BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Unintentional threadrot, non-malicious trolling, and how to deal with it in the Revolution?

 
  

Page: 1(2)

 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
10:39 / 08.06.04
Hmmm. Haus, I'm not entirely sure Lord Morgue's claims are off-topic, but then I'm not entirely sure what they are. "Following me around" seems to be a misunderstanding of the structure of the board and the likelihood of two posters reading and posting in the same thread, but if "pissing on" is intended to mean "making moderation requests or suggesting courses of action based on a personal vendetta against me" in addition to merely "disagreeing with things I have written", then that probably needs looking into. For what it's worth, in all seriousness I can assure you that this is not the case as far as I'm aware: it's just unfortunate that LM seems intent on repeatedly posting things which don't have much revelance to the thread in question and/or are nigh incomprehensible - my problem is with the practice, not the poster.
 
 
Lord Morgue
11:31 / 08.06.04
Oh, go away. You're too boring to argue with.
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
15:15 / 08.06.04
Oh grow up Morgue. Your adolescent desire for pissing contests with other Barbeloids are so dull.
 
 
Char Aina
15:42 / 08.06.04
man, morgue, dude.
they are right.
you dont come across like a groovy iconoclastic rebel living on the edge, you come across like a wee boy.
but you knew that, right?

i reccomend breathing deeply at all times and unplugging your keyboard for a week.
i also suggest you listen to flyboy, even if only so that you can explain properly why you dont like him. you might even realise he's fairly worth reading.
 
 
Lord Morgue
10:26 / 09.06.04
Oh, all right. I'm sorry, Flyboy.

My Dad's still a feminazi, though.
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
13:26 / 23.06.04
Why does the Policy menu keep telling me this thread's been updated in the last couple of days, yet my eyes tell me otherwise?
 
 
grant
15:56 / 23.06.04
A couple new posts were deleted because, I think, they were (ho ho!) off topic.
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
16:14 / 23.06.04
Ah, that explains it. Cheers, grant.
 
 
Lord Morgue
10:29 / 25.06.04
Ooh, these last three posts aren't on-topic, are they? They're about the thread, not the thread topic! I demand they be deleted or moved, and the posters have their ears stapled to a ceiling fan!
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
11:41 / 25.06.04
Don't be tedious, Morque.
 
 
Tryphena Absent
14:55 / 25.06.04
If we deleted those last three posts then the same question might come up again. I'd be far more inclined to delete the two before this one for being utterly irrelevant but then this post would make absolutely no sense so I'm not going to.

Will you look at that, the best explanation I've ever written of barbelith's moderation system in two sentences!
 
 
Lord Morgue
05:21 / 26.06.04
MORGUE, godfuckinabucket!
Oop, now I'm off-topic.
It's a fair cop (Presents ears for stapling).
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
08:06 / 26.06.04
I'm going to move to have this thread locked, I think. It was brought up to discuss Lord Morque not being able to stay on topic in the Revolution, and has become another avenue for Lord Morque to seek attention. I think the moral of the story is probably just to warn if somebody is new, and then move to delete.
 
 
Lord Morgue
08:33 / 26.06.04
I don't give a fuck about the attention, shithead, call me by my fucking name.
 
 
Lord Morgue
09:09 / 26.06.04
Grr, alright, I'm over it now, but you and Flyboy are both worse trolls than I am, you're just more polite about it.
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
11:48 / 26.06.04
Hmmm. I don't think that's true, but then I also don't think you are a troll, particularly, just a bit simple and inexperienced. It is also, if you want to launch a complaint, the subject of a new thread.
 
 
Lord Morgue
05:41 / 27.06.04
So "Morque Morque Morque" and "A bit simple" aren't trolling for a reaction? Get off the high horse, pal, you're a stirrer, same as me, just less overt, and more personal. And as "fighty" as I am, I've never blasted anyone who didn't flame me first (Flyboy and his comment about putting me in my grave, you and the Morque thing.)
And shit, if I can't vie for attention in a thread begun to discuss what an arsehole I am, where can I?
If any of us didn't want at least a little attention, would we be here? No, we'd be curled up at home with our collection of comfy pullovers and "precious moments" figurine sets.
I'm willing to let this go, I barely have the attention span to maintain a feud, especially when everybody keeps changing names. It hurts my brain-meats. But I'll always respond in kind to insults and threats. So don't get pouty when you keep walking into my Battle Aura(tm).
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
08:25 / 27.06.04
No, no. No insult was intended, only explanation. Your inability to stay on topic suggested that you were a bit simple. If you can manage to stay on topic, and manage further to maintain some sort of borderline utility, nobody will have any reason to insult you or call you Morque. We'll see how it goes. Angry reactions to perceived mistreatment are likely to lead to people taking the piss a bit, but that's just the Interweb for you. Sorry!
 
 
Lord Morgue
01:51 / 28.06.04
All righty then.
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
14:08 / 11.10.04
This issue has, regrettably, not gone away. I have moved for these to be deleted as threadrot in their original context, but Flyboy, reacting to a wave of Barbelove for Lord Morgue, on account of the time and effort he has dedicated to questions about Star Wars, his mood affected by having had to delete a "comedy" post Morgue made in a Head Shop thread about sexual assault:

Yeah, Lord Morgue's just fucking hilarious, isn't he? What with the constant mindless thread-rotting and the jokes about goosing in a thread discussing attitudes to sexual assault, which moderators then have to spend time deleting - what a riot!

This set off a bit of a kerfuffle, the relevant bits of my contribution to which I will place here:

I think Morgue is probably one of those "split" issues for Barbelith. If you want to talk about the minutiae of certain major-grossing 80s sci-fi film franchises or comic books from the Timely era to contempo hentai, he's an absolute godsend. If you want to discuss anything else without him bouncing up and seeking attention with a single-minded pointlessness that would make Gary Coleman weep - not so much. I maintain that he would be far happier on Fade to Black. In fact, Fade to Black appears to be designed for him - but whaddayagonnado?

Now, there is in fact already a thread about Lord Morgue's inability to stop himself from posting to the standards of the board he moderates elsewhere. That topic is here. He appears to have confessed therein that he is not mentally competent to judge the worth of his contributions, and has asked us to act as his conscience by deleting his posts if we feel that they are self-advertising drivel. That seems fair, although I had hoped that he would have smartened up by now. In the meantime, his depth of knowledge about Star Wars, comics and online gaming is no doubt a vital resource, and one worth the hassle of cleaning up the odd turd on the living room carpet, no? If you have trouble working out whether a post is threadrotting or not, please look carefully at the title and summary of the thread, read the thread so far and, if still confused, wait to see if the post is deleted before replying to it to the exclusion of the rest of the thread so far.


This seems to cover it. Morgue, despite his best efforts, tends to leave little puddles around the place, like the sexual assault thread, here, here, here, and so on... Hopefully he will get the hang of how the board works, rather than trying to turn it into his other board, at some point, or failing that realise that Fade to Black is right over there if he wants a more familiar experience in a slightly different colout, but until then I guess we're just the indulgent owner with the carpet cleaner.
 
 
w1rebaby
00:51 / 12.10.04
I don't, to be honest, see any of those linked posts as terribly significant. I didn't see any of the "sexual assault" stuff so I can't comment on that.
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
07:01 / 12.10.04
I don't, to be honest, see any of those linked posts as terribly significant.

Precisely. They're unintentional threadrot, non-mailicious trolling... LM has a bit missing from his mind, and he's asked us to help him deal with it by deleting his posts when they are irrelevant and likely to cause rot - for example wandering off at a tangent about Dragonball Z in a Temple thread about what magical practitioners call themselves. It's a bit of a pain, but it seems a reasonable compromise.
 
  

Page: 1(2)

 
  
Add Your Reply