BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


The Dido Generation

 
  

Page: (1)2

 
 
Fist Fun
12:15 / 14.02.02
Are you part of The Dido Generation. How many of these albums do you own. Honestly. You start.
 
 
theskunkymonkey
12:20 / 14.02.02
Only 2!!
Mezzanine & Dummy...
Thank fuck for that!
 
 
Bear
12:20 / 14.02.02
Well I own 3 of them, Oasis, Moby and um Eminem..and I think I've probably listened to the rest at some point
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
12:22 / 14.02.02
Um, I've got the Lauryn Hill, U2, The Strokes, The Verve, Radiohead, Oasis, Pulp, and Eminem LPs listed there. That's nearly the 12 that would put me in the Dido Generation. And of course, those 8 records are sooooo indicitive of my record collection, right?
 
 
The Natural Way
12:25 / 14.02.02
I fucking win - I own exactly none of those albums. I am positively not a member of the Dido generation (but I reckon Fly is).

"The big wheel keeps on turning, on a simple life, day by day..."

So, so beautiful....

[ 14-02-2002: Message edited by: Fantastic YOU [I, Runce] ]
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
12:31 / 14.02.02
Was talking about this article this morning over breakfast with my fellow Guardian reading scum flatmate, and decided that though some of it is quite funny, the main problem with it is that it's objective is to make the average Guardian reader think that their CD collection is really hip and dangerous.

I have six of those on CD: The Strokes, Portishead, The Verve, Radiohead, Pulp and to my shame Texas. Oh, and there may be a copy of Play in my collection as well but I have no idea how it got there, I honestly never bought it. Then I have the Eminem, Massive Attack, Lauryn Hill, Oasis and U2 on tape.

You can't really be part of that generation unless you have the Tracy Chapman and Suzanne Vega though: that's what indicates your mid-thirties-ness...

Runce: you can suck my plank, kiko.

[ 14-02-2002: Message edited by: Flyboy ]
 
 
rizla mission
12:33 / 14.02.02
I got two of those.

And they ain't my favourites.

THANK KRIST.
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
12:37 / 14.02.02
I think the idea that just be owning these it makes you ________ isn't even the point of the article , anyway - the kind of person it describes wouldn't have much else, and would view them in a similar manner to that described (Strokes too rocking, Eminem unplayed, prospect of Kid A scary etc).
 
 
Bear
12:37 / 14.02.02
quote:the main problem with it is that it's objective is to make the average Guardian reader think that their CD collection is really hip and dangerous.

Thats exactly what its for isn't, lots of trendy people breathing a sigh of relief, thank god I'm still hip....pretty sad really
 
 
sleazenation
12:39 / 14.02.02
of course it would be interesting to see which of those dido gen albums had never been featured in the massive organised sales regularly held by HMV/Virgin etc.
 
 
The Natural Way
12:49 / 14.02.02
So?

It's fun in a really childish way. And yeah, my taste is SO COOOOOL, yours is rubbish. Get w/ it.
 
 
The Natural Way
12:51 / 14.02.02
In fact, my taste is SO SO COOOOL I've just had a work colleague come up to me and tell me just how cool it is.

Yr just jealous that yr not cool, Dido lover...
 
 
Bear
12:54 / 14.02.02
Your just jelous because I've got the new S-Club-7 album !!
 
 
Saveloy
12:59 / 14.02.02
I've got two of them, so that makes me - what - 1/6th of a wanker?

But, Jesus, don't you just love these "hah hah demographics smirk smirk I'm so fucking observant, me, I've got your fucking number, chummy" pieces? It's a pretentious version of the "aren't those girlies who like boy-bands really shallow" bollocks, which is quite right and proper when you're fifteen, but for a grown-up to be doing it in the pages of a broadsheet is a bit much really. The point of it is to make the author feel a bit special and clever, and possibly a bit daring because they probably imagine that yer average Guardian reader does own every single one of those albums.

As with everything wrong in music crit today, it's the NME that's to blame. But I won't go on about that yet again.
 
 
The Natural Way
13:01 / 14.02.02
Basically, when the Guardian tries to be groovy, it all get's a bit like dad dancing at the party....

[ 14-02-2002: Message edited by: Fantastic YOU [I, Runce] ]
 
 
Tom Coates
13:26 / 14.02.02
It was a bit of a difficult one for me, this. I had precisely THIRTEEN of the listed albums. Which is a worry.

But I have decided that it's eased by realising that I since I have several hundred CDs I'm probably going to own more on the list than someone who owns ten. So now I"m comfortable in pretending I'm not a loser.
 
 
Sax
13:38 / 14.02.02
Twelve. Oh dear. But that is counting some my girlfriend bought before we merged our record collections. (I would never, ever be seen dead with a Texas album).
 
 
pointless and uncalled for
13:44 / 14.02.02
One and I will never be ashamed to own Portishead. Hell, I own that sweet little baby on vinyl as well as CD.
 
 
Kit-Cat Club
13:50 / 14.02.02
Oh Christ. Six, and it would have been seven if I hadn't sold my copy of the Oasis one years ago.

I have the Portishead one, the Radiohead, Pulp, Massive Attack and Eminem... and (MORTIFICATION) the Travis one.

I'm going to kill myself.
 
 
captain piss
14:01 / 14.02.02
It's just a classic example of the record collection of the non-music fan- you know it when you see it, and it's easy to smirk disdainfully if you're a bit more of an NME-reading type who's more actively into music.
 
 
Laughing
14:03 / 14.02.02
I have six of those albums. And?

I like Moby. And? AND?

[ 14-02-2002: Message edited by: Storm of Blue vs. The Banana Splits ]
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
14:08 / 14.02.02
quote:Originally posted by Meme Buggerer:
it's easy to smirk disdainfully if you're a bit more of an NME-reading type who's more actively into music.


But NME champions all that sort of thing - I look at the website, all you see is Oasis, Radiohead, The Verve, Travis, Pulp et al.

I am baffled by you Brits who think the NME is in any way cutting edge or geared towards serious music fans...maybe it was several years ago, but it's the UK Rolling Stone at this point.

Now, if you don't mind, I'm going to read my copy of The Wire...
 
 
Saveloy
14:35 / 14.02.02
Flux>
I don't think many people do think of the NME as cutting edge. It's just the most prominent mag occupying the middle ground between The Wire and the 'Bizarre' column in The Sun (tabloid paper). So, while not cutting edge, you will read about bands you won't see mentioned in The Sun or The Guardian.

They're also good at spotting - you could argue they help to make - small time indie rock bands who go on to make it big in the mainstream (Oasis etc), and that's something you won't see much of in the Wire.

So what I'm saying is that meme buggerer's point is valid, in so far as yer NME reader's musical knowledge will probably be greater than that of yer so-called "non-music fan", and that you don't have to believe the NME to be cutting edge to make such a statement. (Of course, disdainful sneering is wanky in any context).

[ 14-02-2002: Message edited by: Saveloy ]
 
 
deja_vroom
14:47 / 14.02.02
I have three: Ok Computer, Urban Hymns and Different Class. All fucking great rock records.
 
 
bio k9
16:20 / 14.02.02
Like Tom, I have 13 of those albums. Hooray for me!
 
 
Not Here Still
16:23 / 14.02.02
I've got the magic 12; they nestle next to my other 500+ CDs and 300+ slabs of vinyl.

I care not for this bullshit. I never throw or give records away, and I have a wide taste in music.

Who gives a fuck?

My 'dull' CDs are right next to my 'cutting edge' CDs. As Noel Gallagher says on the 'Wibbling Rivalry' bootleg I own somewhere, 'It's all about Music. Music. Music.'

Last time I looked, I wasn't defining myself to myself by the products I bought. So I don't give a shit.

Oooh, all worked up now. Time to listen to Moon Safari, I think... [why wasn't that in there?]
 
 
Ganesh
16:27 / 14.02.02
Between us, I reckon ZoCher and I have seventeen.

%We're off to kill ourselves now.%
 
 
pointless and uncalled for
16:38 / 14.02.02
Combine that with the fact that when it was originally posted I misread the title as The Dildo Generation and you have a truly scary state of affairs.
 
 
Tom Coates
17:09 / 14.02.02
Yay. We rule.
 
 
Sleeperservice
17:15 / 14.02.02
"The Dildo Generation"

lol

How is this scary? ;P
 
 
Ethan Hawke
17:16 / 14.02.02
Is anyone else rendered immediately unconscious whenever a Dido song comes on the radio? Sleepiest music ever.

I own 5-6 of those albums, and I could care less what that says about me.
 
 
pointless and uncalled for
17:22 / 14.02.02
I could go into a major rant here but suffice to say it's I couldn't care less not I could care less. There's a very big difference.

Sorry, apologies for the thread rot, pet peeve, more apologies, going away now, sorry.
 
 
Fra Dolcino
07:24 / 15.02.02
Fuck that! I've got clannad and Dire straits albums lurking somewhere (Gulp).
 
 
A
07:29 / 15.02.02
i don't own a single one of those records, and i have a pretty big record collection. but then again, my theory is that there is far too much great music from times gone by that i don't own for me to bother trying to keep up with what's hip at the moment.

i mean, the Strokes seem to be okay, but why would i sheel out for their record when i don't even have any Stooges records yet?
 
 
No star here laces
08:33 / 15.02.02
I don't have any of them, which I bet is hardly surprising.

But, I always wanted that Lauryn Hill record and never got around to buying it.

However, I'd like to propose the five records that most irritate and irk me when found together in a record collection. They are the ones that to me epitomise striving for a knowledgeable and idiosyncratic music collection without any kind of broadening of horizons or in-depth understanding.

1.) The velvet underground - "the velvet underground"

It doesn't have all the songs that you like best, but you couldn't find "White light, white heat" in the record store and you don't buy best-of collections cos they're too mainstream. A representative choice - most of the collection will consist of similar commonly accepted 'seminal, underground' rock albums.

2.) Leftfield - "Leftism"

You don't really like all that dance bollocks, but this sounds great after a spliff and has, like, proper tunes on it. Never mind the fact it's a soulless pilfering of other men's musical flowers and a dully rockist reinterpretation of the dance scene...

3.) That fukn Ugly Duckling album

Now this is what hip hop should be like - none of those nasty men being aggressive and uncomprehensible, just good fun lyrics and recognisable tunes. Or alternatively a hideous re-hashing of hiphop's glorious back catalogue for the inane and shallow listener.

4.) Teenage Fanclub - "Bandwagonesque"

I really don't think this is that bad a record. But it's all about the company it keeps. In this company, this record defines what you really like - nice, safe, jangly stuff. What you listen to when you're on your own and nobody can hear.

5.) Goldie - "Timeless" and LTJ Bukem - "Logical Progressions"

Again, not individually bad records. But if these are the only two jungle records there, ooo, that makes me mad. This should require no explanation. Haven't been listened to in about 5 years, except on the rare occasions you have a one-night stand (this applies to the Bukem only, the Goldie never gets out its box).
 
  

Page: (1)2

 
  
Add Your Reply