BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Astonishing X-Men Year Two

 
  

Page: 123(4)567

 
 
LDones
00:56 / 30.04.06
Also, how sweet would it be if Scott's the mutant who's destined to destroy the Breakworld, putting his old girlfriend to shame with his own planet/people-eating rampage?
 
 
Imaginary Mongoose Solutions
14:31 / 30.04.06
If he hadn't deep down had some sort of phsychological issues around the loss of control of his eyebeams, then he wouldn't have been able to be impotent in Assualt on Weapon Plus.
 
 
FinderWolf
17:11 / 30.04.06
I really like the idea of Scott being the one who will go crazy and destroy the Breakworld....would also give him some classic guilt character development to go with afterwrads, thereby continuing his repression character bit for future writers to come. And I guess since Whedon's only committed to another 12 issues, we're going to see the B-World get toasted in the remaining 10 issues.
 
 
Benny the Ball
08:30 / 01.05.06
I thought it was Kitty Pryde who was destined to destroy Breakworld.

I still haven't picked this up thanks to working nights, but will try and get down to the shop today and get some comics in.
 
 
Quimper
13:36 / 01.05.06
I say it's Beast. Who knows what he's doing in that lab.
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
13:43 / 01.05.06
I suppose we're all assuming that the Breakworld is just another alien planet. 'Breakworld' sounds like a description rather than a name. 'Break' from what? What if the 'Breakworld' is a metaphor, signifying the Break between humans and mutant-kind, a concept that is able to translate into flesh to attack our merry mutants?
 
 
Mario
14:27 / 01.05.06
For some reason, I keep reading it as "the Beakworld".
 
 
Elijah, Freelance Rabbi
15:24 / 01.05.06
Unfortunately if it is Scott who kills breakworld in a year or two it will be revealed that he was under control of, oh hell, lets say Mastermind, so it wasn't his fault.

I would add my vote to the "Scott is catatonic" side of things, that wasn't a suprised "I puked" look at the end, thats braindead. What the motivations for doing that will turn out to be, I haven't the foggiest.
 
 
Benny the Ball
15:57 / 01.05.06
perhaps it makes him safe from Cassandra Nova?
 
 
Mario
15:59 / 01.05.06
Only one possible motivation. Joss is turning Scott into a tabula rasa so that when he suddenly snaps out of it (as hero or villain, could go either way), he can have a completely different character.
 
 
Spaniel
16:32 / 01.05.06
Well, he's almost certainly breaking him down so he can build him back up. In many ways Scott has been a very difficult character for writers, and it seems to me that Joss is continuing the good work started by Morrison in that he's attempting to give the guy a genuine - believable - personality. I don't expect him to be totally different when he snaps out of it, just fuller, more together, and, dare I say, happier.

He's not being reworked, so much as made stronger and more identifiable.
 
 
Mario
16:37 / 01.05.06
The problem is, every time he gets a personality, the next writer turns him back into a boring, doctrinaire stick-in-the-mud.

Grant is guilty of this too, really. Or was I the only person who actually liked the characterization of Cyclops in "E for Extinction"?

(the rest of the arc was a waste of paper... but I liked Cyke)
 
 
Mario
16:40 / 01.05.06
Correction: the "Eve of Destruction" arc.
 
 
Benny the Ball
17:40 / 01.05.06
Grant always went on paper as saying Cyc was his favourite, so no suprise that he spent a lot of time working on his character. I'm going back and reading all the essential x-men at the moment - not suprising most people take his character as being dull and a bit crap, he was so much Prof X's bitch.
 
 
FinderWolf
19:13 / 01.05.06
>> For some reason, I keep reading it as "the Beakworld".

So do I. A mutant version of Larry Marder's beloved 80s comic "Tales of the Beanworld"?
 
 
Triplets
21:01 / 01.05.06
Hang on, the mutants aren't going to destroy a breakfast show?
 
 
FinderWolf
23:15 / 28.05.06
>> Supposedly a fall gave Scott some kind of brain damadge which made him lose control of his optic blasts, but wouldn't Xavier have just had someone heal his team leader eventually?

I thought I was well-versed in all X-Men geek lore, but I don't remember hearing/reading about this fall. So Scott and brother Alex fell from a plane? How did Alex not get seriously injured/brain damaged as well? Were Scott's parents on the plane and this is why the Summers Bros. were "orphaned" (I know Corsair is Scott's dad, but I don't know who Scott's mom is... brain frying on obscure X-Men continuity)?
 
 
Lugue
00:26 / 29.05.06
Born to Christopher and Katherine Anne, Scott Summers is the older brother of Alexander. During a flight back from Anchorage after a family vacation, the family witnessed a Shi’ar Imperial freighter materialize above their family's plane. The Shi’ar wanted no witnesses, so the plane was set on fire. With only one parachute left, Kate Summers strapped Scott into it and tied Alex to him. She and Chris said their final goodbyes to their children and pushed them out the plane door. The parents were teleported from the plane a moment before it exploded and were transported to the Shi’ar craft where they were kept as Earth specimen. The explosion of the plane set the Summers brothers' parachute on fire. During the fall, Scott used his optic blasts for the first time to slow their descent and shielded Alex from their landing with his body. Though surviving, Scott hit his head in the crash. This injury caused a slight amount of brain damage, affecting the portion of his brain that controlled his latent optic blasts. Alex and Scott were brought to an orphanage in Omaha, Nebraska, secretly run by Mr. Sinister, who had registered Scott manifesting his mutant power.(...)

As found hyah.

(Oh, and as for his mum in particular, I'm not entirely sure, but a post-Claremont Uncanny issue by Lobdell featured a flashback of sorts to Corsair witnessing the Shi'ar murdering his wife, so I'm guessing she was a slave who, errm, did a no-no? Not particularly significant, I suppose. %Unlike the rest%. Hah!)
 
 
This Sunday
00:32 / 29.05.06
Mrs. Summers bought it at the hands of a D'Kenn or one of those Shiar higherups, in either the first or second Corsair/Shiar/X-in-space storyline, back in the day. Corsair flashes back on it around the same time Kitty Pryde was playing dress-up with a costume-machine and the big Russian fellow had been impaled.

The head injury excuse for Cyke came before this, but the plane-fall worked in might have been new with the initial alien-abduction story.
 
 
FinderWolf
12:27 / 29.05.06
Thanks for the info/refresher course!
 
 
FinderWolf
17:51 / 05.06.06
Marvel peeps have said that by the end of Joss' run on this book, Kitty Pryde will be radically changed.

Maybe this means she'll be in an interstellar jail for destroying the Breakworld, as some have theorized...?
 
 
Aertho
18:44 / 05.06.06
She DID send a MegaSentinel into space.

More evidence that Kitty Pryde = Phoenix, Destroyer of Worlds.
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
22:00 / 05.06.06
Whedon has also said that Kitty Pryde is his favourite character to write. I seriously doubt he's planning on putting her in intergalactic jail.
 
 
This Sunday
00:46 / 06.06.06
Why not? Spin her off into her own Whedon-done series, out in another galaxy, no hassle with other books or any upcoming continuity. Space plus ur-Buffy. In a prison. There's a Whedon series, and nobody has to panic about him turning the White Queen EVIL or fear the new mysoginistic Wolverine thug or anything, ever again.

Chuck Austen can come write 'Astonishing...' and cross it over with his topless speedster helps baldy voyeur catgirl team book.

Everybody wins! Well, I win, but that's because I've pretty much quit buying 'Astonishing X-Men' at this point, anyway. If this arc starts gaining some momentum, I might pick up the trade, but at this rate, there were just six issues of this series ever done, and most of those don't count.
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
08:41 / 06.06.06
Verbal Imodium run out again, DD?
 
 
This Sunday
09:49 / 06.06.06
Tell me that's a series that doesn't smell of Whedon. Really.

And that Astonishing X-Men has lived up to that first arc.

I don't know it's the angle they're taking, but it does play to certain interests.
 
 
Yotsuba & Benjamin!
14:45 / 21.06.06
HOLY GOD!

That was like the best Grant-less issue of X-Men ever! BEST LAST PANEL! BEST LOGAN! BEST EVER! BEST EVER!

Best day of comics ever, man. What the hell.
 
 
Triplets
15:13 / 21.06.06
THE COMICS SHOP HAS CLOSED. BAD BENJAMIN
 
 
Quimper
17:20 / 21.06.06
That last panel gave me a fanboy joygasm.


Kitty Pryde is one bad mutha.


I still say the mole is Lockheed.


And Hisako! All that Sunday morning TV watching paid off, huh?
 
 
The Falcon
09:53 / 22.06.06
So, that Kitty panel is basically exactly the Wolverine one from Dark Phoenix saga, innit?

It's a good ish, good cover version, last was miles better, though. Utterly nonplussed by the return of Danger, like SWORD banter.
 
 
PyD
11:11 / 22.06.06
What with Ultimates #11 out this week as well it got me thinking how there were some serious similarities between the way both Whedon and Millar get all their ducks in a row.

Both books nicely advance their plots regarding a team under assault and leave certain questions begging, with jsut enough contiued set-up and development, as to how all the different elements are going to come together and resolve themselves.
Seriously excellently paced and plotted action adventure fiction here folks.
Whedon clearly enjoying channeling the Kitty's inner slayer - very 'We're not ready? [beat] THEY'RE not ready'
Millar's controlling his anarchic streak beautifully with Cap, Banner , and the Liberators focussing it into something really lovely.

Who isn't dying to know who the big bad hooded Hellfire member is, or just what Iron Man 6 is, or just how much ass Thor is gonna kick, or just how the turnaround on the Hellfire club is going to manifest with Kitty as A but likely not the only major catalyst. These guys are in control, crafting some really good plotting.

The major crits all seem to be nostalgia based wherever I look and it just saddens me that folks get so caught up in that kind of mentality that is saps their enjoyment of really good reads like these.
 
 
Mr Tricks
16:32 / 22.06.06
Fun read, "classic" last page. Even that Dialogue was from Uncanny X-man #141 or 142? I forget.

Pete vs. Shaw, great... especailly the "I can't believe you forgot" bit. Just shows how much poor Peter's been through.

The Wolvie / Beast / Cassandra business was great fun. Been a while since we've seen a beastly Beast. He's deevolving nicely.

Emma looks like she's playing both sides. Giving each X-man just enough of a hit to put them into position. There's a huge chess game being played here. The Hellfire Club loves chess, there's just the question of who's playing King & Queen for each side.
 
 
grime
17:25 / 22.06.06
i was thinking of dropping astonishing.

not anymore. this latest issue rocked my socks off.

the best part was kitty falling through the earth. a terrifying concept and a beautiful visual.

it also got my geek-brain working: what about breathing? wouldn't she suffocate? of course, while phased she shouldn;t be able to breath at all. perhaps she enters a sort of biological stasis while phased.

ferocious beast was scary as hell! and hisako nailing him was such a greaat character payoff moment.

yesterday was definately one of the best comics days this year.
 
 
Shrug
22:50 / 22.06.06
I thought I remembered something about Kitty having to hold her breath while phasing?
 
 
FinderWolf
04:29 / 23.06.06
Wow. Very fun to revisit Wolvie in the sewers via Kitty.

Emma can't be all evil here, no siree.

"Can you even smell another person in this room?"

Why did no other writer ever think to write a loopy mind-controlled Wolverine reduced to a vapid babbling British child? His dialogue sounds like Little Nemo In Slumberland. ("He shall be so cross with me! Oh!") Hilarious.

Sometimes Shaw and Wolverine's face looked kind of the same. That's a very minor quibble, however.

And yes, Birdie's declaration of Wed., June 21 as the Best Day of Comics Ever really does hit the nail on the head. So much quality stuff out this week...
 
  

Page: 123(4)567

 
  
Add Your Reply