I like Johns' Flash and Teen Titans, and JSA is pretty cool.
just to get that out of the way.
this... this... errg.
Batman can be a dick. that's fine, if not ideal. you can do grim and gritty melodrama. that's fine, if not ideal, too.
you can even give Ted Kord a last stand and then have him killed off. i wouldn't, but that's just me.
but making Maxwell Lord, who's just kind of an amusing, petty shmuck, into a WORLD-CLASS SUPERVILLAIN... that's just fucking stupid. he's not a villain. he's just not. he's just a little shady and out to make a buck. that's the FUN of him, and that's what makes him, oh, i don't know, NOT LEX LUTHOR.
since when has Max had this hard-on for exterminating metahumans? that's just way out of left field.
but, instead, we learn that Maxwell Lord was secretly Lex Luthor all along. or the real Lex is busy with his little cabal of supervillains, so they had to turn Maxwell Lord into him as a stand-in. something like that.
fucking horrible. fucking horrible, lazy, stupid writing.
also, J'onn likes Ted. they could have done a scene where the JLA is just really busy and doesn't have time for Ted's issue, where J'onn has to be the bad cop and say "gee, Ted, we love you, but there's this interstellar war going on, and we're just a little strapped for manpower right now. sorry!" instead of having J'onn be a colossal asshole. Batman can be a colossal asshole sometimes - that's kind of his shtick, but J'onn's basically a nice, if somewhat weird, guy. i can't picture the guy on the Watchtower in this book eating Oreos, you know?
and, for another thing, isn't the point of summoning every Justice Leaguer you can find grabbing all the scrubs too? if you were leaving off the scrubs, it wouldn't be an all-League summons, would it?
also, the point that that reviewer made about e-mail is pretty solid. |