BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Sigur Ros ( )

 
  

Page: (1)2

 
 
Our Lady of The Two Towers
16:35 / 30.10.02
It's here for £8.99

Just saying, you know...
 
 
Jack Fear
17:05 / 30.10.02
If you live in the UK and were thinking of buying the new Sigur Ros album...

...you should have your eardrums bored out with industrial drills until you can appreciate the sound of real music again, you trend-hopping scumfuck.
 
 
uncle retrospective
17:38 / 30.10.02
Easy Jack.
We're a little testy lately, aren't we?
 
 
Jack Fear
17:43 / 30.10.02
FEAR MY WRATH!! GAHHHHH!!!!!
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
17:59 / 30.10.02
Yes. The Beatles had proper tunes.

ferfucksake
 
 
Jack Fear
18:34 / 30.10.02
Et tu, Tannhauser?

Oh dear oh dear.

Okay then, in less-confrontational language: Sigur Ros seem to me to be vastly overrated and overhyped—like many things, their music works much better in theory than in practice.

In other words, after hearing so many people say they were the Best Thing ever, I was prepared to adore them—until I actually heard a couple of songs, and realized that "Sigur Ros" must be Icelandic for "Smashing Pumpkins."

And now the new record—a free-form orchestral project?

I repeat: oh dear oh dear.
 
 
Our Lady of The Two Towers
18:44 / 30.10.02
Just because Brad Pitt thinks they're good doesn't make them crap Jackie.

Britney Spears has covered 'I Love Rock n Roll' you know?
 
 
bio k9
19:06 / 30.10.02
And her version sucked.
 
 
Locust No longer
21:00 / 30.10.02
I like them, and I think they are more like the Cocteau Twins than Smashing Pumpkins.
 
 
The Return Of Rothkoid
22:00 / 30.10.02
I didn't quite get into the last album. Not enough to buy it, anyway. Maybe this one.

And don't you go dissing free-form orchestral things. I'll get my homes Stockhausen and Ligeti and go medieval on y'ass.
 
 
rizla mission
09:34 / 31.10.02
Sigur Ros have always sounded too damned nice for my liking. They may do long-winded instrumental rock, but unlike certain other groups, they don't seem to want to do anything interesting or challenging or emotive with it.. they just sound a bit too much like "post-rock chillout" or something..

(the next stage of the argument should be someone claiming I only think this because they don't have noisy bits)
 
 
Jack Fear
09:57 / 31.10.02
I think it comes down to chops, quite frankly.

The first 45 seconds of "Ny Batteri" are interesting--all the weird horn sounds--and I'm thinking "That's all right, that, let's build on that..." but at the end of the day it's Yet Another I-VI Two-Chord Drone With Bass Figure High Up The Neck of the type that U2 used to knock out by the shedload. The atmospherics are threadbare: I thinkwe all know what guitar feedback sounds like by now, thank you, very nice, NEXT! And if Jimmy Page got royalties every time some poseur assaulted a guitar with a violin bow, he'd wouldn't have to tour with te Black Crowes for rent money. And then when the drums come in, a moment that's clearly meant to be climactic, the effect is unfortunately laughable because the sound is so cruddy and the programming is so crude.

If you feel I've judged the band harshly in a critique of just one song, thgat's because they've only got one song: that's their fault, not mine.

And Rothkoid? I'll give you medieval--say hello to Hildegard of Bingen and Guillaume de Mechaut, suckah!
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
10:51 / 31.10.02
My former flatmate had what I assume was the most recent Sigur Ros album before this, and used to play it loudly late at night as he fell asleep, especially if he'd been drinking. This was quite nice. Soothing.

However, I've seen them live twice - once for free and the only gig I've ever walked out of, the second time supporting Radiohead in a big park so there was no escape. They are indubitably the most tedious, pompous, plodding live act it's ever been my displeasure to witness, and the reported lack of album or track titles on this latest release sets my teeth on edge.

Britney has better tunes, and could kick their arse.
 
 
Jack Fear
11:48 / 31.10.02
See? See?!? If even the Flyboy agrees with me, then I must be on to something...

When I've got a bit more time, I've got an idea for a thread about music that springs from small, insular, nurturing local scenes--and the failure of recent UK bands to penetrate the US market (remember the hue and cry over the Billboard Top 50 showing no British acts?). The theories are only half-formed at the moment, though.
 
 
at the scarwash
15:56 / 31.10.02
I think Sigur Rós are a wonderful addition to my collection of wallpaper music. Sure, they're pretentious and plodding, but what's wrong with that?
 
 
Murray Hamhandler
19:11 / 31.10.02
I can get w/the Cocteau comparison. There's something very 4AD about Sigur Ros. Which is good some of the time. Definitely more of a background music sort of band.

And, I'm sorry, but Britney is the bunkest load of croaking crap ever shat into existence. IMHO, of course.
 
 
Billy Corgan
19:54 / 31.10.02
"Sigur Ros" must be Icelandic for "Smashing Pumpkins."

What the FUCK, dude? The Pumpkins rocked way harder than these Icelandic sleep-rockers, even when we doing acoustic lullabye ballads! I think that if you knew ANYTHING about my old band, you'd know that we sounded nothing like those wimps. We totally fucking ruled, and these guys can barely even drool! And if they could drool, it'd be really quiet and drone on for about 10 minutes.

God, the only time Sigur Ros ever sounded good to me was when I fucked up on 'ludes, had a few bong hits, and assorted barbituates.

Again, to sum up: My old band rocked like raging motherfuckers. These guys suck. Case closed!
 
 
Jack Fear
12:52 / 01.11.02
Ah, I thought that would draw you out, "Billy"—speaking of plodding, predictable, one-trick ponies...
 
 
HysteriX
16:04 / 28.04.03
sigur ros is icelandic for victory rose (or so i've been told), i like them, they rock live, they're good to sleep to, in that depressing hypnotic trance kind of way. they influenced radiohead's kid A, which is also great, i don't give a fuck how trendy (or sub-trendy as i'd say) these albums are, i'm captain underground, but to not like something as greatly produced and orchestrated as these because someone else different from you likes them is just facist and idiotic. if its just not you're style thats fine. to each his own, and all that jazz. for instance siamese? dream is the only thing i can stand from S.P. (and they sound nothing like sigur ros)
 
 
deja_vroom
18:10 / 28.04.03
vidrarveltil loftàrasa (track 8), I think, from Agaetys Byrjun, Sigur Ros' latest album, rocks so hard it makes me bite my tongue everytime I listen to it. But I'm finding the new album dull. And who are these Pumpkin-people you guys keep talking about?
 
 
Seth
22:44 / 28.04.03
I'm fairly addicted to the newer record. It's got none of the variety of the first, but it seems to work at a deeper level. Give it a few listens and it'll start to burrow it's way into your brain.
 
 
Secularius
11:16 / 29.04.03
You people don't deserve the magic of Sigur Rós. When I hear things like Jack Fear's comments, I wish they'd never left Iceland. But then again that's a bit selfish because of all those people who do appreciate them. But no one should ever listen to Sigur Rós because it's a trend or because they got a free ticket, or because their roommate forces them to. When I went to their concert last december I wanted to throw out the f**king Italian that sat next to me who couldn't hide his boredom. If you don't like it you don't deserve it. It's that simple. Shut your mouth and go listen to whatever crap you listen to, you soulless robot.

I actually think some of their songs are hard to understand for non-Icelanders. For example that Dánarfregnir (Death Announcements) song from the movie Englar Alhemsins (The Angels Of The Universe). When they played that in a bar in England people thought it was just pretentious wannabe-prog-rock and didn't even stop chatting. For most of us Icelanders it's so overwhelmingly emotional that we just stare in awe, speechless. I actually got goosebumps during some of their first concerts in Iceland. It was like a religious experience. And that was long before they were trendy. If a concert with Sigur Rós doesn't have that effect on you you're not really getting it.
 
 
Jack Fear
11:30 / 29.04.03
To sum up, then: It's an Icelandic thing, maaaaaaan—you wouldn't understand.

So much for music as a universal language then, eh?
 
 
Our Lady of The Two Towers
13:27 / 29.04.03
Zadok- You are now my God. I'll do whatever you say. Do you want Jack Fear to die slowly, admitting his sins? I can do that for you, sure. < twitch >
 
 
Quantum
14:31 / 29.04.03
My girlfriend bought Sigur Ros several years ago, because of the angel foetus on the cover, and really liked it. I liked it, then a few months ago met someone who'd heard of them, and now suddenly everybody likes them. Now I know people like Jack hate it when that happens, but personally I see it as a validation of my excellent taste
Sigur Ros, the Icelandic Pumpkins? Great! I still love the Pumpkins (although not sure about Zwan, sorry Billy) so why not love Sigur Ros? It's that or Royksopp. Can anyone not from Iceland name another Icelandic band except Bjork?
 
 
rizla mission
14:49 / 29.04.03
Yeah - Mum.

Probably some others too, but I'm too tired to activate my brain. Iceland is the home of some fine music.
 
 
Pirate Ven Will Teach You To Lambada (The Forbidden Dance)
14:56 / 29.04.03
Mum are from Iceland, I think.
 
 
Pirate Ven Will Teach You To Lambada (The Forbidden Dance)
14:57 / 29.04.03
Haha. Synchronicity.
 
 
Secularius
18:42 / 29.04.03
Do you only want to hear recommendations from somebody who's not from Iceland? Well, I am. Anyway, here's Múm's official webpage. Another band I urge you to look out for is Apparat Organ Quartet. They are a really great band that plays electronic music all live on old organs and synthesizers, without any sequencencers. And they have a drummer. It's really rock'n'roll played on organs, no guitars. Here's an audio clip. I think they played on Roskilde festival in Denmark last year. They're the best thing to come from Iceland recently, in my opinion. Mínus are also quite good but they're more in the hardcore rock department (which is not my department).
 
 
Secularius
10:22 / 30.04.03
What's this comparison with Smashing Pumpkins? Sigur Rós have NOTHING in common with the Smashing Pumpkins. I'd say they're more indepted to 90's shoegazer rock, for example Slowdive and Spiritualized. Also Radiohead and perhaps My Bloody Valentine. And of course 60's psychedelia and 70's prog-rock. But Smashing Pumpkins? No way!
 
 
Poke it with a stick
10:31 / 30.04.03
Sigur Rós = Maudlin, tranquilised whales humming along to the Blade Runner soundtrack.
And there's no annoyingly shouty bloke like the one who marred the Sugarcubes' every move.
 
 
Secularius
10:59 / 30.04.03
Yeah, thank G-d they don't have that shouty bloke. I think he manages Björk's homepage nowadays and releases some annoying tunes on Bad Taste Records once in a while.
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
11:27 / 30.04.03
For the love of Heaven - Einar was without a doubt the best thing about the Sugarcubes, and has gone on, I believe, to be a high-up in the Icelandic culture ministry.
 
 
Billy Corgan
12:29 / 30.04.03
Dude! The Pumpkins had a lot of early 90s shoegazing masterpieces, looooooong before those Sugar Roos kids even knew what an e-bow was. I bet you any sum of money that if you go and check out their teenage record collections, it was all about Gish and Pisces Iscariot and Siamese Dream. And good for them! At least they like something good, right?

Maybe I'll invite them to come out on tour with Zwan, and we can give them How To Rock lessons.
 
 
Secularius
14:41 / 30.04.03
You're not the real Billy Corgan, are you?
 
  

Page: (1)2

 
  
Add Your Reply