BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Atkins diet

 
  

Page: 12(3)

 
 
MattShepherd: I WEDDED KALI!
14:26 / 27.09.07
So it's been about five years since the craze started.

Where's Atkins at now?

Not the man himself -- he's dead -- but I figured five years would be time enough to tell if the thing really works, or if all the Atkins bandwagon-jumpers have keeled over from liver failure or heart attacks, or are lording it over us as the new superfit masters of the diet kingdom.

But it's surprisingly hard to find any information about this.

My pet theory was that Atkins would work fine for a while, but as soon as people touched carbs again they would blow up like balloons; again... hard to find any data.

Somebody somewhere must have started a metastudy tracking the hundreds or thousands of people giving Atkins a shot... but where are they all now?
 
 
illmatic
14:33 / 27.09.07
Try here and then read the rest of his site. I am actually sold on dietary given there - lots of protein, lots of good fats, minimal carbs. A lot of the info on that site seems solidly to point towards excess carbs being the cause of the current obesity epidemic. It's not a huge issue for me as I'm pretty skinny, but in terms of optiminsing the choices I make, this is increasingly the way I'm choosing to go.
 
 
Closed for Business Time
14:34 / 27.09.07
Linky no worky!
 
 
Hydra vs Leviathan
09:34 / 30.09.07
So. I take it it's because this thread is in Lab rather than Head Shop or Switchboard that no one wants to critique the desirability of weight loss diets in the first place, or the whole social construction of "Being Healthy" as a universal moral imperative?

If so, is there a better thread in which to do that?
 
 
eye landed
06:46 / 16.12.07
i found this thread while looking for info about a beer diet, namely: if one is going to live largely on beer for a short period (2 or 3 days), what supplementary foods should be eaten?

im putting this question out there, and id appreciate detailed answers.

since its just for a few days, i dont care so much about weight gain or heart disease. more important is maintaining my brain function, not getting constipated or flatulent, not messing with my sleep patterns, not getting ill, not sweating gravy...

im thinking fruit for vitamins, and meat for protein and iron. now im a (sort of) vegetarian, so meat isnt really appetizing to me, so maybe i will go for some fortified soy protein shakes or something. or more likely, i will enjoy a fat burger and then stick to fruit.

i found a few pages on the 'drinking man's diet' (in a book from the 50s or 60s? and an allan sherman song which i want to hear), which is basically low carb so that you can get your carbs from alcohol, which apparently helps you to burn fat. so alcohol and steak and eggs. however, they recommend whisky and martinis rather than beer. not sure if theres any reason for that, since all alcoholic drinks are basically alcohol and water, right?

here is a somewhat elderly interview with dr ornish, who is one of the anti-atkins fuddy-duddies. he basically says that atkins works because it gets people to eat less refined sugar and white flour and potato chips. its a trick: how can we get people to stop eating these horrible processed foods without saying 'stop eating that'? the answer is to tell them what awful, addictive foods they can still eat. so dr atkins doesnt say 'youre cutting a bunch of crap out of your diet'. he says 'look at all the crap you can still eat and lose weight, as long as you get rid of the worst crap'. and thats why its a fad, because its a trick. people with heart disease risk are probably going to die faster on atkins. but young fat people will probably benefit.

im pretty young, and ive never been obese, but the most effective diet ive ever tried simply involved cutting out sweets. no candy or pastries or soda. i ate sweetened jam (jelly? preserves?) but not often (a matter of personal preference-- i mention it because my girlfriend at the time couldnt wrap her mind around this, that i would cut out sugar and still eat jam; she was more of a jam fiend though). i ate potato chips when i wanted an unhealthy snack. i drank little apart from water. (i dont remember what my alcohol consumption habits were at that time, but thats never been a problem for me, despite what you may think from the opening to this post.) i managed a piece of birthday cake for rituals, and i didnt turn down a single candy if somebody offered. after a couple months, i stopped craving sweets entirely. somehow they insidiously came back into my life (i think via home-baked cookies), but ive never gone back to the soft pimply mess i was in high school. and i recall my time on that diet as the best period of my life.
 
  

Page: 12(3)

 
  
Add Your Reply