BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


The Writings of Ed Brubaker

 
  

Page: 123(4)5

 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
18:01 / 06.02.07
Oh no. Not like that. Especially in one crucial respect.
 
 
Haus of Mystery
16:48 / 07.02.07
Yep. I'd like to see a writer tackle the fact that he's 'the man without fear' - which to me suggests a massive scope for derring-do and hi-jinks.
 
 
Spaniel
17:29 / 07.02.07
I'd like to see a writer tackle the fact that he's 'the man without fear'

That's exactly what I was thinking.
 
 
Alex's Grandma
17:48 / 07.02.07
Oh no. Not like that.

I take your point, but it would still be nice to see Matt having nothing to do with the NYPD, the FBI, the Kingpin and in particular, with his rather dull job as a criminal lawyer for a bit. He should be seeing the inside of blood-soaked temples devoted to HYDRA and The Hand ideally, rather than New York courtrooms. A return to the odd, sort of drugged-out, creepily quasi-mystical tone of late Frank Miller would be good, I think. God knows, Daredevil would be tired of the American legal system by now, himself.
 
 
FinderWolf
13:49 / 17.05.07
Brubaker's DD has shifted to a more 'legal case/someone's getting framed' sort of CSI/legal drama vibe lately, without losing its superhero edge, which is fun.

And DD #100 is coming up - they're getting tons of guest artists from DD's history for that one. Should be fun.

Capt. America #26 has been delayed; so we'll have to wait to see the grisly (judging from the previews) autopsy.
 
 
FinderWolf
17:33 / 03.06.07
Latest issue of DD is pretty good, except....



....spoilers, kinda ....







....too many of the women in Matt's life have died already, I'm sure Bru. is using some misdirection here to make us think/fear another one is about to join that list... he's too smart to go the cheap route here. I hope.
 
 
Quantum
12:30 / 04.06.07
Is anyone reading Criminal?
 
 
The Falcon
21:13 / 04.06.07
Yes. I wasn't totally into the first arc, largely perhaps because of Leo's beard, but the second is off to an absolute flier.
 
 
This Sunday
21:22 / 04.06.07
I'd like to see the Daredevil who used to make up whole brothers to weasel out of things, and then kill them off. I'd like to see the Daredevil who was continually one step behind himself, but always pulling it off at the last minute.

I think Brubaker could pull this off, and it'd be nice if he had the inclination too. But, if the book's like the first few issues of his opening arc, I don't know that I'll be bothered to pick it up again.
 
 
The Falcon
21:42 / 28.06.07
huh, musta missed that post. Mike Murdock was invoked anyway, at the end of the first arc, but frankly if you didn't like that I can't help you. I do think Brubaker's going for more of a swashbuckling thing, there's an aspect of the Wally Wood era (at best guess, having never actually read it) about the run, but I don't think it's been as successful as the Oz tribute. God, I loved Oz.

The book's presently in a holding pattern, somewhat aggravatingly; beautifully paced for the trade, and eminently readable in chunks not so much in singles (although this has been the case for some six or seven years now) but - as Finder mentions - the mystery antagonist got played in year one of Brubaker's run, so I'd just like the [+] [-] Spoiler to step out from behind the curtain now. And we can run from there onto #100, which I emphatically won't be buying the Michael Cunting Turner variant of. I will actually not buy it if that's the only option. I feel very strongly about this.

Love love loving the sharp, high-contrast pencils & inks, esp. the pic on the new recap page, which is a solid argument in-and-of for b/w reprints, I'd say... it wouldn't be right to say I like the art as much as Mazzuchelli, would it? No. I love it almost as much. I'd actually quite like Lark on covers, as nice as the Bermejo, Tommy Lee Edwards and Djurdjevic pieces have been. The panels are actually very similar to Criminal's in as much as you get really narrow ones; I like the halting temporal effect a lot and it seems a very Bru thing, really.

Speaking of Criminal - 'Lawless', is really strong; I think it deepens the whole series, to the point where suddenly you can see matrices of possibility for the storytelling to go, even around this relatively small group and locale and also benefits from... well, not necessarily a more sympathetic lead, but one without - as I've mentioned - a fucking stupid chinbeard. And a bit more intrigue in his past; the Leo reveal was, I felt, a bit leftfield, bit of a cheat, but this whole thing looks set to play to Bru's best abilities rather moreso than the prior arc. Which was okay, don't get me wrong - it's just I think this is going to be - and is, so far - great, a really crystalline vision of what the writer of various murky mysteries is about.

(Incidentally, in case anyone was really interested - the guy in Uncanny X-Men, whose face seeker185 or whatever it was made you all so aggravatedly familiar with: he fucking was Masque. So I suppose we'll never know what point he was trying to make in that witless manner. Cock. It was a markedly better issue than the Shi'ar stuff, but I'd still be hesitant of recommending it to anyone over 18 or whatever.)
 
 
The Falcon
21:43 / 28.06.07
Btw, above spoiler is a guess, but it's the right one.
 
 
Spaniel
22:49 / 30.06.07
The escape sequence in the latest DD was soooo absurdly excellent there really aren't any words.

Except for mine

Win
 
 
Spaniel
22:50 / 30.06.07
And what a fabulous revamp of the Gladiator
 
 
FinderWolf
14:36 / 03.07.07
how do you know it's the [GUY REVEALED/SPECULATED IN SPOILERS ABOVE]? I haven't seen anything online or in print that points to him.

Clearly the Big Bad in this arc has mind-controlling powers, but the latest issue hints that he's passing out drugs that enhance his mind control over people or something...?
 
 
Imaginary Mongoose Solutions
01:44 / 04.07.07
That person makes sense, but so does Mr. Hyde or Mr. Fear.
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
08:34 / 04.07.07
There's also the possibility, since Brubaker and Bendis tend to work closely, that it's The Hood making his move - but perhaps that's too much interdependence?
 
 
The Falcon
10:32 / 04.07.07
I think so, Flybers. I think so.

The main reason I think so is because on the cover to #100 (which you can see here, although smaller than the one I have for wallpaper atm from some Newsarama Broob interview, think) there's one character who's not appeared in the entire Bendis/Brubaker era there and you have to think, along with the m.o., it's probably that chap.
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
10:53 / 04.07.07
Well-spotted, but I dunno how much we can read into that cover, what with the whole Skrullectra business...
 
 
Spaniel
11:35 / 04.07.07
Well, I'm struggling to imgine Mr Hyde as a criminal mastermind that's for sure
 
 
FinderWolf
21:20 / 09.08.07
So it seems the Big Bad in DD has been revealed, but it isn't someone I recognize at ALL, and I know my Marvel & DD history pretty darn well. It looks rather like a major character from the Bruce Timm Batman animated movie MASK OF THE PHANTASM. So I'm off to google & wikipedia to see what the heck is going on here...
 
 
Essential Dazzler
21:25 / 09.08.07
Despite the big-bad reveal being totally lost on me, that was a brilliant issue. I was totally stunned by the Subway events.
 
 
FinderWolf
21:46 / 09.08.07
a quick google search indicates that the big bad reveal was lost on pretty much ALL comics readers, and was disappointing to not only me but many fans of DD and fans of Brubaker.

The subway scene was shocking, though -- I gasped out loud while reading it (on the subway, no less).
 
 
Essential Dazzler
21:56 / 09.08.07
I should add that the reveal didn't dissapoint me in the slightest. I know very little continuity of any of the books I'm reading so rolling with the punches is something I've gotten pretty good at.
 
 
Imaginary Mongoose Solutions
22:42 / 09.08.07
On the other hand, I'm finally happy that I was able to guess the big bad in one of these things.
 
 
FinderWolf
13:57 / 11.08.07
maybe if said Big Bad character wears a costume a bit less silly (esp. since Bru's DD run has been a bit more grounded in gritty-reality, it seems) I could get into him more.
 
 
Spaniel
20:03 / 11.08.07
So, is Milla under the influence of Fear's drugs or is she just another casualty of DD's superheroic life? I kind of hope the latter because the story would be so much more compelling and nasty that way.
 
 
Spaniel
20:09 / 11.08.07
Agggkkkk! It would seem that Marvel have given fucking Alex "so so beautiful, a man in pants" Ross and Jim Bastard Kreuger Captain America's "Return".


No, no, bloody, fucking, shitting, NO! AFAIK, it Brubaker or it's... it's a creative team that aren't semi-bloody-literate at the very least.

Fan rant over.
 
 
Spaniel
20:35 / 11.08.07
Ah, goodie! Over at Newsarama less excitable souls are suggesting this'll chart his defrostment.

Fine by me, then.
 
 
FinderWolf
00:28 / 12.08.07
Milla must have been pushed a bit by Fear's mind-control rage/fear-mojo whammy. It would be a bit too much to make her hateful/evil/so violent that way, methinks...
 
 
FinderWolf
01:28 / 12.08.07
It actually isn't clear from the article whether this will really be Cap's actual return -- many people in the discussion are speculating that it's a Year One sort of story, but there is virtually no evidence in the article for this. The article leaves everything very intentionally vague.

I do agree that it is Brubaker's story to tell and should be his alone. I don't like the idea of pawning it off to Ross & Co. because they'll bring in even bigger sales numbers. And hopefully, that's not what it is.

Or maybe, this is about Cap's return but it's an ancillary book, a limited series to support & enhance Brubaker telling the proper return in the pages of his book. Hopefully.
 
 
FinderWolf
01:34 / 12.08.07
Comic Book Resources has an interview with Ross, in which he says:

>> ROSS: I'm really interested to see what comes next and want them to be left to tell their tale as they're going to tell it. We can provide critical commentary years from now when we know how everything worked itself out. Right now, it's still a very exciting story and it's been a worthy creative endeavor to see how Ed would work it.

So it sounds like Brubaker will still be telling the main story the way Bru wants to, from this -- which is a good thing to hear indeed.
 
 
Spaniel
11:54 / 12.08.07
Ya see, I didn't think she was so violent. Rather she was desperate, traumatised, and driven half-mad from living the superhero wife lifestyle.

I mean, I don't think her pushing a woman who symbolizes a lot of the terrifying hurt in her life constitutes off the charts behaviour under those circumstances. In fact I think that's pretty psychologically truthful stuff, hence my comments above about being slightly disappointed if they go the fear mojo route (although I fully expect them to).
 
 
Mark Parsons
15:18 / 12.08.07
Read the first few Brube DD issues and loved them. Am waiting for a few tpbs to come out, then plan to catch up. CAP is amazing, although I do look FWD to some developments/hints on the inevitable "Return" storyline.

Just checked out the SH'AR X-Men HC, which was good, solid stuff.

IRON FIST continues to amaze me and give me flanboy flashbacks to the era when I was always jonesing for whatever new book was due out (Miller's DD; Prime X-Men & Teen Titans etc).

I will catch up with CRIMINAL soon too.
 
 
FinderWolf
16:59 / 12.08.07
Also, the cover of the Alex Ross return has the hands of Namor and The Human Torch, so it's more likely (hopefully) than not that it may indeed be a Year One story about The Invaders or whatever.
 
 
tavella
18:30 / 13.08.07
The newsarama thread had a clarification from Matt Brady, noting specifically that continuity refers to *contemporary* continuity. And Ross talks about working with the post CW situation in the interview. So it sounds like it might be the Invaders take a trip in time.

Which makes me twitchy. Ross doing WWII Invaders? Great, plays to his strengths (great love for the classics, pulling the mythic aspects of characters.) Contemporary plays to his weaknesses (flat characterization, his whole they must NEVER CHANGE thing.)

Plus, given that Brubaker has said that one of the key themes of his arc is about what happens when this huge presence in the MU is removed, it really seems to stomp all over that story.
 
  

Page: 123(4)5

 
  
Add Your Reply