BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Press reporting suicide

 
 
astrojax69
05:30 / 08.04.05
don't know if this shouldn't be in conversation, but i guess it is a cultural issue...

most people, if asked to rank in descending order the number of deaths annually across australia from motor vehicle collisions, suicide and murder would perhaps replicate the order i have [many western countires would be similar, though the usa has a high murder rate]. they would be quite shocked at the disparity between suicides and mvc's, with the former being far far greater (in austalia, several thousand compared to several hundred)

in australia, and from what i gathermost western states, we don't report suicides (unless the death is also newsworthy for other reasons) and this is a tacit agreement between authorities and press for reasons of minimising the sensationalising of suicide and an attempt to curb 'copycat' suicides by impressionable members of the community.

australia has had some very graphic and deliberately shocking ads about road safety.

it seems that the numbers of suicides are on the increase. and a number of single vehicle motor vehicle collisions are probably suicide but not recorded as such... so perhaps the tactic of non-reporting is failing and we should bolster education of the issues with the shocking facts of the numbers in point.

suicide constitutes just 2% of deaths in austalia, but up to 17% of young adults, so it is a significant health issue; and a cultural issue - a far greater number of rural adolescent men suicide than their urban counterparts.

how do you think you and your families and friends would react to the regular reporting of such deaths, openly? how would affected families feel about it? do you think it would help or hinder the efforts at reducing the toll?
 
 
astrojax69
06:13 / 08.04.05
just found this which compares australian figures with other countries... alarming increase in UK since early 80's in males. and china's female suicide rate is astounding...
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
11:31 / 08.04.05
I wonder if that's the case over here, suicides have got reported a couple of times, normally when they were able to tie them in to 'suicide enabling' websites and newsgroups. I would have thought it wasn't necessary to ban reporting of suicides more that, on the whole, suicides aren't newsworthy.
 
 
Sax
14:16 / 08.04.05
Suicide usually has a reason. If it's a *newsworthy* reason, then it's going to be reported. What's a *newsworthy* reason? Bullying at school, perhaps. Worries about mounting debt. Your wife having an affair with your best friend. The fact you've just embezzled thousands of pounds from your company.

Suicide per se probably isn't newsworthy, but the reason for the suicide may well be to different sectors of the press.

Also, all suicides must result in an inquest and there's an right enshrined in England & Wales and Scotland for the press to be present and to report the proceedings thereof.
 
 
TeN
01:34 / 09.04.05
I think not reporting on them as "an attempt to curb 'copycat' suicides by impressionable members of the community" is stupid, but I agree that they shouldn't be reported on merely out of respect for the deceased's family, who may not want the public knowing that their son/daughter took his/her own life. simply denying that suicides are happening in the community, are common, and are on the rise, however, is irresponsible on behalf of the press. I think the statistics should be published, and attempts should be made to make the public aware that it is a problem, but that they should exclude personal details.
 
  
Add Your Reply