|
|
Oy.
What I haven't seem so far from PW is even an acknowledgement of this:
I'd like to see any evidence of "believes he is often wrong" - humility's a great thing to think you have if you want to feel better about yourself. How about the example above of you telling Randy to fuck off for claiming that your friend didn't exist? Can you show us where he did this? If not, would you like to apologise to him?
Possibly I'm taking the wrong tack, here, but a lot of PW's ire seems to be directed at, for want of a better word, hallucinations of what other people have said. It's the inability to confront the possibility that he is making up reasons to be angry with people which is, I think, the problem.
Hence our PM exchange. I believe that I was inspired to send him a Private Message by PW's demand that I propose that he be banned, and/or move to Private Messages. I reproduce the correspondence with his permission, secured here. Ny words in bold, his in italics, commentary in standard text.
I am not going to start a thread discussing your banning unless and until it becomes necessary. At the moment I am trying my hardest to create a situation in which a discussion about whether or not to ban you does not become necessary. You appear to be intent on frustrating my attempts at pretty much every turn.
I am quite seriously trying to help you here, PW, as are the many people who have taken the time to explain to you why your recent behaviour in the Policy is unhelpful and hostile to Barbelith. I am quite sure that you do not believe that you are doing it \"wilfully\" - that is, that your intention is not specifically hostile to Barbelith - but that really doesn\'t matter. Please just read what people have said to you.
No idea what was going on with the slashes, there - my touch typing is t3h sux00r. PW responds:
I am not going to start a thread discussing your banning unless and until it becomes necessary. At the moment I am trying my hardest to create a situation in which a discussion about whether or not to ban you does not become necessary. You appear to be intent on frustrating my attempts at pretty much every turn.
I am quite seriously trying to help you here, Haus, as are the many people who have taken the time to explain to you why your recent behaviour in the Policy is unhelpful and hostile to Barbelith. I am quite sure that you do not believe that you are doing it "wilfully" - that is, that your intention is not specifically hostile to Barbelith - but that really doesn't matter. Please just read what people have said to you.
Plus, I like you Haus. You're smarter than me. I've told you this, over and over. But stay out of my mind. If you want to know what I feel and think, ask. I may tell you. And how could you possibly know what everyone around here is thinking, eh? Are you commnicating about me behind my back or are you omniscient or none of the above?
If you like, I could send you another PM telling you how I think you are different from I. Would you like that?
Frankly, slightly annoying., I should probably have stopped there. But I didn't. Blame birthday enthusiasm:
And how could you possibly know what everyone around here is thinking, eh?
I know what some people around here are saying, because I read their posts. I have suggested that you do likewise.
http://www.barbelith.com/topic/24716/from/140#post636243
http://www.barbelith.com/topic/24716/from/140#post636251
http://www.barbelith.com/topic/24716/from/140#post636288
http://www.barbelith.com/topic/24716/from/140#post636331
http://www.barbelith.com/topic/24716/from/140#post636349
http://www.barbelith.com/topic/24716/from/175#post636429
http://www.barbelith.com/topic/24834/from/105#post637272
I never said "everyone", and I have no idea why you have made up in your head the thought that I ever claimed to know "what everyone around here is thinking". If you make things up in your head that I have not said, you will, I'm afraid, not be able to respond in a useful way to what I actually have said.
Hence my request that you read what people are saying to you, and why simply parroting my words back to me, as well as being rude and disrespectful - as have your contributions to Policy been pretty much solidly for some time now (ans this is not a commentary on what you feel or think, but on what you do) - is neither helpful nor relevant.
That's a sample of what people are saying to you in public. Private conversations about you are precisely that - private.
Once again, I suggest that you stay out of the Policy, because the other option - behaving in the Policy in a useful or socially acceptable fashion - does not appear on past evidence to be something that you are going to do, whether through capacity or volition. I fear that this is going to create an unhappy situation, which I would like to avoid.
Regards,
T.
Note that PW has hallucinated a claim on my part that I know what everyone here is thinking. This becomes a bit of a problem.
I will no longer respond to you, Haus. You are rude and condescending to people of other cultures. But you are blind to your own faults. I cannot help you SEE anymore.
You might need to listen to some Gil Scott Heron or (Little) Esther. Your soul is obviously hurting and (believe it or not) it's not me who's sticking the sword in.
Good bye and fair ye well.
I aint leaving Barbelith.
Love,
p.w
I was a little taken aback by the idea that I could become culturally sensitive by listening to some Gil Scott-Heron, but of course some of PW's best friends are oh God kill me now. Note that he has also at this point imagined somehow that I have told him to leave Barbelith. It is this delusional process that I think is one of PW's main problems, and I attempted to address it, thus:
I aint leaving Barbelith.
If you can find one place where I tell you to, I will leave myself. If you keep telling lies to yourself about what poeple have said, you will never be able to have an honest relationship with them.
PW's response:
Haus, does it have to be me and/or you?
Look up TUP. And then check out my new threads. I put it on for you. Because I'm sick of fighting in these firty old clothes. I'll even take 'em off if you will do likewise. We both stink right now; and it's turning into another bear-wrestle already.
And I think we should both stay. An that we should both work together tohelp others, as they should work to help us, non?
If you give more new people a break, I'll give you a break. Cool?
I need the loo, again.
Love,
p.w
x (<---- that's my symbol, right there; it means a lot, eh?)
Remains largely inexplicable. I should probably have given up then, but I really thought that if I could get him to confront these hallucinations once, perhaps he could them start to look at the rest of his behaviour:
Haus, does it have to be me and/or you?
No. that's why I asked you to give me one example of when I said you should leave Barbelith. I'm still waiting for that.
Response:
Erm.... Think about the Timing of your posts last night... For starters...
I'm not linking anymore. I want to link arms; but this is the Interweb.
So stop making it personal, you div. You can have the prize money and teh championship. I don't need 'em.
But you know the rules: play straight or let everyone else be bent as well.
X
Not really ontopic.
I am still waiting for you to provide one exmaple of my telling you to leave Barbelith. If you cannot provide one, then I suggest you apologise.
I should have given up by now, I realise. It was very late, however...
PW's response continues the fixation on chess players, but is largely unhelpful.
I am still waiting for you to provide one exmaple of my telling you to leave Barbelith. If you cannot provide one, then I suggest you apologise.
Cheque? Check?
You find one.
xo%?-+X=/* (and other Universal Symbols and mnemes)
Not a clue.
Just one example, PW. That will prove that you actually read Barbelith, rather than respond to things you have made up in your head. While we're at it, I warned you against making things up in your head earlier, and I don't think you've provided evidence of any actual proof of the statement you made up in your head there having existed outside your head either.
If you have in fact been telling lies to me and to yourself, that's fine; we all have our moments. All you'd need to do would be to apologise and to try to do better in future.
PW's response is short, if not sweet.
Are you a lier, Haus?
Still not quite what I was looking for.
Well, if you can find an example of me telling you to leave Barbelith, or of me claiming to know what everybody thinks, then I am clearly mistaken, and will acknowledge such. If you cannot, then I am probably not mistaken in my belief that you are making things up that better suit your personal agenda. If you insist on acting as if such things exist when they do not, then you are a liar, to yourself.
Reading and understanding Barbelith will help any member to contribute in a valuable and worthwhile fashion. No lie.
Again, PW's response seems to skip a few steps:
No lie
Then prove it.
Thought crime, remember?
Not exactly the textual reference I was hoping for, but a 1984 reference, which counts for a lot
Prove that reading and understanding Barbelith will help any member to contribute in a worthwhile fashion? Of course:
http://www.barbelith.com/topic/24716/from/140#post636243
http://www.barbelith.com/topic/24716/from/140#post636251
http://www.barbelith.com/topic/24716/from/140#post636288
http://www.barbelith.com/topic/24716/from/140#post636331
http://www.barbelith.com/topic/24716/from/140#post636349
http://www.barbelith.com/topic/24716/from/175#post636429
http://www.barbelith.com/topic/24834/from/105#post637272
Now, I am still waiting for you to give me a reference to me telling you to leave Barbelith or claiming to know what everyone on Barbelith thought. Or an apology for telling lies to me and to yourself, and an undertaking to think before telling such lies in the future. Surely you weren't presuming to read my mind? I know how much you hate that...
It occurs to me, on reflection, that at this point PW may just be reading the last sentence of each PM and responding to that, as once again we have:
I know how much you hate that...
I hope you do. But you're not given me enough signs to believe it, I'm afraid.
Nevermind.
THIS Game is Over.
X
Again, short on the textual references.
It isn't a game, PW. It's me trying to establish whether you can stand to admit you made a mistake, and whether you will for preference become rude and abusive. this, by the way, is what trolls do. I very much want you not to be a troll. I have repeatedly tried to show you how you are being received by people - from a wide range of cultural and racial backgrounds. If you are unable to be honest with me, please try to be honest with yourself.
And that, I think, was that.
My aim throughout this messy engagement has been to try to make PW aware of how he is coming across, and how he keeps referring to statements which have simply not been made by others, and then, rather than supporting his claims, trying to obscure matters by progressively more incomprehensible, rude and self-pitying responses. So far, no luck, and this thread shows him exhibiting both traits again. It's reminding me a lot of Modzero - and, also, like Modzero, any truce or agreement seems doomed to be shattered the moment one does not do exactly what PW wants, or indeed if you offend him by saying something totally imaginary in his head. I know how we dealt with this, eventually, with Modzero, but I also know how much hassle that was, and I'd rather not go through that again if it could be avoided. However, how do you cope with someone who either refuses or is unable to engage with what has been written in reality? Answers on a postcard, really. |
|
|