The final Comics Britannia last night was possibly the worst of the lot - strange really given that all the major players are still alive and there for the talking to. It covered basically the UK scene from Viz to Alice in Sunderland and Lost Girls, covering all the expected bases like Action, Dredd, Deadline, the US invasion etc. ... having trouble putting my finger on why it didn't work as well as i'd hoped. A few random randoms:
Where was John Wagner? Surely not excluded because he's american? they had melinda gebbie in there after all...
No mention of Hewlett's bound into mainstream pop art ligger luvviedom.
Some of the script was repeated almost word-for-word from the 2000AD radio 4 piece that phil jupitus did on saturday (available on radio 4 website to listen again until Saturday at least, but probably nothing new there for any barbebrits already reading this)
It was annoying the way they only referred to 2000AD in the past tense - mills and wagner are still there, thirty years later, and still turning in very good work indeed, more often than not...
Alan, please, you've got to stop reading out your own work like you reckon it's shakespeare. the baby jesus and the snake god glucose or whatever are both deeply deeply embarrassed. him doing his rorschach
voice was really unbearable, proper nails on the chalkboard time - I had to turn over.
No mention of the fact that the US superhero comic is now, and has been for twenty years, dominated by UK-bred voices. This is basically the only creative industry/genre where this is the case, and the success of gaiman, millar, ellis, hitch, molly etc deserved a bit of a mention over yet another reading from watchmen. (oh how i hated those bits.)
The otherwise superb stewart lee stumbling and looking rather uncomfortable while trying desperately not to say 'there's some pretty fucked up paedo shit in lost girls, but it's cool because mel and alan are just harmless hippies really...'
on the plus side, Viz, carlos ezquerra, lots of nice use of the art, suitably lugubrious voice over from ianucci, moore fleshing out his thoughts about v for vendetta further than i'd seen before, melinda gebbie... what did anyone else think? am i being too negative? |