BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


The Truth About Xorn or: Why Grant Morrison is Dead to my Boyfriend.

 
  

Page: 1(2)

 
 
eddie thirteen
02:57 / 02.04.04
Actually, I should elaborate and say that it's not the *only* means possible at all, but it is definitely a more realistic means than wandering around casting sigils and popping folks with your Desert Eagle, saying witty things. I'm not really sure -- in fact, I'm quite sure it's not -- that KM's solution to the world's ills would be mine; but then again, I just fucking hate video games. In a broader sense, though, turning one's energies to creation in order to effect change seems much more noble than reacting with violence to other people's efforts to change the world. Now, is it inherently wrong to attempt to change things? I guess it could be if you're changing things against others' will, regardless of how well-intentioned you are...gahhhh. This could go on so, so long. And that's not even what the thread's about! What have I done....?
 
 
Bastard Tweed
07:22 / 02.04.04
So, anyway, I finally gave in to my curiosity a few years ago and I bought a dirtbike.

I'd been watching the other kids who already had them and I was quite intrigued. Most of them looked like, well, morons. They'd get out on the tracks and they'd try these really ill-advised, complicated moves that they seemed to be making up while in mid-air and, sure enough, most of them lost control of the bike, sometimes getting really hurt in the process. But, in spite of that crowd, there was this cool and weird minority among them. Their grace and style was so affecting that I changed my mind about dirtbikes and decided to get into it myself.

I didn't regret it. As long as I stuck with the guys who knew what they were doing, it was a fun and invigorating experience. While this may seem like an odd thing to say about a dirtbike I think I even learned a thing or two about the world and myself from the experience.

I was right in the thick of my dirtbike enthusiasm when I met my friend, Grant. Let me tell you, Grant's a really cool guy but, more than that, he really knows his way around a dirtbike. You should see him out there! Not only has he mastered a lot of the cool stuff I already knew about, he comes up with stuff that never even occurred to me. He applies some of the stuff I've seen the others do with skateboards and BMXs that I thought would never work on our heavier dirtbikes but it's like he has the magic touch. The fact that he always shares how to do it with the rest of us is even better.

I know, I know, "Where am I going with all this?". Well, one day, I went out to the track and Grant was tooling around but when he sees me he stops and comes up to tell me something.

"Hey, check it out; I figured out something new we can do."

"Something new?" I said, "Cool. If it's anything like your other ideas, I'm all for it."

"Well, here's what you've got to do, bear with me a moment. First, you get a lot of torque before you hit the ramp; then, when you get in the air, you sort of wrap your leg around the handlebars and then you stick your hands behind the front wheel-(I'll spare you the details, you'd have to be into dirtbikes for it to be interesting; needless to say, it sounded a little crazy)-and then you land on a wheelie!"

This, I wasn't so sure about and I said, "I don't know, Grant. This sounds an awful lot like something those guys we always make fun of would try to pull." And he said, "I know, but trust me on this one."

I thought about it for a second and I finally figured I should go ahead and take the plunge, after all, Grant had tried crazy shit before and it had paid off then.

Needless to say, I soon found myself lying in a very painful crumple on the dirttrack. Shortly after that, I found myself in the hospital, recovering from a broken leg, when Grant came by to pay me a visit.

"Gee, Grant," I said, "I don't know why that didn't work. Maybe when I'm as good with a dirtbike as you are, I'll finally figure it out."

"Oh, that?" He said, "That wasn't supposed to work. You see, I came up with that trick when I was watching those other guys. And I thought to myself 'How can I really drive home the point about what a bad idea it is do to dirtbike tricks like that?' when suddenly I understood it perfectly. What I should do is come up with a trick like theirs only moreso. One that would point out by it's very existence, what a fatuous, idiotic way of thinking that is by exemplify all of it's idiocy and fatuity! And sure enough it really WAS a stupid trick!"

Oh well, I'm sure Grant had a good reason for what he did, I just hope he sticks to good dirtbike tricks from now on.
 
 
spake
07:53 / 02.04.04
Nice analogy. Does someone want to take this Invisibles analysis to another thread. I'm still too new to start one, but if someone else is so inclined, i'd love to see a thread about the dichotomy of where KM was at the end of Invisibles with the whole "I use the N.M.E", and what Jack was up to in retrospect - assassin stlyes with the infiltration of KM's skyscraper. Sound cool?
 
 
PatrickMM
03:00 / 07.09.04
Interesting dirtbike story, but I don't think it quite works. Planet X is not just a parody/deconstruction of superhero stories, or X-Men stories. It's actually the flipside of the entire run. For most of the book, we've been looking at how the world runs without Magneto. Xavier has won, and we see what happens.

Planet X flips things around, as so elegantly shown by the map in 146. Magneto basically achieves everything he ever wanted to, by 147, he's ruling the world, and in the story arc, we get to see why he can never win. Put into practice, all his noble ideas about making a world where mutants can live in peace fail, and he ends up killing humans, while mutants are starving. His ideas are so out of touch with reality that his attempt to build a new world completely fails. What it's basically saying is evolution doesn't come through violence, it comes through finding ones place in a new world. That's what the X-Men have done in Grant's stories, they've found their own place, co-existing with the human world.

Personally, I love Planet X and think it's the best thing Grant did on the book. Obviously, it's got some flaws, particularly the death of Jean at the end, which just seemed arbitrary and tacked on, though arguably, it's an Invisibles type time paradox, where she knows she has to die, in order that the Here Comes Tomorrow future won't exist. I particularly love what Grant did with Magneto. He basically takes the tropes of classic Magneto and throws him into the real world. He fails at ruling the world and is completely out of touch with humanity. I loved the meta-commentary on his "Shakespearean speeches," and the fact that people don't have enough attention span to listen to him. It was brilliant the way Grant continually used Xorn as a counterpoint to Magneto. The person he created as a parody of Xavier's way had become loved in a way that no one had ever loved him.

Besides that, it's full of the incredible character-driven action that made Grant's X-Men so brilliant. Jean and Wolverine on the asteroid, Beak standing strong against Magneto, Scott and the "new X-Men," Esme and Erik. As an on and off X-fan, that story really got to the heart of what makes great X-Men, epic action and great character work. Plus, Jiminez' art was simply dazzling.
 
 
eeoam
23:44 / 11.09.04
OK Ok I get it now. If you're like me and were totally pissed off with the return of Magento - That's what we're were supposed to feel.

The U-Men represented the fanboys who through their insistence on maintenance of the status quo keep the X-Men from evolving.
But there was another consituency of reader that Morrison wanted to talk about.
The people who haven't been reading the X-Men since 1963. Who wanted NEW stuff. Who, like Beak, Angel, Martha, Ernst and co only came on board X-Men with Morrison. Just as they loved Xorn but turned against Magento we loved New X-Men but went ballistic when it became just plain old X-Men. Morrison told us that he was doing New stuff because he wanted us to feel betrayed when he pulled the rug out from under us.

My friends, Welcome to the Special Class.
 
 
Our Lady Has Left the Building
08:09 / 12.09.04
I'm not sure that Jean has to die, by the end of Planet X she's practically all powerful and in 'Here Comes Tomorrow' she's manipulating time and everything, so I suspect that if she wanted to, she could change things so Magneto's attack doesn't hurt her or something. The fact is more that she's 95% Phoenix and it's more that little 5% remaining of Jean Grey, that remembers Scott Summers and being an X-Man that stops her (much as in the original Dark Phoenix storyline) from just eradicating the whole planet, as Quintin suggests.
 
  

Page: 1(2)

 
  
Add Your Reply