BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


New X-Men #135

 
  

Page: (1)23

 
 
Matthew Fluxington
13:49 / 14.09.02


Frank Quitely returns!

This has got to be the best X-Men cover of all time, even in spite of Logan's little goatee. Mmmm. I'm sure we can all speculate on this cover as if it was the cover of Abbey Road - Jean and Scott certainly aren't speaking to one another, but neither is Emma and Scott. Charles and Emma are in obvious conflict. Scott seems depressed. Jean and Henry are leaning on each other obviously, Logan seems to be innocently glancing over to Jean, while Xorn seems to be observing it all. And how should we interpret those headlines in the background? "Riot at Xavier's", indeed.
 
 
Our Lady of The Two Towers
14:16 / 14.09.02
Other than Logan not looking vaguely like Logan (where's his sideburns?) it's a pretty good one, I like the inclusion of the newspaper cutting from the first introduction of the Sentinels. What is 'Scot Free' a reference to, Magneto's trial? And who is the Carnation in 'Carnation trial off', a person or a substance?
 
 
some guy
18:59 / 14.09.02
re: Logan

The Ultimization starts here?
 
 
CameronStewart
20:15 / 14.09.02
Goatee is incredibly naff.

Other than that - this can't arrive soon enough.
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
21:06 / 14.09.02
That "Ultimate-ization" thing isn't going to happen, it was just a rumor.

It occurred to me before that Logan's hair should probably be subject to the healing factor too, right? Wouldn't it just grow right back in after a few minutes after he shaves it?
 
 
some guy
21:32 / 14.09.02
re: Ultimatization - I know it's a rumor, but it looks like they're porting over Logan's look. Hopefully Jean won't be next!

I'm not sure a healing factor would affect hair - isn't the part we see "dead?" I recall he's regrown a full head of hair in a few minutes after various attacks, though. Maybe we should just suspend disbelief. I know I'll have to in order to buy anyone his age opting for a goatee...

Anyone notice how Jean seems to be moving closer to Emma in style? I wonder if she's trying to make herself more attractive to Scott.
 
 
The Falcon
00:00 / 15.09.02
Is Scot-Free (note one 't') not simply a nationalistic pun of some sort?

Many would like to see NXM (as we call it at Hero Realm,) quite literally, Scot-free. I, on the other hand, would not.
 
 
bio k9
03:50 / 15.09.02
Am I the only one that read BWS's Weapon X? His hair should grow back real quick.
 
 
Our Lady of The Two Towers
13:58 / 15.09.02
BWS's 'Weapon X' story rocked. It'a shame it didn't make sense in several places, but otherwise, it was cool.
 
 
The Natural Way
15:46 / 15.09.02
Don't think Jean's style is moving any closer to Emma's - just-over-the-knee skirts have been fashionable for ages now. Quitely's probably just interested in making her dress sense a little bit more modern.
 
 
some guy
18:43 / 15.09.02
I was thinking the hair, too, and the general vibe. She seems to be picking up the sort of fetish tutor thing Emma generally has going on. It wasn't there before Scott/Emma, if I recall correctly.
 
 
Spatula Clarke
19:23 / 15.09.02
Jean's suddenly got the body of a child, while keeping an adult-sized head. How did that happen? I like Beast's boots, though. Thought he was standing on tip-toes at first, then remembered the mutation. Nice little detail.
 
 
Spatula Clarke
19:27 / 15.09.02
No, frosty. Scot-free as in "getting away with it scot-free,"; being guilty of something but not having to face any repercussions.
 
 
Tamayyurt
20:49 / 15.09.02
Wasn't that the outfit Emma designed for Jean in the head program she trapped Cassandra in? I remember her dressed just like that and it was either Emma or her Coockoo's who came up with the trap.
 
 
The Falcon
22:24 / 15.09.02
Oh, right........
 
 
Spaniel
15:49 / 16.09.02
Probly being a dunce, but where is the "riot" headline.

Pranny want riot.
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
11:41 / 17.09.02
I love Jean and Hank's look. "You believe these self-indulgent over-neurotic twats? Let's start telling people we're boning."

Benjamin.
 
 
Our Lady of The Two Towers
11:42 / 18.09.02
That looks so unlike Logan, are we sure it's actually him?
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
11:46 / 18.09.02
That is most certainly Logan, but with ill-advised facial hair and a peculiar Matt Dillon puppy dog look on his face.
 
 
The Natural Way
11:51 / 18.09.02
Info:

"Frank Quitely returns as "Riot At Xavier's" begins. Generation battles generation as the eternal showdown of youth vs. experience hits Xavier's Institute! Pupils against teachers. Children against parents! Who lives? Who dies? Who betrays whom? Be warned: Grant Morrison has promised that this four-part shocker will change the X-Men even more than "E is for Extinction" did."

Hooray. Pranny gets his wish.
 
 
CameronStewart
06:18 / 04.10.02
Quitelygasm!!!!

There is NO ONE who should draw this book other than him. I don't care if we only get five issues a year - It's worth it for uninterrupted Quitelyness.

When's this due???

*jump jump jump*
 
 
The Natural Way
07:26 / 04.10.02
I agree. It will sell like hot cakes. Who gives a fuck if it's late if it looks this good?
 
 
yawn - thing's buddy
09:17 / 04.10.02
sorry for being so fuckin intae caly but:

that art is so scottish!
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
12:46 / 04.10.02
This issue is out the second week of December.

I kinda wish that they wouldn't color this. the blacks and whites are just so PERFECT.
 
 
penitentvandal
15:40 / 04.10.02
Emo-mutant looks horribly like John Hegley...Perhaps his super-power is the ability to destroy people with unthreatening comedy poetry?

And...Schwa T-shirts? These kids are supposed to be the cutting-edge, fashionable, rebel-yell, fuck with the old guard mutants and they're wearing Schwa T-shirts?

What's up with that?
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
16:04 / 04.10.02
Maybe it was the only shirt that was big enough for him that he liked. That's a pretty big guy, eh?
 
 
Murray Hamhandler
23:56 / 18.12.02
This, my friends, is more like it...

After a run of sub-par issues, we kick it back into gear. This certainly lends credence to the theory that Grant saves his good stories fer Quitely and foists the cack off on everyone else.

I like this "testing of limits" thing. There hasn't really ever been a blatantly rebellious student at the school, has there? And I really liked Wolverine's reaction. Seems like the one that'd keep Chuck from getting killed...which is exactly why he'll ignore it.

I'm not sure I like the summary pages so much. I mean, it's a good idea, but I think it's being used as a crutch, to reveal story elements outside of the story. Could just be me.
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
13:10 / 19.12.02
What a great issue. Spoilers ahoy.


* I really love how on the final page of the issue, the "New X-Men" title is finally made literal.

* Piece of dialogue that I really hate: "Cool? SUPER ZEITGEIST! I AM that blackbird! Glam! Industrial! Clockwork Orange! Next level, Quentin -- you score!". Is Tattoo a parody of Barbelith's own Rage? Or is she just really annoying?

* Piece of dialogue that I really loved: Logan's comments about what to do with Quentin, but especially this funny bit - "I don't need telepathy or a psychology degree. I WATCH people. I STALK 'em...." I really like the way that Morrison writes Logan - I think lesser writers would have had him side with Scott and Emma, but of course he wouldn't. Logan is older and wiser, and considerably more laid back and tolerant of mischief. I like that Morrison writes Logan as being more confident than cocky.

* Is anyone suspicious of why Henry is so aloof in the psychic conferance, standing on the outside, saying very little, looking off into the distance on the cover? Any theories on that? Surely, this must be foreshadowing?

* Ah, Emma tried Kick in the name of science. What a great character touch, of course she would. Like Logan, I think Emma is written very well by Morrison - I think he really has a good understanding of who that character is.

* I love Xorn in the hippie-teacher role. He's such a likeable guy, but it's pretty fun to wince along with special class when he says things like "Without us, this is only a place. With us, it becomes an ADVENTURE." I wonder what Xorn would have said about Quentin.

* Any guesses on who is stalking Xorn and his students? I'm ready to be surprised on that one, I don't have any good guess. Probably humans, I bet.

* Hey, it looks like Beak and Angel really have made a love connection! Way to go, Barnell.

* Though it makes perfect sense that drugs would be part of Quentin et al's rebellion, I'm not particularly comfortable with how it may be the cause of it. There's a strong anti-drug feeling in this comic that I find very peculiar coming from Grant Morrison. Why couldn't Quentin and his pals just be brilliant and challenging and dangerous without Kick?

* I *heart* Quentin Quire. Who needs to write more Magneto stories when you've got a crazy theorybitch punk with a Magneto Was Right t-shirt to take up the fight for the old man? His Omega Gang may not be the New X-Men, but they are most certainly the New Brotherhood Of Evil Mutants. New X-Men is way better when there's a villain, eh?

* Is it just me, or does that guy in the group of humans who Quire and his pals attack look a lot like Quitely's older version of Jack Frost from Invisibles Vol 3 #1? And Quire does resemble Reynard.
 
 
Mister Six, whom all the girls
14:06 / 19.12.02
Quite nice. Like a ham and cheese melt and a bj at once. A good X-Men comic and it's X-Men, fer crissakes!

Quentin is a great character and I;m not sure if anyone pointed this out but this is one of the only comics that satisfies on a per month basis. I love it.

Nice to see Quitely back. He was missed. I hear that old-schooler Silvestri is coming back later on... any thoughts?
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
14:11 / 19.12.02
That Silvestri thing is NOT TRUE, thank God. Silvestri will be drawing some X-project, but it most definitely will not be New X-Men.
 
 
kid coagulant
14:34 / 19.12.02
All I know is I purchased this issue expecting Wolverine to have a goatee and, hey, no goatee.

Kid Omega is the shit. Too bad Arnie the Mysterious Fanboy is dead, they would have been a good pair.
 
 
some guy
15:46 / 19.12.02
Who needs to write more Magneto stories when you've got a crazy theorybitch punk with a Magneto Was Right t-shirt to take up the fight for the old man?

People who do things are always more interesting than people who talk about it.
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
16:03 / 19.12.02
Check out Jean and Scott towards the end of the conference. Quitely is a posture master.
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
16:03 / 19.12.02
Well, it depends, Laurence, doesn't it? In every post-Claremont Magneto story that's been written, Magneto does a whole lot but it's very dull, isn't it? Not to mention out of character. I think Quire is a lot more like Claremont's Magneto than the Magneto that's been in all of those stories - a crazed political radical in opposition to Xavier's integrationalist agenda, but without the more suspect "noble anti-hero" baggage. I've never liked the "Magneto is a hero with different methods" approach, I don't like letting him off the hook for being a murderous terrorist just because he has a tragic past.

And based on this issue alone, it's not as though Quentin isn't doing anything. He's starting a rebellion against Xavier, and his gang is out killing humans. It's a start.

I think this is a better Magneto story than anything that's been published since the mid-80s.
 
 
Sebastian
17:43 / 19.12.02
I've always found Magneto's characterisation a bit lame, including Claremont's pen, and also being the "concept" of the character much more appealing than what actually permeates into a story. I like how Millar treates him in Ultimate anyway.

Quitely is a posture master.

I second, triple, and even double that.
 
  

Page: (1)23

 
  
Add Your Reply