|
|
Got pointed towards this article on the Dragon subculture recently. It kind of articulates a lot of the problems I have with the Otherkin subculture.
From the article: "Suspend your disbelief for a moment, and suppose -- hypothetically -- that, once upon a time, dragons really existed. The majestic, wise, and terrible creatures of myth were not mythical at all...
...their souls continued to exist, and eventually were reborn into human bodies. Some of the dragon-souled somehow came to realize their true nature...
What would these people be like? Great statesmen, thinkers, and artists? Would they use their ancient wisdom and noble nature to become influential, wealthy, and powerful leaders of mankind and usher in a Golden Age of peace and prosperity?"
No, apparently they'd end up unwaged or holding down poorly-paid and unrewarding jobs, spending their free time in MUCKs, chatrooms and newsgroups roleplaying "hatchie day" parties and having pretend sex. Now there is nothing intrinsically wrong with having a crap job or being out of work, or with with infantilism, roleplay, or internet sexxings. There is nothing intrinsically fucked up about convincing yourself that you have a Dragon soul. What I found disturbing was the image painted by the writer of a wholly toxic environment where people were encouraged and supported in abandoning consensual reality for a play-party. It's one thing to have a crap job because that's just what's going on in your life atm, and it's another to be stuck in a crap job because you spend too much time pretending to be a Dragon on the internet.
The author harps on in a rather obnoxious manner about the prevelance of obesity in the group, as if this proved something negative in and of itself. Plainly this is a bullshit attitude--one can be big and lovely, big and healthy, big and happy. However, it does have to be admitted that this is not what is going on here. If your Dragon alter ego has arms like two socks full of cantaloupes and a six-pack you could crack rocks on, whereas you yourself weigh 400lbs, something is Not Right. The impression I got was that these poor human bodies simply didn't matter anymore: this is not my body, it's just the human "host" for my soul. My body is not only ripped but can fly, eat people, and probably shoot lasers out of its arse. Therefore instead of loving and nurturing this body (the one I happen to be living in) I am going to ignore it, pretend it doesn't exist. I'm not going to nourish it effectively or give it fun things to do. I'm going to feed it crap and wait for it to die so I can go back to being a dragon.
As with other 'Kin phenotypes, there's a lot of hyoomon-bashing, analagous to the smug comments about "muggles" and "mundanes" that one sees in magical and occult communities. This serves to reinforce isolation from reality and from the rest of the world. Why get out there and mix with people when they are all weak, pathetic mortals, unfit to associate with your noble Draconic self?
Suicide, it appears, is painfully prevalent. No shit.
(NB: although about 50% of the subculture don't actually believe that they themselves are dragons, they aren't challenging the beliefs of those who do. To do so would be a huge breach of etiquette.)
I guess what I found distressing about the lifestyles depicted by the article, and the Dragons and other Otherkin I've come into contact with personally, is that there's no change or transformation going on, no growth. The belief systems seem to be a force for stagnation, substituting a convenient narrative for meaningful action. Why study when you can make stuff up? Why go down the gym when you can just draw more muscles on your alt? Why have friends when you can hang out online with people who can see your Draconic majesty and will agree to call you Lorde NightWing StarBollocks?
There are, of course, people who maintain meaningful practices which have as a componant the idea of interacting with an animal spirit in some way. This might either be as an outside force or as some form of second-self. In the latter case, this will not generally be expressed as "I was an [insert animal] in a Past Life™" but as "I am an [insert animal] right now; there is that in me which is of the nature of [insert animal] and I derive strength from it."
What I notice about people who have this going on in a sane and healthy way is that the emphasis is all on transformation and growth. This is usually expressed as and measured by demonstrable ability and achievement--physical feats, magical accomplishments, intellectual or emotional development (greater concentration, improved mental skills, more emotional stability etc). What can I do today that I could not do yesterday? What can I strive for tomorrow? The beliefs themselves do not fulfill any wishes, it's the quantifiable development and achievement derived from a system utilising those beliefs that creates fulfillment. Make any sense? |
|
|