|
|
Well, it's a great thread and it's wonderful to see my favourite band of the moment being taken seriously, and discussed intelligently. I don't have much to argue with or even to add, except that the whole spoken section of "Swinging London Town" falls kind of flat for me, rather like the talking in "Never Ever" ~ it's one thing to do amateur school-choir ("Wild Horses"), and another yet to do bad school drama. It doesn't seem to scan, and it's delivered very clumsily. Maybe that's the "point" ~ for it to be flat, anyway ~ but the images seem emptily stereotypical. The song escapes 1960s Austin Powers, but this is almost a 1980s stereotype of what the rich kids do ("Sushi... Chelsea chicks...Hooray Henries..." it's like a Christmas stocking guide to Sloane Rangers). This section seems to deal in dated, easy caricature, comparable perhaps to Williams' "Life Thru A Lens" ("Mix with the local gentry and don't crash Tarquin's Bentley") or something from mid-1990s Blur ("He’s never cheap or cheerful He’s Hugo and he’s Boss").
Anyway, the line "Do you know the me that wakes" is stunning by comparison, grimly self-reflective ~ a surprising lyric, very much unlike the shallow list of London drinking types. It reminds me a little of a line I was enjoying last night, Britney's "Say hello to the girl that I am", boldly opening "Overprotected".
xoxoxoxNADINExoxoxoxo
sorry I am just copying stuff out of my rough book there.
Just as a slight addition to the thread, I was going to give my thoughts on why "Biology" seemed a quintessential GA tracks at the moment.
1. Several different songs, cut-and-shut together like one of the cars in the "Long Hot Summer" garage. I think the video illustrates this pretty well, with the girls changing costume and background across the various sections, and changing back again.
2. Similarly, the way the structure slots those sections together, repeating a couple and just abandoning others after one use.
0) Intro
a) Why Don't You Fool Me
b) I Got One Alabama Return + Closer [I count these as 1]
c) You Give It Up
d) You Can't Escape My Biology
a) Why Don't You Fool Me
d) You Can't Escape My Biology
0) Intro
I think I've got that right ~ looking at it this way, it's just incredible that you have one verse, once, never repeated, so whatever glimpse of a meaningful "story" in this more wordy, more narrative-heavy section is simply abandoned after one shot. The glorious "You Give It Up" section is used once, where some songs would try to bleed it to death ~ it's as though it's so great, it could only be played one time only, or as though they've got so much great stuff, they can just throw that out with no need to wring it dry, even with a single repeat.
3. Near-meaningless lyric, which nevertheless has some teasing hint that it could make sense. There's a notion there somewhere, darting between the lines, of a girl who has to get away from a boy (presumably ~ a geek, even) because when they get together it's just too dangerous and hot, but they can't escape their biology.
She wants love, hugs, to be needed, instead of wicked games, and so she's got her ticket away to Alabama (why a return, in that case?), but she's not going to be able to resist that pull back to him.
She knows she should zip it up, give it up, get her head in the shade, freeze and cool off, but the red heat, the thrill, the heartbeat is just getting closer, and closer, and closer...
And that's about all you can get out of it, at a push. Typical.
4. Pastiche and tribute to musical history. I would identify Bowie's "Jean Genie" in the Intro there ~ maybe others hear something different, or something more. Cf. "My Sharona" = "No Good Advice", and so on.
5. I suggest, a bit more controversially perhaps, that the song reflects the band's hierarchy and order of importance. It opens entirely with Nadine. The song is only taken over by Tweedy with "So I got my cappuccino to go", 46 seconds into the track. If you check the video, Nicole does not say a word until about 1.27, and then she says one word: "closer". Once. Sarah and Kimberley come in a little bit earlier.
Tweedy is the closest the band has to a frontwoman, I would suggest, but isn't it the case that Nadine has the only solo ballad ("No Regrets")? If Nicole solos on "It's Magic", I only realised it today, and listening to that track again I found it really feeble.
I might find it hard to support this opinion with anything but my own feelings but I believe those are the two strongest and most dominant members of the band, and "Biology" reflects that order of things. |
|
|