|
|
Olulabelle, if you need contraception, you'd rather be menstruating and you don't mind your periods getting a little heavier, have you considered switching to a copper IUD? The effectiveness rate is pretty much the same, it's marginally higher for Mirena but since it's well over 99% for both I wouldn't let that stop you.
I spent the best part of a year once being amenorrhoeic due to Depo Provera, and while I was overjoyed to be spared the menstrual migraines at first, after a while I just found the whole thing creepy. It's like being stuck in a room with a strong light on 24 hours a day, you feel a little lost without your personal biological rhythms. I hadn't noticed how important they were to me before, but I sure as hell appreciated them afterwards.
I do know what people mean about not feeling quite like a woman if I'm not menstruating, and politically I resent it somewhat because it implies that you're not a woman if you're post-menopausal, say, or amenorrhoeic due to illness, and that your gender identity has to be tied to your bodily functions. The feeling persists, however. I'll do what I can to make my periods shorter and more comfortable short of hormonal intervention, but I'm happier bleeding once a month. Oddly enough, I've felt more in touch with my menses since using a menstrual cup, which actually hugely reduces the amount of time I spend in contact with my blood or able to see any signs of it.
The fertility thing is strange. I do appreciate knowing that I am a (presumably) fertile youngish woman, which I am reminded of monthly. Having a copper IUD means that I'm still menstruating, a little more emphatically than before, and that probably makes me feel like I'm still fertile; I'm certainly still ovulating, the mechanism which prevents pregnancy happens further along the process. I can't get pregnant, though, and the heavier periods are in fact a sign of this rather than of increased fertility. It's a sort of strange doublethink, feeling like my body is normal (once I got over the initially weird idea of having a small device in my uterus, of course) but also feeling completely safe from pregnancy.
Incidentally, you're a little off with your researches on Judaism, at least with how they appear here. For starters, it's worth pointing out that you're describing a minority practice, perhaps only done by 1% of Jews (at least in the Diaspora), the ultra-Orthodox. Men are not permitted to touch their wives during menstruation; they're not permitted to touch other women at all in case they may be menstruating. Ultra-Orthodox Jewish life is sexually segregated as a result. It goes back to a menstruation taboo based on fairly standard notions of pollution, and many Progressive Jews find the whole idea pretty offensive, as well as feeling that restricting touch, both sexual and non-sexual, in this way is unhealthy (never mind sexual repression, what about hugs, damnit?!). I've never heard the theory of tuma that you cite mentioned, and I doubt that it is informing the practice of very many people. I do know that some ultra-Orthodox Jewish women find the cleansing ritual of the mikveh very spiritually meaningful, however.
Islam also has a menstruation taboo which plays out in slightly different ways, although when it came up in a women's interfaith meeting a few months ago the Muslim women strenuously refuted the word "taboo", saying, "But it's just hygiene!" No one I have spoken to in the UK has heard of this, but a woman I know in the US who's doing a PhD in henna has written papers on Muslim traditions (I think in Africa and possibly India) of painting the hands with henna, often very elaborately, to signify where they are in their menstrual cycle. The henna stain, which shades from orange to red to dark brown, reaches its peak around ovulation, giving rise to the myth that henna aids fertility, and has faded away by the next menses. This does at least solve the problem of not being able to ask women the delicate question of whether they're ritually "clean" or not. I find it fascinating, as it's being incredibly public about something that is usually hidden and even regarded as a pollutant in this situation; it's furthering a menstruation taboo which I regard as repressive and derogatory towards women, but at the same time it's artistic and celebratory. |
|
|