BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Ierne's Blind Date

 
  

Page: 1(2)34

 
 
Ierne
16:05 / 16.04.02
...her intention certainly does not seem to be to "out" those who have PMed her, but rather to demonstrate that there is a group of people who believe Mod3 is misbehaving, and advocate a more direct solution than complaining to her, as she is but one. – Haus

I would also be the person who is least able to do anything about it, since any comment I would make would only exacerbate the problem. Otherwise Haus describes my situation quite well.

To clarify: modthree has (thankfully) never sent me any private messages, and hopefully he has no intentions of doing so. The earlier fracas with May has been mentioned above, by her, and as far as I know has nothing to do with this particular matter.
 
 
Ierne
17:26 / 16.04.02
*sigh* In response to May's second post:

I do not have any negative opinion about MOB or the members of Barbelith who have chosen to join it. If it works for those involved, that is all that matters. It is painfully obvious that you have personal issues with me, May, and that's fine. You're entitled to your personal opinion of me.

What you don't seem to understand – and the whole point of this thread – is that I am not the only poster on this board who has taken issue with modthree's tactics, and I am not the only person he has used these tactics on. (I am optimistically using the past tense here.)

It is not a case of Ierne vs modthree.

What it seems to be is that people are very reluctant to confront him and express their feelings towards his behavior. Perhaps they are concerned that he will start attacking them the way Lothar and I get attacked. Perhaps they don't want to stifle his right to "freedom of speech" – neither do I! But obnoxiousness and abuse do not equate with free speech. To be able to say what you want carries the responsibility of making sure you are understood.

If the majority of agitated posters to this thread are correct in their opinion that modthree is not a troll, then at this point he has to realize that his previous methods of expression weren't cutting it, and if he genuinely wants to communicate with people he has to talk TO them, not AT them. And (if most of you are right) he should be more than happy to do that.

If he doesn't...then what?
 
 
w1rebaby
18:02 / 16.04.02
"What it seems to be is that people are very reluctant to confront him and express their feelings towards his behavior. Perhaps they are concerned that he will start attacking them the way Lothar and I get attacked. Perhaps they don't want to stifle his right to "freedom of speech" – neither do I!"

Or, possibly, people aren't actually bothered enough to confront him and, while he may annoy them, they don't really care very much. People have annoyed me in the past, and I have talked about them off-board, but I would not want those messages to be used as support for a campaign to get them to change posting style or be booted off, because that was not the intention for which they were sent.

If you want to prove that a large number of posters object to m3, why not privately set up some sort of petition? Responses to that would be some evidence. Until then, this is just looking like a personal thing to me, particularly considering your exchanges with May Tricks. Her setting up a coven doesn't at all affect the validity of her comments, that's just an ad hominem attack.

I've not exactly seen a massive groundswell of support on this thread from all these people that are apparently so pissed off. Why's that?
 
 
Papess
18:26 / 16.04.02
I just do not think it is fair that just because someone is obscure in their communication, they should be the subjected to this type of inquiry. This because a handful of people are having a problem understanding someone?

I have never had a problem with Mod3. I found ze's posts intriguing because they challenged me to think differently. I do not know what the problem is here. If there are a substantial amount of abuse from Mod3 and others feel he needs to be given a warning or whatever, I have not seen it, even in the diZzy thread. I think there were points where ze could have been more tactful yes, but those were responses to YOU and your persistant antagonizing posts. At first, ze was most polite to you Ierne, but after constant harrasment Mod3 could not meet your bitterness with sweetness no more. (I am not including LOthar in this because HE was tactful and polite in his questioning Mod3!). This draws the conclusion that you have been picking fights with posters and then draw attention to the last resort, fed up post they made in their fustration with your attacks on them and their ideas.

However, I do not have the whole story and partial evidence is not good enough for me. I do not know where your "statments" come from or even if they are made by ten people or one. I have not seen evidence of abusive behavior by Mod3 in the threads I have read except, a little snarkiness in response to brutal criticism. I would think that those things being proven and demonstrated would help to CLARIFY this whole matter. Since this is already posted and in question, could you graciously point me to the threads that can prove this abusive behavior. I just think having ALL the facts can help me and maybe others, to understand what the problem is.


~May Tricks
 
 
Ierne
18:34 / 16.04.02
I've not exactly seen a massive groundswell of support on this thread from all these people that are apparently so pissed off. Why's that? – fridgemagnet

Good question – and one I really can't answer. I never expected a "groundswell of support," to be honest.
 
 
Lurid Archive
19:03 / 16.04.02
I think there has been some support, but I'm not sure that there is much point in further contribution to the thread. All that is left is criticism of Ierne and a challenge to her to find mod's offensive behaviour. If she does so she'll be accused of just spending more time slagging him off and if she doesn't she'll be accused of making baseless charges.

Its a no win situation, Ierne. I think that the point has been made.
 
 
Trijhaos
19:13 / 16.04.02
Would it help if links to pertinant threads were supplied so that people could make their own judgements?

I do remember somebody asking for links since they never ventured into the magick forum.
 
 
w1rebaby
19:57 / 16.04.02
I don't know if links would help - they'd just be links to "bad" posts m3 had made. They'd be intrinsically biased, unrepresentative. I'd rather just judge things from my own perspective.
 
 
Tom Coates
20:15 / 16.04.02
Well the important lesson from this thread I think is for people who have until this point been unaware of this conflict (which I'm afraid includes me) to look at it as and when it appears with more attention and try to determine if we think there is any behaviour that requires action. I don't know that we'll find anything, but I think it's important for mod3 to try and investigate if there is a way to post without pissing of Ierne - and likewise for Ierne to bend a little and accept that other people may have less problem as a whole with this situation. I would advise everyone concerned to examine their own motives and try and start afresh. Perhaps we could leave it a week or so and see how it goes?
 
 
Lothar Tuppan
21:49 / 16.04.02
My last comment before backing out for the suggested week is that Mod3 does piss me off as much as he does Ierne, my 'tact' as May put it may just be that I'm more chickenshit than Ierne is about continually confronting him.

His complete lack of respect for the opinions of those who disagree with him and his intellectual bullying make it very hard to want to engage him in discussion. For those that he has 'targetted' the outcome is always the same.
 
 
w1rebaby
09:16 / 17.04.02
Lurid Archive is right in that Ierne will be criticised whatever she says now...

I can see that people might not want to express their dissatisfaction with m3 publicly, this might be considered chickenshit but that doesn't mean their views don't matter.
 
 
grant
13:46 / 17.04.02
Actually, I'll take issue with the implication that mod3 disrespects all those who disagree with him; I've engaged with him a few times, disputed points (it was about sin and evil) and never caught anything I'd perceive as flack.

I didn't get too involved in the diZzy thing because a/ I recognized the basic gist of what he was doing (trying to find a way to communicate without division of self & other) and b/ couldn't penetrate the vocabulary, which relied on symbolic logic & math terms, so I just cut out of there early, realizing I'd have to settle for the vaguest idea of the details.

Outside of that thread, I haven't noticed anything I'd classify as outright harassment. Maybe one or two barbed comments, but nothing remotely resembling a campaign. Could it have happened in a handful of threads I just didn't read? Possible, I suppose.
 
 
Gek
16:07 / 17.04.02
<: ...Yadda yadda yadda, next thing I knew, I was labelled too...STAY IN SCHOOL KIDS!! Improper communication skills will be your downfall...:>
 
 
—| x |—
20:41 / 18.04.02
Smear me on toast or smear me on bread,
It’s obvious that I’ve made a smear in your head!

:P



[eating popcorn and listening to the “Twin Peaks” soundtrack]

I admit I could be very wrong but the 'mod' has never dispelled that notion in either his public or private posts to me and as a matter of fact his one PM to me has strengthened my belief in this.
--Lothar Tupin

I don’t know how you get your interpretations sometimes, Lothar. Do you read via your projections and traumas (like some others seem to have a knack for)? Here is the message I sent Lothar (in full):

“Lothar,

It’s late Saturday night, and I’m just in from an evening hanging out with a couple of friends, it was both stimulating and abrasive. It reminded me, in some ways, of our relation here on Barbelith: I really wish I could have met you when you were in Calgary! I’ve been meaning to drop you a line for awhile, ever since you last posted to the “Mangoin Up…” thread.

To begin, I sincerely apologize for any frustrations I caused you over diZzy. I found it an interesting ride and I really did feel a very magickal event occurring in that thread, but I am willing to admit that it was, in some ways, a personalized performance (this had to do with the way I perceived the board at the time, i.e. I linked to more than merely the “High/Low booby trap” thread); in other words, I think I agree with some of what you say in the Mangoin post: but as for the rest, I never intended it to be that way, honest! The thread developed the way it did as it moved/stood still. To me it really helped me see some things with more clarity, and others did benefit as well. At times, I was under the impression that you were even having fun in your role as Lothifer! But I think that sometimes I did behave in an erratic or, from some perspectives, inappropriate and irresponsible manner. Again, it was not intended to harm, but it became manifest through the structure, entity, or whatever, that I was attempting to look at and talk about. I don’t know how to explain it better, words fail to express the [?].

I can only hope that you know I sincerely thank you for the role you played in that thread and I am regretful that the thread had its negative fall out (but not necessarily surprised given the nature of the structure, but of course, again, I know this is likely more of my own personal perception of the events). Anyway, I meant you no harm, and apologize for any grievances I caused you. Again, I really wish we could have met, then this would, I feel, all be water under the bridge by now.

So I’m writing you this to tell you that I am not trying to do this to you again (the frustration) over in “magick and mysticism.” Contrary to what Ierne thinks, I was not fishing for [I]your[/I] response or anyone’s response, but only response: we are on a message board, and call and response is the method of communication, ya? What I mean is, I [I]am[/I] playing the devil’s advocate at times in that thread in order to draw out some issues and I am not merely trying to drive you crazy! In other words, I think we complement each other in interesting ways. Um…I’m trying to say that, in some ways, we seem to be on a similar wavelength and I often enjoy what you write. So, I simply wanted to let you know that if you think I’m trying to hound you, I’m not: I think we are foils generating some very interesting discussion at times, and I really don’t think that one of us is right and the other wrong. I don’t know if you understood the terminology of diZzy, but I’d say that your perspective and my perspective are equally (invalid, valid)! Which is to say, like you say, and I do agree, “different strokes for different folks.” I think we work together generating different strokes.

Anyway, I hope we can make some good things happen together now and then, and I want you to know, if it means anything to you, I do sincerely have faith in the fact that you are doing what you can to make the world a better place. I really do desire nothing less than for you to experience the fulfillment of your best of desires.

m3”


So I really don’t see how this PM was intended to cause further discord in this community. It was merely an attempt to recognize that we see the world differently and let you know that, “hey! I’m OK and you’re OK,” kinda’ thing. Of course, you chose not to respond, to which I was mildly disappointed, but c’est la vie, ya? So, it seems to me that you misread this message in some bizarre manner, and I only wish that you had said something to me instead of carrying around this poison inside you. Moreover, I had never intended to draw lines through this community, and in fact, I see us as all part of the same line, but I digress to unacceptable (to some) mathematical metaphor…it appears to me that it was this community which decided to splinter itself around my contributions and in such a way that the lines are sometimes sharper than razor wire. Ierne/Kookla’s continued terror tactics and bullying have only served to string more and more of this wire around, and this thread is merely one more attempt at hir campaign to divide.

Who is it that hurt you so bad in your life, Ierne, that you seek to vomit out your pain onto me? I will not clean up your mess and I will not accept your poison. May Tricks has the situation nicely dialed when she says:

I think there were points where ze could have been more tactful yes, but those were responses to YOU and your persistant antagonizing posts. At first, ze was most polite to you Ierne, but after constant harrasment Mod3 could not meet your bitterness with sweetness no more. This draws the conclusion that you have been picking fights with posters and then draw attention to the last resort, fed up post they made in their fustration with your attacks on them and their ideas.

and also:

This is pathetic behavior. You slam people all the time Ierne and whine when they get fed up and slam you back. You bring these problems on yourself Ierne. Stop slammimg others and maybe you will not be slammed.

Again (again, again) if we look in the threads (such as diZzy, Mangoin’ Up the Magick, Magick and Mysticism) we will see that it is hir who not only starts the shit storm, but drags it on and on and on. I was more than willing to let it go, but Ierne had to cling to hir pain and horror and continue to try to make it everyone’s pain and horror. I tell you what, Ierne, get thee to a good councilor!

Now Lothar also says:

At least he hasn't used the same derogatory names against me that he has Ierne and Mordant Carnival which I found to be borderline misogynistic and offensive.

Ierne deserves all the wrath I have given hir for exactly the reasons that May outlines in her posts above: Ierne appears as a troll (as in a real monster) in sheep’s clothing and, more and more, I feel that s/he continues to reveal who s/he really is by obsessing on my presence here in Litherland. I don’t think, for all hir reasonable contributions to this community (and there are several), that s/he is a very stable person.

As for Mordant, the only “offensive” comment made to her was the “belle of the ball” thing, and again, Lothar, you have totally read this through your dim coloured glasses and blinders; that is, you project your own negativity onto my strings of symbols! The comment was intended to say, “Mordant, you are one of the more popular posters here, and people really seem to dig you.” As my good friend says, “It’s a blast to be the belle of the ball.” So, I don’t know how you get “misogynistic” from my recognition of Mordant’s charm, but I feel it stems from your own prejudices.

[non-linear jump]

Monkies…says:

Mod presents a very strong set of beliefs in...something...and I can't short him for that.

And I say, thank you, My Man Monkies! Part of this incarnation is a drive to nowhere through everywhere. Which is to say, I don’t intend to show you my deck of cards (but occasionally the odd hand) , but rather push people to get more acquainted with their own decks of cards. Or as JM puts it:

RIDE THE SNAKE

A little time out from all this other people’s baggage.

Bear writes:

I'm paranoid enough as it is without thinking that people are laughing at me behind my back...

and I say, Bear, I have always felt a certain fondness for you and I think that we have had some pleasant interaction through this site. It is somewhat shocking to discover that some people here are like hens getting hairdos down at the salon, but people love to gossip and waste their energy and words expressing their own jealousies, insecurities, and issues. Ignore what the other people say because if they are gossiping behind your back it can often mean that you are something that they wish they were but do not have the courage to be. Don’t take other people’s shades and banshees and invite them into your temple for service: leave that at the door and let them say whatever the fuck they want because those sorts of strings of letters aren’t worth much, if anything.

Back to your regularly scheduled carry-on soap.

Ierne puts forth:

You aren't doing yourself or MOB any favors by using this thread to express your personal angst with me; however, it does show those people who might consider joining your coven exactly what they might be dealing with if they cross you.

The earlier fracas with May has been mentioned above, by her, and as far as I know has nothing to do with this particular matter.

It is not a case of Ierne vs modthree.


Which has all the resources and strength of farting in the wind. It has always been a case of Ierne vs. {0, 1, 2}, but you are too caught up in your fear/anger/pain to see this. You have, as you do with May, followed me around and continued to carry this whole outhouse of an argument with you on your back. Get this, you fragile husk of humanity: I AM NOT YOUR MONKEY. You do it to yourself, Ierne, and you remind me of: (a) my friend’s spoiled little four year old niece who has a habit of putting her hands on her hips sticking her nose up at the right incline and saying, “Well actually…” and (b) of my poor brother’s bitch of a fiancee who is pained by having positive and happy people around her, feels that having to be friendly to others is too much of a strain on her energy, and is basically black on the inside. She, like you, has a huge chip on her shoulder, and instead of casting it off, is more content—perversely content—to drag it with her through life. I think that if you had the talents of magick and such that you lay claim to, then you would have laughed all this off before it had even gotten anywhere close to this far.

As far as I can see (and some others who have consulted and/or confided in me) May sums you up with only a small remainder and her operations are bang on: her problems with you, or perhaps better, your problems with her, have everything to do with your motivations for starting this thread. It is simple: you suck, Ierne, you suck giant death dongs in hell! Which is to say, in a jabby-pokey way, and echoing May, you bring these fracases upon yourself, and you create the whiny world you live in. I don’t owe you squadoo, and neither does May, yet we have both discussed ways to try and help you subtlety so you can get off your own back! Of course, I think your walls are very thick, and your shadows very dark.

Also c/o Ierne:

But obnoxiousness and abuse do not equate with free speech.

But if you really feel this way then why are you yourself so obnoxious (at times)?

Her setting up a coven doesn't at all affect the validity of her comments, that's just an ad hominem attack.
--fridgemagnet (on my stove)

As I’ve noted several times in other threads, this is where Ierne goes every time s/he feels threatened or is reminded of whomever it is that has caused hir whatever pain that s/he refuses to let go of. I find it ironic that s/he is hiding behind a veil of starting this thread because others have not confronted me but instead turned to hir via PMs when it is Ierne who has not confronted whatever it is in hir life that causes hir to behave in this “I am the Victim” way.

Also from the fridge:

I've not exactly seen a massive groundswell of support on this thread from all these people that are apparently so pissed off.

[flippancy warning—‘cause I know that some of you need these sorts of markers]

Yeah, where the hell is the party?!? I mean, c’mon I want to meet every one of these pissed off people and give ‘em a big tongue kiss! That’s right babies, pucker up and plant one on me!

[smooch]

And I notice that you can’t answer this criticism Ierne, and that is likely because you are trying to build a castle in the sky…in different words (but words I’ve written before, before, before) you have a problem with me (for whatever cock-eyed reasons) and you keep trying to make it everyone’s problem. You feel wronged (somehow) and you feel that everyone must share in your wrong. NEWS FLASH: even when people care about you your struggles are not theirs, and while your companions may assist you, ultimately it is only you who is able to act in ways to remedy your difficulties. Put differently, stop crying over spilt milk and merely poor yourself another glass, damn it!

And more of fridgemagnet’s magnetic goodness:

I'd rather just judge things from my own perspective.

Now, maybe, merely maybe, that is what a modthread might be about.

His complete lack of respect for the opinions of those who disagree with him and his intellectual bullying make it very hard to want to engage him in discussion.
--Lothar Tupin

Now, more than ever, I am feeling that you are an “…arrogant poster who has been pissed off and is contributing to more discord.” Lothar, I had certain ideas about your strengths and your personality, but I see how far wrong I was. You accuse me of “lack of respect” and “intellectual bullying” and I feel this stems from your own insecurities. Yes, I am sometimes sarcastic and flippant, but it is, more often than not, delivered with a sense of playfulness that you simply don’t pick up on due to your pre(mis)conceptions of what I am about. You have aimed for the bull’s eye and hit the wall. Think for a moment: why would I waste time writing diligently for people I don’t even know or care if I meet only to harass them? If I had no respect for people’s opinions, then why would I write anything? If I was an intellectual bully, then why wouldn’t I merely join a debate club or hang out at cafés or some such junk?

As Runce writes, “The guy has an agenda above and beyond just being irritating, that's obvious. Isn't it?” and this is certainly true—I do have an agenda, and that agenda (not merely here, but life’s work sorta’ stuff) concerns getting people to become more reflective upon their own fears, hatreds, and horrors; that is, I want people to recognize the ways in which they drive the Spectacle further into the sceptic tank and how each and every one of us is guilty to some degree in contributing to a bankrupt world teetering on the edge of oblivion. If you can’t recognize your own prejudices and shadows, then how do you ever expect to assist in coping with those we design through our collective interaction?

I think it is in this way that my role here has often been that of a mirror (which is why some of you may not be able to put me under your thumb, i.e. pin me down). Nobody knows me because nobody truly knows their own reflection.

In closing, thanks for the laughs and the honour of having a whole thread about someone who is no one. I love each of you, even if there is a couple of you that I don’t like.

{0, 1, 2}
 
 
—| x |—
20:43 / 18.04.02


But this is the most interesting:

I am sorry to hear you getting grief from some of the members. Especially since i think it is possibly in defense of a poster I am subject to in real life...so I *know* exactly what they are defending.
In other words, don't let it get to you, they are NOT worth it, you have just seen through it early enough not to get burned to the extent othwers are sure to in time. You will not be the one to look foolish in the end.
The smoke and shadow routines are just that, smoke and shadow...I have been shocked to see first hand the persnality change some people attempt to portray on the internet.


for several reasons!

1) I only know, with a high degree of certainty, of one other poster here with whom I am aquatinted IRL. I don not think that Z wrote this. Thus, if you feel “subjected” to me, then I don’t know who you are and wish you had the courage to approach me with this IRL.

2) If you think that you are “possibly” subject to me IRL, then how do you *know* “what” these other members are defending? Moreover, “what” seems a little inappropriate as I am a human being and not some kinda’ machine!

3) You seem to say that, since other members have decided that they get something from my writings, rants, and retorts, they have no value and are on a road to hell. This seems like a harsh judgement, especially considering it is merely “possible” that you even know who I am. Moreover, I find it somewhat humorous that you feel to have been “burned” by me (if, indeed, I am who you think I am) because of the people that are “subject” to me, most of them I have known for many, many years and continue to be part of our circle. Further, I do not make a very good fireman (in a sort of Bradbury sense); that is, I do not make a habit, nor even a rarely indulged vice, of “burning” the people that I know, love, and respect. Thus, if I am who you think I am and you feel somehow burned by me, then either you brought it on yourself, you made it up for some strange reason, or I inadvertently caused you grief. There certainly could be other possibilities here, but if it is the last that I list, then I wonder why you haven’t spoken to me about this: I am very much a person who seeks conflict resolution (unless, of course, I can see that the other party is more interested in maintaining the conflict—kinda’ like that Sharon fella’.

4) I tend to wonder if this was taken out of context of a larger PM? Was there more information that has been cut out? The references of many words (i.e. “a poster,” “others,” “some of the members,” etc.) are opaque and vague: talk about obsfucation! I get the feeling that this might not even be about me but has been included with crafty editing to make it look like it refers to me.

So, to whomever wrote this PM (and please note that when you send Ierne a PM you can’t be too sure if the ‘P’ stands for ‘Private’ or ‘Public’, please have the huevous (sp?) to either ‘fess up to it via a PM to me, an email to me, or a conversation IRL. Or if you’ve really got big ones, ‘fess up to it right here, as Ierne has already betrayed your confidence.

m3
 
 
Lothar Tuppan
23:02 / 18.04.02

So I really don’t see how this PM was intended to cause further discord in this community.


Maybe our social skills are just operating on different wavelengths but I just found it very odd that your public aggression was very different from your private apology. Your actions (public postings) did not follow your words (private posting). If you had posted an explanation of your intent to not-miscommunicate during DizZy, this whole thing would have been diffused for me, and probably for Ierne as well from the very beginning.

But maybe you're right. Maybe I got wound up and have been overreacting. I'm willing to take a step back, chill out, and potentially start over. The one thing that would be nice for you to realize though is that, in this thread alone, Lurid, Monkeys, Mordant C@rnival, Ierne, myself and the anonymous PMers who sent support to Ierne have been confounded enough by your communication skills to be frustrated to varying degrees.

I promise to take deep breaths and count to ten before coming to any conclusions about your posts in the future though.
 
 
Tony Montana
23:21 / 18.04.02
Modthree ducks to the left, Lothars punch glides off Mods left shoulder, Mod moves in for the kill - OH MY GOD! WHAT A MARVELLOUS UPPERCUT AND LOTHAR IS DOWN! IT'S AMAZING. WHAT A PUUNCH.

And here comes Razor-blade smile Irene, she's got a plank but OH MY GOD MODS GOT A GUN and he, oh my HE SHOOTS AND HE SCORES!!!!!!! THE CROWD ARE GOING WILD!!!!!!
 
 
Tony Montana
23:25 / 18.04.02
Ah, ignore me.
 
 
Lothar Tuppan
00:24 / 19.04.02
Done.
*plonk*
 
 
Persephone
01:51 / 19.04.02
If you had posted an explanation of your intent to not-miscommunicate during DizZy, this whole thing would have been diffused for me... from the very beginning.

You mean like this, the first paragraph of the diZzy thread:

A little pre-reading preamble. In the following post I use the letter Z: please do not be annoyed or put off or otherwise intimidated by the occurrence of Z. It is inspired by some other Lithers use of ‘ze’ in place of he or she. By ‘Z’ I mean the set of {us, them, he, she, you, I, and other such words that reflect this division}. I hope that this makes the following easier to understand…
 
 
Lothar Tuppan
05:30 / 19.04.02
No. As in the whole high/low miscommunication that he never addressed one way or the other. That set both Ierne and I on edge and if I have overreacted at all (which I'm not sure I have but I admit the possibility) it could have been cleared up by addressing it. His brand of 'devil's advocacy', as he called it, in that thread as well as others in the Magick and the magick related ones in the headshop that continued to frustrate the people who PM'd Ierne.

The Z issue was a minor annoyance and as you've participated in the first threads where Ierne and I voiced our complaints, you know that that wasn't the issue. The high/low attribution was.

The PM he sent me, in context, didn't seem sincere at all to me considering the context of public postings he was making at the same time. Or... if the PM was sincere, then his public postings weren't.

Bunny was right, this is turning into a spectator sport.

I promise to play nice if everyone else does.
 
 
Papess
13:05 / 19.04.02
I have a question.

If I could assume for a moment that Ierne's PMs are authentic, then I have to wonder if the comments were made before or after Ierne's conflict with M3. Was anyone complaining about Mod3 before Ierne started in on Ze?

Let's face it, Ierne has been here a LONG time and so have a few others. I am sure that there is some empathy and even a little sympathy for a dear cyber-friend amongst these old-time 'lithers.

So the question is really....Were these comments made in order to empathize with Ierne and be a supportive friend to hir?

It is just something to think about, anyway.

I am trying to take Tom's advice...to look inward at my own motives. I think he is absolutely right about this. Truly, if we are to believe (I am digressing a bit to the Magick) that there is no duality in truth, then it would make sense that this conversation is ridiculous. Of course, it would mean that Ierne IS M3 and vice versa. I am Ierne and so is Lothar and Grant Morrison. I am Grant Morrison and King Mob too!

What this means to me is that my fustrations with Ierne are just my OWN FUSTRATIONS with my own head. I think that Ierne's fustrations are with herself too. Ze seems to have an understanding and passion for the non-dual, so much so that ze gets irrated with discussions on duality. I have to say here that this whole thread is very dualistic and if we want to transcend dualism then I believe we have to treat everyone as if they are our ownself (trolls included! A poor sense of self esteem can really hurt others!!). Well, this is not easy to do, I know, sounds like a Utopia or some primordial state.

This is why I, personally believe in dualism on this plane. Our egos are running the show (well, kinda....shhh, my ego thinks it controls the traffic on the bridge and a few neighbourhood cats!) The ego is very individualized and sees things as Us vs Them., it is somewhat a flaw of incarnation. In order to protect our bodies this id-mechanism has been put in place. Of course, the fear we live with to protect our bodies, leaks over to our ideas and our emotions because us humans are thinking and feeling creatures and our egos never make a distinction as to what is a thought or what is flesh. The ego only knows.."this is mine and i must defend it to the death!"

So really, we are all fighting with our ownself in the end anyway. Taking a good look into a mirror (meant figurativly) before we post, any of us, is a great idea (Good idea for us all Lothar)

I was just thinking about motive, apply my rant as you will.

~May Tricks
 
 
Tony Montana
14:59 / 19.04.02
There's nothing wrong with spectator sport.
 
 
Wrecks City-Zen
18:56 / 19.04.02
Zen: What you hate about others is what you secretly despise about yourself... - an evil tyrant once told me that..
 
 
Papess
19:10 / 19.04.02
I think that tyrant told me the same thing. It makes my mind reel with what I am actually capable of!

Boy, am I naughty! I guess there is a little troll in all of us!

~May Tricks
 
 
Tony Montana
21:31 / 19.04.02
Believe it or not, there has bee a little bit of troll, at one time or another, in 105 women that I have personally met...
 
 
The Apple-Picker
22:14 / 19.04.02
Then your "good vibes" post in Conversation isn't much of a surprise.

I write this with the utmost empathies and Fed-Exing of good vibes.
 
 
Lurid Archive
22:53 / 19.04.02
Just to make this clear. I believe Ierne's quotations to be authentic -I know that her quotations of me are, as are those of Lothar and I assume Monkey. She is not trying to poison people against mod3, but some of us do find his posting style highly annoying.

He tends to respond with the sort of abuse you see above when challenged and that is part of the reason I find him difficult. But lets be clear. Despite what is said, this isn't some personal vendetta conducted by a single poster out to victimise poor old mod. I agree with pretty much everything Ierne says. If you want to assume that I've been "brainwashed" somehow, then feel free. I guess that makes it all the easier to dismiss the criticism.
 
 
Tony Montana
00:12 / 20.04.02
Ah! But that's what they programmed you to think!
 
 
Less searchable M0rd4nt
11:34 / 20.04.02
I was in two minds about whether to respond to this thread again or not. On one hand, I'd actually like to see it die as quickly and quietly as possible so that we can all get on with building some bridges, but on the other hand I feel like a heel for not offering Ierne more public support earlier on. She's my freind, and I feel like I let her down. I just hate conflict so much I'll shy away from it no matter what the consequences are for other people; this isn't something I like about myself. Add to that the fact that I have a lot of affection for many of the people that have found themselves involved in this issue, and I was afraid of losing their respect. Like fridgemagnet said: Chickenshit.

I can't begin to say how sad all this makes me, how sorry I am that people's responses have degenerated to the level of personal abuse, how little anyone seems to have tried to see things Ierne's way. Yeah, maybe there was some overreaction on her part, but the way I saw it, the more hurt and angry and embattled she seemed to feel, the less anyone tried to reach out to her.

Anyhow, that's about all I really want to say. I think I've exhausted the avenue of verbal communication for the time being, so I'm going to take my involvment in this situation onto the spooky planes of magick, where I reckon I can get more done.

Love, MCxx
 
 
Elijah, Freelance Rabbi
16:59 / 21.04.02
sorry if im reviving a hopefully dead thread, but heres what i see in all this, or better yet, what i dont see
I dont see--ANY abusive PMs from mod directed at anybody
having read through the dizzy thread where all this seemed to have started, i didnt see anything i would percieve as abusive from mod, I did see Ierne using obscenity to prove a point, which i have always considered a flawed argument
HERE is what i did see
Mod used language that took me a bit of time to understand, not in a bad way, but in an american watching monty python way.
I saw mod (in his first post of the dizzy thread) say that in his view he percieves that if you see duality in the world, than you fall into the high/low magic trap. I dont buy it, but i also saw what he was doing with the Zs
this is silly, its like if i posted--"i like dogs, you should like dogs also" having a group start telling me that my like of dogs was incorrect. This place is for views, i saw no abuse, just differing viewpoints.

EDN
 
 
Seth
06:53 / 22.04.02
I really don’t have a problem with this thread. Yeah, it’s messy, awkward and antagonistic. It’s not surprising from a site which is a community as well as a debate/idea forum: we were always going to have friction, misunderstanding, and ideas that people don’t agree with. Diversity of opinion, character and background are some of the things that make Barbelith great, and if a few conflicts are the meagre price we have to pay then so be it.

I’m not going to take either side, thus continuing the conflict (it’s not that I don’t have opinions. I have definite opinions on both posters and their actions). What matters here is whether there is any hope of reconciliation between Ierne and modthree, despite any perceived/genuine antagonism on both sides. You may not ever actually like each other, but are there any ways you can coexist here without hitting the ignore button? Would either of you be interested in discussing a means of coming to terms with each other? If either of you are interested, we can take this offsite into a three-way e-mail conversation. I don’t mind mediating. Make what you will of the offer: it’s there if either of you want to take it.
 
 
bio k9
07:32 / 22.04.02
Huggles?

Huggles.
 
 
enough
05:45 / 25.04.02
(stunbles in...)

Back from the desert! What did I miss? [LOOKS UP] Ahhh...
 
 
Nietzsch E. Coyote
05:56 / 15.05.02
Comments made by people here just make it clear that no one understood DiZzy. That doesn't mean there was anything wrong with diZzy I ENJOYED it.

Assuming I understood DiZzy: High and Low are a fiction, both part of the set M = (high,low). It's Discrete math applied to linguistics. A bitch to get your head around but good way to express a unity that wasn't meant for words.

Curious, Irene, why did you only show pm's that supported you? Was I the only one to PM you to argue Mod's case?

Please don't publish my PM.
The very concept of publishing PM's sickens me!
 
  

Page: 1(2)34

 
  
Add Your Reply