BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Weekly review

 
  

Page: 12345(6)7891011

 
 
FinderWolf
16:03 / 29.10.06
Secret Six was also extremely clever in pitting the Mad Hatter against Dr. Psycho - mind-control freakish dwarf vs. mind-control freakish dwarf. I'd never really realized that the two of them are so similar. Go Gail Simone!!

Ult. Spidey continues to rock and go to unexpected places, I agree. And I agree that the Superman/Batman annual was really quite fun and well-done, like a popcorn fun comic with a few exceptionally fun moments. I always love seeing quality depictions of the Morrison-Quitely created new Crime Syndicate (since JLA: Earth 2).
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
20:16 / 29.10.06
Haus: a new Runaways compilation (strong and steay stuff)

I enjoyed this a lot, and I'm glad I've been waiting for the digests to pick these up. I hope the kids don't falter under the new Creative Regime, whoever that is.
 
 
Janean Patience
08:43 / 30.10.06
Haus: a new Runaways compilation (strong and steay stuff)

I just want to know if it's steady stuff or steamy stuff.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
13:43 / 30.10.06
Little of both.
 
 
Spaniel
14:25 / 30.10.06
Planetary: Unbelievably boring stuff. Did this raise anyone's spunk levels?
 
 
Benny the Ball
14:56 / 30.10.06
Was that the last issue ever?

I flicked through it today - not buying anything at the moment, so my comic getting is limited to reading this forum and flicking when in town.

And yes, it looked a little dull
 
 
The Falcon
17:25 / 30.10.06
Planetary: Unbelievably boring stuff. Did this raise anyone's spunk levels?

Raised my ire. Haus is spot on, it really needs to just die. I can't believe after that pish I'll buy the epilogue, but doubtless I will. 12 good issues, and the Batman, back in the 90's, and about 6 issues goodness stretched over fifteen since.
 
 
_Boboss
17:54 / 30.10.06
yes. 'we dropped them in a hole!' o. so, were they really all that worrisome to begin with? no. snow thinks 'i have wasted my life.'

big week for me, nice and quickly:

cap america 22 and 23 - eh - okay, good when the skull does his end of the issue cackle, and perfectly readable really, but the massive-robots-and-action action has been waylaid by civil bollocks war and that's just annoying.

daredevil - not bad or anything, fine really, some lovely anatomy work from michael lark, really great, but, just no, no i'm afraid i feel awfully old fashioned saying this but i don't think dd works that well as a jetsetter, and this well doesn't have the almighty flash and bash that the first arc had.

other side - nice pictures, and nothing bad to say about the script either, it just felt like a nam movie, and that's not a bad thing but i felt i'd seen all this before - i'll give it grow time though, it definitely deserved that much.

nextwave - first ish i've got of this, due to forbush man being in it. dug the doom patrol refs. good fights and jokes in it, except for the editorially bits which think they're very funny indeed but are just shit.

desolation jones - yeh kind of good and gritty stuff with the threat of nasty bloody psychedelia always just around the corner. i'm a little unclear on what happened to jones in his first few pages - was he doing a shit on the floor? it really looked like it. if so then this issue's fucking great, otherwise just pretty good.

authority - yeh good really - it's just the business model that says you can't have an action and superhero free first twenty-odd pages of a superhero book. in an ideal world us pamphlet buying types would just fucking grow out of it and we wouldn't have seen the story until the whole lot was done and out, and there'd be no whinges about this at all.

wildcats - it must have been said before, but 'wildoats' where they're an overt acion team made me laugh in the pub yesterday. very good imagey nonsense - shagging and guns, aliens and damn brash colours. but, um, what? next issue's out in march? for fucksake jim, that's not fucking good enough - see above.

7e7en 7o7dier7 - i'd really rather not have waited but this was very very very good comics. they would have had to reinvent the wheel to justify the time taken, but they just kind of reinvented some superheroes. that's cool too, i love superheroes.
 
 
_Boboss
18:21 / 30.10.06
oh, and punisher too. formulaic of course, but still one of my favourite books on the racks. while i was gettig it there was this like nine year old kid with one of the earlier ennis tbps going to the guy 'have you got anything more like this? doesn't have to be punisher, just something this evil? anything as long as its really evil?'. i'd have to admit, kid's got a good point.
 
 
Spaniel
18:23 / 30.10.06
I'm beginning to think waiting for the trade may be the way to go with this arc of DD. I did that with the o-so-decompressed Runaways and was well rewarded.
 
 
Spaniel
18:33 / 30.10.06
And I'll definitely be doing that with Joss's run.
 
 
FinderWolf
18:33 / 30.10.06
Superman I & II (sort of) film director Richard Donner & Geoff Johns' first issue of Action Comics features a Kryptonian super-baby arriving in a ship that looks like a pound of [circular] cheese. Thus far it's simple, predictable stuff...hopefully it gets better.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
15:44 / 02.11.06
Picked up the big-sexy Phantom Strange Showcase Presents phonebook of love. Terry Thirteen was a tool, even back then, but now I know who Traci's mother is. Makes me sad that they had to make Tales of the Unexpected into the Spectre book that it is, when they could bring in the Stranger and tell some new tales with him.

I like the early formatting of conflicting tales between the Stranger and Thirteen, one of magic and the other of hoax. And the framing devices were usually as interesting as the stories themselves.

Not sure where I stand with Tala, but I still have about half the book to eat (read) before I'm done-done-done.

Cooke & Sale's Superman Confidential features seemingly sentient kryptonite (?) and the World's Ugliest Jimmy Olsen (damn. I'll have to go reread the Quitely Hottest Jimmy version), otherwise it's a pedestrian tale, maybe, so far. I'm not sure why it needed it's own mini.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
05:40 / 15.12.06
After #3, Tales of the Unexpected loses out and drops off my radar. I can't sit through another Spectre story - especially with Batman showing up next issue as part of the Standard Company Formula - just to get to the Doctor Thirteen story, which this issue faltered completely. Much as I love all the individual "Weird DC proto-Vertigo" elements - Anthro, I, Vampire, Doc Thirteen himself, Genius Jones, et cetera - when they're thrown together and treated like some sort of "Dark Silver Age" wonder formula that I'm supposed to instantly react to - well - shit, you know, it's not even like there's a story there anymore. Things just happen, we get some "it's all dream logic" crap, the weird incestual vibe with Traci gets dropped, Thirteen's credibility goes out the window, and I have to wonder: where's the Phantom Stranger?

Really. I would love the series if it was more of an anthology with all those weird elements teased out into their own full-breadth stories rather than crammed into one back-up with a listless "grim-and-gritty" Spectre story up front. The fact that of the two in #3, the Spectre story was *better* suggests something. I'd love the series with Phantom Stranger telling tales of Anthro or I, Vampire and arguing with Terry and bizarre stories of horror or weirdness.

Meanwhile, I *am* enjoying Alan Davis's Fantastic Four: The End, where the FF have become a sprawling dynasty including Wyatt Wingfoot and Thundra, John Storm as a member of the Avengers (no "ny" anymore) and some fun popcorn moments. Kree Sentries.

And, actually, a passably interesting reason behind Inhumans wearing masks which is really just a sideways comment but really made the issue for me, even if they harped on it a little more than it needed.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
01:01 / 29.12.06
Arrr! I'm still reading Ultimate Fantastic Four because Ferry's Johnny Storm is so very, very pretty and I admit I'm digging the weird pseudo-New Gods Thanos-actually-is-Darkseid thing. Cosmic Cubes! Has anyone done any Ultimate Cosmic Cube stuff before?

Also, Blue Beetle is surprisingly good, and has New Gods stuff! Lonar the Great Hunter... sigh. I want a Meso-Aztec-New-God Barbarian loincloth with the zig-zag circles. Mother Box looks pretty Forever People, and we get more hints about this big bad Fourth World event with name drops for Devilance and his terrorizing a planet...
 
 
FinderWolf
03:25 / 29.12.06
>> the weird incestual vibe with Traci gets dropped

Yeah, I noticed that too, what the heck was up with that?!? A bit intense/risque for a mainstream DC comic, no?

I do love Cliff Chiang's art, though, and look forward to seeing him on some majorly high-profile stuff.
 
 
Signifier
18:31 / 30.12.06
This week's Love & Rockets is deeply weird: possibly the first issue in which neither Maggie nor Hopey appear (Jaime's story is all about Ray and the Frogmouth), plus totally creepy sex scenes in Gilbert's stories, a down-and-out Mark Herrera narrating the story of his well-deserved downfall (while naked for no particular reason), etc. Apparently "Julio's Day" ends next issue; apparently the collected version will be much longer, which might even make it make sense.

Also got Daredevil (which resolves the "outing" plotline in a not-quite-believable way), Age of Bronze (still one of the best-drawn and best-written comics out there, I think; just wish it came out more than two or three times a year, but I see why it takes so long), and of course 52, but there's the blog for that...
 
 
Tim Tempest
00:07 / 31.12.06
Care to link to your blog?
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
18:17 / 07.01.07
Do yrselves a favour and go get the Winter Soldier: Winter Kills one-shot if you haven't already, which came out a week or two ago. Brubaker's Captain America has been good, but the last few issues felt a little too entangled in Civil Waugh for their own good - this is less affected, and focuses on what must surely be Brubaker's best achievement on the title, i.e. somehow making the fact that Bucky! Is! Back! (And! Dark!) something that doesn't suck, and in fact gives us a great new character.

It also continues with two of the positives that have come out of Civil Waugh, although you won't find them in the main title itself: Captain America as a plausible hero (after all that terrible Guantanamo apologist stuff he was involved in a couple of years ago, that's quite a feat), and Namor as an interesting character.
 
 
FinderWolf
20:36 / 08.01.07
Is that "Civil WAAAUGGHHH!" as in 'Howard the Duck's famous exclamation'?
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
21:30 / 11.01.07
Picked up the first two issues of Matt Fraction's Iron Fist today. It's taking its time revving up and I'm not sure how I feel about the emphasis on the Iron Fist legacy, although legacy seems to be in the zeitgeist for comics right now so it's a put-up-shut-up situation. Art is slick and sexy although I'm not sure if I like this rendition of Luke Cage. And Night Nurse.
 
 
Phex: Dorset Doom
18:22 / 14.01.07
You quit Tales of the Unexpected at the wrong time Papers- Spectre continues to be horrible, but this month's Doctor 13 has The Haunted Tank, so bad they're good Planet of the Apes references, Infectious Lass from the Legion of Substitute Heroes (I had to look that one up), Gorilla vomit and, possibly, the Seven Unknown Men of Slaughter Swamp!
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
02:04 / 15.01.07
Yeah, but does it fit together and does it make an intriguing narrative? Because while I was still reading it disintegrated into random appearances by cool, esoteric characters that didn't really click much of anything with me. There wasn't enough space.
 
 
FinderWolf
17:41 / 15.01.07
Justice Society of America has been a really great read (issues 1 and 2 are out) - better than Johns' usual writing, and the art by Dale Eaglesham is terrific also...Eaglesham has really grown as an artist over the years and this is by far, his best work.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
22:47 / 08.02.07
Fantastic Four: the End's penultimate chapter is out this week. Alan Davis artwork is a big thumbs up as usual, but I think he likes these big huge epic cosmic sagas too much, with disparate plot threads that all come together (as if you didn't know they would). This one has things revealed which happened off-camera that didn't really make sense as being kept off-camera. Hoping there's a twist on what Sue's trying to do in her particular thread because I think I've got it figured out. Davis needs to steer clear of the cliche of his hero stumbling onto a random villain's machinations with the villain accusing him or her of crashing in on purpose with intent to destroy their plots. Blah.
 
 
FinderWolf
20:26 / 08.03.07
The newest issue of Fantastic Four, written by new writer Dwayne McDuffie (who's written & produced a lot of the Bruce Timm Justice League and JLU animated stuff), features a decent main story with some good character bits and of course, the intro. of the new members of the FF, since Reed & Sue are taking a break from the team to repair their marriage.

The real fun in this anniversary issue (45 years since FF #1 and the creation of the Marvel Universe as we know it) is the backup stories; one written by Stan Lee and drawn by Nick Dragotta and Mike Allred (as a result, the story really looks like it was 100% drawn by Allred even though Allred only inked it), and the second which is written & drawn by Paul Pope, who tells a story of the Johnny Storm/Spider-Man friendship/rivarly that is perfect for Pope's style...Johnny fixing hot rod cars, all the cliches of those Spidey/Johnny stories are touched on here, often to meta-textual effect.

check it out for a good laugh!
 
 
The Falcon
20:38 / 08.03.07
If it has a Michael Turner cover, I am morally obligated not to even consider it, Finder. He is surely the worst comic artist in history, including Stephen Platt.
 
 
FinderWolf
00:03 / 09.03.07
It has an Adi Granov cover.

I'm not saying the issue is particularly amazing, but it's decent writing by Dwayne McDuffie and 2 great backup stories about the FF's anniversary. I bought it (haven't bought FF since Mark Waid left) just to check in on the book, and because I'm a fan of McDuffie from his animated work, and cause the backups looked cool. And lo and behold, they were cool.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
05:17 / 09.03.07
Fantastic Four: The End, ah, ended this week with the sixth issue, wherein Alan Davis wraps up the plot threads with one massive deus ex machina with a famous forked helmet. I think all the Kree/Shi'ar stuff was supposed to be motivated by those weird anomalies they were picking up, which were clearly generated by the main plot and Susan's actions. On the whole, well, who cares? Other than a couple nice pieces of characterization and the beautiful art, this whole miniseries has sputtered to an end having established a moderately intriguing future utopia and a couple shifts to the "status quo" (pointless, being a limited duration alternate future deal).

I liked that the Four were basically in on the actual important action while everybody else was shuffled into a subplot without their knowledge, but I have to say - I'm a little bored of "ultra-rational Reed can't handle magic!" as a defining behaviour, especially given the Waid/Weiringo story with Doc Strange making him learn magic and give up on his own hubris. Although, it's nice to see Sue being the one to be obsessive for once.
 
 
FinderWolf
13:36 / 05.04.07
Birds of Prey continues to be fun, as the new team gels (Barda, Oracle, Huntress, the new female Manhunter [vigilante lawyer] and Lady Blackhawk). I was shocked to hear that Simone may be leaving the book (Dan Didio even blatantly says that Sean McKeever will be writing BOP soon), but was much happier when I heard strong rumors that the reason Simone will leave her beloved BOP is to take over as permanent writer on the new Wonder Woman book, giving that title some much-needed consistency and direction.
 
 
The Falcon
22:43 / 05.05.07
Fraction and Larroca's Sensational Spider-Man annual is, I think, well worth a look if you, you know, ever cared for Spidey. It's really, really good - especially for what's essentially a romance comic with minimal kicks to the face. (I mean, I guess there are certain characters like Spidey and the Flash - maybe even Superman - I'd say, where it behooves the writer to devote a lot of time to pay a lot of lipservice at least to their ongoing relationships, but yeah. Where it should at least be a goodly part peanut brittle, Americana... fuckin' romantic, you schlubs.)

So, I don't really want to spoil it for anyone, but he (Fraction) draws a lot on old continuity without it ever being remotely inaccessible, makes a neat use of the anachronisms of this, does a really clever dual internal narration trick which has some proper emotional punch and makes coherent and appealing the current status quo, which I'm now rather a fan of, given I like my Marvel guys put through the wringer. Defiant. I'm so enthused I give the one panel superhero cry a total pass.

I've not read any Spider-Man comics really since a few Jenkins/Buckingham ones which were decent character-driven, sweet and kind, if a little boring about 5-6 years ago, and before that the big UK reprint books, I guess. Some of which was really good; I mean, the Sin-Eater saga, that's pretty much the gold standard in Spidey, or it was given an eight-year-old's perspective on it, twenty years ago. But this certainly lives up to that perspective, and, furthermore, Larroca delivers the Romita Sr. dimples on MJ.

This is kind of a goofy post, but whatever. It's a neato-keen comic.
 
 
FinderWolf
13:45 / 06.05.07
I can echo der Falke's thoughts on this; I read this and it was really fun. A good take on the Peter/MJ relationship.
 
 
Alex's Grandma
00:44 / 07.05.07
Elsewhere, Der Falke said;

b>You haven't liked any superhero comic except that Batman text issue to the extent you'd share it (in the last six months?), so maybe you should just read Batman? Maybe newuniversal, but that last one was a bit guff.

So ... Well I'm genuinely looking forward to 'The Ultimates' #13, which presumably won't be another drawn-out fight scene. I mean surely it can't.

Other than that, I'm a fan of Brian Azarello's current run on 'Deathblow'. I haven't much time for his Vertigo stuff, personally, but his grim vision seems to work much better when it's applied to characters in the superhero-ish genre, because writing fantasy, paradoxically, imposes certain limits. At the moment Deathblow, who's a character I know nothing about, this after five issues, seems to be involved in some kind of post-Gulf War mind-control experiment in which he goes out late at night to get away from his children, and the sexy au pair, in order to beat up criminals and speak to the only person he can trust in the world, a talking Old English sheepdog. The writing's quite noir-ish, and well-done, and is recommended.

I'm also enjoying 'Astro City', which presumably needs no further comment, and the recent 'Hyperion/Nighthawk' mini-series; I still think that re-imagining Bruce Wayne as an African-American boy whose parents were murdered by the Klan was a stroke of genius, really. Daniel Way and Steve Dillon's 'Nighthawk' six-parter having been a personal favourite, in recent years. In a way that whatever version of 'Wolverine' they're doing at the moment, is not. The idea of a Batman who who sees not just criminals, but specifically white Americans as 'a superstitious, cowardly
lot' seems to open up so many possibilities, both good and bad, in terms of the decisions the character makes.

It'd be fair to say I'm not much interested in 'All Star Superman' at the moment.

Although I am warming to 'Thunderbolts'.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
03:48 / 11.05.07
I picked up the first volume of Adam Warren's Empowered today. 's good, although I think the joke threatens to wear a bit thin at times. I shall make a proper thread probably tomorrow, because it's probably worth discussing.

If for nothing other than the chapter devoted entirely to two characters reading saucy girl/girl and boy/boy slash fiction about other characters in the narrative. Including a guy making out with another guy who looks like a Morrison Doom Patrol reject reinterpreted into a manga hero.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
23:37 / 24.05.07
After the horrifying depression induced by Unnaturally-bent Mary Jane statues doing menial tasks, I have to say my week was significantly brightened when I picked up the first digest of Sean McKeever's Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane, which I thoroughly enjoyed and now plan to pick up the following two digests when I get the chance. Love love love, among many other things, the cameo by Firestar (making me hope that at some point Iceman will show up as well!) and some exploration into Peter's spider-erratic behaviours would seem like to people who don't actually know who he secretly is.

I admit my interest was finally peeked when BUSTER was talking 'bout it here, and today I just grabbed a copy of the first digest to give it a try. Totally worth it and I'm continuing to love these Marvel manga-sized digests!
 
  

Page: 12345(6)7891011

 
  
Add Your Reply