BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Comics this week

 
  

Page: (1)2

 
 
Captain Zoom
09:52 / 09.12.01
Uncanny X-Men #400 - finally realizes some of it's potential. It'll never be NXM, but it's a damned sight better than what Uncanny X used to be. Quite enjoyable.

Star Wars: Tag and Bink Are Dead #2 - not quite as funny as the first one, but still head and shoulders above most Star Wars fare.

Liberty Meadows #24 - Always always always so far above excellent it's not funny. But it is. Frank Cho's artwork is sooooo gorgeous.

Battle Pope #10: The Christmas Pope-tacular - if you're not reading this you should be. The pope is a super-hero in a post-rapture world where demons from hell co-habitate the Earth. Jesus is his goofy side-kick. So. Fucking. Funny.

Doom Patrol #3 - beginning to shake even my fervent devotion to the DP. According to the recent Previews, they're even taking the name Doom Force next month. Please let Arcudi be doing this all tongue-in-cheek.

Zoom.
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
09:52 / 09.12.01
I'm actually kinda upset that Uncanny X-Men #400 was actually pretty good, with no major flaws: I was planning on dropping if the issue sucked, and now i'm going to stick on a little longer. But it actually was good. All the way through.

I guess Casey does have some talent...why he waited til 7 or 8 issues into his run to show it is beyond me.

His characters are still pretty wooden, and his love of testerone macho tough guys is a bit much...
 
 
The Knowledge +1
11:30 / 09.12.01
MARVEL TEAM-UP

Lovely art by John Totleben. GREAT art in fact, and a decent enough story. Can't fault it really, but the two-villain introductions and the integration of their meetings in this single-issue story leaves some things unexplained. 7/10

100 BULLETS

Brilliant. Azzarello starts writing in a Raymond Chandler type styley. Interesting new character, a good-start to what I understand is the first of a 5/6-part story. 8/10

THE AUTHORITY

Reallly good writing, the art isn't as good as Quitely, but it's still pretty decent so I can't complain. I don't know it's because none of the main cast are dead, or it's been so long since I last read an issue of this title, but it left me a little cold. The dialouge continues to impress though. I wonder what will happen next? 8/10

ULTIMATE X-MEN

Big let down after the last issue, which is a real pity, it was a bit anti-climatic and there weren't many repercussions were there? Also, I thought that the resolution of the use of the brotherhood was a let-down. The art by Tom Derenick was absolute toss. This issue left me wanting. Millar sort it out. 5/10

LUCIFER

Jump on now, if you want to start reading this great title. Remember all in the family? Remember The New Scum, remember Seasons of mists? This title is rocking. This issue is an introduction to the three-part Paradiso storyline. It's alright and provides a few shocks, but I really don't get some of Careys characters, where is he going with them? Still, I've got a lot of faith in this writer. 7/10

ALIAS

Nice. I'm really enjoying this title, and obviously Bendis is enjoying writing it. Quite faultless. Great art. 8/10
 
 
the Fool
22:14 / 09.12.01
I really loved the name of the new 100 Bullets story arc...

"the Counterfifth Directive"

And was that Lono seen leaving the building as bandage man enters...
 
 
ghadis
17:54 / 10.12.01
Best and only comic i bought this week (so far) is Tales from Shock City by Mario and Gilbert Hernandez...Re-prints from Mr X...Great stuff

WARNING!!!
I advise anyone whose bane in life is Grip and the Hernandez Bros not to purchase this comic...you proberly wont like it much
 
 
Mr Tricks
20:08 / 11.12.01
Yeah... solid week:

UX-men 400
Was one of this run's better reads. Still not up to the level Casey reached in Wildcats, but enjoyable... Nice use of the varied Art teams... curious how the new artist will help the book. Still I'm wishing it to IMPROVE greatly, quickly!!!

Lucifer:
This title is Rocking!!! Peter Gross as artist helps create a unified feel to the book for me... It's getting easier & easier to forget that this is a "spin-off" title.

Authority:
I feel like that big gap in time has slowed down the pace of this book as well. Still I enjoyed ADAM's art for sure... Excellent dialogue & concepts. Looking forward to parts 3 & 4

100 Bullets:
This just keep getting better & better. The previous arch was a bit weaker... but does anyone remember the baseball 1 issue story??? with a YOUNG Agent Graves? Check it out, nice play on time here.

Ultimate X-men:
Hopped on mid-way through the weapon X storyline... was swept up but disapointed with this issue... not sure if I'll keep following it.

Red Star 7.5:
Is anyone else following this title? Generally I enjoy it... this one was pretty good... a dicent jump-on point.

DK2:
I liked it... not as IMPACTING as DKR those 15 years ago... but still, Liked Cat girl & the Atom... BatBOYS... heh

Spector:
Does anyone read this as well??? The Art's Great the writing is enjoyable... it's vaguely a Promethia-lite. Still a nice x-mas tale

So.... what's on next week's Menue???
 
 
Captain Zoom
20:38 / 11.12.01
I'm looking forward to the Dillon-penned silent issue of the Punisher. Also the latest issue of Phil Foglio's Girl Genius is out. New Star Wars Tales, new Hellboy illustrated novel, new Midnight Nation. Those are just what I'm getting in. Not sure what else is coming out, but I'll ring in with my opinions tomorrow.

Zoom.
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
09:08 / 12.12.01
Not much of interest out this week save for X-Force....

but hey, X-Force is enough for me...

Captain Zoom, as a comics retailor, can you please give me some kind of hint as to when the next Eightball will be out? How long should I be holding my breath?
 
 
invisible_al
09:08 / 12.12.01
Anyone know when the new Adventures of Barry Ween Boy Genius is out, cos the last two fucking rocked :-)
More bad language, more extreme science, more monkeys and more dimensional warps in the basement. Its great.
 
 
Captain Zoom
12:39 / 12.12.01
I've been waiting too Flux. Just got a whole lot of back issues to keep me happy, and perhaps promote the church of clowes. No solicitations, nothing. ONe assumes that he was busy with the Ghost World script and he's not known for his rapid output anyway.

Zoom.
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
13:45 / 12.12.01
It's just been so incredibly long, Zoom!

I'm dying to know what he will do post-Ghost World movie/David Boring. Those were the two most complex projects of his career, and I'm wondering if he will keep going in that direction, or do a few short stories...

I know he and Terry Zwigoff have started on the film of Art School Confidential, so that may push back his comics output even further...
 
 
Hush
14:55 / 12.12.01
The quote below is from a monthly e-mail review I get from one of the comic shops I use. I wish I'd written it, and want to share. Especially when we often, justly, slag of comic shop staff.

quote: New X-Men: E Is For Extinction vol 1 (£11-99) by Morrison & Quitely. Deep within South America, a baldy headed woman with a more than passing resemblance to Professor X reactivates a hidden Sentinel project. Bearing in mind she really *really* hates mutants, this spells genocide, ‘splosions and large metallic objects flying into skyscrapers. After numerous deaths and resurrections, Scott and Jean find themselves further apart than ever before; Prof. X doesn’t seem quite himself and has taken to carrying a gun; teenagers can’t spend their pocket money fast enough on the latest mutant fashions and pop music; outside the school gates, meanwhile, the mob begins to howl…

Like the rest of Morrison’s recent work, NEW X-MEN dances to a choppy, syncopated rhythm, shifting scene and viewpoint in creating a world soaked in corporatism, media trends, fear, loathing and good old fashioned sex. What makes this a spangly great book, however, are the spangly great moments; this is how a the best-selling superhero comic should be done: hip and flip, so pop it hurts. Cyclops, preparing to hit the insurers with another claim on a top-notch airplane reassures his passengers: “Relax. I’ve survived more jet aircraft crashes than any other mutant.” Rather than digging out Magneto for a “Charles, are our are dreams so very different?” scene, the X-Men’s eternal bête noire gets dispatched in a single panel, martyred as a mutant Che Guevara, his face on a t-shirt becoming the latest meme. Dominatrix school teacher Emma Frost sets out her lesson plan: “I propose we spend today’s telepathy period hacking into the minds of some of our favourite screen idols. A gold star to the first girl to discover the awful truth about Tom and Nicole.”

Ideas fly out at a rate of knots and the comic reeks of the now. Where Morrison’s JLA saw him tangle with the monolithic icons of the DC Universe and reinvent them as latter-day saints, here he gets to play with the pop idols and sex symbols of the Marvel sandpit. Most of the art in this volume is by Frank Quitely and bears the familiar hallmarks of his work: fantastic choreography and a real sense of heft and gravity combined with the odd distorted limb and the unfortunate fact the females could also go under the nom de heroine of Giraffe Neck Woman. On very few occasions, the book reads like a Fisher Price version of THE INVISIBLES (especially when the Beast says stuff like “I feel like a Hindu sex god” , but mostly it’s the best superhero book on the stands by a country mile, wired to the present and ready to play. Leave your coat at the door and dance to the new.


from Page45@Page45.couk.com
 
 
Captain Zoom
19:58 / 12.12.01
Nice.

And whaddaya mean "justly slag off comic shop staff". Grrr.....

so, this week....

Punisher #7 - the first Nuff Said I've read, and Dillon's art is always a treat. Quite a nice change to see the art without Ennis' trademark crudeness. I'm still not sure if this silent issue thing is going to go well, but this one at least was relatively enjoyable.

Star Wars Tales #10 - Ennis and McRea doing a day in the life of a Stormtrooper that reads more like one of Garth's War Story books? This one's worth every friggin' cent.

X-Force #122 - More pop, more squabbles. I'm hoping that this book doesn't rest on it's laurels. I still enjoy it but it seems like every issue's the same sometimes. Edie complains about her media career, Guy gets, well, sensitive about something. The stories just don't seem to grip me the way NXM is.

Also, new Hellboy novel is out today. I cannot wait to read it.

Zoom.
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
20:04 / 12.12.01
I think X-Force gets better with every issue, really...with this issue, I finally admitted it to myself: This probably is better than NXM, or at least Germ Free Generation with the second string illustrators...

I really loved Lacuna.
 
 
sleazenation
20:22 / 12.12.01
on the 'justly slagging of comic book shop staff' thread...


Earlier today i went to london's comics showcase looking for copies of the establishment:

Me: do you have any copies of the establishment
Comicshopmoron: Which issues?
Me:Any
Comicshopmoron: issue 3 is the latest issue and we have soild out.


Er hello .. could you not have said 'sorry we have sold out of all copies of the estasblishment ' immediatedly rather than attempting a pointless attempt at monty pythons cheese shop skit?
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
20:27 / 12.12.01
you know, this is a really dumb thing to whine about, but I hate how at some shops they suddenly start putting all yr comics in bags with cardboards...I have to stop them as they are doing it, and stifle the part of me that wants to say "oh, that's not necessary...I READ the things..."
 
 
tracypanzer
12:19 / 13.12.01
X-Force is growing on me in a major way. The letters page is the best, still getting complaints from fanboys all up in arms because Cannonball isn't on the team anymore. This comic is subversive as hell.
 
 
Hush
13:00 / 13.12.01
Hi Zoom

quote: And whaddaya mean "justly slag off comic shop staff". Grrr.....


Sorry about the missing word 'some'. I'm all in favour of intelligent, literate people, and especially helpful ones in comic shops. And now I know two.

[ 13-12-2001: Message edited by: Ian Jawbone ]
 
 
Captain Zoom
17:42 / 13.12.01
Flattery will get you everywhere.

(And i mean eeeeeverywhere)

Zoom.
 
 
Mr Tricks
19:07 / 13.12.01
GOOOOOOOOO X-force!!!!
 
 
Sharkgrin
19:42 / 13.12.01
Vertigo's promotion of the anti-heroe is the best thing IMHO that ever happened to comics.
100 Bullets, Lucifer, and Hellblazer are testimonies to variety, flavor, and breadth that brand of character. Is there's a good guy (or at least altruistic) in any of these series, I've failed to find them.
Frank Miller promises the same, but never quite delivers anything but cookie-cutter 'lonely, surly, violent' types throughout Sin City and the DK's.
 
 
CameronStewart
19:52 / 13.12.01
>>>you know, this is a really dumb thing to whine about, but I hate how at some shops they suddenly start putting all yr comics in bags with cardboards...I have to stop them as they are doing it, and stifle the part of me that wants to say "oh, that's not necessary...I READ the things..." <<<

Do it, man, do it!

There's a particularly loathsome comic shop in town (which will remain nameless), who primarily caters to the speculator fanboy crowd. I happened to be in there one day and decided to buy a reprint of the Spider-Man "Death Of Captain Stacy" storyline (gorgeous Kane & Romita artwork). I bring it to the counter and after I pay for it the guy pulls out a bag and board, which I wave away. "I don't need those, thanks." The guy eyes me strangely and I decide to have a bit of fun. The cover of the reprint book was a new crappy piece of art by some unknown Marvel hack, so I said, "come to think of it, I don't need this either," and tore the cover off. Then I folded the coverless book in half and stuck it in my back pocket.

The look of horror and sheer bewilderment on the guy's face, like someone had taken the horizon away, is something that still brings a smile to my face...

[ 13-12-2001: Message edited by: CameronStewart ]
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
19:58 / 13.12.01
Vertigo's promotion of the anti-heroe is the best thing IMHO that ever happened to comics.

Reaaaaaalllllly?

100 Bullets, Lucifer, and Hellblazer are testimonies to variety, flavor, and breadth that brand of character. Is there's a good guy (or at least altruistic) in any of these series, I've failed to find them.

okay, so breadth is achieved by limiting characters only to that of being amoral and fairly rephrensible? Variety is achieved by keeping in the narrow confines of the crime, fantasy, and horror genres?

If there is anything within the current state of the comic industry that drives me up the fucking wall is the claim by certain fans and creators (hello, Frank Miller in Onion AV Club) that they are somehow expanding the horizons of the medium by doing non-superhero genre comics. Genre comics are genre comics are genre comics... westerns, crime stories, fantasy, horror, sci fi...these are not new or progressive things for the industry, in fact, they are quite retrogressive. I fail to see how doing pulp genre stories in lieu of superheroes moves the medium away from being considered a junk medium for degenerates by the populace at large...

[ 13-12-2001: Message edited by: Flux = Mute Superstar ]
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
20:06 / 13.12.01
quote:Originally posted by CameronStewart:

The look of horror and sheer bewilderment on the guy's face, like someone had taken the horizon away, is something that still brings a smile to my face...


Ah, that brings to mine the similar look of bewilderment when I was questioning an employee at the Forbidden Planet about why people were actually coming in to purchase up to 20 copies each of The Dark Knight Strikes Back, and me playing dumb when he was slowly explaining to me as if I were 8 years old how some folks were planning to sell them on eBay at an inflated price when they sold out, and I shot back with these three points:

* how the hell is it going to sell out? every comics retailer in the country ordered more than they could possibly need, even with a high demand
* non-comics retailers were carrying it, like say, the Virgin Megastore across the street, who ordered a similarly absurd number of copies, AND are selling it at a 30% discount
* the trade will come out immediately after issue 3 is released, so most people who missed out wouldn't have to wait long to get the story

the guy just *tsk tsk*'d me, and acted like I was talking gibberish...

then he pointed out that they were selling Origin #1 for $30. I told him I'd give him my copy for free, cos it sucked so hard.
 
 
The Knowledge +1
20:22 / 13.12.01
Well, every art form has its fair share of connotations relating to a moral divide, even if its just us judging whether it is 'good' or 'bad'. Vertigo uses Fantasy, Crime and Horror because these genres are rarely represented in mainstream superhero comics these days. To say that Lucifer, the characters from 100 Bullets, and most of all John Constantine are reprehensible people is narrow-minded and further, it reflects your own sense of a moral divide. In 100 bullets you have people making moral choices, in Hellblazer you have a central character who is uncannily and freakishly aware of the moral divide and his true place on it, and Lucifer is about Gods former right-hand man abandoning Gods moral divide and therefore denying science, reason, law etc, in view of something new.

Preacher was all about a third way past the moral divide, Transmet concerns a romantic torn apart by the maddness of walking the thin line of the moral divide, Invisibles looked at picking sides and judging each other based on our own sense of a moral divide.

Sandman is the only one which I feel avoids the moral divide, which is partly the reason it is so unique and well-loved.

Miller never fucked around here either. Moral divide is dealt with in Dark Knight, Daredevil, and, most of all, the harsh merciless black and white of Sin City.
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
20:35 / 13.12.01
Knowledge, that's all well and good, and I'm glad that you like it... it still doesn't answer my question about why it's the 'best thing to happen to the comics industry ever' or how doing genre work moves the industry foward in any way.

Issues of morality are nothing new to comics, or any other artistic medium. Not making any judgement call about the quality of any of those comics, but so what? What's so special about morality plays? What's so special about anti-heroes? These are tropes and cliches far more than they are examples of people moving the medium fowards...
 
 
Mr Tricks
09:21 / 14.12.01
um . . . did anyone read Detective comics???

I liked the new cover charactor . . .
 
 
Sharkgrin
09:21 / 14.12.01
Oh, that's easy Fluxy-pooh.

Besides 'Archie and his Friends (#2)', they (IMHO: antiheroe: the non-traditonal, aberrantly-behaving protaganists (#3)) were the third choice in comics besides the beat-to-death super heroe genre (#1 choice - I still follow them).

I wonder why people would give the cold war, raging, self-destructive loners, like the Hulk or Wolverine, so much praise? The maturing Batman (the Frank Miller/Tim Burton-translation consumed all his titles)? The alcoholic, girl-troubled, self-loathing Thing? Godzilla? the Sandman (consorts with devils, creates nightmares, drives folk insane, as required by the job)?
Because its more than a soundbite or a 'cliche'. It's variety and a whole range of writing to choose from within the medium of comics.

It also told parents, "Whoa, this stuff maybe just for adults. What happened to the old days of corny bank robberies and smiling, photogenic radioactive teenagers?"

But hey, if the Hulk, Hellblazer, and Batman's new clothes did'nt take morality into question (people getting explicitly killed/tortured to death/going insane), and didn't move the medium forward, then I guess we are probably meant to disagree.
 
 
The Natural Way
09:21 / 14.12.01
I think the point is....

Yes, that stuff might've been "revolutionary" in the late 80's, but it's all gone a bit stale now.
 
 
Haus about we all give each other a big lovely huggle?
09:21 / 14.12.01
Well, good thing we have New X-Men around to "reek of the now".

God almighty. And page45 is meant to appeal to the top end of the comics market....
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
11:53 / 14.12.01
Re: the new issue of X-Force.

Two words: special ointment.

Special. Ointment.

Genius.
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
13:25 / 14.12.01
quote:Originally posted by Sharkgrin:
It's variety and a whole range of writing to choose from within the medium of comics.


So, you're saying the only variety of literature in the comics medium that is worthwhile is variations on male power fantasies in superhero, crime fiction, sci-fi, horror, fantasy or western genre settings? That the depth *and* breadth of the medium comes from "grim and gritty" "dark" comic stories about anti-heroes, and that's that?

Sir, I do believe they are hiring at Wizard...
 
 
deja_vroom
14:48 / 14.12.01
Sorry, but here we get like 3 yers delayed when it concerns to comics. So:

I just bought PREACHER - ONE MAN'S WAR for a friend (the deal is, since this specialized comic shop is nearer from my work place, I buy them for him, read them, then give to him and he pays me back).
That's the edition telling about the past of Herr Starr. Great story. The bit where the lil girl is in his lap, face torn apart, and he says : "This is not how the world should be" was really touching. (Even though I know he was not meaning "oh, the poor little girl got killed, boo-hoo..")

As for myself, I'm only buying Sandman (they're republishing all the series in Brazil - I didn't catch the first time it came out cos I was too young and in my town we didn't receive these - then - obscure comic books). Can't get arsed to follow anything else.

Last one I bought was the second part of the Doll's House. Still waiting to see what's gonna happen.

Oh, and waiting for the announced publishing of The Invisibles.
 
 
CameronStewart
14:58 / 14.12.01
>>>It also told parents, "Whoa, this stuff maybe just for adults<<<

Well, I for one happen to think that Batman, The Thing, Spider-Man, Green Lantern, et al should be for children.
 
 
Chuckling Duck
18:52 / 14.12.01
quote:Originally posted by Flyboy:
Re: the new issue of X-Force.

Two words: special ointment.

Special. Ointment.

Genius.


And you love rubbing it in, don't you?
 
  

Page: (1)2

 
  
Add Your Reply