BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


On Human Universals...

 
 
Tom Coates
13:06 / 24.11.06
I know that there is a list, supposedly generated by Anthropologists, of aspects of humans that are supposed to exist in all cultures across the world. However I cannot find the list online. Can anyone help me with this? I think it might be the basis for a good conversation about universalism and consctructivism in the understanding of human identity.
 
 
Closed for Business Time
13:34 / 24.11.06
Try googling for emics and etics. Etics being the universal, emics the constructs...
 
 
Closed for Business Time
15:19 / 24.11.06
Tom, I found this. Hope it helps. It's a pdf in case anyone with a slow connexion wanna have a peek.
 
 
*
17:40 / 24.11.06
You want cross-cultural universals, Tom. I don't think anyone's collected a definitive list, because discussion is still ongoing about how scientific the idea of cross-cultural universals really is, and how you define what's universal. For instance, I've been told that every culture thinks murder is bad (by someone emphatically absolutist). But how any society defines murder varies, naturally enough, so much that the most inclusive definition would most likely be "bad causing a death," which is pretty circular. The use of language is a cross-cultural universal, but that doesn't actually tell us much about language or about how various societies are likely to use it. Eating is a CCU, but not cooking, or eating together— they're ALMOST CCUs, but almost doesn't cut it; that's what universal means. The most reliable CCUs are bare exensions from biological needs and the results of (biological) evolution— all people sleep, and all people dream, so all people have some way of describing their experience of dreaming— from journeying in spirit worlds to expressing unconscious wishes to neurons firing randomly.
 
 
Closed for Business Time
22:28 / 28.11.06
Also, this anthropology professor at UCLA Alan Page Fiske has a rather nifty theory of CCUs in social/relational cognition. Worth having a look.
 
 
Closed for Business Time
22:30 / 28.11.06
aaaarggghh bad link, we try again here
 
  
Add Your Reply