BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Weekly review

 
  

Page: 1(2)34567... 11

 
 
BrianFitzgerald
20:43 / 17.03.05
I just have to give a thumbs-up to JLA #112. Busiek's story, which grows out of last year's JLA/Avengers crossover, started very slowly, but the last two issues have brought the heat. This week's issue beautifully handled a multi-universe team-up of the JLA, JLE, and JSA, and
.
.
.
.
S
P
O
I
L
E
R

S
P
A
C
E
.
.
.
The New Gods (in a total joycore entrance that made me literally speak aloud, "Holy Shit!!!")
.
.
.
E
N
D

S
P
O
I
L
E
R

S
P
A
C
E
.
.
.
against The Crime Syndicate (who Busiek writes deliciously), the antimatter world of Qward, possibly Krona (the big bad from the JLA/Avengers croosover), and at least two other baddies who have yet to step out from the shadows.

Very cool stuff. Not convinced yet? Two more tidbits, then:
.
.
.
S
P
O
I
L
E
R
2
.
.
.
Due to the crossover with the Marvel Universe, the forces of good no longer get a guaranteed win in the DCU. Last issue, the Crime Syndicate humiliated the JLA, realized the playing field had been levelled, and started their rape of the JLA's earth. I haven't seen the JLA scared like this in a long time.
.
.
.
S
P
O
I
L
E
R
3
.
.
.
The teams have to split up to deal with the multiple threats. While the big guns hit the cosmic and planetary threats, Batman, Hawkman, Green Arrow, Black Canary, and Plastic Man go to the Crime Syndicate's earth to stir up hope and rebellion. Did I already say "Joycore!"?
.
.
.
E
N
D

S
P
O
I
L
E
R
S
.
.
.
 
 
FinderWolf
21:16 / 17.03.05
Busiek may be telling a fun story in JLA, but Ron Garney's art on that book repulses me so much that I just can't do more than skim it in the store and groan. I liked Garney's Capt. America work just fine...it seems Garney's art has actually gone a bit downhill, plus he's been put on characters I don't think he really fits with.
 
 
Pooky Is Just My Pornstar Name
03:52 / 18.03.05
Grimoire from Speakeasy comics. The first ish just came out this week, so there's still a chance to pick it up at your local comic shop. First issue is the set-up, obviously; the story is pretty standard - girl protagnist with magical powers is at odds with mother, while looking for absent father. Magic books, creatures, flying carpets, and one smart racoon familiar abound. So far, the book seems to be all ages rated. So if you've got kids in your life that enjoy reading and/or comic books, you might want to let them read Grimoire. For preview pages, go to: Speakeasy and take a gander at the lovely art, which looks a lot like animation cells.
 
 
FinderWolf
15:39 / 21.03.05
I have to say, even though we all know he's a conservative psycho and was going to do that horrible-looking Freedom Power or whatever series with CrossGen, Chuck Dixon is turning in a fun Bat-world story like he used to over in the pages of NIGHTWING: Year One. I enjoyed Dixon's work on the bat-titles for years until just before he left the DCU, when I felt he was beginning to get stale and start to hack things out.

I know even Dixon in his prime is hardly Alan Moore, but I felt his Bat-stuff was always solid, entertaining, fun, like a pretty well-written action movie (up until his last year at DC as I mentioned above).
 
 
FinderWolf
20:29 / 25.03.05
Any reading that Chaykin-written Russ Heath-drawn LEGEND miniseries? It apparently is based on a sort-of famous adventure novel GLADIATOR or something by someone named...Philip Wylie, from the 1930s, which supposedly inspired characters like Doc Savage and Superman? Heath's art is ok, gave it a skim...the writing seems typical cliche Chaykin "hero who fucks a thousand hot girls" sort of softcore porn.
 
 
Solitaire Rose as Tom Servo
09:40 / 02.04.05
OK....I had to do an unexpected overnight shift, so I actually got to read a bunch of comics the week they came out (I'm SO far behind). Quick notes on a few of them:

Flash 220: Geoff Johns can do stuff I really like in JSA, but why does this book always feel like it's falling just short of being good? This issue was all set-up to let us get to to know Flash's Rogue's Gallery AGAIN.

Pulse #8: I know it's trendy to bash Bendis, but this issue was the best I read this week. Jessica Jones is offerend a LOT of money to join Hydra, and with just a simple conversation, Hydra is interesting. Don't know where the story is going, but it's leaves the questions there in such a way that I want to know more.

Outsiders 22: Issue long fight scene tying up plot threads and showing that Infinite Crisis has been in the planning for quite a while...or Winick is good at mkaing it seem like his stories have a point. Either way, a perfectly average super-hero comic.

Spectacular Spider-Man 26: I think I would have enjoied fucking a toxic waste barrel more than the "Gwen Stacy's Kids" stories. I hope this stuff gets shoved in the same box as the Spider-Clone, Gwen's Clone and The Rocket Racer, never to be opened again.

Astonishing X-Men: A transition issue in the story, and while it wasn't BAD, it seemed like it was all exposition, and very little of the snappy Whedon dialogue that usually brings the book above average.

Legion of Super-Heroes 4: More world building, and a fill-in artist already. Still, Waid keeps things going with smart dialogue and a nice twist. So far, I'm liking this Legion re-boot.

Secret War 4: With this book being quarterly, it's not holding together all that well for me. It's also moving pretty damn slow to be wrapping up next issue. I can't judge it singularly, but will have to wait and read it all at once.

Fantastic Four 524: The last issue by Waid and Wieringo, and it's pretty clear that they both love these characters. A nice tribute to the characters with a very "Silver Age" plot.

Countdown: Meh. The entire plot structure seems like it was copied directly from Identity Crisis #1, where we spend an entire issue learning about a character, just to see them die, so that the death has more impact. Most fanboys will be loving this, but I just saw it as very lazy writing, and I really expected better for Johns and Rucka.
 
 
Solitaire Rose as Tom Servo
01:34 / 06.04.05
OK, I have to ask after reading the first three issues of the Age of Apocolypse story:

Is there anyone on the face of the planet who has half a clue about what is going on in this book?

All I could figure out from reading it is: This is a sequel to one of the worst comics in Marvel's history. And it can't even get that right.
 
 
Haus of Mystery
10:36 / 06.04.05
Surely only a halfwit would buy it in the first place?
 
 
FinderWolf
15:09 / 06.04.05
Marvel said at a recent press conf. that AOA is selling so well they might make an AOA regular series.

NOOOOOOOO!!!!!!
 
 
fluid_state
15:58 / 06.04.05
Or they could just give Chris Bachalo a decent series.
 
 
XXII:X:II = XXX
05:21 / 07.04.05
As much as I dig Bachalo's idiosynchratic style, he's far too often completely opaque in his layouts, and he often oversaturates the image with inks, which are then colored far too darkly. Honestly, I've not seen anything by him that wasn't completely muddy since the early days of GENERATION X, and even then I might have been cutting him slack because I loved his work on GHOST RIDER 2099 so much.

This week I broke a long comics fast, as there were a number of things I really wanted that all came out at the same time. So what the hell, I get a discount, so here's what I ate ramen to afford:

POWER PACK #1: Actually, I hate the writing on this. I am, admittedly, biased, since I wanted to write a POWER PACK series that would have been in continuity and gone in a completely different direction than this. I'm such an old school fan, one of those cultists for whom it came into their lives at just the right time and is the reason I'm still reading comics. But it's so fucking annoying that every time they try to resurrect this book they feel the need to go directly to a fight with the Snarks. Hello? Has anyone actually READ the original series? The Snarks used to represent this dreaded menace; now they're like a termite infestation that returns every spring. The art is nice and clean, and if this were marketed somewhere other than comic shops it might have a chance at success, but since that ain't happening I'm not holding my breath. Still, it's so unfathomable that the majors can't market anything that's not manga-flavored to kids; had I had my shot with this book I'd have gone in a different direction visually, too.

DEATH JR.: I don't know if it's a function of Ted Naifeh's personality or that the only books that Slave Labor seems to put out anymore are all gothy in some way, but seeing him on this book just makes me wish he'd do more COURTNEY CRUMRIN or a sequel to HOW LOATHSOME. He's a big talent and despite that he's got a spindly, vaguely Tim Burtonesque style without being Jhonen Vasquezish, I so wish to see him do something not predictably goth. Of course, goths buy comics, so you can't really fault him for working to his strengths. But he's one of those people I think could do just about anything, so why doesn't he?

BEAR #7: Haven't read it yet. I have no idea why this gets filed under 'goth,' even if it is from SLG. He even rags on goths in this issue. This is so consistently hoohah funny. I like to read it aloud in funny voices.

DEEP FRIED v.2 #2: Also haven't read it yet. I'm not crazy about the longform stories Youngbluth has started doing with Beepo, Roadkill and Squints; I prefer if he's going to do longer narratives that he break them up over sequential issues. Variety is one of his great strengths. Just the back cover of this issue, a spoof of Super Nintendo-era ads for peripherals, sold me on the issue.

There were also a couple things I wanted to get but finances dictated I put back:

TRUE STORY, SWEAR TO GOD #12: Tom Beland is a very fine gentleman who gave me the rough for a page out of #7 or 8 which looks as good as the finished product, signed, for having been a solid customer since SPX 2000. That's classy. His comics are candid, funny and truthful, about the star-crossed way in which he met his future wife and left his entire world behind to go to Puerto Rico to be with her. There is definitely a niche waiting to be filled for romance comics that aren't schmaltz, and right now he'd seem to be one of the few in that niche.

GREAT LAKES AVENGERS #1: Dan Slott is a bud. A short, round bud. He makes me scream laughing, and he knows entirely too much about the Marvel U. When I suggested to him he write an unwinnable battle between Mr. Immortal and Madcap, he scoffed and pulled outta his chubby ass a far more obscure character that he correctly surmised would make for a more interesting matchup. The gag in this first ish with the classified ad and one of the respondants is just gold. That, and "The Quinjetta," followed by Monkey Joe's disclaimer. Just fucking GOLD.

/+,
 
 
FinderWolf
12:34 / 07.04.05
>> POWER PACK #1:

I really liked the original PP series; this new one just looks soo awful.

And yeah, True Story Swear To God is fun, well-told stuff.
 
 
-
13:43 / 07.04.05
AOA: i happened in to the shop and i dont buy comics but Bachalo and Townsend you can't go wrong. ok i might be willing to pay for 6 books. i go in a couple of weeks later and they have up to #5. ok. 2 looks good. (now i don't remember exactly) 3 is Bachalo and finishes by 5 other guys. ok they're not his explosions, not his rocks, i can deal with this, but it takes away from the style of the whole thing. and i'm missing Townsend already. same with 4. 5, the art has deteriorated so badly that they're not Bachalo's characters anymore. i mean, you use an artist or a writer to sell a book, i'm thinking mini series, these guys are already ahead of the game. not. well, Marvel fooled me, got my $3. they could have done a nice job with one artist, one inker per issue. but don't let a team fall apart like that.

and where were the brilliant neon colors?
 
 
Solitaire Rose as Tom Servo
03:58 / 08.04.05
Just for the record....Death Jr. is a video game tie-in, and the fact that Ted is working on that instead of his own stuff makes me very sad indeed.
 
 
XXII:X:II = XXX
05:20 / 11.04.05
Yes, I discovered that to my horror a couple days thereafter. I'd always prided myself on not being one of the dinguses (dingi?) who comes into the store and only buys STREET FIGHTER and BLOODRAYNE and the like. To have taken that step closer to them, despite having no functional game system newer than the Atari Lynx, makes me shiver, and to have somehow encouraged Naifeh to possibly participate in such crass cross-marketing again makes me mad. And contrary to my previous statement, DEATH JR. is published by Image. Videogames for Image is like what goth is for SLG. There's a vortex of suck that happens when videogames and goth are combined that the wonderful talent that is Naifeh may be unable to overcome.

Other notes on books I purchased the other day:

DEEP FRIED v.2 #2 is at least half recycled material from off his site and his minicomics. Even the cover is two years old. I'm going to give Yungbluth a piece of my mind when I see him at MoCCA.

BEAR #8 is very funny, but not as funny as other issues. I understand now why the book is called "Bear" and not "Looshkin"; he can't support the book on his own.

/+,
 
 
FinderWolf
14:14 / 19.04.05
Ult. Spidey has been decent (with the Hobgoblin storyline), and even though Devin K. Grayson's run on Nightwing (which I mostly skimmed or read in the store) has
gone in and out, I kinda like the idea of Dick Grayson doing a Donnie Brasco and going undercover in a mafia family to get at the big guys. And I really like Phil Hester & Ande Parks’ art on the book.
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
16:28 / 19.04.05
Finally got my hands on the Paul Pope Solo: brilliant, especially the one about the city.
 
 
FinderWolf
19:00 / 03.06.05
Re: Jeph Loeb and Ed McGuiness' bizarre parody of the Ultimates this week in SUPERMAN/BATMAN --- don't quite know what to make of this. It's a straightforward parody, but the Maximums don't recognize Batman and Superman? And meanwhile, there's Bizarro and Batzarro as Batzarro kills his parents in a 3-page scene of backwards Bizarrospeak? And Bizarro speaks normally and intelligently when presented with blue kryptonite? Trippy...
 
 
FinderWolf
11:59 / 10.08.05
Gotta ressurect this thread to say that the "Dead Robin" Gotham Central storyline that's running now has been pretty great so far (although it does evoke a POWERS storyline in my mind).

Also, Hellboy: The Island was fantastic, and Runaways by BKV continues to delight - this latest storyline with Victor Mancha, son of Big Marvel Supervillain, is the best yet, I think. Favorite lines include Gert calling Ultron 'Speak and Spell' (sad to think that people under age 25 will probably not get references like that anymore) and Victor, when discussing Doctor Doom, says "His name's not 'Doctor SEMANTICS!'"
 
 
Are Being Stolen By Bandits
12:50 / 11.08.05
Gotham Central is indeed on top form at the moment, although Kano's art in the latest issue seemed a little 'off' to me - it was the first time I can remember being genuinely bothered by the "I can't tell the characters apart!" syndrome which lots of people have seemed to find problematic with this book in the past.

Of course, the 'Dead Robin' arc would be a lot more effective if it weren't so heavily reminiscent of the first issue of John Byrne/Jim Aparo's "Many Deaths of the Batman" story, too...

On a more positive note, it was refreshing to see Montoya's lesbianism used as the source of an incidental 2-panel joke, rather than an issue-long rumination on sexual politics in the workplace - for the first time in a while, she came across as a well-rounded and interesting character who just happens to be gay, rather than a heavy-handed "issue-raising" plot device. The core appeal of the book, for me, has always been the ensemble cast, and the near-exclusive focus on Montoya and Allen over the last few issues has been frustrating. It's been a pleasure just seeing the likes of Driver, Chandler, and Stacy again, and I really hope Rucka continues to use them once Brubaker actually leaves the book, following the current story.
 
 
rabideyemovement
02:34 / 13.08.05
I have read the Chaykin series LEGEND, and I enjoyed it thoroughly every issue... until the end. W T F ??? I'm a big fan of Chaykin's work, but the last four pages of this series was ridiculous, and a total cop-out ending. My friends and I were all quite shocked at this most terrible of finales.
 
 
Solitaire Rose as Tom Servo
22:29 / 21.08.05
I was shocked at how much I like "Ultimate Spider-Man Annual". It coudl have been complete fan-wank/slash fiction, but instead it put a nice cap on the "break-up with MJ" story arc, as well as showing how uncomfortable it can be to be a teenager. I don't know where they are going to go with it (if anywhere), but it's a story development that rang true for me, and made both of the characters involved seem a little more human.

I also read the Captain Britain/Betsy/Sub-Mariner reprint, and the Captain Britain reprint was horrible. Just everything bad about comic book dialogue, crappy art and a story that simply was a waste of paper. The reprint of the X-Men issue showed that Claremont, even at his wordiest, used to be a decent storyteller, and had a nice little plot that used the whole team, rather than a simple fight comic. The Sub-Marnier story (reprinted from a Human Torch comic from 1941) was typical Marvel Golden Age story where it seems that they are just making it up as they go. I wouldn't say it's good, but I do like the Marvel Golden Age stuff just for how insanely goofy it is.
 
 
Axolotl
10:46 / 22.08.05
Anyone else picking up Godland by Joe Casey & Tom Scioli. I'm not sure about this book, it's good fun, well paced with a nice mix of expostion and action, but it's basically a Kirby pastiche (not that there's anything wrong with that) and I'm not sure if it's going to develop beyond that.
Still it's worth checking out if you fancy a bit of Kirby-style silver age fun.
 
 
FinderWolf
12:43 / 22.08.05
Ultimate Spider-Man Annual #1 was really terrific - one of the freshest, most fun things Bendis has done in a while. Great idea to pair up Ultimate Peter Parker and Ultimate Kitty Pryde for dating.
 
 
Mr Tricks
20:37 / 25.08.05
Picked up that second issue of GøDLAND. It's fun but also kind of an annoying read. Seems to highlight the weaker aspect of Casey's writing. There certainly potental there, It's visually enjoyable but I just don't know how sustainable it will be once you get past the Kirbyesque WOW factor.

Was very disapointed with the newest TOP 10 mini debute.

Daredevil was very solid but comics have been rather lame of late. I find myself rereading older stuff with greater satisfaction.
 
 
Axolotl
07:34 / 26.08.05
I picked up the Ultimate Spiderman annual and it was great. Good mix of fight scenes and character interaction. I don't know if the storyline should be developed further but it was a good fun comic book.
Unlike the Ultimate X men annual which was dross. poor art, poor writing, just yuck.
 
 
FinderWolf
20:13 / 26.08.05
Quesada said in a newsarama interview today that he's 'not quite sure Bendis is finished with Ultimate Gwen Stacy yet'.... (ominous music plays) So we're either going to get more Gwen flashbacks or Gwen-as-female-Venom-Carnage?
 
 
FinderWolf
14:11 / 30.08.05
The Batman books lately have been pretty weak, and I speed-read the last Detective issue - it's the whole thing with reporters clamoring on about Stephanie/Spoiler getting killed in the stupid War Games Bat-crossover event. It comes up that someone denied Stephanie medical treatment, and none other than crappy writer Bill Willingham reveals that Leslie (can't remember her last name at the moment, but she's Batman's doctor friend who took care of him after his parents bit it) was the one who denied Stephanie treatment to protest Bats taking kids under his wing in the superhero game.

The issue ends with Bats tracking her down, yelling at her and telling her she's a murderer. She defends her position but is a tiny bit ashamed. He says something like 'I better not see you again.'

The end. What an awful story. Leslie was one of the stalwart Batman friends; it's like having Alfed become a villain because he doesn't approve of what Bats does. If I cared more about what's going on in the Batman books lately I'd be annoyed. What's funny is that there's only a tiny bit of complaining about this among fans - seemingly because not many other people are really following the Batbooks lately with any enthusiasm (apart from blithe interest in the 'why is Jason Todd alive again' plot).
 
 
The Falcon
16:08 / 30.08.05
If that's the same Leslie as was in Brubaker's Catwoman, it's a pretty saddening waste.

What the fuck's happened to my 'City of Crime' I want to know?
 
 
X-Himy
16:29 / 30.08.05
Yes it is the same Leslie Thompkins from Bru's Catwoman. The same Leslie who is a staunch pacifist, trying to convince Batman that not only should he not kill, but that he can stop crim with even less violence. Not only does the story suck terribly, but it makes no sense for the character (neither does the finish of that story, which was just so confusing I stopped reading).

In addition, Alfred just killed a guy to protect Bruce Wayne's identity, in Gotham Knights I believe. Simply rubbish, though it will probably be revealed that the guy just tripped in some lobsters and mousetraps (a la Simpsons) before accidentally dying.

I gotta say that I have like Anderson Gabrych's writing on any of the bat-titles, particularly Tec (before Lapham's run). I wouldn't say that he necessarily writes stories that break the internet in half, but he writes stories that use the characters very well. Each story follows whatever crappy continuity he is forced to write within, and oftentimes makes them better. His small contributions to the War Games mess actually added a measure of sense to the whole proceedings. And he somehow works with artists that I like. Unlike Willingham's artist on Robin, who was so muddled the entire thing was unreadable.
 
 
Hieronymus
16:43 / 30.08.05
It comes up that someone denied Stephanie medical treatment, and none other than crappy writer Bill Willingham reveals that Leslie (can't remember her last name at the moment, but she's Batman's doctor friend who took care of him after his parents bit it) was the one who denied Stephanie treatment to protest Bats taking kids under his wing in the superhero game.

Bless you Finder. Here I was about to start looking into the Bat books again (stopped reading them just before Knightfall really) and you just saved me the trouble. I owe you one.
 
 
Mr Tricks
16:58 / 30.08.05
well here's a reveiw on that War Crimes mess... BATMAN's bummi'n these days
 
 
Hieronymus
17:05 / 30.08.05
Jesus christ, Willingham. Breakdown much?

Here's something you readers need to realize: Though we generally hope readers will like our stories, hating them is almost as good. Hating them so much that yours is the one book everyone is talking about now -- well that's golden. One can't hate without passion and involvement. The one reaction we most fear is indifference.

Yes, I'm a little put out by the (at least three and counting) reputedly male readers who posted testimony that they wept after reading this issue (one claiming it was for the loss of innocence). Not that I believe they actually did. But I'm still from an early enough American generation to find men claiming to act like overly dramatic little girls just a little bit cringe-making.

And of course there were scores of those claiming that this incident was the last straw and they're giving up my books, or the Bat books, or all comic books, forever. Here's a splash of water for everyone who ever has or ever will make such an hysterical claim on a message board: We never believe you. If you're the type to indulge in "how dare they do that!" we know you'll always be back for further outrages. Those addicted to indignation need constant indignation feeding.

But, that aside, all is good. Feel free to blame me for ruining Batman. I could claim that editorial mandates were in force here and thereby split the blame a bit, but I think this time I won't. I willingly took the job, and I'm too greedy to want to share the credit this time.

How do you like them apples?


That sound you're hearing is Willingham urinating on his own mealticket.
 
 
FinderWolf
17:22 / 30.08.05
Willingham's writing on Fables is ok, mediocre and entertaining with a few clever ideas, but his writing on Robin and the Batman books is really bad, I think.

Bat-editorial mandated that Leslie go bad...bizarre. Is Bob Schreck still the group Bat-editor? I can't imagine this would happen on his watch.

On the other major Bat-subject, Jason Todd, one theory I just heard that's interesting is that Talia al'Ghul brought Jason back from the dead using a Lazarus Pit to distract Bats from the Secret Society's machinations (and she can further use him to throw Bats off his game when they attack all the heroes).
 
 
Jake, Colossus of Clout
18:21 / 30.08.05
Wow. What a total asshole.

"Blah, blah, blah... I don't give a shit about the fans who pay my rent... blah, blah, blah... You'll buy whatever shit I put out and like it, fanboy worms... blah, blah, blah... You're pussy little girly-men and I'm an old-school tough guy..."

The more I think about it, the more that guy pisses me off. If was buying any of his books, I'd stop.
 
  

Page: 1(2)34567... 11

 
  
Add Your Reply