BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


New X-Men #139

 
  

Page: 123(4)56

 
 
Matthew Fluxington
22:56 / 16.04.03
I took the "playground bully" remark to be a criticism of certain smug leftists too.

And as much as I pity Scott, who is being belittled by virtually everyone in the comic in one way or another, I mostly pity him for wearing that ridiculous motorcycle gear with the x-trenchcoat.
 
 
Quireboy
23:21 / 16.04.03
Morrison's been building up to this for a long time. Ever since Jean and Emma clashed at the end of E is for Extinction. Jean asked: "What makes you such a bitch?" Well now she's found out.

I know a lot of people will be sorry to see Emma go - she's been my favourite character in NXM. But as Jean says she always causes trouble and that goes double now she's apparently dead. "What if the real enemy was inside all along," warns Quentin in NXM138. It is now: suspicion threatens to destroy the team.

Morrison's storytelling in NXM is straightforward. All the major plot twists are foreshadowed. For example in NXM114 Cassandra threatens Xavier that she'll become him and make him a murderer - two issues later she does. In NXM134, Herman Glob says there are four Stepford Cuckoos not five - and two issues later Sophie dies.

So now think how this pattern fits with Emma's apparent murder.

The obvious prime supect is Jean - given her history with the White Queen and that she's just discovered Emma's been having a psychic affair with her husband.

In NXM128 Jean herself says: "Everybody at the school seems terribly worried about my expanded telekinetic senses. Basically, I need you to tell Scott I'm not turning evil, Charles."

In NXM131 Beast warns Emma: ""Don't mess with Scott and Jean's marriage. It's undignified. And Jean will kill you."

Jean has the most obvious motive and she is one of only two X-Men (bar possibly Xavier) capable of killing Emma - by shattering her diamond form with telekenisis.

But consider these comments by Jean when fellow X-men have expressed concern about the return of her Phoenix powers:

In NXM122 Scott says: "Jean you know what happened last time you lost control of these enormous thoughts of yours.

She replies: "Do I look like I'm losing control? These are different times, Scott. Everything is different.

Then in NXM128 Xavier says: "The X-Men underwent great trials and loss during a previous rogue Phoenix manifestation on this planet. people died. No one wants anything like that to happen again, Jean."

And she replies: "I know. It's nothing like that."

Morrison's not going to rehash the Dark Phoenix saga. Although in NXM132 Araki warns Xavier that "The Phoenix has hatched ... And she is merciless", he talks about "disinfection". Now this might be another word for ethnic cleansing but I think it's more than that.

Consider Emma's comment: "Jean had a little rummage around in my mind and knocked a few things over. She can do that...she's more than just a telepath...she sees right through us and gets to decide whether we're innocent or guilty. Like a judge and jury."

This goes back to Araki's comment about judgement being passed down on mutantkind - "nature itself has chosen to deal with your kind." Jean may be judge and jury but she won't be the executioner. The Phoenix will cleanse the mutant race - having received taste of her own unethical use of telepathy and forced her to confront her own weaknesses, Emma has evolved, casting off her emotionless diamond form.

I don't think Jean is 'going psycho' as Kingsalamander says she's becoming a paradiagm. But this issue also recalls Xavier's conversation with Jean just before she asks him to investigate her emerging Phoenix powers. He says: "I see her [Cassandra] now as an agent of nature, testing its own boundaries, forcing change into stalemated systems. And yet ... 16 million mutants had to die to prove a point to humanity. I can't help wondering ... I wonder if we have any control over our own destinies or if we are just biomass maniulated by an intelligent evolutionary process itself." Cassandra - as the host of the mummudrai was one part of that evolutionary process ... Jean as the channel for the Phoenix is the other. Where Cassandra was a carpet bomber, Jean will surgically remove potential cancers from the mutant race. So I think Quimper may be onto something - this could be more psychic surgery than a catfight.

BUT I THINK THE MOST LIKELY EXPLANATION FOR EMMA"S APPARENT DEMISE IS:

She literally falls to pieces while transforming into diamond form. Why? Well every time she's confronted with or overwhelmed by unpleasant or traumatic emotions Emma has turned into diamond - in which state she has no telepathy, no emotion. For example, in the annual after reliving Xorn's memories and feeling the death of the mutant catepillar girl she goes diamond saying: "Enough ... enough. I've had quite enough of these painful emotions. I have no telpathic powers in diamond form and no empathy. No compassion. Just a cruel sense of humour and a cold, hard heart."

In NXM138 Emma, clearly distraught by the Stepford Cuckoos scathing criticism goes into diamond form rather than confronting/considering their criticisms. And she later tells Scott she's checking her nose for cracks.

So in NXM139 when she turns diamond in a bid to contain the mountain of emotional turmoil that Jean's telepathic onslaught throws up her system can't take it and she shatters - or at least her skin breaks off.
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
23:28 / 16.04.03
I will be very upset if Jean did not kill Emma.

I will also be very upset if Jean's Phoenix-fueled dementia is portrayed as being a good thing.
 
 
Quireboy
23:30 / 16.04.03
So, if Emma really is murdered are there any other suspects? The Cuckoos don't have the power to shatter her, especially after the loss of Sophie. Scott was away from the mansion. The only other X-Man powerful enough to destroy the White Queen and the Institute's unknown quantity - Xorn.

Xorn appears to possess a Zenlike calm - and with the special class he has been shown to be more adept than his fellow teachers at finding his students wavelength.

Recently we've seen a rather sinster side to him. In NXM135 Basilsk says: "You look like a total serial killer Mister Xorn."

Then in NXM136 Xorn kills the U-Men who've been stalking the special class. And he tells a shocked Angel to keep it a secret. You could say he acted in self-defence. But when the U-Men attacked the school Jean humiliated them - and like Xorn destoyed their trucks - but unlike him she didn't kill them.

Then in NMX138 - the infirmary scene. Quentin is undergoing unstable secondary mutation. Does Xorn really liberate Quire from his pshyical cocoon - or kill him just as he seems to be on the verge of making a major revelation to Xavier: "What if the real enemy ... was inside all along?" Xorn uses his energy blast on Quentin - which we've only ever seen him kill people with.

So he's a healer - but one who wears a deathmask. He's a godlike being. One who gives life and takes it. Or possibly he's a psychopathic healer in the Harold Shipman mold - a British doctor who killed hundreds of his elderly patients.

And consider this from the NXM annual - a communist official says: "he was only kept alive because they [the Communist party leaders] imagined he might be turned loose as a doomsday soldier in some future conflict with the enemies of the Republic ... is Xorn linked to the Weapon Plus programme? Is he Weapon 11? And he is looked up in Feng Tu prison - which Emma reveals is the name of the capital city of Hell.

As Domino says: "Seven little words, one awful concept: Unknown, insanely powerful mutant on the loose."

But what would be his motive? Well if he killed Quentin - his obvious next target would be Jean - as only Omega level telepaths would stand a chance of reading his star-mind - while a telekinetic could match his gravity and energy powers. But as jean is already far more powerful than Quentin he can't risk an open confrontation - so he kills Emma, knowing Jean will be the prime suspect - getting rid of her that way.

HOWEVER, on balance I think this is unlikely. It's too convoluted. There's nothing in NXM139 to tie him to Emma's death, or to suggest he sees Jean as a threat. Anyway, he could simply have not healed her at the end of Imperial. But thinking about it does make me wonder if he has some tie to the Weapon Plus programme.

Xorn and Jean increasingly sem like complementary opposites though. Xorn as Zenlike healer and Jean as wrathful purifier.
 
 
Quireboy
23:45 / 16.04.03
Emma's comments about Jean losing her humanity and being a playground bully are on the mark I think. If you're omnipotent do you need anyone else? I've compared the Institute to the Bush administration before and seen Jean as the Colin Powell figure. But perhaps Xavier is the dove and Jean the hawk - and her disinfection of mutantkind a telepathic form of regime change?

In Claremont's run Jean chose to die to preserve her humanity, given that Morrison's said he wants to see what will happen if she really becomes a goddess presumably this time she will chose to give it up.
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
01:35 / 17.04.03
Waaaaaaaaaaaaaay back when NXM was starting up, Grant said something vague when describing the "Man From Room X" in a Wizard interview, something to the effect of "he has the most deadly secret of all."

That could fit in well your speculation, Quireboy.
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
01:52 / 17.04.03
I'm definitely feeling the "Xorn is a wolf in sheep's clothing" thing, by the way. I'm pretty sure I was the one who first suggested that Xorn murdered Quentin, but I hadn't even thought that his motivation was to silence him before Quentin outed him. That's probably exactly it. But was Quentin talking about Jean or Xorn? Or everyone in the cast?

I think Grant intentionally downplays the negative effects of 50 years of solitary confinement to keep us from noticing Xorn's malevolent side. Even after the creepy events of #136, I think most people went back to "Xorn's a nice zen weirdo." But there's just no way he can be a sane, well adjusted guy, with or without the godlike power, you know?

He's still friendly and nice and good natured, though. I believe him when he says "if I could save everyone, I would." I think Xorn and Jean are being set up as examples of what happens when people with good intentions are given incredible power, and what can go wrong. It's the Spider-Man "with great power comes great responsibility" on a global scale - with huge far-reaching ambitions comes very difficult questions about morality.
 
 
Raw Norton
02:56 / 17.04.03
I was drawn to the muscled-face in the corner of that one page as well, and I associated it with QQ, when the cuckoos psi-blasted him. Someone here identified that as the cuckoos metaphorically stripping away Quire's outward image, revealing his vulnerable self. Which, to me, totally applies here, too.
Speaking of stripping away ridiculous images, why is no one celebrating the disappearance of Logans goatee? Just one more reason to love Jiminez.

Having said that, something about Jiminez's work on this issue, coupled with Emma's confessed cosmetic surgery, has led my to weirdly conflate Emma and Fanny...
 
 
fluid_state
04:57 / 17.04.03
How many people have possibly "gone conceptual" in NXM so far? Magneto, Quire, Emma, Sophie (all arguable)... and the special class, the "new" X-men, have a conceptual member of their own (somewhat less arguable). I'd bet on Xorn being the murderer, except I'm not sure anyone's been murdered yet. What if he healed Emma of that frighteningly long backlog of dirty, mean karma? What if she just stored all that psychic trauma into an unbrakable physical form?
 
 
onorthocrasi
05:36 / 17.04.03
great discourse here on n xmen guys... the connections you all have made have enhanced my enjoyment and understanding of the series.

One thing that really stuck out in my mind about xorn after reading issue 138 was quentins deathbed comment "look at the curve of time... manhattan is gone... the school is gigantic!" It's the school is gigantic line that strikes me, it remindes me of the new xmen annual where someone is talking about xorn saying something like "he could have powered 10000 communist super cities". Those 2 lines seem like potential foreshadowing to me especially in the light of xavier stepping down and a need for a new headmaster... maybe one with a name starting with the letter X.

I certainly think it is a good possibility that xorn is the "murderer"
but maybe (especially since it seems that in some form emma is still alive) he simply facilitated her metamorphosis in a similar fasion as he did for quentin.
 
 
Simplist
05:41 / 17.04.03
Speaking of stripping away ridiculous images, why is no one celebrating the disappearance of Logans goatee? Just one more reason to love Jiminez.

I'll celebrate that! I suspect it was an editorial decision and not just Phil bucking the man, particularly since Logan's hairstyle has changed as well, suddenly conspicuously resembling that of Hugh Jackman in the X2 posters.

As for Emma, I very much doubt she's dead in a permanent sense, though she may appear to be next issue, if for no other reason than I can't see them killing off a character and announcing a new series featuring her in the same month, even if the series does focus on her earlier life. My guess is she was partway into some kind of metamorphosis when the process was interrupted by our ill-meaning "murderer" (who may or may not have intended the degree of harm that appeared to occur, ie. murder may not have been the intention). I predict Emma reappears in some form at the end of the arc, but that even she remains unaware of just who "interfered" with her.
 
 
I'm Rick Jones, bitch
07:06 / 17.04.03
Wait- in what sort of context is Emma's body seem in? Do we see her dead in the real world, or is there the possibility this some sort of psi plane thing?

(By the way, anyone know of a decent comics shop in middlesborough?)
 
 
LDones
07:32 / 17.04.03
solid state's comment above about Emma storing 'psychic trauma into an unbrakable physical form' strikes an interesting chord w/ me. That particular 'mutation' did manifest itself directly during/after the attack on Genosha - It may have been as much an emotional mutation response as a physical one. A defensive asset that became a handicap, preventing her from healing - So perhaps Xorn shattered it to heal her.
 
 
I'm Rick Jones, bitch
07:32 / 17.04.03
Also, here's a crazy fucking theory about Jean I've had for a while- what if Grant's going to dust off one of his Invisi concepts for the mainstream and have Jean "step outside the game" at the point of her final mutation? Jean is going to become a godess- in a western philospophical sense of the word, God equals begininglessnes and endlessnes (a neccesary being) and God equals omnipotence. The Phoenix is "all that lives and all will ever live" or whatever (hate that phrase)- hence it is omnipotent- perhaps when Jean finishes her secondary mutation she'll move beyond four-dimentional timespace and become a fifth-dimentional being, existing in a state in which beginings and endings are inapplicable, manifesting fourth dimentionaly as a big fuck off "Phoenix force". That'd be a pretty interesting way to smooth out the garbled wreck of continuity. Although if Jean has to manifest the Phoenix to evolve into the Phoenix, that's a hell of a paradox.
 
 
Nietzsch E. Coyote
07:34 / 17.04.03
I think it is grant's love of Reichian Therapy. Someone helped her remover her emotional armoring.
 
 
I'm Rick Jones, bitch
07:48 / 17.04.03
If Jean disinfects mutantkind by removing it's negative aspects, it's going to be a boring fucking series after #150. I'd suggest a more biblical event- either a cataclysmic purging or a symbolic gesture- a Christ-like sacrifice?

Then again, both of these concepts have been done into the ground. I hope Granty-boy hits us with a real curve ball.
 
 
perceval
08:14 / 17.04.03

Of course, who's Emma to throw stones? This is someone who's regularly violated people for kicks. Emma's favorite tactic is to break someone down psychologically. Now, she's gotten a taste of her own medicine, and has discovered it's not as fun when you're on the recieving end. At least Jean had to be provoked.

And Emma did a lot of provoking, here. She was deliberately pushing Jean's buttons, trying to make her as enraged as possible. Normally, Jean's reserved, calm, rational, but when you set her off, things are going to fly, sometimes literally. Logan, of all people, once had to calm her down so she'd stop dropping cars on Sebastian Shaw. Emma figured with Jean in that state, she could break her down, reduce her to a crying wreck. It backfired.

E
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
14:54 / 17.04.03
Jean's not going to 'disinfect' anything. She's going to fail.

Doesn't that seem very obvious?

I think Xorn is going to become the new headmaster too - Emma's out of the picture, Scott and Jean are headcases, Logan is Logan, and Henry might not want the job since he prefers to be a doctor/scientist. Storm and all of the other people who would be obvious candidates are in other X-books. It's all set up for them to hand the school over to a potentially dangerous person whom they barely know.
 
 
Suedey! SHOT FOR MEAT!
15:03 / 17.04.03
Hooray! (I mean, storywise, that's cool. I don't often cheer potentially dangerous types being in control of important establishments...)

Also: anyone else notice the (not so sly) dig at the "Search for Cyclops" mini-series? Made me giggle.
 
 
Quimper
15:30 / 17.04.03
Did anyone else think "King Lear" while reading the scene with the Frosts? Daddy Frost (Lear) is giving his estate away to his three daughters, Emma (Cordelia), Cordelia (hee hee) and Adrienne (Regan and Goneril). Christian (The Fool) is useless to him. Instead of getting daddy's fortune, Emma goes into exile, much like Cordelia. In Lear, Cordelia returns to her father a better person, married to the King of France.

Another Lear reference by Morrison! Tom-O-Bedlam, anyone? And speaking of the Invisibles, is that magic mirror in the big panel featuring Emma's surgery?

And notice how Daddy Frost describes his daughters. Cordelia is subtle, dark and devious. Adrienne is cold, heartless and brilliant. All traits taken on by Emma in her White Queen fiction suit.

The last page kind of reminds me of the biblical Garden of Eden tale. If Scott and Jean are the Adam and Eve of the X-Men, Emma is the serpent. Serpents shed their skin in times of change.
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
15:39 / 17.04.03
Just in case you were getting some ideas, Grant did NOT make up the names for Emma's siblings. They've all been established in previous comics.
 
 
FinderWolf
15:51 / 17.04.03
I TOTALLY thought King Lear in that scene. Morrison definitely draws on a wide and diverse array of sources -- The Prime of Miss Jean Brody & King Lear, to name some recent fonts of inspiration!

I agree, it's the whole Reichian shattering of her emotional armor thing, snake shedding the skin, etc. She'll be back, no doubt. Morrison loves her far too much, and so do we
 
 
Quireboy
16:14 / 17.04.03
The King Lear comparison is spot on. And Sleazenation told me that Emma's supposed to be based on Morrison's current girlfriend, while Jean is based on his ex. Which suggests she'll be back.

I though Emma's comments that Jean was losing touch with her humanity were rather significant - this is the danger of Omega-level mutation. Emma was by far the more sympathetic character throughout this issue.

I was struck by how Jean seems to be developing into an Old Testamnet God - will her dissinfection be the mutant equivalent of the Flood? Contract that to Xorn - mutantkind's Buddha. She passes judgement while he enables the special class to find their potential.

If Jean is to evolve further then she needs to move more towards eastern philosophy - I'm sure Grant's setting up a comparison here, especially with the introduction of Dust. And didn't he turn Wonder Woman into a goddess in JLA - making her haughty and unapproachable.

Jean's psi-attack was very reminiscent of Quentin Quire stripping Slick's self-image but on a much deeper and more humiliating level. Jean's line about Emma being enfolded in her thoughts was creepy. I also liked the desciption of the fire of the Phoenix burning away lies and deceit, seeing through self-deception like an X-Ray. And we all know what happened to Quentin - he got a taste of his own medicine. Perhaps Emma will be back in an evolved form to dish that out?
 
 
Simplist
16:38 / 17.04.03
[Emma's diamond form] may have been as much an emotional mutation response as a physical one. A defensive asset that became a handicap, preventing her from healing - So perhaps Xorn shattered it to heal her.

I think you nailed it, LDones. I'd bet this is exactly what happened, though it probably won't be revealed on-panel until well into the Phoenix arc, possibly setting up a confrontation between Xorn and Jean (as he attempts to do something similiar for her?).
 
 
Quireboy
16:41 / 17.04.03
If it's not Xorn who does that then perhaps the transformation happens once Emma's left alone - both Xorn and Jean (as Omegas) could have the potential to kickstart further mutation.

But I like the idea of it being Xorn and that setting up a showdown with the Phoenix given my thoughts about them as contrasting deities.
 
 
Quimper
17:53 / 17.04.03
I also like the idea that Emma's shattering was due to Xorn's healing touch. It reminds me of a scene in Generation X after the kids took on Black Tom. They were on a raft in the middle of the ocean. Husk was stuck in a transitory phase, like a cocoon. Chamber didn't know what to do so M shattered the cocoon so Husk could heal. Her line was that they learned in class that metamorphs sometimes need external help to transform.

But the real meat is what Quireboy said about Old Testament God vs. Buddha. I do think Dust's role will be to take Jean away from judgement and more toward growth and enlightenment. Maybe she will eventually reject her role as Tribunal of Mutantkind and have to fight the Phoenix entity herself as Jean Grey. Emma's comment "What's in there were YOU used to be" is very significant. Jean's most prominent characteristic has always been her human emotions. She will not relinquish her humanity so easily.

I think the next time we see Emma, it will be in an 11th hour appearance during a time where the team is in distress. If she had an epiphany before, she will again. But this time it will be benign now that she is healed emotionally. In E is for Extinction, she showed up at the last minute and saved the day (sort of). In Imperial, she showed up at the last minute and saved the day. Third time's a charm.
 
 
sleazenation
18:37 / 17.04.03
I think quireboy is giving me a bit to much credit - it is only my *theory* that emma is based on Kirsten and that jean is based on his ex - but the physical resembelence is striking and proceeding from that and Grant's reluctance to do bad things to people who look like him (although he did put his new avatar Xavier through the wringer at the start of his run) leads me to believe that there is more to Emma's apparent demise than first appears. Having said that - Grant has also said that the "death" in the mansion will be left open throughout his run so we will probably not see emma again untiol grant has gone.

Is there any difference between the way grant is doing this and the way chris claremont would kill people only to resurrect them later? I guess that's a whole other question...
 
 
Mr Tricks
19:03 / 17.04.03
Anyone remeber Phil's first Invisibles story arc?

Looks to be like this is Emma's Shamanic Initiation.

I think the running theory about her Diamond/emotional armor is pretty spot on. I'm wondering if perhaps the emotional "unraveling" she experience had her "emotionally shattered" and an attempt to become diamond had her fall apart on her own, the flaw being an internal one. There was no murder, just the suspicion of one.

Dug the "Search for Cyclops" comment as well...

also what's up with HANK showing up with a bottle & Roses???

History:
Emma's been killed before & reconstituted her body (after inhabiting Iceman of all people) She's also swapped minds with Storm. So it's reasonable to suspect her conciousness has experience with out of bod experiences.

Perhaps an aspect of her resolving emotional baggage will be to reconstitute her own body. "Pulling herself together" in a mannor of speaking
 
 
makeitbleed
19:31 / 17.04.03
Maybe it's just me, but I found the background of the panel towards the end of the issue where Hank is gleefully singing his way to cheer up Emma hysterical.

In an ironic way.

Contrast Hank's almost visible bouncing to rescue a damsel in distress (and maybe get some) with the evidence of the destruction of the school from the riot.

And the riot isn't even the latest calamity in the past few days for these people.

The first time I read it I was wrapped up in the excitement and tension of the story and the panel had a completely different emotion. I'm finding this is easily to most interesting issue of Grant's run to re-read.
 
 
Quimper
19:48 / 17.04.03
That background is fantastic. I love that he's a) checking himself out in the mirror before he sees Emma OR b) looking at the medium-sized crack in the mirror right before he sees Broken Chandalier Frost on the floor. Kinda makes you forget about the crack in the mirror.
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
20:05 / 17.04.03
More foreshadowing: back in Germ Free Generation, John Sublime ponders smashing Emma's diamond body to make a "kinky human chandalier."
 
 
Mike-O
02:57 / 18.04.03
Xorn certainly appears to be the most likely "suspect" in what will likely be Emma's transformation, physically and emotionally, as has been made evident by you bloody philosophers and sooth-sayers. Wonderful insight by all, truly. Whether he has healed her, or destroyed her in an attempt to resolve the situation will be interesting to see (mind you even his involvement is purely speculation, but I digress).

Given Morrison's affinity for these characters, and his distaste for stagnant storytelling (thank God), I think it's resonable to assume that in all forms he is constantly evolving his characters, much as this "Shattering" will most likely be an evolution of Emma's character. What strikes me is just how built up all of this has been... He is undoubtedy the most prolific and epic creator to have ever touched the X-Men concept, in my eyes. Perhaps the most dominant theme within his run as been the idea of emotional repression, and it's consequences. Look to each character and you will see this to be true: Emma's repression of her insecurity; her dysfunctional childhood and what as much thus produced in her early adulthood with the Hellfire Club, and how even her mutation has come to serve this inherent psychological complex... she is is an emotionally confused individual, and by that she is able to do things that are quite insensitive but in the end she ends up more confused than ever in an attempt to understand/reconcile that resultant pain. So she finds herself in a cycle: pain causes her to remove herself from the reality of her actions, which in turn results in more pain for her to run from. Ultimately, that leads to repression and stagnation, when all Emma really wants is to feel loved and truly understand who she is. But instead what has resulted is an unavoidable fear of making the journey to understanding, of facing herself, and that fear throttling her in the form of Jean's "exploration" and exploitation of as much. She is her own worst enemy, as we all are through neglect of reconciliation with our own complexes.

Compare her dysfunction outward to the rest of the cast (especially relevent in these issues): Hank's insecurity(#117, #122), Scott's (#116, #126, #131, #136, #139), Xavier's (#121, #131, #138), Jean's (#120, #128, #139)... Xorn as being repressed through his inprisonment and torture (NXM Annual), and the way the effects of as much have been expressed in his actions (#136, #138, possibly #139). God, even Logan has been shown as controlled by his dysfunctional psyche through his manipulation at the hands of QQ, or Cassadra's attempt to manipulate him animalistically...

The cast is undoubtedly emotionally repressed due most prominently to their inability to reconcile their respective complexes, which in the end results in their stagnate vulnerability. But I think it is Morrison's intention to see them through as much, to evolve them through trial and consequence to individual's who possess self-understanding and enlightenment... though he is making them partake in that journey under the pretenses of mutancy as well. God, this all works on so many levels. And Emma is just the latest example of this, but likely not the last.

More than anything, New X Men seems to be about vulnerability, brought on both internally and externally, and thus how we combat as much to grow as individuals and as a species.

Excellent issue by the way, but Jimenez was smoking the pipe when he drew that image of Cyke on the bike... Hahaha...
 
 
Raw Norton
04:29 / 18.04.03
Fave dialogue of the issue-
Scott: It's not what you think...
Jean: It's exactly what I think.

Has anyone yet pointed out that Beast's sexuality is only further muddled in the last two pages. Not that singing opera and bearing roses are greatly hetero tendencies, but still...

And yeah, Xorn is definitely my lead suspect. Which I hate, b/c all my reasons for suspecting this are very dull; much as I'd like to picture Xorn as the elevated, mutant-Buddha ascendant headmaster, I think he's likelier to be the awfullest mutant in creation.
The basis for my suspicion lies in all-too-human, character-based reasons. Simply put, years of isolation are likelier to produce a murderer than a savior. Xorn possesses ridiculous power and lacks "people skills." Here I think he killed Emma in a simple, childlike attempt to help Scott, his friend. Here's what else: Xorn's crude attempts at justice will somehow threaten Manhattan. That's based only on my understanding of Xorn's character plus a vague sense of foreshadowing in the Xorn issue of NXM (i forget the issue.) In New York, Xorn saw humans abort an act of mutant metamorphosis; I suspect some other event will inspire his wrath on this grand scale. After all, since NXM started, NYC has twice been the setting of human-on-mutant violence.
Not to say that Xorn will actually destroy Manhattan; Jean will stop him. It's a logical conclusion. Grant has created two uncertainties:
1) Who will head the school?
2) Who killed Emma Frost?
The likeliest answers to either questions would be Jean and Xorn (significantly, the two mutants that best represent mutation-as-evolution/trancendence). It seems that one mutant, representing human advancement toward enlightenment, will head the school; the other, violent mutant, represents progress's tendency toward self-annihilation. I've already stated my reasons to suspect Xorn as a threat to Manhattan; my conclusions are likewise supported by the "rules" of superhero comics. Much as it'd make sense, Marvel simply won't let Jean Grey, all-American girl, be a cold blooded killer; Xorn, being a GM original creation, is pretty much disposable. Likewise, Marvel obviously won't wipe out Manhattan, hence someone must stop him. Who else but his thematic opposite, Jean Grey?

And, yes, I realize that I've really gone too far out on the limb this time...
 
 
Quireboy
07:33 / 18.04.03
I'm more inclined to think that Xorn will have to 'stop' Jean after reading this issue.

I think Xavier's comment about humanity being manipulated by an evolutionary process is the key to what Grant's doing with the Omega/cosmic characters. Cassandra destroys Genosha after giving Trask a lesson in caveman genocide - and her actions transform human/mutant relations. The Phoenix will disinfect mutantkind - removing the toxic threat it poses to the universe. In this context Xorn's killing of the U-Men could be read as a purging of an inferior hybrid species that has no place in human evolution.
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
11:21 / 18.04.03
I think Quireboy's right - chances are, The Phoenix is here to destroy Xorn, but we've been misdirected earlier on to believe that it was Charles Xavier or Quentin Quire.

I don't think Xorn or the Phoenix are meant to be villains or heroes - they are just awesome, terrifying forces of nature with very good intentions.
 
  

Page: 123(4)56

 
  
Add Your Reply