BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Weekly review

 
  

Page: 12(3)45678... 11

 
 
FinderWolf
19:05 / 30.08.05
What comics creators fail to realize sometimes is that getting fans pissed off when they have a character act totally out of character (or kill off characters for shock value alone) isn't always intrinsically a good thing...it's not always the case that any press = good press. 'gosh, they're talking about us, we must be doing something right!'
 
 
Kid
19:30 / 30.08.05
I completely agree, Finder. The problem with this story and, ( if what Willingham's saying is a prevalant thought in the industry) with all these big 'to do' sorts of events is that it's something done purely out of spite to generate some dischord in an already shrinking market.

Congratulations fellas, you've pissed somebody off to the point that they relinquish two dollars and fifty cents one more month. This won't stay the execution of mainstream comics. It's been a long time coming and now it looks like they're taunting the executioner.
 
 
Krug
22:29 / 30.08.05
What a cunt. I'm glad I never spent a red cent on his shitty comics. And even sold the free Fables trades I got from someone.
 
 
FinderWolf
14:27 / 31.08.05
Comics might be delayed this week due to the hurricane disaster - saw this on a comic message board. Call your shops before you go this week to see:

>> Diamond's in Memphis, so everything originates there, I would think next week's shipment might be more effected by the hurricane, depending on when Diamond sent the Memphis books to the local shippers.
 
 
FinderWolf
18:25 / 09.10.05
I will give a shout-out to the strong ending of Gotham Central's recent DEAD ROBIN storyline - nicely done by Rucka, Brubkaer and artist Kano (doing his Michael Lark impression).
 
 
LDones
03:55 / 13.10.05
These threads always die such sad deaths, and I am compelled to systematically describe what I am buying, for better or worse, accompanied by actual reasoning of opinions.

Doom Patrol: Down Paradise Way TP, by Morrison, Case, et al. Just starting in, but I'm looking forward to it. Anybody else feel like Bolland's covers these days have become sort of... standard? By rote? His shapes and color palette seem unremarkable these days, from this latest to that new Alan Moore DCU TP cover. Maybe he's just playing straight to work with the source material...

Livewires TP (Digest Format) Warren, Mays. I read a lot of good things about this 6 issue random Marvel mechatech story, but didn't know anything about it except that the Gen13 guy was doing it and there were robots with Nick Fury's head. Picked up the digest on a lark and, embarrassing subtitle of "Clockwork Thugs, Yo" aside, it's a real joy - just really fast, twisted, manga-induced populist stuff - no philosophical meanderings, just lots of half-cute violence, smash and splode and fun character bits, unsettling plot twists, and a gruesomely fatalistic climax/ending that's extremely satisfying. Great, fast read about a team of five 'mechatech constructs' designed by a top-secret research group and programmed to annihilate other top-secret research groups in the Marvel universe, as seen through the eyes of their newest 'recruit'. They eat each other's flesh to recharge and learn new nanotech tricks and generally behave in morbidly enthusiastic manners. I'd be curious if anybody else read this previously or just picked it up.

Ghost Rider (2 of 6), Ennis, Crain. Officially ashamed of buying this, and ceasing to spend the money on this now. Ennis on autopilot meets overpainted Todd McFarlane-isms. (Huge Bastard in Position Of Power With Submissive Nerdhot Assistant in Glasses! Angels are aloof dicks! I like New York! Also Butts!) Ennis, like some other writers, requires an artist like Steve Dillon or Glenn Fabry, who knows how stupid the material is/should be.

I don't know why every Ghost Rider reboot tries so desperately to clothe the character in White Trash trimmings, but it's painful. As a wee'un I adored Howard Mackie's absurdly convoluted Ghost Rider arcs, even with all that miserable Midnight Sons business. Those issues were crap, of course, but something intangible about Ghost Rider was really nailed then, that made him the popular figure he is in memory now - it had less to do with white trash American identity than with absurd old testament fire and brimstone meeting, y'know, Venom and Dr. Strange. The part of me that likes Ghost Rider doesn't want to relate to him, it wants to be scared shitless of him.

Ex Machina #15 Vaughn, Harris. Starting to get bored with this. The first 3 storylines were really fast, good TV, but I feel like it's been spinning its wheels a bit since then. The payoffs are nice and subtle so far, but the setups are getting hard to bear with, and last arc's forced cliffhangers seem to be sticking around if this issue is any indication.

Yotsuba&! Vol. 1, Azuma. Yotsuba is a small child with a single father for a parent and an overpoweringly positive attitude, who may or may not be an alien. God, what a cute, fun read. Yotsuba is adorable and insane, and Azuma still has that great smug irreverence that doubles as sensitivity. Really recommend this for anyone who enjoyed Azumanga Daioh on any level or who doesn’t cling too hard to cynical or edgy tropes, or has watched a cartoon like Hamtaro and understood, even for a moment. A real breath of fresh air.

I also picked up Infinite Crisis #1 because I am a schlub at heart. More in that thread.
 
 
Tim Tempest
21:06 / 26.10.05
Did anyone else buy "Wha...Huh?!" The goofy parody one-shot marvel put out? I bought it, but haven't finished reading it yet.
 
 
FinderWolf
06:33 / 29.10.05
Wha...Huh? #1 looked like it was pretty mediocre (from my read in the store)....trying hard to be funny but not succeeding very much. The average issue of THE GOON, say, is much funnier.
 
 
Kirk Ultra
19:13 / 29.10.05
Did Wah...Huh? Have Spider-Ham and Bat-Pig in it like the old What The!? comics? Spider-Ham's the man.
 
 
Mistoffelees
20:40 / 29.10.05
The average issue of THE GOON, say, is much funnier.

Reminder: There´s a Goon comic out now for only 25 cents!
 
 
X-Himy
14:19 / 03.11.05
Outsiders 30, by Winick. Why did I even bother to Byrne steal this? Day of Vengeance consequences, some gay sex/incest jokes (in more poor taste than normal), and not much else.
 
 
Krug
17:45 / 03.11.05
What is Byrne Steal? I seem to have missed what it means.

Do you mean download a scan? And if so what's the reference to Byrne?
 
 
Billuccho!
17:59 / 03.11.05
"Byrne-steal" = Reading it in the store. Byrney got all riled up about it and said people were stealing when they read any or all of a book in the shop.
 
 
Krug
05:08 / 10.11.05
Hahahahahhahahahahahahha....

Long live John Byrne. A fountain of eternal amusement.
 
 
Spaniel
07:21 / 10.11.05
I really think people need to make a bit more effort with this thread. It's called the weekly review, for cryeye, so I don't think it's asking too much for people to put some thought into actually reviewing their weekly purchases.
 
 
Benny the Ball
08:16 / 10.11.05
I picked up the Bulleteer and Desoloution Jones this week (I order online so they arrive about a week after release).

Bulleteer - kind of fun start, the whole thing of her husband being desperate to be a hero, any kind of hero, was interesting. The art is very cheesecake, but it was a nice book. I'm kind of half reading the 7S series, trying to save it all up to re-read once complete, but this book felt more stand alone than the others.

Desolution Jones - Jones gets into a fight, he sits down, he talks a lot. I'm really enjoying this book, even though it's drawn out, the art is great and the characters are being well put together, despite a lot of them feeling created for the moment (I'm putting this down to the fact that it's a new series and that the support cannon is still being drawn up).
 
 
Krug
23:04 / 08.02.06
Ennis just concluded his latest arc on the Punisher. Between the ott violence, moral simplicity, Ennis' macho social vengeance fantasy has a beaten poetry to it. I wonder how long it will take for it to get old and I'm pretty sure (or hoping) Ennis will continue for a long time and kill off Frank by the end of it.
 
 
Alex's Grandma
00:38 / 09.02.06
Is, or I should say was, anyone else reading Nighthawk by Daniel Way and Steve Dillon? It's just that I'd rather not get into this if I was the only one.
 
 
FinderWolf
03:03 / 09.02.06
I'm glad I'm not the only one who's enjoying Ennis' Punisher. It amazes me how he continues to, for the most part, tell engaging, intelligent, well-written pulp crime stories which are basically the same revenge/justice story over and over but have more than enough twists, turns, and interesting ideas to keep them feeling fresh and original.

I mean, it's the Punisher. We know what's going to happen, he'll kill the bad guys. But Ennis keeps managing to get my interest (except for 1 or 2 failed or uninteresting arcs here and there). I mean, in superhero comics, it's the same thing, the hero will win (well, usually), it's the getting there that we care about, and if that getting there is well-executed. But Ennis doesn't have the supporting cast or other facets of the superhero genre to fall back on, so he keeps managing to come up with unique scenarios and topics for his Punisher arc (the NYPD declaring that they will take Frank down once and for all, Punisher goes to Russia to deal with nuke silos, Punisher tackles a prostituting ring) that somehow really work despite how cliche they might sound in plot summary form.

I think a lot of it has to do with Ennis' voice as a crime writer having grown a lot...even the dialogue/first-person narration is usually pretty sharp.

But I haven't even looked at any of the Supreme Power spinoffs - I only read the main series by JMS, which is ok and was more engaging at the beginning of the run but which is now starting to lose me a bit...
 
 
Axolotl
19:40 / 09.02.06
Ennis's work on The Punisher is really good. It got a bit patchy towards the end of the Marvel Knights run, but really took off again once it moved to the Max line. I've picked up the first issue of his new Nick Fury series (I think it's a mini-series) but can't whole-heartedly recommend it. Sometimes I think Darick Robertson's a certified genius, but sometimes his work just seems well below par. Whether it's an inker thing I don't know, I'd need to dig out some old stuff and look at the credits.
What I did pick up and really enjoy was "the Middlemen" a black and white thing on Viper Comics (I think). It's about this temp who get mixed up in the titular quasi-official agency investigating all the weird shit that goes on. It's written by one of the writers from Lost and the art has a kind of cartoony retro feel which works really well with the tone of the book. The've just started a new arc, and the tpb is out now. I highly recommend it.
 
 
DavidXBrunt
06:04 / 10.02.06
A strong week for me. Fables was perhaps the weakest issue so far but then I find when it moves away from the main narrative for these side steps it's always that way. Still a fun read with unusual art.

Jonah Hex continues a strong run of one off tales that are true to the spirit of the original character but updated in terms of content and style. A great book. If you've not tried it check out issue 3, guest starring Bat Lash, the dandiest cowboy of them all.

Best of all though was the bargainous D.C. Showcase Presents The House Of Mystery. 500+ pages of spine chilling and rib tickling sillyness with contributions from (among others) Jack Kirby, Sergio Aragones, Bernie Wrightson, Len Weinm and jaw droppingly great Gil Kane work. Wonderfully silly, overblown nonsense which'll set you back £10.99/$16.99/$22.99 )delete as appropriate) but will be more than worth it for the mariners ghost story, or the one with the cats, or The Man Called Kane, or the silly Page 13's or...
 
 
FinderWolf
17:17 / 11.02.06
Yeah, FURY #1 was pretty weak, and I say that as someone who loves most of Ennis' Punisher work and really enjoyed all his War Stories books over at DC. I also noted that it ended with a note of 'to be good at war, learn to enjoy it' --- isn't that the same line of thinking that got Ennis in trouble with Marvel over his MAX Fury series a few years ago? (The mini showed Nick Fury as a grizzled solider who missed serious war, this was pre-9/11, and some old Soviet foe of his starts a major warlike incident just so the two of them can engage in their old brinksmanship and fighting. It showed Fury as a character who really just wanted to kill people, missed having a war to fight, was ok with manipulating things to create war cause he missed it so much and was ok with his old Soviet foe doing the same. The story goes that George Clooney was interested in doing a Nick Fury movie - maybe to erase the memories of the David Hasselhoff Nick Fury from the public consciousness, although Clooney's a lame choice for Fury also - but read the paperback of Ennis' super-violent MAX Fury mini and was disgusted, this got back to Avi Arad and Marvel felt they'd lost the chance to make a major movie with Clooney's people.)

I'd also recommend ACTION PHILOSOPHERS written by Fred Van Lente -- they got a Xeric Grant for it, they named their self-publishing company Evil Twin Comics, a terrific name if I ever heard one. Very fun stuff; it tells little short stories about humanity's greatest philosophers.
 
 
Solitaire Rose as Tom Servo
18:54 / 11.02.06
This week? Franklin Richards was a hell of a lot of fun. 4 short stories with kid friendly art and witty stories. I'm betting most comic fans looked at it, shook their heads and moved on. It reminded me of the GOOD Dell comics that kids could read and like and adults woudl enjoy as well.

Young Avengers is normally a lot better than it was this month, and the character work they have done so well in the past was completely gone this issue for all plot. That wouldn't bother me if the plot was any good.

Superman was the first part of the three part Golden Age Superman, and they had six artists on the damn thing. I liked that they worked with his early exploits as kind of a "leftist hero of the working man", and we'll see if this is more than just "fanboy continuity porn" or if they are going somewhere with it.

I gave Sensational Spider-Man a try, and regretted it. Angel Media can draw well, but he didn't here, and the story was no great shakes.

I Heart Marvel Web Of Romance, however, was a blast of fun to read and showed that Tony Bedard can do more than autobiographic comics. It's the best Spider-Man story in ages.

Batman: Legends of the Dark Knight had a story by Eddie Campbell that I liked, but DAMN, I can't take Bart Sears's freaky muscule drawings.

Now I'm off to read Showcase: House of Mystery. I was kind of shocked that they started the horror run with reprints...I think it means that they made the decision to go with short horror stories quickly.
 
 
FinderWolf
15:07 / 12.02.06
Not Tony Bedard, but Tom Beland, of TRUE STORY SWEAR TO GOD fame. Former editor Bedard has written Exiles and some CrossGen stuff.

And let me just add about FURY #1 that the logo for that book is one of the worst, most boring logo designs on a comic that I've ever seen.
 
 
DavidXBrunt
20:59 / 12.02.06
I think they started with reprints cause Orlando got the editorial job very close to the deadline for a new issue and nowt had been commisioned because it was close to being cancelled. He picked stories that would show off the style of thing he wanted and, not the least, to have a very cheap issue which would help if the next few issues didn't sell well. It would help keep the series from the accountants grip while he worked it into what he wanted.

I could be wrong but that's what I read.
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
00:18 / 14.02.06
Quiet week - Just Marvel Zombies 3 and Runaways 12.

Marvel Zombies is basically ridiculous. In a parallel dimension, the Marvel heroes have been infected by a virus that turns them into largely unkillable (albeit decomposing) cannibalistic corpses. For some reason, it has also made them all talk in exactly the same way. Having devoured every human they can find, they sit around and discuss being zombies and, whenever a non-zombie appears, they eat him. That's pretty much it. There's a ghoulish delight in watching Captain America with the top of his head chopped off, or Giant-Man carefully chopping bits off Black Panther to keep his meat fresh and uninfected, though, but this is basically undemanding zombie fun.
 
 
Jack Denfeld
00:58 / 14.02.06
I want to get Marvel Zombies. The covers look super cool.
 
 
FinderWolf
01:14 / 14.02.06
I agree about the covers - some of them are really hilarious. I'm thinking specifically of the X-Men #1 parody cover...made me laugh out loud. I haven't read much of the actual comic...though 'basically ridiuculous' seems to sum of the appeal from what I've seen in a few cursory skims.
 
 
Solitaire Rose as Tom Servo
02:22 / 14.02.06
Marvel Zombies is puyre over the top fun, but it's kind of silly to buy any Marvel mini-series as individual issues. They come out as trade paperbacks within a couple of weeks of the final issue, and end up being a buck or two cheaper than buying them as individual issues.

I'm flipping through them on the stands, and they look fun in an over-the-top way.
 
 
LDones
02:25 / 14.02.06
The consequences of their latest meal had me laughing pretty well.
 
 
Jack Denfeld
03:13 / 14.02.06
Who was their last meal?
 
 
LDones
03:26 / 14.02.06
To spoil it partially, the Silver Surfer shows up on Marvel Zombie Earth to herald the coming of his master.

Let's just say a bit later Zombie Captain America nukes Zombie Hank McCoy's face with his Kirby-bolts and Zombie Iron Man becomes a cosmically powered floating torso with a lust for Galactus brains.
 
 
Jack Denfeld
03:44 / 14.02.06
Goddamn I want the trade when it comes out.
 
 
Markle Sparkle
18:22 / 15.02.06
LOL! Marvel Zombies was excellent.

Also read and enjoyed over the last month or so:

Girls - I just started my first ever Lith thread about it.

Y - The Last Man - I felt like this was starting to slip a little but this most recent issue picks it back up and made me fall in love with it all over again. Monkey dreams!

Nextwave - worthy of the hype and its own theme tune. Looking forward to more of it.

FF & Iron Man - Big in Japan - Wow - I was totally blown away by everything about this short run. The art was mind-meltingly awesome... the colors, the lines, the manga in-jokes... I sighed audibly when I read the last page of the last issue.

BPRD - I love the direction he's been moving the characters in.

Fables - waiting for this storyline to be over and for things to be interesting again.

Franklin Richards - Everybody Loves Franklin - Did anyone else read this? I know nothing about it but loved it. Was it a once-off?
 
 
FinderWolf
18:49 / 15.02.06
I think there were some back-up Franklin Richards by the same guy in recent Marvel comics...that's all I know about this. It looked fun.
 
  

Page: 12(3)45678... 11

 
  
Add Your Reply