BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


One Year Later

 
  

Page: 12(3)4

 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
18:58 / 16.04.06
Yeah, I caught that too. My bad. I reread Bludhaven and I could follow it a bit better second time around. I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of these slick, Acuna-fied hero teams weren't influenced by Grant, especially that Silent Majority guy.

We'll never know for sure but I think the overall feel of the New DCU has a kind of pervasive Morrison slickness, at least conceptually. Radioactive fetuses, the new Human Bomb chilling in Filth Rainbow Juice. The execution is a bit wanting but Bombs Over Bludhaven seems to be a nice little playground for all this new leathery slickness to go at it for a while. If each member of the creative team had been upgraded just one level (Gray/Palmiotti -> Rucka, Jurgens -> Cliff Chiang) it could've been really fantastic.

OYL, everything just feels like there's just a little more freedom, more potential for craziness around the corner. It's why Nightwing feels so limp, as that potential is stifled at every turn.

In pretty much every book, there's been at least one new idea introduced that just infuses some new level of coolness. Firestorm now being unable to stray more than a mile away from the person he's merging with means a US Senator needs to chill in his dinky apartment's kitchen while he makes time with his girlfriend. And so on.
 
 
FinderWolf
21:50 / 16.04.06
Plus, the art in the OYL Nightwing has been pretty awful.

Green Arrow writer Judd Winnick has referred to the 'well, no one figures out Clark Kent is Superman' thing in interviews when asked the inevitable "why don't the people of Star City put two and two together, esp. given Ollie's distinctive blonde goatee?" Ah well, I guess it's just a convention of comics.
 
 
Jack Denfeld
23:31 / 16.04.06
Wow. I've been reading comics forever and all this time I thought Ollie's I.D. was always public knowledge after he came back from the dead for some reason. Oops.

One little funny part in the Green Arrow issue was when that big monster guy was destroying the criminals on the street, Ollie shot an arrow that had a note that said something like
Keep up the good work, but stop killing them
 
 
LDones
00:35 / 18.04.06
It's just been revealed that the lovely JH Williams III will be doing the business on Paul Dini's Detective Comics once James Robinson's arc is finished.

A fine interview, wherein it's also mentioned that 7S will most likely be further delayed, has been posted at Newsarama.
 
 
Phex: Dorset Doom
01:04 / 18.04.06
DC's July lineup, with plenty of OYL goodness.

Firstly, there's a bunch of books with concepts in 'inspired by the ideas of comics superstar George 'fucking' Morrison', SHADE from Frankenstein creating an all-new Freedom Fighters, Nightwing as a girl (HOT111!) and (not OYL related but still notable) Frank 'Shameless' Miller proving once again that he likes big butts and he cannot lie.
 
 
H3ct0r L1m4
03:23 / 18.04.06
an Asian ATOM! that jolly Johnny Byrne finally gets to work with Morrison, haha! through Gail Simone - surely - but, hey, that's way cool.

THE ALL-NEW ATOM #1
Written by Gail Simone
Art by John Byrne & Trevor Scott
Cover by Ariel Olivetti
The startling adventures of the new Atom begin in this series based on concepts developed by comics superstar Grant Morrison, written by Gail Simone (VILLAINS UNITED) with art by John Byrne (ACTION COMICS) & Trevor Scott (THE AUTHORITY) and gorgeous covers by Ariel Olivetti (SPACE GHOST)!
Strange things have been happening in Ivy Town since Ray Palmer disappeared. In fact, it appears that the the whole town's been experimented on for decades. Enter Ryan Choi - the young hotshot professor who's filling the empty slot on Ivy University's teaching staff… and who inadvertently ends up filling the old Atom's super-heroic shoes!
Can Choi make a difference in a town more creepy and mysterious than anyone ever realized? And can he live up to the towering legend of his predecessor?
On sale July 6 o 32 pg, FC, $2.99 US Edited by Mike Carlin
 
 
Phex: Dorset Doom
03:47 / 18.04.06
As long as he gets to fight a spider with a safety pin I'll be happy.
 
 
FinderWolf
13:03 / 25.04.06
The second OYL Robin issue came out and I missed it?? D'oh!!! Midtown Comics must have been sold out when I went in.

How was it, for those who read it?
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
18:46 / 25.04.06
FWII didn't do a half bad job (except for that one face he draws, the grimace one? That looks so out of place among his usually competent renderings? There were a few of those.)

The story itself seems to be chugging along nicely, although Robin got out of that situation way too easily. Nice confrontation between him and Lady Shiva. Good stuff.
 
 
FinderWolf
14:09 / 27.04.06
wow, that *was* a good Shiva/Robin scene (tracked it down at Midtown yesterday; they still had some...Hanley's was sold out of it, though).
 
 
FinderWolf
23:07 / 19.05.06
So Robin contiues to be pretty good (although FWII does do that Robin grimace not-so-well and a bit too much) and the writer shows promise for the future; Hawkgirl is pretty much crap (bought the first issue for the Chaykin art and in hindsight it was pretty weak; I love Simonson's Thor but his writing style isn't very good today, esp. on Hawkgirl)... I like the idea of Bats appointing the 'good' side of Harvey Dent as Gotham's protector in his absence, but other than the exceptional art by the former Aquaman art team (who seem to be drawing 1/2 an issue every other issue or something) this arc isn't very good and James Robinson's writing style is almost unrecognizable from his wonderful STARMAN epic.

And Busiek & Johns on Superman have at least made it entertaining; the most entertaining the monthly Supes books have been in years, I'd say...
 
 
Jack Denfeld
04:02 / 20.05.06
Newest Green Arrow was pretty cool. kick ass Ollie vs Deathstroke spoilers



Deathstroke shows up to carry out a contract on Ollie, but Ollie's the one who hired him and is totally ready to spring his trap! A bunch of booby traps that catch Deathstroke offguard, has him fall in some adhesive so he can't move, and guess what? Ollie took up intense martial arts and sword training on his year off! Deathstroke goes to escape, but uh-oh! Ollie called in about a thousand national guard snipers who all have their guns aimed on Deathstroke, and the Terminator is under arrest. Really fun read.
 
 
FinderWolf
14:19 / 20.05.06
Yeah, I Byrne-stole this and I agree, it was a indeed a really fun read. Deathstroke's first-person narration was great -- "What? Whoa! I'm totally screwed! Dammit!" etc. And who'd have thought a full-page spread of the hero gleefully screaming "YOU'RE UNDER ARREST!!" could be so fun and hysterical? But it was. It was.
 
 
Jack Denfeld
15:55 / 20.05.06
And who'd have thought a full-page spread of the hero gleefully screaming "YOU'RE UNDER ARREST!!" could be so fun and hysterical? But it was. It was.
That was indeed awesome, just because that never happens in comics. It was like Dragnet or something at the end. Real smiley read.
 
 
assayudin
17:09 / 20.05.06
I just got done with that Green Arrow. It was good. So good I narrated it for my wife, who could care less.
 
 
Jack Denfeld
17:23 / 20.05.06
That is true love.
 
 
Triplets
17:28 / 20.05.06
Right, which OYL comics should I have bought/should be buing to be following this?
 
 
Jack Denfeld
17:49 / 20.05.06
Green Arrow. Cool 1st issue, 2nd issue kind of a letdown cuz we think he's gonna fight deathstroke but he doesn't, 3rd issue is the payoff and really good stuff.
 
 
Spaniel
18:18 / 20.05.06
And Busiek & Johns on Superman have at least made it entertaining; the most entertaining the monthly Supes books have been in years, I'd say...

Despite the fact that it's littered with annoying little johnserisms, I agree with that. It feels fresh and fun and features a proper super battle every episode.
 
 
FinderWolf
01:24 / 21.05.06
It's funny, I feel like the Supes run is much more full of Busiek-ism thans Johns-isms (it feels to me like Johns & Busiek co-plotted and Busiek is primarily doing the scripting, in terms of knowledge of each writer's mannerisms and such).

OYL Teen Titans is worth checking out too, quite fun and well-done.
 
 
FinderWolf
23:04 / 28.05.06
Had no idea where to put this, so I figured I'd put it where we were discussing recent Superman comics...

I've heard about this book by Alvin Schwartz, which Alan Moore mentions as a major watermark book in comics history. Neil Gaiman mentions the book in an otherwise boring article about why people like Superman so much as opposed to other super-heroes; but this paragraph from that article is what's interesting. Apparently Schwartz was the first, pre-Moore, pre-Morrison, etc. to posit the idea that the really famous, universally recognized superhereoes, like other powerful icons, have become living entities in and of themselves. (then again, if the book was written a decade ago, maybe it doesn't pre-date Morrison talking about tulpas regarding superheroes. the article doesn't mention the details of the tantalizing bit at the end where author Schwartz (not Julie S.) describes his own encounter with a guy channeling Superman (which sounds not unlike Morrison's encounter with a guy channeling Superman years ago at a comic con.).

>> About a decade ago, Alvin Schwartz, who wrote Superman comic strips in the 1940s and ‘50s, published one of the great Odd Books of our time. In An Unlikely Prophet, reissued in paperback this spring, Schwartz writes that Superman is real. He is a tulpa, a Tibetan word for a being brought to life through thought and willpower. Schwartz also says a Hawaiian kahuna told him that Superman once traveled 2,000 years back in time to keep the island chain from being destroyed by volcanic activity. Maybe it happened, maybe it didn’t, but it does sound like a job for Superman – all in a day’s work for a guy who can squeeze coal into diamonds. Schwartz then tells of his own encounter with Superman in a New York taxi, when he learned firsthand that Superman’s cape is, in fact, more than mere fabric.
 
 
eargang
01:49 / 29.05.06
What's a "Johnserism"?
 
 
Benny the Ball
06:46 / 29.05.06
I'd say it's a plodding, cluncky bit of over continuity rich, over explained bit of "I know more about the DCU" writting, right in the middle of an okay-ish issue...
 
 
Spaniel
19:26 / 29.05.06
I like to think of the "Johns effect" rather than Johnserisms. It marries the above with a penchant for homely and conservative (with a big and small c) plotting and characterisation.

That's not to say I hate everything Johns does - I'm quite enjoying GL, for example - but his stuff does tend to get on my tits.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
22:31 / 01.06.06
The Spectre (boogety-boogety!) #1 came out this week, the first in a three-issue miniseries. Did anyone else pick this up? Mostly I was attracted by the Chiang artwork (I loved the Beware of the Creeper he did for Vertigo, and I think he was a Human Target agent, yes?), especially that first splash page with Crispus Allen at a crime scene, invisible, with the gigantic Spectre addressing him from behind. Beauty.

The one year gap seems to have been filled by endless wandering. I'm surprised Crispus didn't end up insane, and I like that without the Spectre his ghostly powers pretty much extend to...well, existing, not even having a solid presence. I'd like to see Crispus bind the Spectre into making a more street-level magic deal, rather than full-scale cosmic; something ghastly like some of the older Golden Age stories but without the bigger element, to counterpoint Hal Jordan's tenure as the Spirit of Redemption, which was all splash pages of Heaven and Hell.

Otherwise, a first issue that felt like a first issue. Setting up the starting point and that's about it. Here's hoping for a comparable rogues gallery, possibly using element of Morrison's SEVEN SOLDIERS (I'm thinking Zor in some fashion).
 
 
Mario
23:19 / 01.06.06
One Year Later isn't working for me. The great majority of the books I've checked have spent too much time dancing around things that happened in the gap, rather than a clean jumping on point.

I did like Secret Six, tho.
 
 
FinderWolf
01:33 / 02.06.06
A goateed Spectre...it'll take some getting used to.
 
 
FinderWolf
16:03 / 03.06.06
from an DC panel interview from Philly, at Newsaram:

>> DiDio said the three biggest chances in the DCU after Infinite Crisis: 1.) Superman's youth is now "hazy." 2.) Batman brought in his parents' killer, Joe Chill; 3.) Wonder Woman was a founding member of the Justice League of America.

Ok, so I guess #1) explains why we see glimpses of Clark-as-Superboy in Infinite Crisis.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
22:52 / 08.06.06
Did anyone else pick up Wonder Woman #1 this week? I thought it was a lot of fun...

(spoilers)


























...Mostly because (1) the Secret Society of Wonder Villains, (2) Donna Troy gets to grow up and inherit the mantle, even though nobody acknowledges she should get to, and (3) the all-new team-up of faux-Human Target Nemesis with the return of mod super-spy Diana Prince. The last two pages were killer.

So who do we end up with as Diana & Donna's rogues? Doc Psycho, Giganta, and the Cheetah. Leaving Circe and Ares to potentially show up. Is there anybody else?

The Dodson & Dodson art was very Adam Hughesian, and Heinberg did pretty well with a first issue that had to set things up, although the first half felt a bit light. Donna is an interesting choice for the short term (because presumably Diana will get the title back at least in time for the movie, if not far before) because it's been on the air for a while, even if Donna's perpetually fuckered continuity could be a sticking point.

Anyone else like/hate? I've been picking up the trades for the Perez revamp as well.
 
 
Mario
23:25 / 08.06.06
It was pretty good, although the bait-and-switch with Dr. Psycho was a bit annoying.

Two comments:

Tom "Nemesis" Tresser has always been similar to Human Target. In fact, I'm not entirely sure who came first. He's also been thought dead twice.

I'm curious how Troy went from "cosmic heir to Harbinger" to "Wonder Woman replacement"
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
01:40 / 11.06.06
I'm thinking we've gone back to the (second*) origin of Donna being raised by the Amazons and following Diana into the Patriarch's World...which would be nice and (relatively) simple.

The bait and switch was annoying, mostly because I don't particularly like Psycho's look now. The creepy big-headed little guy was more distressing.

I have some old Nemesis stories lying around in a couple issues of The Brave & The Bold, including one where he impersonates his own assassin. Or the man who killed his father. I can't remember. I'm hoping he and Diana Prince get some kick-ass development. Actually, I'd probably be totally keen on a Diana/Nemesis-centric series, but I love mod decadent spies.

* - First origin being "Wonder Girl" (and Wonder Tot) were Wonder Woman pulling a Superboy routine.
 
 
FinderWolf
06:06 / 11.06.06
This Nemesis character has really been around before...? Weird; I thought he was totally new. Thanks for the background! Yeah, Heinberg's WW #1 was fun...I second that emotion on the killer last page.

So has Donna really been run through with a sword? They can't "kill" her AGAIN.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
06:12 / 11.06.06
Honey, brutal puncture wounds are what the Purple Healing Ray was designed to handle.
 
 
Aertho
16:08 / 11.06.06
The sword was Dr. Psycho's focussed totality of illusory expertise. No grevious wounds.

Donna may be a shipwrecked girl adopted by Amazons, or another clay model girl... She's got superpowers... let's hope not derived from "Titans of Myth".
 
 
Mr Tricks
17:44 / 13.06.06
Enjoyed it. Was hoping for the return of the Mod Spy and am glad to see it.
 
  

Page: 12(3)4

 
  
Add Your Reply