|
|
(This is all so subjective it hurts. If the opinionated stuff starts to grate, call me on it, but know I know it's filtered through my messed up psychology.)
Harley does violate the mythic connection of submissiveness in masochists, which is kinda nice. She's not really submissive to the Joker, in most stories, in that she's really going out of her way to get his attention, desperately, but she also sort of comes at him on occasion with violence directed right at him, as opposed to those around. Almost paralleling the Joker's relationship to Batman for the past forty years or more. She wants the Joker to hurt her, and the Joker wants Bats to hurt him.
Her relationship with Ivy, has a fair amount of deliberately baiting Ivy into wanting to hurt/kill her. The dynamic the relationship spins on is almost the same as her relations with the Joker. Basically, Harley's like watching a version of Butterfly Kiss with more swooning, a laugh track, and no ending. She's never going to stop being fucked up because in some weird way she's functionally fucked up. We see the Joker let go when Bats dissipates into the aether, often, in little 'imaginary stories' or 'elseworlds' or whatever, but when the Joker's not in a Harley Quinn story, if the Joker ain't there, he's replaced by Ivy or some other form of react-with-violence warm body.
Batgirl, on the other hand... wow, I really did want to marry and be Batgirl when I was a kid. Specifically the Batgirl from the otherwise missable Elliot S! Maggin story where she kissed Robin while he was interning for her, beat a Satan-powered Benedict Arnold, and had the whole motorcycling spandexy congresswoman thing going on. Yeah, the purse and the brown-belt limitation are/were annoying, but it's annoying to note that she had to be shot and put in a wheelchair - that is, limited more - before she could be allowed out of those annoying trappings. Like growing up required knocking the legs out from under her. No walking equals acknowledging competence, because she's somehow been reduced down the threat-gauge. Because if she had functioning legs and that brain, it just might be too much!
I know Moore probably never even intended The Killing Joke to be canon, and that none of the various writers or editorial likely got together and planned all this out, but it certainly reads that way. At least, to me. She played damsel-in-distress, innocent side-victim, in Moore's oneshot, and then it's a matter of 'wow, she's exceptionally brilliant and focused' or such. Rather, than just removing the 'and she can't get a black belt' or Batcosmetics stuff.
Is it my funny memory, or was Batgirl on the old liveaction TV show more competent than her immediate follow-up/intro in the comics, while Harley worked the flipside, and got to be more competent and developed in things like Mad Love than she did in those early appearances in the cartoon? |
|
|