thought watching DD and then Cronenberg's "Spider" gave two very different, but both ultimately moving, portrayals.

I just love this film more every time I watch it. It just gets more thoughtful, more emotional, and, goddammit, FUNNIER with every viewing.
 
 
Cherry Bomb
09:27 / 26.06.03
Dunno what dvd you have or if you still have it, but the meds are placebos.
 
 
Our Lady of The Two Towers
19:56 / 01.07.03
I watched it with the director's commentary, interesting in places, though it makes me feel like he almost makes a wonderful movie despite himself, and there's lots of cool things which we've read into it which he doesn't comment upon.

But it clarifies some things for me which I didn't get. I thought the tangent universe was created by Frank getting Donnie out of the house at the beginning, I didn't realise it happened just before that, and Frank getting Donnie out is just the first step in healing the rift.

And at the end, I always wondered how Donnie got the car into the rift and past the plane engine to arrive home first, I didn't realise that by getting the engine into the rift that does everything and then the tangent universe ends and everyone jumps back to when the rift first opened, just with some level of awareness of what happened to them in the fortnight, which is why Jim Cunningham is crying, because he's been forced to acknowledge what he is, and that teacher has her faith in him broken.

Can someone confirm for me that what the director is saying at the end is that Donnie chooses to die, that he could still have got out of his room before the engine hit if he wanted to and it wouldn't have done any harm to the space/time continuum?

And why, with the last scene with the two teachers in bed, is Drew Barrymore's character turned away from Noah Wyle's?
 
 
invisible_al
22:10 / 01.07.03
I watched the DVD only recently and I remember the director not exactly being sure of what Donnie was thinking in that last scene himself.
I think he said he's either laughing because he thinks it was all a dream or because he knows when he's going to die and experiences a burst of enlightenment. I think the director says he's succeeded at that point but I like the idea that Donnie has to complete the circle.
I also like the idea that Frank and Donnie are partners, they are trying to save everyone but Frank can't do it alone. That horn honking after he drops the sister off is him trying to warn Donnie in that moment after everyone drops back into the Primary universe that it's all ok and Donnie can get out of there.
It's a beautiful film, that last scene gets me every time *sniff*.
 
 
PatrickMM
22:39 / 01.07.03
Can someone confirm for me that what the director is saying at the end is that Donnie chooses to die, that he could still have got out of his room before the engine hit if he wanted to and it wouldn't have done any harm to the space/time continuum?

I don't know if this is consistent with what the director said, but I think that when Donnie leaves his room and creates/takes the first step into the tangent universe, he also begins the chain of events that leads to Gretchen's death and Frank's. The entire movie is showing Donnie what it would be like if he lived, and in the end, Donnie chooses to stay in his room, despite Frank's honking and the knowledge that he will die, because he doesn't want Gretchen or Frank to die. I haven't seen it, but I think in that way the film parallels the plot of Last Temptation of Christ, which is seen at the movie theater.

And why, with the last scene with the two teachers in bed, is Drew Barrymore's character turned away from Noah Wyle's?

I think this shows that Drew Barrymore is asleep and happy because in the tangent universe, she didn't "sell out," and she did her best for the kids, despite what the administration said. However, Noah Wyle is up because he put his job security ahead of helping Donnie. I don't think the fact that they are facing apart has that much significance, other than to make the shot work, since if they were facing together, you wouldn't be able to see both of them.

And, I think it's a testament to the movie's greatness that just by reading about that sequence I began to play 'Mad World' in my head.
 
 
weepy_minotaur
18:52 / 02.07.03
Okay first off I've never posted to a message board so be patient with the newbie.
That being said I have one of the weirdest theories concerning this spectacular film. Donnie was an experiment gone wrong. In the first scene of the film, where he'd crashed his bike, I like to think he had just escaped from the place of his creation. I haven't quite figured out who made him.(Government/Aliens?) So I'm open for speculations on that, or any of this really. I probably just drink too much Kool-Aid or something.
 
 
Morlock - groupie for hire
12:18 / 03.07.03
Well, I'm confused now. Somehow I never got round to watching the commentary on my copy, and what has been posted here just doesn't fit into the framework I'd built up in my head. I'll have a look at it myself, soon.

So much of the film deals with fear, death, and the fear of dying. I'd assumed that was the point of it. The scene where Donnie's back in his bedroom, waiting for the jet-engine to fall opens with a close-up of a drawing of a skull reflected in a human eye, looking death in the eye and laughing! Throw in the big hypnotherapy scene and the idea that his sleepwalking has always been in order to avoid dying in his bed and, well, you see where I get confused.
 
 
sleazenation
13:36 / 03.07.03
In many ways Donnie Darko is the anit-its a wonderful life...
 
 
dlotemp
00:34 / 04.07.03
I'd just like to point out a few things to the recent posters:

1) Donnie escaping from a gov't/alien factory is an imaginative idea but there's no context for it so I don't know how useful an interpretation it is. I'm not knocking it; I'm just saying it might not take you too far. Stil, pretty nifty. FYI - Donnie was sleep biking, if you can believe that.

2) The drawing by Donnie's bed doesn't actually show a face laughing at death. It is a drawing by M.C. Escher called EYE 1947(?). I'm not positive about the year. You can check out the Donnie Darko annotated thread via the Barbelith search bar for more information on the Escher stuff.

Thanks for sharing your thoughts, guys.
 
 
PatrickMM
19:33 / 30.07.03
But it clarifies some things for me which I didn't get. I thought the tangent universe was created by Frank getting Donnie out of the house at the beginning, I didn't realise it happened just before that, and Frank getting Donnie out is just the first step in healing the rift.

I watched the commentary, but I must have missed this. When does he imply the tangent universe is created, the beginning of the movie? I think it makes much more sense for it to begin when the plane crashes into his room, because that's the point that they return to at the end of the film, not the previous day when he would have been biking.
 
 
Warewullf
13:33 / 31.07.03
I just watched this and l-o-v-e-d it! Really, really good film.
Funny, thoughtful and surprisingly heart-warming in places.

More thoughts once I read throught this thread.
 
 
Our Lady of The Two Towers
13:43 / 31.07.03
Not being able to check the DVD right now, but the director says it some time when we see all the family asleep, before/as his sister gets home from her date before the jet engine crashes into the house.
 
 
FinderWolf
01:22 / 05.08.03
Hey, so what the heck were the 2 school bullies (one of whom was played by one of the lead actors from FREAKS & GEEKS and UNDECLARED) doing in Grandma Death's basement (on the other side of the "cellar door")?!?!?! (not that it matters too much, just wonder if anyone else wondered about this...)
 
  

Page: 1 ... 23456(7)8910

 
  
Add Your Reply