BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


The Spirit

 
  

Page: 1234(5)

 
 
vajramukti
21:58 / 04.01.09
any redeeming qualities? hard to say. if you went into it with no expectation except a completely absurd mess of overwrought millerism with no plot, no character, no eveness of tone, no discernable theme, just a kind of horrifying void that can only be filled by sam jackson going so far over the top that he seems to make the screen vibrate in an uncomfortable way... it's like he knows full well there's nothing there and he's trying desperately to fill a completely aimless hour and a half with his arsenal of typcast mannerisms. it would be fun, but it smacks of desperation.

it's either a heartless and brutal attack on one of the seminal works of the comics medium, or a reading of that work so wrongheaded you have to wonder if he even read the spirit at all.

it takes itself too seriously to be laughable and it's too laughable to be taken seriously. it not only fails at what it wants to do, but fails to even know what it wants to do. the fact that miller can even look this over in an editing suite and see a film makes me wonder about his state of mind.
 
 
CameronStewart
04:22 / 07.01.09
I'm actually shocked to find that, while watching The Spirit earlier this evening, that I was entertained through a lot of it.

I wouldn't say it's a great movie or even a particularly good one, but my rock-bottom expectations (indeed I went to see it for morbid train-wreck curiosity factor alone) paid off as I found myself actually interested in parts of it. I think it may actually be closer in tone to the comic strip than a lot of online fans care to admit (as Kyle Baker wryly illustrates here), it's just been filtered through Miller's lens. He gets praise for the same trick with Batman and Daredevil but viciously attacked for it here.

I think another pass in the editing room would have done it wonders - the sluggish pacing is, for me, the film's biggest weakness.

It's ten times more ambitious and interesting than Punisher: War Zone.
 
 
osymandus
09:58 / 07.01.09
I saw it last weekend and pretty much agree with most comments .
Its not really got any point other then midnless fun (which as mentioned Samual L gives it) , the guy playing the SPirit was pretty bland mind , and acctress's we'll basiclly millernised into his sterotypes .

Still at least his not Mark Millar
 
 
Evil Scientist
09:21 / 10.01.09
Visually I thought it was pretty good. It seemed to be more of an exageration of the Sin City style rather than more of the same. Still, to someone who hasn't really read any of the Spirit comics it did feel like more of the same from every other angle.

Samual Jackson is entertaining, for sure. But this is one of those films where he's just playing the ranty Samual Jackson charicature rather than actually acting.

Overall though I thought the film was quite boring. Far too many monolithic, monotonous, droning mono/dialogues which went on far too long.

It hit the mark on occasion. I found the Octopus's henchclones quite sinister with their ever-cheerful smiles and messy deaths, and the sheer overblown ludicrousness of the Octo-Nazi scene made for gigglesome viewing.

Other than that, mmm, not so great.
 
  

Page: 1234(5)

 
  
Add Your Reply