I think Crowley was dead serious about that definition.
If he is, then I don't agree with him.
Personally, if I get the result I want, I'm indifferent about whether it came by supernatural or supposedly mundane means. And, over the years, I've come to believe that there's a lot of magic in the supposedly mundane.
It seems to me that this amount a lot to says that everything is, in a way, magical. Which of course implies that nothing really is.
"When Frater I. A. was in danger of death in 1899 e.v. Frater V. N. and FRATER PERDURABO did indeed invoke the spirit Buer to visible manifestation that the might heal their brother; but also one of them furnished the money to send him to a climate less cruel than England's. He is alive to day; who cares whether spirits or shekels wrought that which these Magicians willed?"
Well *I* care. There is a world of difference to me to know if that man was cured by a spirit or by proper climate, or both. And I'm pretty sure that it would do a world of difference to quite a lot of people.
It all amount to the very simple question: 'Can we, by a mental act of will alone, without any kind of other direct physical intervention or utterance, modify reality, or make things happens?'
If the answer is 'no', then magic is nothing but dressep up psychology.
And I understand very well the 'change your view of the world to change your reaction to it which will then bring about proper results' part of it all. This is very important, but this is not what I'm talking about, and I don't believe this is only what there is to it.
Of course, I'm also all for joint approaches, and doing something more than just magic to get results is always a good idea, but that is not the problem I'm poking here either.
What I am forced to constat is that I am doing magic on things that are totally out of my grasp and that most of the time I got results just like I wanted them. I did manage to modify reality by an act of will. This, I call magic.
Writing a letter, or getting ideas out or finding a cure for cancer is not at all, at all, in the same bag. |