BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


One Year Later

 
  

Page: (1)234

 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
11:32 / 01.03.06
Newsrama drops the two biggest One Year Later previews today and a world is torn asunder.

Not really, but Bullock is back on the force (YEAH), KGBeast is back (brIEFly, and also, what was he from again?) and, what's this? Superman was last seen in Metropolis fighting Doomsday? He crashed to Earth a Continuity Shattering And Apparently Official "68 Years Ago"?

Also, today we catch up with The Outsiders, Aquaman, Batman (Detective Comics), JSA, and The Demon (sorry, y'all are on your own with that one).

The dust settles, the skies clear, and there is only one question on the lips of every comic book reader...

Is it a crisis or a boring change?

We find out in just a few hours. Back to you, Tom.
 
 
Jack Denfeld
11:45 / 01.03.06
I hope Jason Todd's in that Batman arc.

The 68 years Superman thing. Maybe after crisis, they worked in Golden Age Superman into the new continuity, to be replaced by Earth 1 Superman at some point.
 
 
Dan Fish - @Fish1k
12:25 / 01.03.06
I read that Superman thing as it being the (DC-Universe) film version, not the actual one. Clark and Lois were pointing out some inaccuracies afterwards.

I was confusing though, when I started reading I thought it was a retcon, but reading the rest I don't think it is.
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
14:35 / 01.03.06
As always on WOYL, there are spoilers ahead...

Detective Comics #812
CRISIS!

I was going to just make one post sharing my thoughts and feelings about the new OYL books but I just threw this one down and just have to give it a brief "Gangs Away".

Shit, man! For starters:
- Bullock is back on the force.
- Harvey "Ol' One Face" Dent has been taking care of Gotham for the past year because Bats has been on holiday
- 9 Months Ago: Corruption Was Finally Discovered In The GCPD (Um, duh)
- 6 Months Ago: Bullock Broke The Case
- 3 Months Ago: Jim "Hotfoot" Gordon Returns To His Post As COMMISIONER
- Batman and Robin return in full old school flavor.

If this ish is any indication of the OYL direction then it is going to be a whole assload of fun. You've got Jimmy Robinson on Keyboards, those Aquaman guys we're all so fond of on the art, and a really nice balance between Batman noiry goodness and madcap, Poison Ivy eating a building greatness.

Seriously fun stuff.
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
15:50 / 01.03.06
We now return to WOYL, spoilers ahead...

Aquaman: Sword Of Atlantis (ostensibly...) #40
CRISIS!

I have no idea what's going on, but combine a whole Prince Valiant Underwater vibe with Gold Key style art and Todd "Titular" Klein on the letters, we're talking recipe for success here. Apparently this new Aquaman has the same origin as the old one, but, like if it happened recently? Superman: Birthright style? And all the stuff that's happened to Aquaman since hasn't happened yet? Yeah, I don't get it either, but it's one gorgeous looking book and I'm looking forward to Busiek going to town with this.

The Outsiders #34
Crising Change?

Sure, most of this issue is just heavy handed set up about an African dictatorship, but then the Outsiders show up! And Captain Boomerang's on the team! And apperently the Outsiders have been dead all year. Tell me more, 52!

JSA #83
Boring Change

If you didn't like JSA before, you sure won't now. Apparently they grew lax with their meeting schedules. That is all. Now they fight The Gentleman Ghost. Snoooooze.
 
 
FinderWolf
17:18 / 01.03.06
Innnteresting. Thanks for the update...I'm kind of in shock that all these major books are coming out this week (all these OYL titles, IC #5, NextWave, the Ultimates).
 
 
Mario
17:54 / 01.03.06
WRT to Aquaman. The new guy is NOT a reboot of the one we all know (and, mostly, mock). And his origin seems closer to the GA version.

I find myself considering some of the other upcoming releases, like Freedom Fighters, but I could still end up loathing it.
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
17:56 / 01.03.06
Try out Detective. It is as a shining beacon to all that is great about comic books.
 
 
FinderWolf
18:01 / 01.03.06
what does "YRT" mean? In all my years of internet reading/posting I have never heard that abbreviation before. WTF, yes, but not YRT.
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
18:09 / 01.03.06
With Reference To
 
 
FinderWolf
19:04 / 01.03.06
thanks...and who knows why I typo'd YRT instead of WRT above, but I did.

DC will probably make a lot more money than usual this week, with all these new OYL books coming out and a lot of curious fans.
 
 
Aertho
19:07 / 01.03.06
When can I say what I've seen in the 52 preview?
 
 
FinderWolf
19:17 / 01.03.06
well, now, since it's out there, but maybe you should post it in the 52 thread.
 
 
FinderWolf
19:25 / 01.03.06
to clarify, of course I'm not a moderator or anything, but it seems like 4-page previews have opened the door for spoilers being discussed here in the past (esp. in the Whedon X-Men thread history).

My suggestion is that we keep this OYL thread for assorted OYL stuff that doesn't have its own threads (JSA and Aquaman, perhaps, being a key example; not sure if we really need an Aquaman thread). Just an idea; all this OYL/52 stuff will have a lot of cross-pollination to it.
 
 
LDones
22:34 / 01.03.06
Seriously seconded on this week's Detective Comics. A great sign for the direction they're taking Batman in.

Batman cracks smiles at Jim Gordon and namedrops Swamp Thing. Not sure if that's Tim Drake as Robin anymore.

A good time is had by all. Oh, except for KGBeast.
 
 
FinderWolf
06:34 / 02.03.06
It is Tim Drake.

I like the new Robin costume (shades of the red leggings from the second season of Bruce Timm's Batman animated series), but I find myself missing the dark green sleeve thingies on his shoulders.

James Robinson's writing didn't seem quite up to Starman-levels here, but it was entertaining. We'll see how this story arc in Detective goes...maybe Robinson was just giving us lots of editorially-dictated setup thus far.
 
 
FinderWolf
18:01 / 02.03.06
And if Bats is less of a dick now, why did he snub the young rookie's greeting?
 
 
Spyder Todd 2008
18:54 / 02.03.06
Damnit! My distributor sold out of detective before I got there. Crap. Now I have to wait for him to reorder some more for me.
 
 
FinderWolf
14:52 / 03.03.06
Also, DETECTIVE features the Aquaman art team having graduated to Batbook status -- layouts by Leonard Kirk and finishes/inks by Andy Clarke.

Robin's comment to the cop 'Wellll, let me see how it is to be back before I say how good it is to be back' was nice.

And a clean-faced Harvey Dent who's been working as a superhero/vigilante in Gotham in Batman's absence...interesting. But I thought The Questions was Gotham's new protector during the year-long gap...?
 
 
Billuccho!
16:50 / 05.03.06
Detective bored me. Nothing really happened. Status quo's back to 1995 or so. Eh.
 
 
Spaniel
17:10 / 05.03.06
New Robin looks like he should be in G-Force, which is a good thing.
 
 
Juan_Arteaga
18:01 / 05.03.06
Batman still seems to be a bit of a jerk. He left that woman hanging! She just wanted to shake hands!

NOT COOL, BATMAN! You jerk.
 
 
Krug
21:15 / 05.03.06
I'm puzzled what the hooha is about Detective. I feel exactly like Bill of R. Wake me when Grant comes on.
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
16:35 / 16.03.06
WOYL apologizes for the one week hiatus but trusts that none of you were really interested in Firestorm anyway. We now return to our award winning, Malkmus/ComicBlogosphere-pilfering segment: CRISIS OR BORING CHANGE, already in progress. As always, spoilers abound.

Superman #650
CRISIS!

Superman, Powerless!
Supergirl at his Wrist-Com beck and call!
An All New, All Vanilla Kryptonite Man!
Lex Luther kicked off his own board of directors and hit in the head with a rock!
Whilst not as viscerally satisfying as Detective, Superman was quite an enjoyable read, focusing as it does on young Clark Kent, mysteriously freed from the burden of being a superhero, riding a wave of journalistic integrity as he dishes his editor Percival "Hudsucker Who?!?" White on scoop after scoop. He gets his ribs broken by a petulant Lex Luthor and watches his movies in the park with his wife and his chum Jameserly Olsen, who he also neglects from time to time. Apparently he's off Rucka's crime beat and back in the big leagues. Also, the Planet has some interesting headlines in its Easter Egg section: WHO IS BATWOMAN and SUPERNOVA SIGHTING among them. Well, 52? WHO IS BATWOMAN? And, does she ride in a BATWHEELCHAIR? Time (52 weeks of it!) will tell...

Nightwing #118
Crising Change?

What's this? Dick's marriage to Babs already in tatters? You'd be forgiven for your confusion on the matter as Jones et al have decided to open on Dick banging (adeptly, apparently) a redhead in New York City. But apparently not our favorite paralyzed redhead. Bait and switch, or colorist ASLEEP at the switch? We may never know. In other news, that rascal Jason Todd is also galavanting around Manhattan, displaying some incredibly awful narration (including the return of comics favorite non-expletive, "FRAPPIN'") and a knife he uses to kill people. And he's also claiming to be Nightwing! Quel confusion! What will happen when Nightwing faces Nightwing? Is the Manhattan Guardian covering the story? Will they all take five for a performance by Shilo Norman? Has all of Grant Morrison's lovely NYC geography been razed to the ground?!? And just who was Mr. Grayson arguing on the phone with? Time (52 weeks of it!) will tell...

Green Arrow #60
Crising Change?

America reels as what was once thought to be a hackneyed attempt to ape Ex Machina turns out to be...HURRICANE KATRINA COMMENTARY WITH TIGHTS! Yes the horrible bombing we witnessed in the closing issues of Green Arrow has left Southern (Or Northern? You don't care.) Star City in shambles and the quixotic government of the DCUSA has seemingly left them behind. But lo and behold, Winick raises the stakes as a newly built highway overpass has forms a de facto wall seperating affluent Star City and the Mardi Gras Star City. Who will protect the downtrodden? Ex-criminal Brick? Of a fashion. More likely their new mayor Ollie Queen! But, does the city know that Queen is also Green Arrow? Did they really not recognize the beard? Time (52 weeks of it!) will tell...

Birds Of Prey #92
Crising Change?

What's this? Black Canary gone into training related seclusion in Asia? Replaced by Lady Shiva who now calls herself JADE Canary? Has the whole world been turned upside down?!? Babs still sitting pretty in a wheelchair? Fingers ringless?!? But what of the fairytale romance of Dick and Babs? Was the ridiculousness of their shortened names strung together too much for them to bear? Time (52 weeks of it!) will tell...
 
 
praricac
12:04 / 18.03.06
i enjoyed superman 650, which is the only OYL i've seen/bothered with thus far.

intriguing (if not wholly original) premise of a depowered clark and it feels like a nice continuation of rucka's direction on adventures... (which i loved), ie - a well written, well rounded and quasi-believable (at least from a human emotional perspective) superman operating in a real and interesting world with amusing and classic but also decently elaborated background characters (ok so far only at the daily planet in this one, but i'm hoping it will extend further in subsequent issues)
 
 
Spaniel
15:24 / 18.03.06
Just a quick thought on Nightwing. Why the Christ are we supposed to buy Nightwing's stuttering horror when he discovers that twinny is a metahuman? This is bloody Nightwing, Batman's ex-partner, the cool as a cucumber defender of Bludhaven, ex-leader of the Titans and top ranking superhero, and Nightwing should not be stuttering and gasping when faced with teh awesome power of some bloody unheard of minor villain EVEN if said minor villain is destined for great things.

Fucking silly writer.
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
17:01 / 18.03.06
He was frappin' flabbergasted!

Yeah, I recall when Bruce Jones wrote a pretty mean Hulk. This stuff, combined with the pretty uninspired art ends up pretty uninspiring. Jock's covers are more compelling than the whole book. Matter of fact, that might be just how I read the book from now on, unless the Guardian shows up. Until he does, COVERS ONLY.
 
 
Spaniel
17:07 / 18.03.06
Yeah, I liked Jones' Hulk, but it was sooooooo ssslooooowww.
As much as it would be lovely for the Guardian to make a slew of guest appearances, I'd much rather he got his own book. He's my new favourite.
 
 
FinderWolf
19:42 / 20.03.06
Notice how the S on Supes' chest in the double-page splash of Supes 650 was a little more like the Superman Returns "S" logo than the usual comics fare...a slightly smaller S shield too. I liked the little jokes about the Smallville-esque moviereel/retelling of Superman's history.

Why did Lois say that young Clark went to Chicago in the newsreel when we clearly heard it state that he went from Smallville to Metropolis?

But how is it that OYL, Supes came to earth '68 years' ago? Is Supes almost immortal or just very very slow-aging in this new, OYL later?

Busiek & Johns did sum up the essence of the characters nicely here.
 
 
FinderWolf
19:43 / 20.03.06
I skimmed Green Arrow in the store...it looked pretty boring. Next issue might be more interesting as we only got the "Ollie is Mayor!" on the final page of the new issue.

Midtown Comics was sold out of Nightwing a mere 3 days after Wed. ......odd.
 
 
Mario
21:09 / 20.03.06
FW: It wasn't a newsreel. It was a very badly researched movie (with an Easter Egg for RL fans)
 
 
praricac
00:37 / 21.03.06
oh riiiiiiiiiiiight, so the origin retelling was part of the movie! play within a play ... i wondered why my brain was hurting.

i did likewise with green arrow, he's a character i always *want* to like but sadly he is always very boring.
i seem to recall someone rubbish is drawing it too.
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
02:44 / 21.03.06
Highly, grotesquely rubbish.
 
 
FinderWolf
20:20 / 21.03.06
shock shock shocker SPOILER SPECULATION / POSSIBLE SPOILER from ze Lying in za Guttairs:


****


****



is it really...


... a super-______?


>> I hear quite a lot of advance movement from chaps wishing to cash in on the upcoming "Action Comics" #839, shipping in May. The solicitation includes the phrase "and three unexpected words mark a turning point for Lois and Clark".

>> Speculation by speculators (and who better to engage in such) are calling this the moment that Lois tells Clark she's pregnant. This is bolstered by the solicitation for "Superman" #652, that indicated that dueing the One Year Later gap, Clark is made vulnerable - which nicely sidesteps the whole Larry Niven-penned dilemma.

>> Okay. Who'll be first with an embossed silver cover then?
 
 
Jack Denfeld
06:29 / 22.03.06

Babies never work in comics though. Spidey's wasn't even written out of continuity, writers just never ever mention it. Cyclops kid got sent into the future to return as a grownup, and Franklin Richards has been 6 years old for decades (except for some future stories).
 
  

Page: (1)234

 
  
Add Your Reply