BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


The Prisoner... returns?

 
  

Page: 1(2)

 
 
Mister Six, whom all the girls
20:20 / 23.11.05
Well at least that's sensible.
 
 
Spatula Clarke
23:04 / 24.11.05
Didn't I already cover all of this in the second post? I think I might have.

that sense of things having been cobbled together adds to the skewiff atmosphere.

Ah, yeah. There it is.
 
 
Elijah, Freelance Rabbi
16:01 / 05.05.06
Chris Eccleston named as #6 in the remake of The Prisoner, due out early 07.

I find it funny he left Who so he wouldn't be typecast in geek TV. Good job Chris.
 
 
Kali, Queen of Kitteh
17:53 / 05.05.06
I don't care. He can be my Number Six any time he wants.
 
 
This Sunday
19:36 / 05.05.06
Just visualize him in that beasty mask from towards the end! Marvelously unnerving.

Between a new version of 'The Prisoner' and a presumed feature film, plus those 'Matrix' thingies probably pulling decent bank still, on DVD and torrent downloads... what's left for an 'Invisibles' film that isn't set in the twenties and involving a two-handed Beryl?

And can we get someone to fund that, please? Especially if it has to star Chris Eccleston as Beryl.
 
 
H3ct0r L1m4
21:18 / 05.05.06
Sky One's biggest drama commission ever" will have more in common with glossy conspiracy fare like 24, which incidentally goes HD in two weeks time, and Lost than with the surreal Patrick McGoohan original, famously set in the Butlins-meets-Alcatraz Welsh village of Portmeirion.

Suck Alert: AMBER
 
 
Kali, Queen of Kitteh
22:26 / 05.05.06
Daytripper, you're reading my mind....
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
23:21 / 05.05.06
I kind of think they've dropped the (big, inflatable) ball on this one- before Lost, they may have been in with a chance.
 
 
penitentvandal
06:59 / 12.05.06
Yeah, Lost is the Prisoner of the new millennium...

That sounds like an old Superman cover, doesn't it?

Superman: (in kryptonite chains, natch) Lois is dead...Batman has turned evil...and Jimmy and Robin are his captive slaves...and there's nothing I can do about it!

Cover line: A future world where heroes have turned villains and evil reigns supreme! DARE you read the terrifying tale of Superman: Prisoner of the New Millennium?
 
 
sleazenation
07:47 / 12.05.06
Sounds like someone at sky was... um lying, or at least, exaggerating the truth to breaking point. Just as Joel Silver misrepresented Alan Moore as being very happy with the V for Vendetta movie, it appears that Chris Eccleston hasn't signed anything and apparently has only had the vaguest of meetings with Sky who are now claiming that they are seeing other people.

Sounds very much like the makers are wanting to link their rehash with the success of Dr Who... regardless of the dubioud merits of a reheated version of The Prisoner...
 
 
PatrickMM
22:55 / 12.08.06
Apparently, Christopher Nolan's working on a film version of The Prisoner.

I wasn't particularly impressed by any of Nolan's previous work, but even if I did like his stuff, this feels like a creatively bankrupt venture. Much like The Wicker Man, so much of the appeal of the project comes from the uniquely 60s aesthetic. The original still holds up really well and generally speaking, remakes work better on a project that didn't quite work the first time.

Admittedly, Miami Vice took a pretty good series and made a fantastic film out of it, however I don't see Nolan going towards arty abstraction like Mann did. Also, Miami Vice had the advantage of not being a specific story that was remade, in the case of The Prisoner, there's a clear arc already in place. Why can't Nolan just write an original script inspired by The Prisoner, rather than going for the remake?
 
 
Bandini
19:05 / 03.02.09
News from the production of this

AICN

I can't believe Jesus is playing Number Six.
 
 
ghadis
05:20 / 05.02.09
I was getting all excited about Robert Powell then until i clicked the link.

There's a quick chat with Number 2 here...

'There's nothing about this version of The Prisoner which is challenging the first or commenting on it. It's simply taking that nightmare of being in a place you don't want to be in, apparently for your own good, and unable to do anything about it. Stuff of nightmares.'

Nicely anti-CCTV is Sir Ian...

There's been no law passed to have all this surveillance. We weren't asked what we thought about it. It's all for our own good, we're told. I'm resisting strongly, trying to get out of my suburban street what a lot of the locals want there, which is constant CCTV. I don't want it. I don't want people to know who comes knocking at my door or who I ask into my house. The war on terror as a concept is catch-all, isn't it? If you object to television in the streets, you're supposed to be on the wrong side in the war on terror. Well, then I'm on the wrong side'
 
 
BrianFitzgerald
16:31 / 12.08.09
A 9-minute preview of AMC's reinterpretation of "The Prisoner"

I love the original and of course have the usual reservations of seeing a reinterpretation of something treasured, but this looks pretty great.
 
 
Spatula Clarke
19:08 / 12.08.09
You mean apart from the way that they've fucked with the basic premise by turning it into The Truman Show?
 
 
BrianFitzgerald
19:28 / 12.08.09
"The Truman Show"? I thought they were trying to turn it into Seaguy: Slaves of Mickey Eye.
 
 
Kali, Queen of Kitteh
22:32 / 12.08.09
Ohh, yes, I saw that. It looks terrible. I'd only watch it for Ian McKellan. So many hopes dashed...
 
 
Jack Fear
00:19 / 13.08.09
Could be a mildly interesting spin, actually—the focus has obviously changed from interrogation to persuasion. Judging from that trailer, at least, Two doesn't seem to want information from Six—only agreement. Ontological consensus as nightmare.
 
 
Kali, Queen of Kitteh
11:12 / 14.08.09
Jack, you always do find a bright side.
 
 
Jack Fear
16:33 / 14.08.09
I'm just sayin'. It looks like an honest-to-Allah re-imagining, rather than a remake—using familiar tropes to make a different point, rather than simply swapping out seaside for desert and playing out the same action.

It could still be disastrous, of course; but at least there's a chance it will be disastrous in an unexpected way.

If that's incurable optimism, then God help me.
 
 
Kali, Queen of Kitteh
09:50 / 15.08.09
Nah. No one said it was incurable.

Anyway, despite my misgivings, I have no doubt that I will still watch it. I can't really pass judgment on something unless I have seen it. Saying "oh this will suck" without actually laying eyes on it is not the way to go.
 
 
Alex's Grandma
23:22 / 24.08.09
Judging from that trailer, at least, Two doesn't seem to want information from Six—only agreement.

I've not seen the orginal in ages, but to an extent, wasn't that always the case?

I suppose the main disappointment about the trailer's the absence of the Pop Art/surrealist (avant garde at the time, at least in TV terms) approach to the Village - what's on screen so far could be an out-take from 'Lost.'
 
 
grant
13:09 / 25.08.09
Funny - I've just been watching The Prisoner on the Netflix (up to The Schizoid Man so far). Haven't seen it before, although I did read that mystifying comic sequel that came out in the 1980s.

The people in charge - the parade of Number 2s - they definitely want information. They say as much in the title sequence, I think. The nature of the information is never clarified, although there's an implication that it's not so much a "what" (what do you know?) as a "why" (why are you *really* retiring?), which throws it into that existential territory.

They want Number 6 to share the same motivation as them… to choose a side. That's a kind of agreement.
 
 
Alex's Grandma
00:42 / 26.08.09
To clarify my above post, I don't mean the new Prisoner should have aped the original's style, so much as attempted a proper Twenty First century/American take on the psychedelic, class-based weirdness of the show's design.

The move to the desert's okay in principle, but it seems a bit light on rotting symbols of empire; I'd have included something to do with Skull And Bones iconography (after all, there's room to manouevre -who really knows what those guys get up to?) and set it in a strangely re-vamped Aztec ruin in Honduras, or Guatemala.

It also seems a bit hopeless that Number 2 (*coff*) is an Englishman. If you don't have the stones to attack your own country, is The Prisoner a project you should be going anywhere near?

Oh well. Hope it passes a few idle hours if it happens to show up on telly, and I am alone.
 
 
FinderWolf
20:25 / 13.11.09
anyone watch this? It's gotten weak/bad reviews, it seems... I am a big fan of the original show.
 
 
FinderWolf
20:25 / 13.11.09
anyone watch this? It's gotten weak/bad reviews, it seems... I am a big fan of the original show.
 
 
Kali, Queen of Kitteh
11:00 / 14.11.09
Hasn't premiered here (Canada) yet and I am not entirely sure if it's something I want to download.
 
 
NewMyth
11:01 / 05.12.09
SEMI-SPOILERS: I've only seen the first night's show of two hours. I will reveal a few things. But there were two more nights of two hours each which I did not see, and hence cannot spoil.

The basic setting as you've seen in the trailers is cool: the desert, the A-frame houses, Ian McKellan as Number 2, a really large Rover...

But sadly, the details are not very compelling.

Number 6 did not seem to be a resigned spy, but some kind of statistician. There's a guy who may or may not be Number 6's brother -- 6's memories are messed with, so it is not clear. Number 2 apparently has an ailing or drugged up wife. There's a mysterious young man, 2's son.

Basically, so much is changed and new, it is not really the Prisoner. I couple friends who had never seen the Prisoner were rather enjoying it; but a friend who's a big Prisoner fan, and myself, did not particularly like it.

The plot of these first two hours just felt like a whole different show. Depending on how events developed, it might be interesting, but it really is not the Prisoner.

There's a nice bit where 6 comes across a bearded man who escaped from the Village -- he's wearing the classic Number Six black with white trim outfit from the original series. I understand this cameo was going to be played by Patrick McGoohan.

I suppose I will try to see the remaining four hours at some point. I enjoy remakes when they are true to the spirit of the original, re-envisioning it for a different era. But they've made so many changes here, I think Prisoner fans will be disappointed.
 
 
Mistoffelees
14:40 / 05.12.09
On io9 the critics were quite harsh. And most of the posters also were dissatisfied. The twist also disappointed a lot of people and apparently it was lifted from another TV show.
 
  

Page: 1(2)

 
  
Add Your Reply