|
|
Understood. First off, I should say that my not caring about your life or death has less to do with you than it does my own unwillingness to see the thread turn into a place for personal attacks...put a different way, I believe that right now my life, or yours, or Ibis', or whomever's, is secondary to the overall good of the nation, and the world. I realize it sounded like a personal attack, and it probably was -- to cheerfully announce as a counter-argument that someone is "full of shit" is the death of intelligent discourse. To be honest, if we kill it here, I'm not sure where it's likely to survive. And that's not grandiosity, either -- when the most intelligent conversation one can find on the internet is located on what is ostensibly a blog devoted to obscure comic books, the world is in huge fucking trouble. Which it is, clearly.
I am sorry that you felt/feel personally insulted by what Ibis had to say, but unfortunately, your emotions still have not proven her wrong. I would not like to think that a person I loved was in any way evil, insane, unreachable, etc., or any other nasty adjective one may apply here. But when it comes to judgment on a Bush voter, it seems to me we have few options -- that person is either vile (which is to say, they have a clear understanding of what Bush represents and are okay with it), deluded (they have an understanding of what Bush represents based on religious beliefs that do not correspond with consensus reality), misguided (they have what they believe is a clear understanding of what Bush represents, based on the same evidence the rest of us have, but they are in point of fact not right), stupid (their vote represents a Stepford Wives-style falling in line with the perceived standards of their community, unquestioned), or ignorant (their vote represents an understanding that is either incomplete or based on shallow evidence).
NONE of these things are things we want to be true about people we love, and yet one of them must be the case. Therefore, it is unlikely that most people who did not vote for Bush will tell you the thing about Bush voters that you seem to want to hear -- that there was anything right about their decision. Aside from brain damage, it is hard to imagine a scenario that would lead a person to vote for Bush that does make that person seem, at best, horribly reckless. They made the wrong choice, and America will suffer for it. None of us likes to suffer, and it's unlikely that positive thoughts will be directed at the agents of suffering. I am sure the friends and family you are referring to love you, but I am equally sure that through hate or negligence they have committed a hateful act. If you take criticism of these people personally, I'm sorry; but the actions of the Bush administration are AFFECTING a great many people personally, and not positively.
That said, loathing for such people is unlikely to sway hearts or minds...which leads us back to the original question. In your experience, is it any way likely that any of the Bush voters you know can be made to see that they were wrong? |
|
|