BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Millar and the Spider-Man.

 
  

Page: 12(3)

 
 
Solitaire Rose as Tom Servo
17:58 / 23.10.04
I think the organic webshooters are here to stay, since they are from the movie.

Yeah, they are changing the characters to fit the movies, which means thats oon, Captain America will get a motorcycle where his shield is see-thu and he uses it as the windshield on his cycle. The Hulk will wander into small towns, chased by a reporter and Daredevil will reprint the Frank Miller issues out of order.
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
20:16 / 23.10.04
I've know the bad guy in this was Ben Reilly for months.

Millar is the kind of guy who loves stuff like the Clone Saga.
 
 
FinderWolf
17:19 / 15.11.04
Last few issues have been pretty good - anyone else still reading?
 
 
Mr Tricks
17:58 / 15.11.04
Yup... great treatment of Venom... This is more & more becoming the default Spiderman series.
 
 
_Boboss
11:16 / 16.11.04
i think it was a bit poor. hasn't yet surpassed the kick-ass battle with electro a few ishs ago. (where's the scorpion? you never see the scorpion around any more.) he told jonah it was john? won't john get angry, maybe, y'know, lycanthropically angry, at this slight taking of liberties? does john jameson know the real deal, and has agreed off camera to help peter out? and how could venom get the guy on the roof mixed up with proper spidey? was man on roof doing the whole 'how can you do this venom' thing? and when he hands the girl the dog he just rescued, are we supposed to forget the poor bloke driving the truck who's completely crispyfried? tempted to say these moments of disconnection are to show us how much of spidey's super-life is front and selective memory, how blind to himself he is, but that's qute a big, dark cloud to cast over the character and i think sheer millarian hackery is more likely. he's taking the 'hush' route on both spidey and wolvie now, and i fear that none of it's as good as he or loeb think it is. (johnny romita certainly doesn't seem inspired enough to turn out the normal good goods.)

interested to see the ben reilly thing work out, much as it might stick in craws. it's silly to leave this slice of continuity out in the cold when there's a potentially good character there: a neglected eighties-style version of parker, with a grudge burnt into his dna, an uzi and a ripped shirt? as a villain there's nuff potential there to turn reilly into the first iconic spiderbaddie since venom-and-spawns. must admit not entirely confident millar's writing has the verve to pull this off these days.

but, after the whinging diminishes, as directionless as this book very often seems i think in a run it will read as a good self-contained spidey tale, something which there isn't really much of historically.
 
 
FinderWolf
17:08 / 16.11.04
True that there aren't many good self-contained Spidey tales...

I also had a problem with the way the scene with the 'average schmo trying to get a reward' was laid out, visually. Surely he wasn't the one screaming at Venom. I kept flipping the pages back to follow the visual flow of it. This random dude in a Spidey suit just shows up out of nowhere right near where Peter was standing during a fight with Venom? The misdirection was so poor as to be horribly unclear...surely not worth the psyche-out shock of making the readers think he killed Peter by putting his entire fist through Peter's midsection.

>> he told jonah it [Spider-Man] was john? won't john get angry, maybe, y'know, lycanthropically angry, at this slight taking of liberties? does john jameson know the real deal, and has agreed off camera to help peter out?

Ditto. I really wondered about this. Does this mean John Jameson knows Peter is Spider-Man? Or is Peter just taking a huge risk here, counting on triple J to never mention it to his son? Will this have long-term continuity ramifications (namely, will JJJ stop his anti-Spider-Man crusade suddenly)?

Those criticisms aside, I am enjoying this book.
 
 
FinderWolf
16:56 / 09.12.04
New issue out today, which apparently reveals some major SPOILERS, one of which is that the big villain/kidnappers are not who some of us thought they would be, perhaps...?
 
 
FinderWolf
14:15 / 13.12.04
New issue which reveals the master plan is kinda crappy. ohh, so supervillains in the MU are mostly funded by the govt. to keep superheroes in line? gosh golly, no one's ever thought of that before as a story idea....
 
 
Mister Six, whom all the girls
14:20 / 13.12.04
Yeah I was really digging this series before this issue.

The scorpion's spiel is so forced and silly and plain stupid that it had me repeatedly asking, "Yeah but... where's Aunt May??"

Big let down. I hope it picks up again.
 
 
FinderWolf
16:50 / 13.12.04
I wanted it to be Ben Reilly, back from the ranks of the comic book "dead."
 
  

Page: 12(3)

 
  
Add Your Reply