BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Bleach (Manga)

 
  

Page: 1 ... 23456(7)89

 
 
Seth
17:21 / 05.09.08
Is anyone else thinking that Hisagi's fight against Findor is ramping up to the revelation that Hisagi has attained bankai? Findor claims to be at the level of Lieutenant but still has a fragment of mask left, which possibly implies that he can go further (he seems to be cruising at his current level)... if that's the case, then Hisagi will probably have to go further in order to beat him. That seems to be the logic of this battle, and even though we get the visual reveal of his shikai in 324 I'm thinking that this fight may go some way past that.
 
 
Mysterious Transfer Student
19:30 / 05.09.08
If so, this fight will need to last several chapters more, as Hisagi is one of the least explored lieutenants, certainly in proportion to his popularity. Since sword release always accompanies character development in this series we first need to learn a little more about Hisagi - in particular how he handled his captain's betrayal. While he doesn't seem to have the burden of guilt and/or complicity that Kira and Hinamori carry, and which plunged them into depression and insanity respectively, I'm interested to see whether Findor will attempt to push his buttons over his own and his society as a whole's failure to notice or prevent Aizen's conspiracy, the way Abirama tried to do with Kira. In the past I've decried Hisagi for being dull, but there are some things stacking up that make me curious to know what's going on with him.

With Turn Back the Pendulum we saw, as El Directo said, his imprinting moment, the encounter with Ninth Division Captain Kensei Muguruma - an absolutely exemplary captain, a total straight arrow and 100% committed to his underlings. You couldn't ask for a better role model for a wannabe Shinigami... which makes it all the more of a shame that Hisagi, another of those famous prodigies à la Gin and Kaien, wound up serving under Tousen: one of Bleach's most violent, vicious and self-deluding characters, whose true qualities passed unnoticed as everyone believed in his public image as a disciplined pacifist and seeker of justice. From the omake material (this bit) we know that the Ninth in general and Shuuhei in particular have a literary, creative, contemplative bent* - and yet here he is with a shikai that looks pretty nasty. Since he certainly didn't have bankai during the Rescue arc, or else his fight with Yumichika would probably have gone in his favour, we'll know if he uses it now that he's been training his arse off ever since then, presumably either to settle things with Tousen personally or, perhaps more in the spirit of his mentors and Ichigo, simply in order to protect everyone. I'd be happier with the latter, since it would be nice to see Hisagi prove out as an actual hero of justice (a Nonoriri, if you will) simply to show up Tousen. Meanwhile, his sword (Kazeshini, 'Wind Death' - interestingly, Kensei's zanpakutou was named Tachikaze, 'Earth-severing Wind') in shikai form seems to be a double-bladed kusarigama - there's currently some fierce debate on various manga fora over whether this does or doesn't violate Yamamoto's pronouncement that Ukitake's and Kyouraku's are the only two dual-bladed zanpakutou in all of Soul Society.

*Only slightly undermined by his ardently gauche and doomed attempts at scoring with Matsumoto by becoming a sensitive guitar-strumming troubadour. I always loved that idea.
 
 
Seth
19:03 / 06.09.08
You couldn't ask for a better role model for a wannabe Shinigami... which makes it all the more of a shame that Hisagi, another of those famous prodigies à la Gin and Kaien, wound up serving under Tousen: one of Bleach's most violent, vicious and self-deluding characters, whose true qualities passed unnoticed as everyone believed in his public image as a disciplined pacifist and seeker of justice.

Yeah, it is interesting that there hasn't been more material dwelling on how Tousen's betrayal effected Hisagi. What have we actually seen of that? One shared moment with Komamura at the grave of Tousen's unnamed friend, one fleeting conversation with Ukitate while Rukia and Orihime were training in the background. On neither occasion does he say what he feels. The one emotional reaction we've seen him display is when Kensei saves him as a child, when the former 9th Squad Captain tells him not to cry and that he has a strong name.

In almost all respects Hisagi seems to have only ever treated Kensei as his model, which makes his relationship with Tousen rather interesting. We don't know how Kaname explained away the fact that he was the only non-implicated, non-Hollowfied survivor of the incident that created the Vaizard. We also don't know how much Hisagi knows about what happened to Kensei... having been established as present at the scene did he stick around to watch what ensued? Did he work like stink to get into the Gotei 13 in order to rumble the man who betrayed his saviour, waiting until he had evidence? That rather seems to resonate with your hope that it is actually Hisagi who is the 9th Squad's true champion of justice. Or has he been gaining strength and biding his time in order to enact revenge?

That speculation might cast Hisagi's facial tattoo in a very different light. Rather than being an just imprint moment, a symbol of hero worship, is it also a public statement against Tousen that he is making for the benefit of anyone old enough to understand, one that Kaname is incapable of seeing but to everyone else is written all over his face? Komamura's feelings of betrayal were evident to everyone, but what if Hisagi's weren't because they never existed in the first place?
 
 
Seth
10:14 / 12.09.08
Ahhhh!

You bastard!

You bastard!

I have to wait a week!
 
 
Seth
10:15 / 12.09.08
(325: All sensible analysis temporarily suspended)
 
 
Feverfew
21:01 / 12.09.08
And suddenly my Hisagi action figure - bought nearly a year ago on another continent, sight unseen (random box) and which confused me at the time - seems that much cooler.

It's Friday night. I'm a bit shallow at the moment.
 
 
Triplets
21:34 / 12.09.08
UH-OH SPAGHETTI-OHS
 
 
Seth
07:09 / 19.09.08
325 and 326 have both knocked me sideways to the point at which I have to admit that I was wrong when I said a while back that I was disappointed with having to wait through the fights of the four pillar guardians.

First of all I'm actually really angry with Ikkaku and the price that everyone is having to pay for his pigheadedness. I can still admit to loving the idiot for his amazing riposte to Po ("Don't make me laugh. I haven't got anything, and if I did I wouldn't waste it on you"), but for fuck's sake... the stakes are far higher than just one man's life and career path. I knew that if Yumichika was allowed to get away with keeping his power secret a second time then Ikkaku would be forced to face sterner odds, but the consequences of one man sticking to his guns has endangered everyone, especially considering the fact that he could probably have won this fight.

The most powerful of all the pillar guardians - the one who really shouldn't have lost - deliberately stayed true to type and threw the fight... and I get the impression that Iba guessed what had really happened. There is definite blame in his voice when he says to his former teammate "... if you try not to damage it," and the shock on Ikkaku's face implies that Tetsuzaemon's admonishment hit home. Previously Madarame poked fun at Iba for abandoning the slug-fest ways of the 11th in order to become the kind of Shinigami who might get promoted to a position of responsibility. But now the tables seem to have been turned. Whereas before the Third Seat of the 11th previously congratulated himself that the Lieutenant of the 7th seemed to stick to 11th Squad principles we can now clearly see who is the bigger man. Bleach is nothing if not an examination of how and why people choose to attain power, and Ikkaku has become a cautionary tale, someone who chose to seek power but not responsibility. His personal principles, which previously seemed almost admirable in a stubborn sort of way, have endangered everyone.

326 shows us the actual mechanics of what is at stake. Four pillars held the transfer in place, but now that one has gone we can really see what a losing battle this is. The reserve measures that are intended to prevent the return of the real Karakura Town are so shonky as to almost defy belief. They're just a bunch of tent pegs, aren't they? The Soul Society forces are on the defensive and their position is precarious in the extreme. They are protecting a town that naturally occupies the position from which they have moved it, and they are now fighting a battle on two fronts: against Aizen's forces and against the encroaching return of reality as it should be.

The stakes have also been raised immeasurably by the fact that it's both Komamura and Iba who have leaped in to plug the breach. In one fell swoop the Captain of the 7th has demonstrated that he believes Po - a mere Fraccion - to be beyond the abilities of a Lieutenant. We've gone from being lulled into a false sense of security with a group of mostly known characters achieving easy wins to an instant knife edge tension. That actually seems to be an understatement. Komamura's actions reek of desperation and are horribly revealing of the apparent fragility of Urahara's plan. There is no doubt that Komamura will win against Po, and there's only a relatively small doubt that Iba himself could win against the same opponent. But we have been shown that it takes two men to plug the gap left by one. That's already potentially disastrous.

Elsewhere, Hisagi's shikai was beautifully executed but still tells us next to nothing about him. That fact that its movements cannot be predicted seems fitting for a character about whom so little is known. Even though he demonstrated that he had learned lessons from Tousen the precise nature of his relationship with his former Captain is still ambiguous.

I loved Yumichika leaping in to save Ikkaku and shouting at Hisagi (with nothing to back it up, at least nothing that he's willing to reveal), it was exactly what that character needed to do to make me adore him (as opposed to merely quite liking him). You get the impression that their secrets bind them together just as much as their friendship and shared history. What must Yumichika be thinking now, knowing that he has gotten away with it once again and knowing that Ikkaku hasn't? How must he feel to have been stopped by Hisagi, the one person who knows his secret (and by extension the one person who could have guessed how he defeated Charlotte Coolhorn amidst the thorns). Could it be guilt as well as friendship that spurred him on to save Ikkaku so desperately, as though by doing so he's redeeming himself?

And Kira... having just committed Bleach's first successful execution he now turns his attention to ruthlessly rendering the 5th Seat of the 11th unconscious without even trying to reason with him, siting the chain of command as his flimsy rationale. The stakes now are higher than they have ever been previously but he is determined to score an own goal of only slightly lower magnitude than Ikkaku's: to deprive his own side of a key soldier... a pillar guardian, no less. Just what is going on with him?

At this point I'm very worried that the stubbornly chaotic diversity of the Shinigami in Soul Society will be their undoing, and that Barragan as battlefield general has rather more of an advantage than I ever thought he could have through sheer dint of his cold-hearted organisational ability alone. Kubo previously gave us flashbacks that contextualised and made us love characters that we previously found infuriating, and now he's shown that he's capable of turning a character's apparent assets into horribly exploitable weaknesses. In the space of two issues he may have heavy implied how he has painstakingly sowed the seeds of the Gotei 13's downfall over the course of many years worth of excellent characterisation and how it can be turned against itself in exactly the worst kind of situation.

Two cracking chapters back to back, and it's now a free for all...
 
 
Seth
13:11 / 20.09.08
More thoughts from the chronological read through...

- There's a peculiar moment when Ishida looks at the seal that Ukitate has given Ichigo when the Nakamakuras leave Soul Society. His attention is drawn to it, and he checks himself: "Am I thinking too much?" Ichigo calls it a seal of approval, Chad jokes that it looks more like a seal of disapproval. So far it has done nothing to justify this suspicion (apart from being unrecognised by Zennosuke), it has merely functioned as a combination of Rukia's cell phone and glove. The only clue as to what alerted Chad and Ishida is that the insignia seems to resemble Ichigo's Vaizard mask.

What interests me is that Ukitate gave it to Ichigo... the same person who unsealed a means to destroy the Soukyoku that was curiously emblazoned with the Shihoin Clan crest, a likely indication of a continued loyalty to Yoruichi despite her status as a hundred year wanted criminal. A covert affiliation with the disappeared head of the Shihoin Clan (with which Kyoraku would undoubtably be in collusion) might explain how Urahara et al receive supplies and intelligence and how Ukitate has come into possession of a seal that may or may not be linked to the Vaizard. All speculative, of course... but Ishida's reaction was jarring enough for me to really sit up and take notice.

- One of the things that the insertion of the Bound Arc screwed up was Ichigo's feelings of responsibility for the loss of Ishida's powers. That's a real shame that deserves to be corrected on some DVD special edition, which will probably never happen...

- In the scene in which Shinji first shows Ichigo his mask, he chooses a moment when Zennosuke is present. The only reasoning for this that I can determine is to deliberately ensure that a message is sent to Soul Society that the Vaizard are on the move.

- When the Grand Fisher reappears Urahara and Yoruichi both seem to sense it. When Yoruichi appears from Urahara's shop, what is she wearing (or not wearing)? She has a reputation for being provocative, but I do tend to broadly agree with the speculation that suggests that there is something going on between these two.

- Urahara's comment to Isshin (which I've probably mentioned before elsewhere), "If you became weaker and blamed me for it, it would be problematic." With lines of foreshadowing like these I wouldn't be surprised if an ambiguity of translation ruined the intended meaning, but it does seem as though Urahara is partially responsible for what happens to Isshin and how he might have ended up in Karakura Town.

- The manga translation that I've read opts for the exact reverse of Dattebayo's when it comes to Hiyori's lines to Shinji as he carries her away after she nearly attacks Chad and Orihime. In the anime she says that she hates Shinigami and humans, whereas in this manga scanlation she says that Shinigami and humans hate "us" (meaning the Vaizard). This makes Shinji's reply, "Just wait a little longer, things will change," seem to mean that they will take Soul Society's side in the upcoming battles (in that it implies the Vaizard will no longer be hated). Again, this reading could just be a product of the idiosyncrasies of translation.

- It's been said many times... the violence has been dialled way down for the anime, which makes me especially concerned that Bleach has been moved to an even earlier slot. If they couldn't show Chad's arm being torn in three pieces and Orihime having half her face torn off in the cartoon then how will they adapt the second two thirds of the Szayel battle (possibly the longest, craziest and most horrific fight sequence in the history of Bleach)? See also Ururu vs Ilfort Grantz.

- Ulquiorra's Hollow hole moves. It's initially up near his neck, but later Kubo lowers it to where his heart should be. It's a rare example of a continuity gaff (the only other one that I can immediately think of is when Aizen says that he released Kyouka Suigetsu in the Chambers of the Council of 46 to convince visitors that they were still in session, but this rather seems to contradict the fact that in order for it to work the target needs to witness the moment of release. The Central 46 would have been dead by that point, and visitors by definition could not all have been there at the moment of release. If Aizen Sousuke releases his sword in the forest, and no one is around to see it, what does it do? Supposedly nothing... apart from that one time, apparently).

- Ulquiorra's line to Orihime: "You're very unique, aren't you... woman?" Is this the start of his seeming obsession with her?

- The more I think about Ulquiorra's interactions with Ichigo, the more I believe that he was not sent to assess Ichigo as a threat, but as a potential asset, someone to use as a wildcard to distract and divide Soul Society and to use for Aizen's spring cleaning (to wipe out the Arrancar who aren't loyal). He can see that Ichigo is potentially more powerful than he is, but he doesn't kill him. When he returns to Hueco Mundo and does that weird eye-crushing thing he even talks about the possibility of recuiting him ("There is also a possibility that we could bring him to our side one day"). I'm coming to believe that the Arrancar Arc, characterised as it was by a series of three deliberately interrupted guerilla raids into Karakura Town, was a plot by Aizen to train Ichigo, in order that he has sufficient power to invade Hueco Mundo and wipe out the opposition (who Aizen deliberately weakens, as I speculated ages ago) but not enough power to pose a serious threat. I now think Ulquiorra was under secret orders, that he was deliberately assigned so that he would seem to fail in his mission to kill Ichigo. Aizen predicted that Grimmjow (or another high ranking Arrancar) would jump the leash and muller Ichigo just enough for him to want to grow stronger, and he deliberately used Tousen and Ulqiorra to spare his life and cut the fight short when its purpose had been served.

These tactics are a no-brainer if Aizen was watching Ichigo throughout the Soul Society arc (which we know that he was). The two defining aspects of Strawberry are that he goes nuts if you endanger his mates (guaranteeing that he will storm Las Noches to save Orihime) and that his power grows at insane rates if he fights people who are harder than he is. One of the key moments of the end of the Soul Society arc is when Aizen realises that Ichigo is not Urahara's subordinate, that he knew nothing of the fact that Rukia harboured the Hougyoku. When Kurosaki's real motive becomes apparent (that he's there to save his friend) the seeds are sown for all Aizen's subsequent plans involving him.

Consider that Ulquoirra doesn't kill Ichigo again when he mullers him just before Ichigo fights Grimmjow. There is some speculation amongst by mates that it was this attack that punches more Hollow reiatsu into Ichigo and enables him to maintain his mask long enough to win against Grimmjow. If that's the case, was it intentional on Ulquoirra's part? Did he deliberately leave Orihime undefended so that Grimmjow could use her to heal Ichigo? Something strange is going on with Ulquiorra, enough to make me think that he either has a hidden agenda of his own, is being used by Aizen, is under secret orders or being controlled, or some combination of the above.

- Just what in the blue hell does Renji want to talk to Urahara about? And will we ever see it? Renji was supposed to work for him for three months before getting his answers, and so far he's only trained Chad for a month. When he mentioned it initially Renji seemed to be looking at Rukia, so I think it's likely that it has something to do with her and the precise moment that Urahara concealed the Hougyoku in her.

- I loved Karin's sidelong glance at Rukia when she finally officially moves in to the Karakura Clinic. She knows exactly what Rukia is. The only person there who doesn't seem clued up is poor old Yuzu.

- Orihime seems to live in a different flat in the comic. I think she moves after her Hollow brother trashes the place, whereas in the anime she stays in the same place. Whatever. The art is masterful in the sequence in which she confesses her feelings to Mastumoto. The framing of the panels, the detail in body language, the facial expressions... you can see Rangiku's thought process without a single thought balloon in place. It's this level of detail that seems to be missing from most Western comics I've read, which unfold at too quick a pace to allow the artist to dwell on these moments.

- One flashback panel during Ikkaku's fight against Edorad suggests that in the comic it was Renji who trained him, not the other way around. Why the possible (arguable) reversal in the adaptation? Dunno innit. Again, this might be the product of a difference in translations, especially considering that Renji still offers him a little bow when he finds out Ikkaku's motivation for refusing even the possibility of promotion (a motivation that has now become so problematic).

I've said it before, but I love that this battle is shown from Edorad's perspective, with Madarame as the wildcard. A really nicely judged and unexpected perceptual shift.

- By far my favourite new inference from this part of the chronological read through involves the Super Hiyori Walker, the reiatsu-sapping cross-trainer that annoys Ichigo so much and that even Shinji refers to as "crappy." Now that we know that she was Urahara's Lieutenant in the 12th Division, indeed the second Lab Technician under Mayuri, it's rather implied that it is named after her because it is her invention. This hidden gem of a detail is completely fucking brilliant. Initially the notion of her trying her hand at making such a thing is hilarious, until you realise that Urahara got through to her, and that despite how she comes across Hiyori does pay attention, does learn and can be influenced. The thought of her doing her best and producing something that's actually rather rubbish (and having Shinji mercilessly taking the piss out of her for it) is so endearing that she's risen even further in my estimations. At the time it seemed like a pointless inclusion intended to pad out the issue, now it's a little goldmine of implied history for the attentive (read: unhealthily obsessed) reader.

- Kensei blows Ichigo's arm off with what appears to be a Cero! And he seems to do it purely to test out the extent of Strawberry's rapid regeneration ability, a latent aspect of his Hollowised form that may help to explain many of Ichigo's rapid last minute recoveries in combat. The sequence in which Ichigo undergoes Hollowisation also includes him firing off a cero... these are two abilities that have not been seen since, although it's arguable whether we're likely to see the latter again in a hurry when Ging can just use Getsuga Tensho instead.

- Why can't Kensei remember that Mashiro didn't need training to maintain her mask? She's his former Lieutenant, he should have been there. What is this hinting at?

- I love that the Vaizard appear to have dropped all pretense of their former ranks now that they have been abandoned by Soul Society. It is as though they have rejected all trace of that culture's obsession with heirarchy, in a similar manner to how Urahara, Tessai and Yoruichi have also excised all traces of status. It is largely what defines all the players resident in Karakura Town as different to either the Hueco Mundo and Seireitei characters. Rose refers to the Vaizard as a "family" (and a lonely one at that), Ichigo's crew are referred to as "nakama," and the Urahara store functions as a business.

- Orihime's observation that Ichigo's newfound determination is "Not exactly kindness" resonates well with Strawberry's admission to Grimmjow that he came to Hueco Mundo to fight. It seems that this self-awareness (that he learns from the representation of Kenpachi while he fought his inner Hollow) was the key for him to dominate his Hollow nature. Ichigo does seek fights and power and he needed to admit that to himself and accept it before he could go further.

- Yamamoto knows the whereabouts of the real King's Key. Whether or not he will reveal it in order to protect Karakura Town should his forces fail remains to be seen, but it does rather strike me that Kubo has a narrative escape route there if he needs it.

- Finally (this post is long enough as it is), if you're a fan of screaming idiots one of the most important details in the entire history of Bleach is the manner in which Keigo Asano both blocks Matsumoto's kick and maintains his posture. Rangiku's surprise confirms that it's not a throwaway detail. Even though she's in her gigai he should not have been able to do it. This promises that future Bleach will surpass everything we have seen so far!
 
 
Seth
18:19 / 21.09.08
Another installment from the chronological read through:

- Aizen is a real piece of work. In the daddy-showing-home-videos-to-his-Espada-children conference room scene he goes as far as to almost overtly declare that the strategy we've speculated about is actually the case: "Please return to your chambers and act normally, neither too proud, nor too scared. Just wait for the enemy patiently. Do not fear. Even if something were to go wrong, as long as you walk with me there is no enemy before us." The subtext is clear if you follow the implied reversal of that last statement: "If you do not walk with me there will be an enemy before you." I'm guessing Aizen knows what can be achieved by Gin manipulating the corridors, effectively he can tie the Nakama up in knots indefinitely by switching their path around. The Espada would therefore only encounter the enemy if they went seeking them. It's effectively a loyalty test, if they had stayed in their quarters they would probably be alive.

Halibel is later seen from her balcony, observing from a distance. Stark stays asleep until he is called upon. As such they remain obedient, and therefore remain alive. Everyone else is alone, and therefore far easier for the invaders to pick off.

- Interesting little snippet of dialogue here, from the same scene:

Aizen: "They were once called 'Ryoka.' These four managed to enter Soul Society and started a war against the Gotei 13."

Zommari: "Four people. There is one missing. Who is it?"

Ulquoirra: "Inoue Orihime."

Schiffer is aware of what happened in Soul Society. He is at least operating with more information than Zommari, and by implication he is probably more clued up than the rest of the Espada. Ulquiorra seems to have been taken into Aizen's confidence, there seems to be a different sort of relationship between him and Sousuke than there us with the remaining nine. I'm therefore betting that many of the hidden aspects of the Hueco Mundo arc will be revealed in the forthcoming 4th Espada's battle with Ichigo. In Bleach there's nothing like a good scrap to dislodge a few home truths.

- Ulquiorra's comment to Orihime: "In body and mind you are already one of us. You putting that on signifies as much, Inoue Orihime." How literally are we to take this? Is this further evidence that something has been done to her that we can't quite see yet?

- Nel has all the best lines: "Stupid Ichigo!! Baldie!! Doodie head!! Limp dick!! Virgin!!"

- It was Aizen who put the idea into Orihime's head that she could destroy the Hougyoku by rejecting it out of existence. He showed her its location and told her, "Your power is the rejection of events. You reject the very essence of events and erase the very existance of that event even happening." He restates the nature of her power three times in two sentences just in case she doesn't get the message: "Here is the Hougyoku and this is how you can destroy it." However, in the same scene Aizen says he needs the Hougyoku to create the Kings Key. Is this a lie? Because if it's the truth we can assume that he's probably taken it with him to the fake Karakura Town, which would seem to deny Orihime her opening and therefore hint that manipulating her to use her power on the Hougyoku is not his objective after all. If that's the case then why put the idea in her head in the first place? Is it just another part of his psychological trap? He knows that Ichigo is coming for her, so is it another attempt to make her stay of her own volition, to make her believe she has a purpose in Las Noches for which she needs to appear to remain under control? It could be interpreted as part of his strategy to stall the Invasors. On the one hand he gets Gin to work his mischief on the corridors, on the other he manipulates Orihime into wanting to stay. If that's the case then he may actually have been telling the truth when he states that he doesn't actually need Inoue's powers after all.

- The people hanging in Szayel's sample store... I'm now 100% certain that they are Dordoni and Cirucci and that both are still alive. When the Exequias come for the former in the comic there is no implication that they have killed him like there is in the anime, and when they come for the latter Rudobon says: "Cirucci Thunderwitch-sama. We have come to claim you. We would appreciate it if you came along quietly." That's not what you say to someone before the moment of execution, is it? The legs hanging on the left of the panel are female and booted, matching Cirucci's from the splash page for #257. The legs on the right match Dordoni's pre-Resurreccion appearance. Moreover, despite it being ambiguous who is doing the exclaiming, either Renji or Ishida recognises at least one of the hanging figures. Previously I was surprised that Unohana healed Gantenbien, but if the other two Privaron are also alive it makes sense for the complete set to have survived. And what's their defining characteristic? None of them have any reason to remain loyal to Aizen after not only being replaced but demoted to such humiliatingly low numbers. Two of the three may themselves have loyalty to the Invasors for restoring some of their dignity by treating then as opponents worthy of their time (that's certainly Dordoni's sentiment, and Gantenbien expresses at least some kind of desire for Chad to survive Nnoitra's attack). But there's more...

Who else has no loyalty to Aizen? Grimmjow Jaegerjaques. Who wants to be King of Hueco Mundo? Grimmjow Jaegerjaques. Who is the second strongest Espada currently remaining in Hueco Mundo? Grimmjow Jaegerjaques. Who therefore gets to rule the roost when Ulquiorra gets his ass handed to him? Grimmjow Jaegerjaques. And who will make up the beginnings of his new Espada? Dordonni, Cirucci and Gantenbien, that's who. And who may now be rather more sympathetic to Ichigo, seeing as how he prevented Nnoitra from delivering the killing blow? You guessed it...

My working theory is that Ichigo will again end this arc with new allies, that the leadership of Hueco Mundo will pass into new hands, and that as much as Aizen is using him to clear out the disloyal Ichigo will inspire a different sort of loyalty.

So effectively I'm on the side that says Grimmjow Jaegerjaques = The New Abarei Renji. But if he's left in charge what will become of Ulquiorra? Kubo seems to have invested a little too much in him to simply kill him off, but if anyone will land that killing blow it will probably be Number 6.

Rule of Fiction: If your number happens to be 6 then you're going end up to occupying a very interesting position.
 
 
Mysterious Transfer Student
19:42 / 21.09.08
Wah. Comprehensive readthrough was comprehensive. Far too much meat there for a point-by-point response, so I'll just follow along with some recent musings of my own. First, since we've been caught up in big-ass flashbacks and the Fake-kura theatre of war let's just recap who all has been left marooned in Hueco Mundo by Aizen's latest gambit:

One bankai-using Vaizard; four captains; four lieutenants; two unseated (if in name only) Shinigami; one Quincy; two humans with spirit powers, one of whom may be a Hollow-human hybrid, the other with the ability to reverse time; three Espada; four Privaron Espada; and two Numeros.

Even assuming that Yammy and Ulquiorra wind up dead or incapacitated at the conclusion of Ichigo's next fight and that no one else's status changes, that's still the most bizarre, heterogenous and crucially, extremely fucking powerful irregular fighting force in the series' history. Is there really any challenge this group couldn't take on and win, particularly with someone like Ichigo at its head? And as pausing for reflection is something that hasn't been seen in the series since the end of the Soul Society arc, I'm wondering if this ad hoc assembly might not be the line-up Kubo intended all along for the next lollapalooza of a storyline: the King's Palace expedition. If the defining trend of the series means anything, it's only right that humans, Hollows and Shinigami get to discover the innermost secrets of heaven together.

[The] violence has been dialled way down for the anime, which makes me especially concerned that Bleach has been moved to an even earlier slot.

I've been wondering how they'd cope with this in light of the increasingly explicit material ever since the Hueco Mundo arc began; the scenes involving Grimmjow and Luppi, and Loly and Menoly beating on Orihime, had to be censored prettily heavily (and obviously) as it was. My dream solution would be for an unedited late-night broadcast with the visceral goodies kept in, something the shonen anime Soul Eater has pioneered this season (and indeed made a selling point - though that show's late broadcast is virtually identical to the regular version save for the odd bit of fanservice). If TV Tokyo, who air both SE and Bleach, can't get it together to put this obvious solution in place it'll be disappointing to say the least, not because I especially yearn to see Nemu Kurotsuchi horribly violated in explicit digital colour, but because adaptations that have to excise larger and larger portions of the source material in order to be broadcast are never satisfactory.

I'd be interested to talk a little more about Bleach's audience reception in both manga and anime and how that feeds back into the series' creative process... and before anybody's tempted to say 'it doesn't', consider that Hitsugaya was introduced quite openly to broaden the series' appeal among younger and female fans, something that has worked out massively in inverse proportion to his interest level as a character. (And amusingly, Kubo allegedly really dislikes Hitsugaya compared to his other characters, which may be why the kid never has any interesting storylines in canon that don't directly involve either Matsumoto or Hinamori, two characters for whom he seems to have much more affection.) This aside, TK does seem to pay attention to reader popularity polls - beyond treating them as another opportunity to draw pin-ups of the cast in stylish seasonal clothing - and to have a good knack for introducing new characters that'll get a positive response from everybody (look at the reception for Grimmjow, Ulquiorra and Nel). It's interesting to me that successful manga-ka like Kubo tend to have a much more dynamic and open relationship with fan responses to their work than English-language superhero comic writers who seem to have a far more precious attitude to characters that, ironically, they usually didn't invent and don't own... though I'm not sure what evidence I have for that impression, and may just be talking bollocks.

Oh, and -

If your number happens to be 6 then you're going end up to occupying a very interesting position.

If Grimmjow, Byakuya, Renji and Ichigo (Ichi + Go = 1 + 5 = 6!!!) have any scenes together in the near future I predict some sort of pairings apocalypse.
 
 
Feverfew
17:54 / 22.09.08
Beautiful posting, ED. Particularly the phrase if you're a fan of screaming idiots. Which, of course, I am.

I loved Karin's sidelong glance at Rukia when she finally officially moves in to the Karakura Clinic. She knows exactly what Rukia is. The only person there who doesn't seem clued up is poor old Yuzu.

I only noticed this upon rereading vol.23 this evening, but, damn. I think I was distracted on initial reads by the sheer batshit craziness of Isshin, and his "Our family has gained a third daughter!" speech to the memorial poster. Isshin, who also must know about Rukia, and all the other shinigami's, presence, but is still so deeply in character as Dad Of The Year because he has some reason for never revealing it to Ichigo, and the only other people who know are either (a) dead, (b), in on it, or (c), Kon.

For no apparent reason, I was thinking about Kon the other night, and I think there's a lot more character in the details left out than those put forward. From what we're told - discarding the Bount arc for now, as this is the manga thread - the mod souls were created as an experimental way to re-animate corpses and make them warriors, but when this was deemed icky, they were ordered to be destroyed.

Now, we're not given a strict timeframe on this. But it's implied that the Konpaku has some degree of environmental awareness when it's in pill form - Kon shows knowledge of the decision to destroy the mod souls, and if I recall there are a few moments when he's first introduced that imply he has some awareness when he's strictly pill-like.

So if his mind is still in there when it's not installed in a body, this meant that he knew he was to be destroyed. And he was stuck, unable to do anything, in pill form, waiting for death / destruction, not knowing how long he had left to 'live'. Powerless, helpless, and hopeless.

But through a fluke - we're told - he survived, and got sent to the Urahara shop. Where, curiously, Urahara keeps an entire box marked 'defective / poor' merchandise, but that's another matter. It's even implied that Urahara knows who Kon is, by referring to him as speech-marks "He", although this could be a generalisation.

So this little, helpless, 'defective' gikongan suddenly gets another shot at life, and all, barring initial mucking around, is more or less well. But I can't help but feel that Kon, with all his girl-loving perverted ways, is compensating for being helpless and expecting destruction at any moment, and may, in fact, have hidden depths all the way underneath his shallows.

Not that we may ever get to see them, mind. Also, back to Urahara; who keeps a box of defective merchandise around a killing machine that apparently can't read? Hat-and-clogs, that's who. But what if there were more in the box, waiting for a rainy day?
 
 
Triplets
19:29 / 22.09.08
Excellent analysis and specumalations, both of you.

Randomly, doesn't this shopkeeper look a lot like Barragan?

EDIT: I mean, look at his right eye
 
 
Triplets
14:58 / 23.09.08
I want to restate my guess that Aizen has pulled an over-arching bluff on everyone.

We see Hachi, 100 years previous, pull off a Level 99 Kidou spell without the incantation and fears that he actually overdid the effect. 100 years later, at Rukia's rescue, Aizen hits Captain Komamura with a Level 90 destruction spell but tells Gin that he only managed to generate a third of it's damage.

This is at odds with Aizen's claim that he's mastered the four main Shinigami techniques (footwork, swordplay, magic and bankai).

100 years ago, when Urahara backattacks Aizen the latter is visibly shocked and startled, if only to us. Which means, at the time, Aizen might have feared such an attack. We certainly haven't seen him so scared since. Could he have grown so strong in 100 years? Or has he just gotten better at hiding his true stature?

Shortly afterwards, he asks Gin to execute Rukia while he holds her. Surely Aizen could do this himself?*

He deflects Ichigo's strike with a finger. Impressive. But what if it was the work of Absolute Hypnosis? I can't point to a time Ichigo was exposed to his release, unfortunately.

We've not actually seen Aizen kill anyone on-screen either, though we see the bodies of the Central 46, for which he takes full credit. They're old bureaucrats, however, so surely it wouldn't take much for a standard-level Captain (and one with Absolute Hypnosis to boot!) to kill them all swiftly?

My hypothesis is this: Aizen's not that much stronger than a regular Captain, if he is at all. But the man has ran a fantastic image campaign to make everyone THINK he is. Why? Because someone who's demonically powerful has a far easier time making people fall into line and makes enemies wary of direct attacks.

This would fit with Seth's theory that Aizen is using both sides to do his spring cleaning for him. If he, Gin and Tousen are buff but not shatteringly so it makes more sense for him to let his opposition take each other out.

Put it this way: Aizen's archetype is that of the Genius Mastermind. Now, as this is Shonen, he also has to be hard enough to take on our ginger protagonist in a swordfight, fair enough, but doesn't it make sense for him to bolster himself with lies and subterfuge, his best talents?

*Unless, of course, this is a test of Gin. Also someone who, as Seth has pointed out repeatedly, has yet to kill someone on-camera. In fact, it's only Tousen so far who WANTS to get his hands completely dirty.
 
 
Mysterious Transfer Student
16:12 / 23.09.08
the four main Shinigami techniques (footwork, swordplay, magic and bankai)

The fourth branch is hakuda (hand-to-hand-combat) rather than bankai, which I guess should be considered the culmination of sword arts; we don't get to see much of this type of fighting in Bleach compared to the other three, and Aizen, Yoruichi, Soi Fong and Urahara are the only characters I can recall fighting barehanded at any point. (Maybe Aizen's one-finger stoppage of Tensa Zangetsu was a hakuda technique rather than just him being super-strong or using illusion magic; do recall, though, that Ichigo only learned bankai a few hours earlier and was already wrecked from rescuing Rukia, fending off three lieutenants and fighting Byakuya to a standstill.) It'd be fun to have this really gone into at some future stage.

My hypothesis is this: Aizen's not that much stronger than a regular Captain, if he is at all. But the man has ran a fantastic image campaign to make everyone THINK he is.

I think the next major clue will come when the four pillars battle ends and it becomes necessary for Aizen to leave Yamamoto's fire cage. If he really could just walk out, why doesn't he? I anticipate that he'll simply arrange things so that Yamamoto either has to turn off the cage himself or is overpowered by one of the Espada, saving Aizen-sama 'the trouble of' going into battle himself. I've been wondering whether Aizen's vaunted powerlevels were all that for a while now, and the last post is the most concise summary I've seen of the evidence against.

There's a weak spot in the series plot that needs addressing in re: the Aizen-god-tier-or-not question: if he isn't ungodly powerful, exactly what did he do to make all those Arrancar do the unprecedented and obey the orders of a Shinigami? It's stated that the Arrancar follow Aizen because of his strength, which presumably he must have demonstrated to them at some point prior to leaving Soul Society; possibly he killed or enslaved the then Espada and began assigning positions of power to their replacements, leaving the likes of the Privaron Espada as a disposable echelon force and a warning to others not to rebel against him. Zommari, Szayel, Aaroneiro and Neriel all have their own various rationalisations for following him, while Grimmjow and Nnoitra just go along with the flow after accepting him as the the new alpha-predator in Hueco Mundo. Thinking about it, it would be fun and fitting if all three of the rebel captains turned out entirely different to their public image:-

Tousen - outwardly a placid, righteous pacifist, in fact a barely-restrained bloodthirsty berserker (this we know);
Ichimaru - appears to be a smarmy, untrustworthy slimeball who fucks with people's heads for fun, may yet turn out to be a stand-up guy (if El Directo's analysis holds water);
Aizen - gives the image of an all-powerful Nietzschean super-Shinigami; might not be.
 
 
Seth
16:45 / 23.09.08
It's stated that the Arrancar follow Aizen because of his strength, which presumably he must have demonstrated to them at some point prior to leaving Soul Society

We've also seen it demonstrated in the comic itself when Grimmjow is seen to not even be able to stand in his presence. If Aizen is not as powerful as he appears (a theory that I love because it's in keeping with his characterisation) we'll need to find some means to explain how he is capable of bringing the 6th Espada to his knees by the force of his reiatsu alone.

Issue 175 is the only time I can recall in which Aizen mentions the limit to a Shinigami's power. It's worth noting that at no point does he claim to have reached that limit himself. He says that he wants to fill "the unbearable vacancy of the throne in the sky" and the Shinigami have assumed that obtaining the Hougyoku and the Ouken are the means by which he will achieve this. If that is his genuine objective perhaps it is simply not achievable without Hollowfication regardless of whether or not you are at the limit for a Shinigami.
 
 
Triplets
20:37 / 23.09.08
Good points.

One thing that has just occured to me: the whole series seems to be a subversion or tinkering with the standard rules for a Shonen fighty boys series. Aizen's stated goal is that he wants INCREDIBLE, COSMIC, POWER! But isn't that basically the goal for every cookie-cutter Shonen badguy? They're always trying to get ever-more buff, cool and unbeatable. On the surface it appears Aizen wants this, but, as Seth and others have pointed out, Aizen wants to fill the position, with all the political and societal muscle that entails, not just personal strength. Which leads us back onto the strand that suggests this is all about reforming Soul Society (and possibly Hueco Mundo) with a Yoruichi/Urahara/Tessai triumverate racing to beat him to it.

Also! Oooh, what if to be The True King of the Dead you need to be both Hollow and Shinigami? To rule you need your feet in both realms?

Double also! Which would mean Urahara, if he wants to beat Aizen to it, would have probably Hollowified himself by now.

Which kind of feeds back into the idea that Ichigo is the Son of God (blah blah Messiah-cakes) and why he's got so much potential on both his Shinigami and Hollow sides.
 
 
Triplets
20:42 / 23.09.08
What intruiges me, and I'll say it now before I forget, in the current filler arc Ichigo faces a Fail Ninja who can generate pocket realities/hell-dimensions to crush an opponents spirit. This is, essentially, what a lot of people have predicted Aizen's bankai to be like, the generation of pockets of reality he has full control over. Which would fit his controlfreaky nature. It seems a bit odd that, if it gets to Aizen using his bankai, which narrative momentum says we will, we'd have already seen it being used by someone who isn't even as memorable as a Bounto. Honestly, can you even remember Fail Ninja's name?

So, odd that we've already seen a very similar ultimate technique to one speculated about. Obviously, how much say Kubo has/wants in the filler has to be considered...
 
 
Mysterious Transfer Student
19:38 / 25.09.08
New interview in US Shonen Jump with Kubo. Transcribed here. (Offtopic, El Directo asked ages ago if any sites specialise in translating interviews with Japanese creators; AnimeSuki forums take some trawling but sometimes have the goods, like now.)

Best snippet: Urahara was based on Snufkin. Hells yeah!
 
 
Seth
16:12 / 27.09.08
Ouch. Komamura seems to have blown his bankai wad rather early, doesn't he? Despite developing a sneaking suspicion that he is either the same as Kenpachi and Ichigo (stuck at shikai) or is unique amongst Shinigami for being an all-or-nothing fighter (he may have no shikai) I'm still concerned that he has released at all against a Fraccion. Previously we've only seen a glimpse of him fighting against Kenpachi and an even briefer glimpse against Aizen. The latter sheds next to no light on his actions, but in the former we see a single panel in which it appears as though he releases just the sword arm of his bankai without calling out the release, in the same manner than a powerful Shinigami can exhibit with their shikai (the first example I can think of being Renji in his fight against Byakuya).

The only other non-Espada battle in which a Captain has gone to bankai is Hitsugaya against Shawlong. Koufang was one of the Numeros but we don’t know whether he was officially one of Grimmjow's Fraccion, or indeed whether Grimmjow had any Fraccion. Shawlong seemed to exhibit his own agency when arguing with Ulquiorra over his decision to allow Ichigo to live, and it seemed as though he was allied to Jaegerjaques through having the same goals rather than being under command. But the distinction between Numeros and Fraccion power levels may be moot considering that the Top Ten can command any Arrancar numbering eleven and above, which effectively makes any non-Espada a potential Fraccion. Just because Kubo hasn't overtly awarded numbers to any of the Arrancar since the Privaron doesn't mean they don't have them, and given that numbering is chronological outside of anyone who either is or used to be an Espada the Fraccion/Numeros would be wildcards regardless of whether or not their number was known.

Having Abirama, Findor and Coolhorn dispatched by Lieutenants (or under, in the case of Yumichika) has lulled us into a false sense of security, and if Po approaches the Espada in terms of power then any of Halibel and Starks's Fraccion could too. That leaves the Gotei 13 looking horribly underpowered for this fight. It's also worrying that Hisagi and Kira seem to have left their respective pillars undefended, while Izuru has rendered Yumichika incapable of defending the fourth. Not a good position to be in. The Shinigami seem to be freaking out in general. Ikkaku has wilfully stuck to his guns and blown his mission, Kira has horribly overreacted and dispatched Yumichika, Kira and Hisagi have left their posts, Tetsuzaemon wants to run away (a very different side to his character than what we've seen previously given that he was raring to go against Ichigo, who at the time was holding his own against Byakuya) and Komamura has gone full-strength against Po. They're in complete disarray, aren't they?
 
 
Seth
16:13 / 27.09.08
Great Kubo interview, by the way. I'm thankful that we've been spared Snipe in favour of WIKKID SWORDFITING.
 
 
hachiman
19:42 / 28.09.08
The Fight stuff going on currently has been fun to read.

Kubo definitely has a yen for staging cool battles.

On the other hand the batle seems to be going from bad to worse for the Shinigami, as a captain going Bankai this early in the confrontation seems like desperation.

On a related note, My God El Directo O_O!!!.

I dont know who i'm more frightened off. Kubo for placing all those subtlete clues or you for digging them up and going thru them.

 
 
Seth
13:32 / 29.09.08
More from the chronological read through...

This section of the read-through makes me believe that we're much less familiar with the history of Hueco Mundo and the Espada than we might think, that there is some kind of secret history. Some of this speculation may be the result of the translation, so I'm currently downloading Ju-Ni's version for comparison. It's impossible to fully recreate a timeline for the characters and events, but that is what this section seems to encourage.

- Zommari calls Aaroniero, "The last survivor of the inaugural Espada." He seems to have been around the longest. Aizen seems to have made him a promise that he will be "Released from all that pain" if he serves him, which could be a hint at the kind of deals or promises he made with the original Espada before he actually attained the Hougyoku.

- Las Noches, with its sky that mocks Soul Society (that was installed by Aizen), has been there for a long time. We know this because Nnoitra says to Nel during their fight, "How many years do you think it has been since I first kicked you out of this place?" When the action flashes back to their fight they are shown in Las Noches with the blue cloudy sky clearly visible in the background. Nnoitra's hair is shorter and his Zanpakuto lacks two arcs, a visual clue that he became much more powerful by the time the Nakamakura invaded. When he shouts at Nel in this sequence he opens his mouth, and the number 8 is clearly visible on his tongue in place of the expected 5. Nnoitra's question "How many years...?" is clearly not that of a sadistic bastard taunting an amnesiac: in Bleach changes to appearance in flashbacks are always a signifier that a good deal of time has passed. Aizen's Las Noches was therefore not erected in the couple of months between the revelation of Aizen's defection and Ichigo's invasion, it has been there for a long, long time.

An aside: The anime makes reference to Las Noches being built upon foundations of an older structure, whereas the manga doesn't that I can recall.

- At some unknown point before Nnoitra and Szayel betrayed Nel, Szayel was demoted from the Espada for reasons unknown (Szayel: "Would you please stop ordering me around like that?" Nnoitra: "Hah! For you, who isn't even an Espada any more?"). Interesting that it is Nnoitra who is the 8th in this flashback and that this very same evil piece of shit inventor will later take that same number. They talk about their goals and interests; Nnoitra seeks to topple Nel because in his misogyny he cannot tolerate being ranked lower than a woman, and he hates the way in which he believes she looks down on him (interesting that he also comes to argue with Halibel during Aizen's freakydad tea party); Szayel's motives more than likely involve being reinstated into the Espada (posssibly taking the position opened up by Nnoitra's promotion after the betrayal). Aizen seems to turn a blind eye to these antics, and the fact Nnoitra is promoted seems to indicate that he encourages them, or at least that he also wanted Nel gone.

To this end Szayel creates a device that allows Nnoitra to sneak up on Nel, which we only see twice. It appears to be a bloody black clump of matter on the floor, nothing more can be seen of it at all. It may be what tore off Pesche and Dondo ChakkaChakka's masks, as Pesche later remarks, "Looking down upon us with scorn, as mere 'Enemies whom I have defeated once before.'" Nel's cry of "How could you..." at Nnoitra could therefore be interpreted as either "What kind of bastard are you to do this to my Fraccion?" or "How were you able to do this to my Fraccion?" The answer to the latter interpretation seems to be that it was Szayel who tore their masks off.

- Szayel's analysis of Nel's apparent reduction to amnesiac infancy: "Fascinating. This is a phenomenon I've never seen before. The reiatsu coming from her broken mask wound caused her spiritual body to shrink? Or possibly…" Then Nnoitra interrupts him. What was he about to say? It would strike me that it is likely for there to be some kind of deeper explanation for what happened to Nel, if only to explain how she can temporarily regained her former form. She says later that she resisted taking on her Resureccion form so soon after being physically restored because of the strain it would place on her. Can we interpret this as the reason that she so inconveniently changed back?

- The implication that Nel was betrayed years before Aizen defected indicate that the Espada were under his command a long time before Rukia transfered her powers into Ichigo, because Nnoitra and Nel were both ordered by Aizen to locate Vasto Lordes for alteration. That would seem to fit with the fact that Aizen has been experimenting with actual Hollows for at least fifty years (rather that Hollowfied Shinigami, with whom he has been tinkering for a lot longer). I would speculate that he allied himself with the Espada at some point between becoming a captain and modifying the Hollow that possessed Kaien (even though Aizen was at least as powerful as a captain when he was a lieutenant I can't imagine the proud Top Ten obeying someone who is ranked as a mere lieutenant).

- Consider the numbering of the Numeros:

Shawlong: 11th
Edorad: 13th
Ilfort: 15th
D-Roy: 16th

Shawlong says to Hitsugaya: "Our number is not 'the order of strength' but 'the order in which we were born...' First by means of the Hougyoku we were reborn from Hollow to Arrancar. Then from the order we were born we were given a number." What we don't know about this group is why Grimmjow didn't eat them when Shawlong made that request of him. Given that Grimmjow is an Espada he could have become an Arrancar at any point before or after these four. However, we know that of the Numeros this group is the oldest, and that they were all born from the Hougyoku, and so must have been created after Aizen's defection at the end of the Soul Society arc.

- However... there is either a continuity gaff or a translation error involved here. Way back in #25 we see Iceringer and D-Roy (both in Arrancar form) present at the moment that Grand Fisher becomes an Arrancar. D-Roy could not have been there in that form at that time if he was supposedly changed two to three months later by the Hougyoku. This can be fixed with only minor fanwank if we speculate that this sequence is a flashforward, otherwise we have to reconcile the numbering of the Numeros with the fact that Aizen did not possess the Hougyoku at that time. The anime places Grand Fisher's transformation after Aizen's defection, although we still see Iceringer a long time before in Episode 8... which would imply that his number should be higher than Shawlong's, unless the Numeros are only given a number if they are transformed by the Hougyoku, not if they were earlier pseudo-Arrancar.

- "If you have even a piece of you eaten by a Hollow of your same type, then your evolution stops forever." That explains D-Roy, because Grimmjow already ate a part of him ("D-Roy will never become a Vasto Lorde. That's a given"). What does "Of the same type" imply? Adjuchas? Gillian? However, we now know that the reason D-Roy was a failure was because he was also a snack, and that the others had their evolution halted much later (if they were snacked upon at all).

More to come...
 
 
Seth
13:34 / 29.09.08
It all begs the question: what did the Espada do for tattoo removal before they kidnapped Orihime?
 
 
Seth
13:42 / 29.09.08
However, we know that of the Numeros this group is the oldest

It's just occurred to me that Aizen's numbering seems to be a form of revisionist history, another means of stamping his authority on Hueco Mundo. By renumbering the Privaron as much lower than the Numeros he makes it appear as though they were born a long time after the first to be made from the Hougyoku, which he is treating as his new Year Zero for the Arrancar.

I've also just remembered that Grand Fisher is said to have a much more chaotic reiatsu than Grimmjow's Karakura raiding party, indicating that he may have been a pre-Hougyoku pseudo-Arrancar and lending weight to the theory that the sequence as depicted in #25 was a continuity gaff rather than a flashforward.
 
 
Seth
13:29 / 03.10.08
328 is up. I am a little concerned that I am becoming predictable for my hyperbole, but this issue is really something else.

First of all, I loved the cut backs to the other characters witnessing Komamura in action. Omaeda is back to his role of being the idiot stooge compared to his inscrutable Captain (although I got the slight impression from Soi Fong's stance and facial expression that she's sizing up the 7th Squad Captain and wondering how she'd fare against him). Hitsugaya and Matsumoto are played entirely for laughs (although notice how the former's physiology is an exact mirror of the 2nd Squad Captain). Notions of pay and working conditions amongst the Gotei 13 are always incongruously silly. But the three strike payoff is comes in the tiny panel featuring the late-to-the-scene Hisagi and Kira, both utterly humbled by the property damage on display. It's fun to see Kubo taking such pleasure in his own OTT destruction.

The payoff between Iba and Ikkaku has been far longer in the making, based as it is on what originally seemed to be their throwaway drinking competition/battle during the Soul Society Arc. I wrote about that upthread, and I must admit that I felt a thrill to see that speculation rewarded in such fine style. Even when exposed Ikkaku is not one to take such a dressing down, so Kubo rightly spends nearly half the issue pulling the rug out from under him. You get the impression that either this status switch has been brewing for years, or that Kubo deliberately digressed into such rich character groundwork (which at the time seemed a little superfluous) for these moments to logically suggest themselves over time. Either way it's better than I could have hoped for, organic and utterly in keeping with their characters... but their discussion of Iba attaining power to seek promotion way back in #160 rather makes me come down on the side of thinking that this was planned a long time ago.

Interesting that Komamura chooses to turn a blind eye. Kubo is making him an enigma. On the one hand he's clearly noble and principled. On the other, he either has a crushing inferiority complex or great humility, which he isn't above using to insult his enemy (one interpretation of the closing lines of #327 could be that it only takes a worm/insect to defeat someone of Po's power).

The battle combinations hinted at on the final page are interesting. It appears that while Barragan has two more Fraccion to waste he himself isn't up to fight any time soon. Halibel has also been kept out of the mix despite her Fraccion being deployed. While that might initially seem alarming for the Gotei 13 they have hidden assets that aren't currently on the battlefield (although the Arrancar probably do too). I'm pleased that Kyoraku seems about to be pitted against Stark, they seemed too similar for Kubo to not set them in opposition for contrast's sake. Despite his deployment coming relatively early compared to the remaining top three Espada I'm still of the opinion that there is some misdirection going on regarding the pecking order.

It's worth noting that Yamamoto is the only one without an opponent besides Komamura. That's compared to Aizen's forces, who have two Espada and three former Captains currently on the subs bench. Once again, the flashy detail on display allows us to enjoy the prospect of each upcoming battle, but the subtext is all in what has been omitted. This is not a good situation for the Gotei 13.

At this point the tension has become so unbearably high that I'm convinced the only thing Kubo can do now is cut back to Hueco Mundo next issue, and I'm betting he'll focus on Renji, Rukia and Chad vs the Exequias. I doubt we'll see what happens next in Fake-Kura for at least two months.
 
 
hachiman
12:38 / 04.10.08
I hope your wrong, i really want to see this showdown go apocalyptic.

Btw as an aside, loved that bit between Hitsugaya and Matsumoto, damages in battles coming out of the salaries of shinigami. It was hilarious.
 
 
Seth
16:00 / 10.10.08
Wrongfooted again, although I still suspect we won't remain in Karakura Town too much longer.

329: Who else suspects that Matsumoto is trying to lure out Gin?
 
 
Mysterious Transfer Student
20:36 / 10.10.08
For certain, though I doubt his blasé attitude (rather than any sort of pride) will permit Gin to show any form of weakness or consideration for her. I also think Hitsugaya's quite wrong to believe she'll hesitate for more than a second before she puts Gin down. (This message courtesy of the Rangiku Matsumoto We Like Her As A Person Fanclub.)

Re Hitsugaya, I think Kubo will need to provide some good reasons why he stands any chance at all against a top-tier Espada, given that Shawlong fought him to near-exhaustion and he only won against Luppi thanks to the element of surprise and Luppi's own arrogance. It seems like so long since we've seen an Espada in actual combat, I'm really looking forward to seeing if Halibel or Stark have moves as insane as those of Zommari or Szayel.
 
 
Triplets
21:19 / 14.10.08
So far we haven't seen Halibel's hollow hole. Given that Nnoitra had his you-know-where, does anyone else suspect her odd collar is hiding a hole where her mouth should be?
 
 
Seth
12:27 / 16.10.08
Hitsugaya is a firm fan favourite, one with unfinished business against both Aizen and Gin for what they did to Hinamori. Both he and Matsumoto have been tied into the fate of Gin's character in a manner that no other character really has been, although the perpetually absent and brain-fried Hinamori must also have some further role to play.

Matsumoto must have some trick up her sleeve in order to have asked to face Sun-Sun, Mila Rose and Apache single handed. Last time we saw her in battle she had just been struggling to attain bankai along with Yumichika. We can safely bet that he didn't achieve it, but what if she did (at some point after the fight with Luppi, Wonderwice and Yami)? The three Fraccion have so far only been seen trying to cover up their terror during Ichigo's fight with Grimmjow, and so a particularly effective bankai might be all she needs to whoop their collective asses.

I'd also reframe our understanding of Hitsugaya to the point of speculating that he's largely untested in combat against the Arrancar. He was at one fifth of his strength throughout the majority of the fight against Shawlong, and unlike Renji (who commented that he needed the element of surprise to win) Toshiro may have needed no such leg up. His fight against Luppi was also broken up before it reached its conclusion by Ulquiorra's return . Neither he nor the erstwhile 6th Espada were even close to being on their last legs. However, Hitsugaya has a history of being the most pessimistic of all the characters when it comes to speculating on the war against the Arrancar. On several occasions he has theorised that either Soul Society may not be able to win or that they have been lucky with their opponents so far (during the briefing in Ichigo's bedroom; in private to Matsumoto on top of the school building after Grimmjow's disastrous raid; and in Urahara's bizarre dojo after the Orihime Kidnap Distraction Troops were called away).

However, I get the impression that something special has been saved for Halibel and her Fraccion. And that's not just due to the casting of Megumi Ogata. Frankly, they don't seem like a bad bunch. Halibel seems to care for her subordinates. And the four of them seem to carry the mild implication of being some sort of feminist enclave within the Espada. Halibel certainly appears to be loyal to Aizen, but in practise I'm not sure we'll see anything quite so straightforward.

I think we'll get something really interesting from these fight combinations. Beneath her frivolous exterior Matsumoto has an indomitable will, compassionate insight and fierce loyalty. It's not her largely unseen history of friendship with Gin that gives her the greatest chance of getting through to him, it's everything we've seen about her since. I also reckon she's capable of balancing that with her loyalty to her Captain. And while I'd resist speculating too far on the little we've seen of Halibel, on the little we've seen so far I'd guess that she and Matsumoto have a lot in common. Halibel may also be the first Arrancar who provides an opponent with an opening due to her concern for her Fraccion. Her apparent icy detached loyalty makes her a good foil for Hitsugaya, who again seems strikingly similar in some ways. I think we'll see a lot of mutual respect throughout these fights.

Likewise with Kyoraku and Stark, who seem like twins separated at birth. I cannot imagine what will happen during their fight. My only clue is what Nel said in the aftermath of one of her battles against Nnoitra, "There was a time when we ceased to be humans and became beasts. Now as Arrancar, we have regained our sense of reason." The issues since Ichigo's invasion of Hueco Mundo have been an examination of this line of reasoning. Dordonni, Gantenbein, Nel, Pesche, Dondo Chakka, Coolhorn, Halibel and Stark all have redeeming qualities. Ulquiorra may have shown enough complexity (and arguably mercy, although it's typically portrayed in an inscrutably merciless fashion) to be redeemed. And Grimmjow's stubborn rebellious individualism gives him a great deal in common with Ichigo and Renji, which could be why he hates the former so much: Ichigo may remind him of himself.

The only fight parings that don't (yet) have this kind of nuance are Soi Fong and Omaeda's, and so I'd be willing to bet that they're dealt with first (let's see how wrong I am). And frankly, Barragan (when he finally does battle himself) does not seem to fit into any sense of a New Order in the making. The narrative since the return from rescuing Rukia has been about breaking down the polar opposites of the Hollows and Shinigami into something richer and more complex, and I think that Aizen has probably accounted for his Arrancar subordinates rebelling against him. Fear of/loyalty to Sousuke now seems to be the primary motivator setting these characters in opposition rather than what we might have previously believed about their *basic nature* being antagonistic. I rather think he'll be banking on some of the Espada turning against him for what happens next, because if Kubo is true to form the next story arc will involve him manipulating his newly united enemies into weakening Division Zero for him.
 
 
Seth
12:28 / 16.10.08
Given that Nnoitra had his you-know-where, does anyone else suspect her odd collar is hiding a hole where her mouth should be?

Yes. Yes, I do.
 
 
Mysterious Transfer Student
18:58 / 16.10.08
Very interesting comments regarding Matsumoto. It's worth remembering that we haven't seen a character achieve bankai within the timeline of the series since Ichigo and Renji, and Rangiku is certainly the most obvious contender to have done so of all those who've been seen making the effort. And since allegiances and new friendships in Bleach always begin with trash talk, standoffs, scrapping and beatdowns (and as **SPOILER** #330 continues the warmup for Soifon, Hitsugaya and Matsumoto's fights), it's a strong possibility that the eventual alliance between the remnants of the Arrancar and whatever becomes of the Gotei 13 might have one of its starting points here and now.

I don't think we're going to see a return to Hueco Mundo until all of the top three Espada and their Fraccion's fights have played out to the end. Given that this labyrinthine story mirrors the Soul Society arc in so many ways, the final confrontation between Ichigo and Ulquiorra - who is very much to this arc what Byakuya was to the earlier one, icy demeanour, cloudy motivations and all - will be the decisive conclusion to the Espada saga, and whatever revelations emerge from the resolution to that battle will be the ones that power the next storyline, whether it's a direct plunge into the King's Palace and Division Zero or an unexpected new turn. I'll also come out and predict that Barragan is indeed Primo Espada, but that the exact meaning of his being 'King' will be more of a self-declared status than anything concrete and that the differences in level between him and the other two are no more cut and dried than they were when we saw the jockeying for position that attended Neliel's ejection from Las Noches.

The relationships between the Espada and their attendant Numeros are interesting to me for the light they shed on the way each character views him- or herself and the way they fit into the pecking order of Las Noches. Barragan and Grimmjow, the two self-styled kings, have a 'court' of half-dozen or so Fraccion who are very clearly subordinate and in Grimmjow's case, represent the pack/entourage of junior predators he's kept since before becoming an Arrancar; his Fraccion from Shawlong down, while no pushover in most cases (*LOL D-Roy*), were clearly far inferior to him in power level, and the same is likely true of Barragan. Zommari, Luppi and Aaroniero had no known Fraccion, something that seems likely to have stemmed from humility in the former case and arrogance in the latter (though one-man-army Aaroneiro would probably have no particular need or wish for servants). Szayel, of course, treated his Fraccion strictly as the disposable materiel they were and relied entirely on his own abilities, occasionally outsourcing to the Exequias when he thought he could get away with it. Tesla was more or less a squire to Nnoitra's knight, and given that Yami is Ulquiorra's Fraccion in all but name I'd say the same was true for those two. Halibel's mob feel, as El Directo intimates above, more like a team or gang with a clearly defined leader than a set of hangers-on, and Stark's relationship with Lilinette - another character in the 'bothersome child' vein of Mashiro Kuna - has a certain father-daughter air that's fun to watch given that his counterpart, Kyouraku, treats his own lieutenant at all times like a strict yet beloved governess.

I haven't got time right now but I'd to talk more about the relationship between Aizen and the Arrancar as a whole and whether Aizen does indeed view himself in some way as a reformer and civilizer of the 'state of nature' that Hueco Mundo represents, or whether he's entirely cynical and sees HM and all its inhabitants as fuel for the greater glory of Sousuke. Ja nai, teme.
 
 
Seth
09:20 / 20.10.08
Seele Schneider: I agree that Ichigo's fight with Ulquiorra is likely to form the big action set-piece climax to this particular story arc, but I don't necessarily think that it will form the narrative climax. The actual ending of the Soul Society arc came rather a long time after the Ichigo/Byakuya scrap finished. Byakuya's true motivations weren't revealed until after the Central Office of 46 were found massacred, Aizen's faked death was revealed, Hinamori betrayed, Hitsugaya mullered, Tousen was unmasked, Renji and Rukia recaptured, the Hougyoku secured and Aizen/Tousen/Gin had defected. The major reveals during the Ichigo/Byakuya fight were the former's bankai and his partial Hollow transformation. All of the glue that held the previous one hundred and seventy or so issues together was revealed quite a while afterwards by Aizen in his megalomaniac speech, a story moment so important that Ichigo had to be present to hear it.

However, the storytelling mechanics have certainly been put in place for the two arcs to mirror each other. Both Aizen and Ichigo are in a holding pattern right now. The former is apparently content to be surrounded by fire, the latter is 'safe' in Hueco Mundo with the enemy seeming to be vastly outgunned having just begun what is probably his final major battle of the arc. The stage is set for a weary Ichigo and his buddies to return to their fake home just in time to see the aftermath of the carnage and be the recipient of another round of megalomaniacal posturing.

Nevertheless… from the moment everyone went to their separate fights at the execution ground in the Soul Society arc we were never away from the Nakamakura for this long. The action would return to show us brief glimpses of the earlier stages of Ichigo vs Byakuya, or Renji and Rukia on the run, or the rest of the gang as they were guided to the scene by Yachiru and Maki Maki, or we'd see the execution ground fireworks from a distance to remind us that the real battle was taking place nearby. I'm surprised that we've barely had any similar moments this time around. What with Turn Back the Pendulum and then the fake Karakura battles we've barely seen the major characters for about twenty five issues. That's six months. When you take into account that for the six months prior to that the Nakamakura were bleeding to death, having their organs pulverised or their limbs shattered one by one, it's been around a full year since the major characters were actually driving the story. Don't get me wrong, I love seeing the return of the Gotei 13 in full force and having the Vaizard incorporated as major historical players in the main story… I think we're overdue some kind of switch back to the main protagonist, and so I'm a little surprised that he and his closest friends haven't received more attention recently.

I like your speculation on the Espada and their related Fraccion. Kubo excels at these kinds of relational dynamics and how they're essential for creating characters that seem three dimensional. Too many writers ignore this. No matter how apparently complex their characters are, they are complex in the same ways regardless of who they are relating to. That's excusable in one or two cases, but to have an entire cast of monolithic players without relational nuance seems rather false. Different people draw out different characteristics. The only problem that I have when this is applied to the Arrancar is that Kubo has made it difficult to know to whom we should become attached, because he's killing them off at a rate of knots. Admittedly he hasn't yet killed any that I've been particularly fond of (if my speculation about Dordonni and Cirucci is currect). The majority of their respective mullerings have raised a cheer, particularly Szayel and Aaroniero. I think we're all wondering who will remain at the end of this storyline, along with what implications that might have for the series' themes and cosmology.

As for how Aizen views himself and his relationship with Hueco Mundo and the Arrancar… at the moment we know very little. In fact we're almost completely in the dark about the central antagonist. We know that he trusted Tousen and Gin to keep silent about their conspiracy. We know that he takes great pleasure in social etiquette, apparently because he revels in a perverse enjoyment of all the horrors that he can keep hidden behind his impeccable manners. We know that he likes to reveal to people how clever he is when he believes there's no way in which those revelations can cost him anything, and unlike most other fictional megalomaniacs he hasn't laid open a single obvious blind spot through his pontifications. We know that he either has a background in science or has access to scientists, but we have no idea whether he had any involvement with Szayel at the time Turn Back the Pendulum was set. We know that he experimented on both Shinigami and Hollows, but that his results with the latter group seemed considerably more stable and less, well, fatal. We know that he has no problem with revealing his intention to merge Shinigami and Hollow to the Arrancar, whereas he kept it secret from the Shinigami. We know that he has made several decisions since taking over Hueco Mundo that many Arrancar find questionable; demoting the original Espada; installing the blue sky in Las Noches; leaving Ichigo alive; kidnapping Orihime; his orders to the Espada to remain in their quarters; refusing to save any of his subordinates (including Tousen, although he could have banked on Kenpachi staying true to form and leaving him alive). We know that he appears to have left Hueco Mundo practically undefended. We know that any witness to the moment he released his shikai are rendered under hypnosis. Are there any other concrete facts?

Regarding Matsumoto. It's also occurred to me that she might be seeking to defect. By placing herself in the Karakura Town advance party with Renji she was asking to be stationed in the most likely location for Gin to show his face. Renji stated that she asked to go, and that Hitsugaya rather counter-intuitively decided to go with her. Isn't it the Captain's role to order his subordinates around rather than follow them around? Maybe he wanted to see what she was up to, to keep track of her. Hmmm…
 
 
ORA ORA ORA ORAAAA!!
22:27 / 20.10.08
I've just read the first several hundred issues (up to about 325), in the last couple of days, and it hasn't all filtered through just yet, but to address something mentioned above, I certainly got the impression that when Aizen releases his shikai, 'from then on' the person is subject to complete hypnosis - i.e. it's an ongoing effect and you only need to see the release once to be done in forever.

This makes a bit more sense of the central 46 scene, the fact that people stumble across his 'dead body' at different times (so not all of them could have been there for that release) but they all still see it, and the fact that shinji didn't notice he wasn't being followed by his vice-captain for several days (and the random shinigami on patrol, as well as the captain on the scene [flower-hat-robe-guy - you know the one] saw 'Aizen' that night). I'm at work, though, so I can't go back and check how it's worded when he gives the power reveal, either time.
 
  

Page: 1 ... 23456(7)89

 
  
Add Your Reply