BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Darwyn Cooke presents: The Spirit!

 
  

Page: 1(2)3

 
 
Billuccho!
17:11 / 16.12.06
Bought Batman/Spirit and The Spirit #1 yesterday. They're just plain fun comics. I've only read three Eisner Spirit shorts before this, so I don't have much to go on in terms of familiarity, but I quite liked this. Hell, Loeb was involved in Bats/Spirit and I didn't run screaming. That's a bloody miracle.

Ebony's appearance was great. The double-page splash should be a poster. Yeah, there wasn't a lot of formal experimenting, but it's the opening issue-- probably don't want to alienate anybody. I dunno.

The cover stock intrigued me as well. A little too stiff, kinda messes with the slick thin pages inside, but it's nice that they put a little effort into presentation.

It's not going to light the comics industry on fire, but it's a damn fine comic and a fitting tribute to Eisner, I'd say.
 
 
FinderWolf
17:52 / 17.12.06
The cover stock seemed the same cover stock to me as the old Kitchen Sink individual-issue (not hardcover or paperback) reprints of The Spirit that were done in the 80s. Maybe it was a tip of the hat to that, or just an unrelated publishing/style choice.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
18:42 / 18.01.07
Well kids, Will Eisner's The Spirit #2 came out this week with a beautiful cover chock full of light bondage. Cooke continues to impress with relatively understated storytelling choices and slick art. P'Gell's given some backstory, although I'm not sure how much is actually Cooke's and what was Eisner's; I've only read a couple shorts with P'Gell in them recently in my trolling of the Eisnerworlds. I'm hoping Ellen gets more space to shine in, though, especially as the Barbara Gordon vibe is there to be toyed with. Did anyone else pick this up?
 
 
FinderWolf
18:51 / 18.01.07
I'm getting it today... I don't recall P'Gell ever having been given in the original Eisner stuff (I've read most of it). Love Cooke and really enjoyed the first issue of this (I even enjoyed the Batman/Spirit crossover!)
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
19:09 / 18.01.07
I'd say it all hinges on that gorgeous two-page splash at the beginning, with P'Gell dangling a sweet, sweet bon-bon (after a fashion) for the audience to devour. Lovely.
 
 
Spyder Todd 2008
19:41 / 18.01.07
It's fun storytelling, and I'm enjoying this book. I rather liked Hussein Hussein, though I'm not entirely sure why. And the scenes between Spirit and P'Gell were great. Like Catwoman and Batman, only without all the bitching and general angst.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
20:31 / 18.01.07
Best line, bar none, P'Gell talking to a visiting prince: "I usually date kings but you'll do."
 
 
Haus of Mystery
15:57 / 20.01.07
Yeah...but this book's still disappointing me, I'm sad to say. Or perhaps underwhelming is a better description.
Once again, the beautiful double splash at the start aside, the storytelling is so straightforward. It's almost like a Saturday morning cartoon version of the Spirit. Like I said before, it's a real nice loking, accessible fun comic, but for some reason I want more than that. Look at Cooke's playful and brilliant issue of 'SOLO' - couldn't we have some of that joyous experimantation in 'The spirit'? It is after all what the comic's best known for.
I suppose he's writing and drawing a monthly book, that's certainly one of the freshest and purdiest on the racks and that seems to be on schedule, so I should be thankful for that. I dunno though... I think I'd like to be more blown away by it.
 
 
The Falcon
13:04 / 21.01.07
I think that's a fairly adequate summary of how I, too, feel, MacG. It's all a bit fluffy and whimsical, nice and pleasant certainly, but it's some way off capturing the post-McCarthy zeitgeist that New Frontier did so well, or anything much really other than a vague olde time sensation.

Part II of my confessions: I've not read any of the Eisner stuff, so don't really know how accurately this serves as homage.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
21:13 / 21.01.07
Well, I'm giving it some time to find its "voice" separate from attempted Eisner homage...we saw some beginnings of it in #2, I quite liked the flashback sequence with P'Gell -- the art style changed and the use of colour was good.

I'd actually be interested to see J. Bone pencil an issue as well as inking it - I've been a regular to his general and beefcake sketchblogs for a while and I'd be curious to see him drawing the Spirit more completely - maybe giving Cooke more time to come up with weirder story concepts.
 
 
FinderWolf
13:35 / 22.01.07
Yah, J. Bone is good stuff! Thanks for those links; very fun, they were.
 
 
Axolotl
16:26 / 23.01.07
J Bone does excellent work, and I highly recommend Mutant Texas by Paul Dini and J. Bone, and the Alison Dare: Little Miss Adventures, which is that rare thing: a comic that's actually meant for kids.
I enjoyed this issue, but I agree with Macready and Der Falke about its lightness: it's nice, but it's not as excellently awesome as say, "New Frontiers" or "Selina's Big Score", like I was hoping for.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
16:55 / 22.02.07
Hello, Central City!

Third issue's out this week and it's a beauty. I've only skimmed it so far with the swapping of point-of-view and the loose, neon flashback style. Was Spirit's father originally as he's presented here? Some soft examination of Denny's transformation and meeting up with Ebony, who's got some great potential this time round.
 
 
FinderWolf
18:07 / 22.02.07
I don't recall Eisner ever showing Denny's true "origin" per se - but I've only read about 3/4 of the Spirit stories or maybe a little less than that. Can anyone answer that question(i.e. did Eisner ever do a definitive origin...?) I just know Eisner would say 'he faked his death and lives in the cemetery, that's what you need to know' basically....
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
18:38 / 22.02.07
I'm pretty sure the first story revolved around it, which was reprinted in the "Best of..." with the Gaiman intro. I don't remember much about the story's detail work. I'll acquire it at work and have a look. PRETTY SURE there was no terrorism angle but it's been a while.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
04:17 / 27.02.07
Just rereading the third issue. Cooke does an excellent job of making Ellen look younger than she did in the previous issues, during the flashback...even just something about her eyes. And the weird, whispy-white inkwork accentuates everything so much...not a misty hazy flashback, more like a hyper-real, electric one...there's something very. I don't know, the slightly off-line colouring makes me think of Chaykin.

Nice to think of this as an alternate Earth's Central City, where Ebony isn't some terrible Minstrel Show stereotype.

Still unsure of how I feel about the inclusion of modern technologies like cellphones...I've noticed that many of the plots depend on them...Ellen's Fateful Call (tm) this issue, or the ongoing cellphone monologue by Ginger Coffee in the first issue. Ellen digging up dirt on P'Gell's marriages using the internet, which seemed a bit too "easy" as far as detective work goes, but I suppose they handle it just fine on Veronica Mars so I should probably give up on that. I think the series might grow into itself as far as its setting's anachronisms go. As it stands they stick out as plot-points but Cooke might get a better handle on them; they never really stuck out in his Catwoman run, although Brubaker was writing that one so never mind. He should go back and read those comics.

Actually, I'd love a Slam Bradley guest appearance, especially since Cooke seems to love him some Slam.

As much as I'm liking the supporting players, Cooke would do wonders if he'd maybe focus on them individually in upcoming issues. I think he handles the shifting perspective reasonably well (and the change in font/caption colour snaps it) and it just highlighted for me how important Ellen, Dolan, and Ebony are to the Spirit and how I'd love to see them fleshed out more.

Stand-alone that sets up future storylines. Elvarro could very well end up being the Octopus, couldn't he?
 
 
Haus of Mystery
08:58 / 27.02.07
It would be a real shame to give the Octopus an identity though wouldn't it? Kind of spoils the appeal of the character.

This was a nice issue - really liked the shifting narratives. This was almost a primer issue. It explained all the major characters connection with the Spirit, and gave them basic motivations.
I also really dug the colouring of the flashback - 50's Playboy/coctail hour primary colours that perfectly complimented the edgy simplified linework. I get the feeling that the eventual collection will look beautiful sans adverts.
And of course another beautiful splash page.

I maintain my slight reservations, but basically this is a solidly enjoyable comic. If Cooke remains onboard for a while it will hopefully carve out it's own stronger identity. Alongside 'Brave and Bold' this provided a good healthy dose of old school fun.
 
 
The Falcon
22:49 / 22.03.07
#4 seems to have sealed the deal, on top of what MacR & Papers above are saying. First of all, great cover; I'm a total mark for some stark backgrounding (pref. white) but I like the whole gender-reversal aspect, still moderately subversive alas, of it and the opening page or so of internal narration which is, I think, meant to trick you into thinking you're reading Denny, rather than Satin. If not, and the boxes are different to his in prior issue, my reading comprehension ftl, I guess.

It also pulls the tasty trick of now bringing the serial fiction aspect into what could, I believe, still be read independently as a single issue. Other things I am a mark for include: (quality) serial fiction, and the first three issues maybe felt too loose and unrelated, hence moderate disappointment. But now, momentum!

Good.
 
 
The Natural Way
08:21 / 23.03.07
Indeed. First two were about dropping us into the world, portraying a generic Spirit adventure and introducing some of the players, 3 was the primer/origin story as has been said and 4's kinda where it really starts.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
17:24 / 26.03.07
Read #4 on the day of, but only insofar as to get the gist; reread it this morning at the laundromat (as is my way) with a closer eye to detail.

The Spirit makes rather a habit of being handcuffed to women he both dislikes and is attracted to; so soon after the first issue's sewer (ah, sewers & tunnels with handcuffs) with Ginger Coffee, I'm left hoping against hope that Mister Cooke can break out of this particular formula before he's crushed under the weight of his own cliches. What's experimental once doesn't necessarily carry the same adjective the second time, and with a comic like this stale lurks around every corner. That said, it is a straightforward and to-the-point way of demonstrating and examining Denny's strong commitment issues, which are more humanistic to my eyes than, say, Batman scribbling "I must be alone on this lonely crusade," over and over again down a chalkboard. Denny being handcuffed to beautiful women who are also demonstrably more competent than he is suggests things about his relationship with Ellen (who also shows him up on her own) and maybe she should think about handcuffing their wrists together to get him to stop disappearing on her so they can have a quiet night in like grown-ups. Might also keep his eyes on her when P'gell saunters onto the panel again. Perhaps this handcuffing will prove a leitmotif.

The last page mirrors Denny's origin succinctly and suggests that he can't be bothered to remember his own origin, recapped just an issue before, with regard to supporting cast members possibly dying but we can't see their body. Seriously, Colt's an idiot playing detective. Silk Satin's final word states succinctly who she needs: herself. She doesn't need anybody to pull her out, doesn't need to have a dramatic resurrection scene, she's going to just quietly keep her eyes on the mysterious Octopus and follow him. Catch him.

I really don't want Elvarro to be the Octopus, but something itches in me that this is the way Cooke's pushing.

I'm still unsure of the scene with Silk kissing Spirit in the tunnel. It's awkwardly written - she knows he's breathing so she doesn't have to perform CPR, but given that she's trying to wake him up and then feels creepy using the sex appeal (which is a really good piece of character work), the whole thing comes off like she's suddenly overwhelmed by the situation & the Spirit's good looks rather than employing a tool she's uncomfortable using. Her attraction to him is interesting, how it's played, sometimes a little too forced but I like that she's a female doppleganger to the Spirit - their names are both insubstantial and epheremal-seeming, they both have death/rebirth/clawing-out-of-grave scenes, they both have a problem with femme/homme fatales (each to each other, of course).

Hussein Hussein seems problematic to me. I can't decide if he's demonstrating enough of a fleshed character to me or if he stands to become a thematic reincarnation of Ebony White Mark I while Ebony gets to be a real boy.
 
 
Haus of Mystery
23:29 / 26.03.07
I have to say, I like the slightly kinky aspect of the Spirit (both versions). Quintessential Spirit image is him handcuffed, possibly unconscious, with lipstick on his cheek.
In my head, anyway.

Liking the way that Cooke seems keen to delineate the various ladies in the Spirit's life - they are, after all, as important as Denny himself in the strip's flavour.
 
 
FinderWolf
14:35 / 27.03.07
Yep, MacReady - that's not just in your head, that's the way Eisner often presented The Spirit, so it's clearly very intentional on Eisner's part. It seems like 60% of the Spirit stories have that imagery or something very much like it... and yah, Cooke is doing brilliantly as the heir apparent to Eisner with the character.
 
 
Haus of Mystery
15:53 / 27.03.07
Compared to Batman's lurid roooftop S+M sessions with Catwoman, the Spirit seems positively well adjusted.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
16:45 / 19.04.07
Number Five!

I admit, I've been waiting for this one on the strength of the cover alone -- a great teaser image if there ever was one, in a world where comics covers are increasingly pin-ups rather than covers -- although it's been slightly altered to take a faux Manga tack with the Spirit's image on the pork n' beans.

Carrion's part of the classic rogues gallery, yeah? His relationship to Miss Julia is rather alarming. Presuambly, the Cossack's also an oldie.

Another mention of Mortez makes me wonder what role he has in the larger drama that's beginning to reveal itself. They do seem to be setting him up as a possible Octopus, but I hope it's not that simple.

Ellen is the Oracle. I'm wondering how her role as detective to Spirit's wo-fisted crime-fighter is in keeping with the original, but I think it works here.

Anyone else pick it up? I loved the commercial sequence!
 
 
Spyder Todd 2008
18:22 / 22.04.07
Indeed, the commercial was most excellent.

I like how we're sort of slowly reintroducing characters in this book so far, and this issue had two characters come back and be all kinds of cool. That's fine by me. And Julia is awesome.

All that being said, is anyone else terrified at the prospect of this?
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
00:21 / 25.05.07
Number Six! "Almost Blue."

[+] [-] Spoiler
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
21:12 / 20.06.07
Number Seven's out this week, featuring three stories by guest writers & artists - including an unexpected Chris Sprouse rendition of Central City & the Spirit - a story wherein the Spirit is the only one to not fall under the femme fatale's spell. Is the masked man finally showing some growth of character?
 
 
Haus of Mystery
11:28 / 27.07.07
Balls.

That's not good news.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
15:04 / 27.07.07
On the other hand, Bone doing more Jett Vector stuff is kinda sweet. I'd probably vote for Sprouse to take over the art chores, based on his fill-in short from #7.
 
 
Mark Parsons
04:27 / 01.08.07
Yes, Cooke's departure sucks ass. I hope he and J Bone get to do those other 12 issues some day. Read rumors that Jeff Smith might do some SPIRIT, which made be slightly less bummed. But I can't think of any other creators who I'd like to see follow Cooke's footsteps.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
04:41 / 01.08.07
Brubaker & our dear Cam? Their Catwoman had an Eisnerish sensibility to my untrained, tragically unhip eye.
 
 
Mark Parsons
15:40 / 01.08.07
Cameron S!
***smacks forehead***
Of course...

I just hope they don't rush a team onto the book and/or give it a hiatus if needed.
 
 
Haus of Mystery
18:33 / 28.09.07
Issue #10:

Nice enough issue - perhaps a little heavy handed, but it whipped along at a fair pace, and managed to be both 'Eisnerian' and very modern in it's approach. That said I found the little prologue bit with Dolan a little odd. I mean this meta-textual playfulness was common in Eisner's Spirit stories, but Cooke has for the most part being playing very linear with his version. Which made this stick out for me, and not really in a good way. It's been the lack of 'playfulness (nee 'risktaking') that has made this series a sometime lacklustre reading experience IMHO.

Is the next issue his last?
 
 
CameronStewart
00:15 / 29.09.07
Thanks for the nod, but I don't think I'll be doing any Spirit stuff in the foreseeable future. Darwyn and J. are both friends of mine and there's no way I'm gonna top them. And besides, I haven't been asked.
 
 
CameronStewart
00:15 / 29.09.07
Oh and their last issue is #12.
 
  

Page: 1(2)3

 
  
Add Your Reply