BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


The Writings of Ed Brubaker

 
  

Page: (1)2345

 
 
FinderWolf
13:38 / 19.02.06
We already covered Sleeper in another thread, I believe, and Brubaker's run on Authority is mentioned in the Grant Morrison/Gene Ha Authority thread. So this thread can be about Bru on DD and Captain America, as well as his Deadly Genesis if you like (although I believe there's already a thread on that too).

Brubaker's "The Fall" crime one-shot from long ago (a nice little story) is supposed to be on track to become a film, although we know how long that can take.

Brubaker's first issue of DD strikes a fine tone, I thought that the design and layout of the book echoed Alex Maleev's work on the Bendis run (specifically, little things like black backgrounds on the pages outside the panel borders and the exact same thickness of panel gutters as Maleev's, plus Lark's wonderful linework, echoed Maleev's art and design for me).

A new guy running around as DD on the rooftops of Hell's Kitchen? All we know about him is that Foggy is (probably) not involved with him and he was just trying to help Matt Murdock.

Matt's in prison and a lotta baddies are after him. The prison warden keeps arguing with the FBI over the irrationality of putting Matt in a cell block with super-villain-level criminals...and the Kingpin.

Matt still has to stand trial somehow...how will he get out of this, now that the whole world 'knows' that he's DD? And is Foggy really in serious danger, or will recover? And are all the 'Foggy will bite it' rumors and covers from upcoming issues that hint as much just misdirection from Marvel?

Oh, and Dakota North shows up too. Fun! I think Marvel is about to do a Dakota North miniseries. Saw some promotional art for it a while back.

I especially liked where a hood is talking to Matt and says 'a lot of guys here want to kill you, but my boys think you could be useful in a fight and a leader of sorts, why let your skills go to waste?' Matt keeps saying 'I'm just a lawyer, scram, you've got no business with me' and the hood points out that if he really were nothing but a lawyer, would he be talking so tough to a killer who could snuff him in 2 seconds?

Brubaker's Capt. America run has been very entertaining, too. First time since Mark Waid that the book has been solid.
 
 
FinderWolf
13:39 / 19.02.06
oh, and i know 'writings' isn't gramatically correct, it just sounded fun to me to put it that way...fake Chaucerian-sounding and such, I dunno.
 
 
FinderWolf
03:27 / 21.02.06
And it looks like Bru will be using the Shi'ar a lot in his upcoming X-Men run...it'll be interesting to see them in the X-Books, it's been a while since Grant M. used them in "Imperial"...
 
 
Alex's Grandma
03:37 / 21.02.06
How do you picture the events in DD developing while BB's in charge, FW? Is it all just going to be a bit like a terrible nightmare? Or do you feel more positive?
 
 
Mark Parsons
04:00 / 21.02.06
Dunno on DD. Truth be told, I've been a tad over the horned blind one since Miller & Mazzuchelli's BORN AGAIN. Smith was OK, Bendis vastly better but still seemed an extension of Miller. Brube has won me over with Cap (best ever) and the X-Men min1-series and his pitches RE the upcoming run on whatever book he's slated for. But as much as I really liked & admired his first DD ish, I somehow don't quite care what happens to Murdock. of course, I'll give him the benefit of the doubt and stick around for the first arc. I'd LOVE it if I became an active DD fan again: it's been a long time...
 
 
The Falcon
12:27 / 21.02.06
Thanks for doing this Finder. I forgot/never got round to it.

Anyway, I first read of Brubaker as part of the new wave of apparently very post-noir, 50's influenced American scriptwriters that were coming up in the late 90's; Bendis and Rucka being the other two, otoh. Might've been one more, but I cannae mind. At the time, he was by some distance the least famous, BMB had taken over Ultimate Spidey, and Rucka was doing, I dunno, Detective? Batman? Yeah, I think he'd done a lot of that 'No Man's Land', anyway. Brubaker had done Deadenders at Vertigo (which had nice art, iirc, not read it) or something, and was about to start doing Batman - some of which I later read, and wasn't very taken with, possibly partly due to Scott McDaniel's rubbish pencil-work.

Anyway, I sort've disregarded him (bought one ish of Dead Boy Detectives when there was sod all in that week - it's a Sandman spin-off, so you can probably imagine pretty much, though his Prez one-shot's decent) and carried on reading comics by Brits who'd done Vertigo titles at some point or other, the majority of whom ended up doing Marvel books over the late 20th/early 21st century. Until a pal, who'd lent me a not small amount of money when I was needy, the majority of which I'd paid back, expressed an interest in this Sleeper comic. As I went for the comics on a regular, anyway, I figured I should just get him it (and read it to myself first, of course.) Sleeper was pretty much the bomb, as you may know; it brought the grime to Wildstorm comics when there was pretty much fuck all else going on there, post-Authority, and between Planetary issues which largely aren't worth the wait anymore (I've yet to be convinced of the virtues of Joe Casey.) Sean Phillips, who must be one of the most underrated artists in the game, brought a suitably blocky, shadowy atmosphere and there were lots of nice narrative spins, like the embedded origin stories the villains told. So, at that point, I was sold.

Not much later, I think, I'd signed up to Barbelith and Cameron 'don't call him Cam' Stewart was showing his art for Catwoman off in a thread or link somewhere; I'd noticed the earlier Cooke/Allred redesign of the character and been really impressed, but it was Catwoman, y'know? Years of Jim Balent and his breast fetishism had their toll on perceptions of the character; but having read some of Sleeper, and been suitably impressed, I picked up the 5-6 issue arc with the Black Mask. I was pretty blown away; again, it was street-level, but the art combo of Stewart and Matt Hollingsworth's brilliantly chosen, flat palette alongside a really pretty grotesque denouement and wonderfully-realised characters (especially Holly, Selina's ex-junkie, gay best friend) made it really feel like an anachronism, something unique. The following arc, illustrated by Javier Pulido, 'No Way Down' was - in retrospect - the best character arc that came out that year (2003?) Again, it brought a great disjunct in presentation (four colour palette or something close, verrry elegant, simple linework) with content - a superheroine comic, albeit a very emotional (depressing, sad) one. Embedded stories ruled it here too; Holly's memories and dreams when she pocketed some medication were beautifully linked with childhood memories of listening to a shell-conch, wordlessly. Selina's dreams of everything being okay slipped away into her painful new life. There followed a tour of DC's lesser cities - Opal, Central - and a hookup with Ted 'Wildcat' Grant, which should always be good, and was and it was a nice bit've kitsch. Then Paul Gulacy came onboard for art and sucked it, massively, which is a shame 'cos I liked his Shang-Chi when I was 8 or so, so I stopped reading. (I've only read bits of Gotham Central, half of which is Rucka anyhow, but I did think it more than decent; perhaps Benjamin can fill people in on that a bit more.)

I'll get to the Marvel stuff later; just reread Cap. Tapped out for now.
 
 
FinderWolf
19:13 / 21.02.06
his Catwoman was terrific and thankfully redefined the character, his Prez one-shot was indeed great, and Sean Phillips is indeed a vastly underrated artist (although his style has been evolving a lot lately; I find myself liking the style he used a few years ago more than the current style - though he's still a fantastic artist either way).

I never read Deadenders, just admired the Philip Bond covers.

As for DD under Bru, I think it's in good hands...I'm not really sure what to expect. How do you write your lead character out of prison when his ID has been blatantly uncovered for all the world to see? Should be interesting...
 
 
Robert B
19:19 / 21.02.06
Based on this thread and my nostalgic love for Captain America (The Scourge of the Underworld and Super Patriot stories being old favorites of mine) I'm picking up Brubaker's run on the new Captain America book. Looks like it should make for a good read.
 
 
Solitaire Rose as Tom Servo
01:23 / 22.02.06
I generally like his stuff, but his X-Men mini-series is a hard, hard slog and doesn't bode well for his run on the main book. Issue three in particular was pure filler that seemed to just be there so that Marvel could snap up another $3.50. His Daredevil has promice, though, since he didn't just pull a magic "it's all better now" story and seems determined to continue the idea of DD being a book where actions have consequences and THAT is the theme of the story.
 
 
Jack Denfeld
01:37 / 22.02.06
Based on this thread and my nostalgic love for Captain America (The Scourge of the Underworld and Super Patriot stories being old favorites of mine) I'm picking up Brubaker's run on the new Captain America book. Looks like it should make for a good read.
There's a cool inexpensive hardcover covering the 1st part of Winter Soldier.
 
 
Robert B
01:43 / 22.02.06
Thanks Jack. I just looked it up on Amazon and will probably go ahead and pick it up later this week. I'm eyeing one the first Catwoman trade of his as well... hmmm...
 
 
Sniv
12:31 / 22.02.06
Deadenders is great stuff. I'm not sure why I picked it up - probably Bond's covers, even though I didn't know who he was then - I was quite young and it was pre-invisibles for me. It's a lovely story filled with lovely cliches about the post-apocalypic world, but the nu-mods on their scooters, and the friendships between the characters are well worth reading for. Nothing groundbreaking but they're good, wholesome comics, kinda like a roadtrip/rites of passage movie for alternakids in the future.
 
 
Spaniel
12:31 / 22.02.06
His Daredevil has promise, though, since he didn't just pull a magic "it's all better now" story and seems determined to continue the idea of DD being a book where actions have consequences and THAT is the theme of the story.

Apparently it was Brubaker that made it possible for Bendis to end his run on such a down note, in that he offered to take up the baton with Matt in prison.
 
 
sleazenation
13:10 / 22.02.06
I'd like to speak up for The Fall, because it is a brilliantly engaging and fulfilling , self-contained narrative and it makes use of Jason Lutes on artwork detail, a cartoonist who is, in my opinion, one of the most tallented out there...
 
 
Axolotl
12:30 / 26.02.06
The first Brubaker book I read was a little mini-series he did back in the late 90s on Vertigo back when I pretty much picked up their stuff exclusively. I think Lark was on art duties as well. I t was a nice little 4 part crime story. I picked up some of his other work like Deadenders and some of his Batman run. Really though it was Catwoman and Gotham Central that really won me over. I'm a bit dissapointed with the cancellation of GC and I've never been a big DD fan. How ever his Books of Doom thing is quite good, though that might just be my pro-Doom bias speaking. I reckon he's definitely one of the better writers in comics at the moment.
 
 
The Falcon
16:10 / 26.02.06
Scene of the Crime, Phox?
 
 
FinderWolf
19:06 / 26.02.06
Also, Brubaker first broke into the comics scene writing and drawing (!) an autobiographical indie comic called LOWLIFE, IIRC.
 
 
Axolotl
18:17 / 27.02.06
Yeah, that sounds about right Dunc.
In fact having just googled it, like I should have done in the first place, that's the one. Cheers.
 
 
FinderWolf
13:12 / 23.03.06
Bru's new DD issue is out...pretty great stuff. I'm also digging Tommy Lee Edwards on covers (I always thought he was underrated and underused & deserved to be put on A-list books, nice to see Marvel getting that now...DC would put Edwards on The Question mini and The Wintermen miniseries, Marvel puts him on Daredevil).

So Matt is really being pushed over the edge...Brubaker shows us a super-violent scene where Matt shows the Owl who's boss, but takes away the 'kewl, Matt just totally kicked that guy's ass!' feeling when Ben Urich and Dakota North point out how Matt's really lost it, and it's not at all 'kewl' for Matt to be reacting to everything with fury, rage and violence, especially when he's in gen. pop. I loved seeing Ben Urich vowing "We're going to save Matt Murdock."
 
 
Robert B
15:33 / 23.03.06
Well, I'm all caught up with Brubaker's run on Cap'n America and I have to say it's fantastic. The Nomad issue is my favorite so far. I kind of expected the ending but I didn't predict it which is always good. I liked it so much I picked up the first two issues of his Daredevil run and from what I've seen and heard I shouldn't be disappointed.
 
 
Jack Denfeld
18:05 / 23.03.06
I just read on Newsarama that the identity of Daredevil on the streets while Matt is in jail is gonna be revealed by Mark Millar in the Civil War books, Weird.
 
 
FinderWolf
19:28 / 23.03.06
oh, you mean that new 'replacement' Daredevil running around Hell's Kitchen? where did you read this?
 
 
Jack Denfeld
19:32 / 23.03.06
There's some Civi War spoiler stuff there but here's the link.
CivilWar
 
 
The Falcon
21:02 / 23.03.06
The word I'm hearing is...

SPOILERS!




Iron Fist.
 
 
Jack Denfeld
00:10 / 24.03.06
Duncan, wouldn't that be a bad ass reveal? You see the Daredevil dude fightin' some heavy baddie, and then BOOM hits him with his Iron Fist!
 
 
Robert B
10:47 / 24.03.06
Duncan,
That was the first thought running through my mind when reading issue 82. That's who my money's on.
 
 
The Falcon
12:48 / 24.03.06
I could kick myself. Forgot this shit (DD) today. Got Cap, though, but still. Damn.
 
 
Spaniel
17:17 / 22.04.06
And as usual Daredevil is the shit. Another star studded episode, another bout of intrigue and gritty prison drama. Daredevil beating the living shit out of Hammerhead, and Bullseye being delivered to Ryker's in the style of Hannibal Lector (perhaps Brubaker will do the character justice - imo, Bendis's treatment of the character was gravitas-sapping and dull). Oh and a killer sucker punch at the end.

This might be my current favourite book.
 
 
Jack Denfeld
00:50 / 23.04.06
That ending kicked all kinds of ass.
SPOILERS













As soon as I saw Bullseye there I started thinking, Man they need Punisher in that prison. And sure enough! But why is Punisher going there?
 
 
FinderWolf
00:56 / 23.04.06
To kick all kinds of criminal ass.

He just might think he'd be 'helping' Matt Murdock. But something tells me his version of 'help' might not help all that much.
 
 
Jack Denfeld
01:11 / 23.04.06
Maybe he's ready to bring Matt over to the dark side? Punisher and Dardevil have always had a strange relationship over the years, with Punisher usually taking the worst of it.
 
 
Spaniel
06:54 / 23.04.06
Why does the Punisher do anything?

Gunishment.
 
 
FinderWolf
13:35 / 23.04.06
this is my new favorite word. Thank you.
 
 
dmj2012
22:05 / 23.04.06
I haven't been a regular comic reader for a long time now. I really liked Scene of the Crime, both for Brubaker's writing and Michael Lark's fantastic art. I recently read his Authority miniseris, which I liked as well. I'll have to start looking out for some of his stuff.

I recall a buddy of mine who runs a comic shop in Santa Fe saying that Brubaker stopped in from time to time. At least I think it was Brubaker. Does he live in NM, does anyone know?
 
 
Eskay Uno
03:16 / 24.04.06
Can someone please explain how MM/DD managed to escape his cell so he could go beat on Hammerhead???? Did he use his radioactive-magick-ninja-powers? WTF? It was done so fast, it's like the door wasn't even locked.
 
  

Page: (1)2345

 
  
Add Your Reply