|
|
Mordant: Hurrah for Grant Morrison! Examining the concepts of sex and sexuality in contemporary comics through a catfight between two gorgeous women, one of whom has big breasts.
There are many different ways of subverting cliche or genre convention for effect. Traditional depiction of comic book heroines is being subverted here, riffing off the existing tropes -- this is one way of accomplishing this. If you want to see see a different form of subversion (possibly with woman of different body type, smaller breasts, et cetera), could you discuss this more? And if your issue is more with the choice of Yanick Paquette as artist -- he only seems to draw one female body type -- I'd refer you to earlier pages of this thread, where that was discussed, and how stereotypical female depication can be used for subversive effect. I'm not exactly happy about Paquette's style - partly because he does favour two, maybe three body types across the board and many of his women end up looking too similar (in that, Alix is at least allowed some diversity), but the choice of two "gorgeous women" having a super-catfight can be used effectively to point out the problems with the genre that generates such catfights (look at Alix's continuing desire to stop the fight and find out what Sally's problem is, rather than continuing the melee).
Bulleteer is about cottage superheroics and the super-powered pornographic industry, there has to be a certain "porn star" quality to the female characters to further this aim - it's comparing/contrasting, to some extent, the wish fulfillment that drives both super-comics and porno. Sally Smart is a child with a particular view of the "ideal woman" she'd like to grow up into, probably because of media portrayals around her, and is given a magical whistle that lets her change into that ideal woman -- and then traps her between her two selves, with no room to grow and move. She is caught being a "gorgeous woman" and a "bad girl," and will never grow or change beyond that.
I'm not saying that the work is a perfect examination, but there can be no perfect examination. Want to discuss your take further? |
|
|