BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


New X Men #140

 
  

Page: 12(3)45

 
 
vajramukti
02:11 / 01.05.03
it's possible that beak did kill emma. but that emma made him do it, ala suicide theory, and that the diamond bullet actually comes from emmas own body. she could also have been the kick supplier, adding incentive to her suicide.

just a thought
 
 
onorthocrasi
02:51 / 01.05.03
anybody remember part 2 of riot wher4e at the end of the issue after they incapacitate xavier the omega gang enters an inward folding fake bookshelf and tattoo says "secret x-labsssssss. I smell kick."?

That makes me think that the hypercortisone-d mystery is deeper that just barnell.

Anyone have any thoughts on this?
 
 
Jack Denfeld
03:03 / 01.05.03
I love the fact that a teacher was murdered in the school, everyone's a suspect, these serious mutant detectives are interviewing everyone as possible suspects, and on pg. 9 Basilisk is saying "I did it! I did it...hyukkk!" I love that kid.
 
 
rexpop
04:41 / 01.05.03
It could have been a lucky hit. The murderer fired, Emma turned to diamond form and the bullet happened to strike the weak spot.

Reading through the issue again I think Barnells confession is very suspect and completely out of character, although he and Angel have the best motive so far. Given that Flies have a short gestation period its entirely possible that she could have layed the eggs in the time that elapsed during issue #139. That whole ending part was very David Cronenberg.

I'm also willing to bet that Jean is the person who puts Emma back together again. After all Phoenix is a force of life as well as death.
 
 
Raw Norton
04:52 / 01.05.03
I love that Basilisk refers to Charles as "Professor Sex."
 
 
Ethan Van Sciver
08:20 / 01.05.03
I like the preview pages. It's funny to see Phil Jimenez drawing some of those geeks from #117. BTW, unless Beak is drawn exactly the way I drew him, he is drawn incorrectly. No artistic liberties should be tolerated. Punk rock chicken boy is the idea, and it must be followed to a 't'. Inform Bachalo and Silvestri.

-Ethan Van Sciver
 
 
Aertho
13:36 / 01.05.03
I thought Beak was mutating closer to human the less "chicken" he got. Something about evolution of form as evolution of confidence. At least, that's how I liked to understand it.
 
 
Aertho
13:52 / 01.05.03
So anyway... I keep thinking about the "not quite rightness" of 140 -and I think it's due to the Mulder and Scully aspect of Sage and Bishop. We're not safe in our NXM cast anymore, and everything feels strange.

And I'm sticking to the mindscape idea. I'm thinking MAJOR misdirection. What if the bodies hanging from the "archetypal cabin in the woods" are the "souls" of Emma's dead students? What if that skinny arm holding the gun is the a-cupped, young, and rebellious Emma from NXM 139? I think there are clues all over 139 that can be pushed like a filter through 140, i just haven't done it yet...

I mean WHY were we propelled to those significant scenes in Emma's mind?
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
14:29 / 01.05.03
What if the bodies hanging from the "archetypal cabin in the woods" are the "souls" of Emma's dead students? What if that skinny arm holding the gun is the a-cupped, young, and rebellious Emma from NXM 139?

Oh dear God.

Let's hope NOT, okay?
 
 
Mike-O
14:35 / 01.05.03
History teaches us that the simplest conclusion is often the correct one.
 
 
Quimper
15:36 / 01.05.03
I'm jumping onto the Fantomex=Christian Frost bandwagon here. There is obvious misdirection occurring...Fantomex. If Fantomex is Christian, there is your motive. Fantomex is VERY obsessed with money. The money he was denied by his father? Hell, he's even wearing a beret at the piano. I'm sure Fantomex does too when he doesn't have the ceramic plates on his head.
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
16:45 / 01.05.03
Gosh, again I've got to say that I'm very glad that some of you folks are a) consistently incorrect in your speculation and b) not writing the comic yourselves. I think the Christian Frost = Fantomex thing is just ridiculous and pointless, and just way too leftfield.
 
 
Aertho
18:02 / 01.05.03
...we love you too, Fluxy. Chances are we're all worng and Grant will hit us in the face yet with some whack resolution... but i think it's fun in the meantime
 
 
CameronStewart
18:36 / 01.05.03
>>>However Emma was shot in her flaw... One would have to be a pretty good shot to hit her square in the nose...
...who else knows about that flaw?<<<

The killer is KARNAK!
 
 
Regrettable Juvenilia
19:36 / 01.05.03
Fantomex is clearly the third Summers brother. From the Age of Apocalypse.
 
 
Quimper
20:07 / 01.05.03
Beast was able to tell us that Jumbo Carnation was drunk, had his organs cooked, was sweaty from dancing, had on Liz Taylor's White Diamonds, last pooped 42 hours before he died, and that he was an aquarius...all by smell at his murder scene.

And you have Logan who can do the same thing.

Why, again, do we need Bishop and Sage?

And I think Angel is really Selene and Jeff Goldblum's love child. And Emma knew!!!
 
 
NezZ
20:15 / 01.05.03
She committed suicide. The diamond bullet is from her. She shit it out while in diamond form. Voila one diamond bullet!
 
 
Ganesh
00:12 / 02.05.03
Alternatively, it's one of her characteristically prominent nipples, converted to a Zen bullet.
 
 
klint
01:02 / 02.05.03
Did Jean brainwash Bishop, show him that they were living in a fake world, or something else entirely?
 
 
Persephone
02:14 / 02.05.03
Holy crap, MAGGOTS.
 
 
Ganesh
02:18 / 02.05.03
S'what happens when the birds get it on with the bees...
 
 
Quireboy
11:59 / 03.05.03
Bit of an anticlimax after the last issue. Only things to say:

Who was Esme meeting? Did they hire or persuade someone to kill Emma - though that seems rather extreme - Fantomex, even? Notice how they could easily become the White Queen substitutes.

Angel and Beak supplying Kick. Beak has said he doesn't do drugs and didn't the Cuckoos say during Imperial that Angel hadn't either when they telepathically guided her into the mansion to get Cassandra's DNA?

Is it plausible that they've set Angel up having read her mind? They could easily have found out about her pregnancy.

Did Angel seem out of character or is this just her anxiety/defensiveness over what we must assume is her brood?

Is it plausible that Emma has jumped into Angel's body? I would say almost certainly not.

Who is holding the gun to Sage's head: Esme, Angel (doesn't sound like herself) ... or even Emma? (Although as Beast was examining diamond aorta she would have to have jumped into someone else's body or be pure psionic energy now, which seems too complicated.)

There has to be a less convoluted explanation - but I don't see what it is yet- and don't think it's coming next issue if, as Morrison has said, the indentity of the murderer remains a mystery.
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
12:28 / 03.05.03
The Cuckoos were leaving, to be trained by another mutant teacher. I can't remember her name, and I don't have the comic near me. You know, the woman who Emma says "has hair on the back of her hands!" in #138.
 
 
Ganesh
13:03 / 03.05.03
It seems slightly unclear whether Emma's actually dead or just, uh, resting. Clearly she would be dead if she reverted to human (mess-ee) but in diamond form, she may be something akin to Sublime's 'living chandelier'. For all we know, she may still be capable of moving to reassemble herself, jigsaw-style but, for some reason, isn't doing so (psychic 'shutdown' caused by Jean's breach of her defences?)

(Incidental niggle: one would've thought that Beast, with his medical training, would've said 'aortic' rather than 'aortal'.)

Emma's 'flaw' also intrigues me. Are we assuming that this refers to the cosmetic surgery she had on her nose (which presumably rendered her human form 'imperfect' and thus her diamond form 'flawed') or something else? Has she had other surgery, for example? She seemed pretty flat-chested in the flashbacks; has she had a boob-job? Or - and this is the romantic Hans Christian Anderson 'Snow Queen' version - does her 'flaw' refer to falling in love with Scott? Beast is, after all, quite literally piecing together her broken heart.

Oh yeah, and didn't someone bring up the question of 'who knew about Emma's flaw'? The U-Men first discovered it, but who was also present? Scott and Martha, the disembodied brain - who's now one of Xorn's special pupils...
 
 
Ganesh
16:57 / 03.05.03
Could Esme be going to see a man about some pupae?
 
 
ciarconn
01:48 / 04.05.03
Emma has jumped twice to other bodies in moments of danger, once to Iceman's and once to Jean's. Heck, even Psylocke pulled that one over in Ultimate X men
 
 
Hero_Zero
06:23 / 04.05.03
I just picked up my 3 months worth of comics, and just digested 138-140. 1.) Grant keeps getting better and better and 2.) Dear god what the hell happened with the prices of comics ? Seems I might have to cut out my diet of all X comix (any Marvel for that matter and stick with Vertigo.)

What I first picked up on was that it was somehow had to do with the Stepford Cuckoos. The whole deal with them paging Jean psychically. But, I suppose their alliby seems plausable.]

The bit that caught me was the last 4 pages of issue number 140. Beast is examining/putting together Emma when Beak walks in and says "I sold the Kick to them, I killed Miss Frost"...I don't think he did it directly, but he also mentions "She was going to tell and, I did it for her. I did it for the babies"...And on the last page we see larvae of some kind and a gun pointing at Sage.

The thing that hit me was remembering back when Angel first appeared in New X-Men and how when she slept she had larval like looking states.

I don't yet know the motive, but have a feeling it was Angel. Also remember the odd talk of Emma taking her under her wing.
 
 
penitentvandal
16:00 / 04.05.03
Y'know, if you were gonna choose such a cheesey alias, you could at least have gone for 'Soma Riot' and got a Brave New World reference in...

Badly anagrammed invocations of famous pianists, and the recent joining up of AWT - is this some kind of sinister new trend on the 'Lith? The Attack of the Celebrity Aliases? Hmmm...

It has been said, before, that Grant has telegraphed a lot of events in NXM thru things people say. Given that, consider Bishop's line about how in a world of 'shapeshifters, telepaths, and disembodied consciousnesses, crime takes on a whole new meaning'.

Seems to suggest that either that isn't Beak at all, making the confession - perhaps something Hank will sense next issue? - or that it is Beak, but someone else is in control of his mind.

Now. Here's another thought. Has anyone considered the idea that Sophie's 'disembodied consciousness' could still be hanging around?

I don't think that's either Fantomex or Scott in the cabin. Both have long sleeves. Rebellious A-cup Emma sounds like a nice idea, but probably not. Who knows?
 
 
Ganesh
16:06 / 04.05.03
(If I was so minded to change my Barbe-ficsuit, 'Rebellious A-Cup Emma' would be up there with the best of 'em.)
 
 
LDones
17:09 / 04.05.03
After re-reading the Riot arc, I've had to reconsider a lot of what I previously thought about this arc. I'm now confident that the sinister feeling running through this issue is a lark, to some degree. I don't think Morrison would make his children murderers, especially in light of what his New X-Men is about. It's so obviously pointing to Angel that I can't believe that's the direction it'll take.

Loathe as I am to admit it, Emma has had a past habit of jumping bodies, so I certainly see it as a possibility. Perhaps she even jumped into the murderer's body before the bullet hit. Or perhaps murdered her own body after doing so. Possibilities, I suppose. I'm less interested in constructing a cogent theory than understanding the story facts up to this point.

A few things. In 140, Angel starts to tell Emma about her pregnancy, at least that's my assumption. When they're at the department store (don't have it in front of me, so I can't remember the exact line, but it seems fairly explicit now). 2-3 pages later she tells Beak about it and says they have to do something, and fast.

Also - Beak and Angel never had sex. When they're off in the forest in 138, Beak chickens out (so to speak), and Angel says something about him turning down the first, last, and only chance he'd ever get with a girl. So it never happened, unless it was off-panel the night before the Riot, after the U-Men incident in the forest. So the babies in the cabin couldn't be Beak's.
 
 
El Gato Was Right: the t-shirt
17:50 / 04.05.03
I'm not sure exactly what point I'm trying to make, but there's one here somewhere about Angel, the Stepford Cuckoos, the eggs, whose they might be and what the future may or may not hold for the hatchlings...

From crazyaboutcuckoos.com:

"The cuckoo’s breeding season is from May through July. The cuckoo is known for laying its eggs in the nests of other bird species including pipits, warblers, and robins. Once a suitable nest is found, the laying female sits down on the nest and lays the egg. If the nest is situated such that this is not possible, see will lay the egg nearby on the ground, place the egg in her bill, and carry the egg to the nest. The eggs of the cuckoo are extraordinarily small. The color resembles that of the birds into which nest the eggs will be placed. Each female puts only one egg into the nest, usually only if the nesting bird already has her own eggs in place. Each cuckoo may lay up to 25 eggs, 1 per nest.

"The egg hatches in the nest after approximately 12 days at which point the nesting mother bird will feed the cuckoo as if it is her own. The cuckoo bird will throw any remaining birds or eggs from the nest, leaving it as the sole bird receiving food from the nesting mother. The smaller host parents incubate the egg and feed the young cuckoo. The host parents will continue to feed the cuckoo even after it grows to be much larger than they are. A cuckoo chick will also use its call to lure birds other than its host parents to feed it.
 
 
Quireboy
18:32 / 04.05.03
So what you're trying to say is that Angel or maybe one of her children could be the unwitting host for Sophie? Or is this leading to a revelation about the Cuckoos that there was originally one of them and she reproduced copies of herself - perhaps in a similar way to Quimper in the Invisibles.
 
 
Shrug
20:17 / 04.05.03
I like your theory El Gato, both plausible and inventive. I too think it was the Cuckoo's, although I didn't consider the "egg" scenario. Wouldn't the possibility of an actual murder mystery in the Xavier institue with the suspect being someone other than a telepath requires some suspension of disbelief? (although now I think about it, this could be explained away by Kick)
Their is something yet to be explained about the Cuckoo's in any case.
Why did Glob Hermann only see four? Did Quentin guess something about them (other than attraction was their any other reasons for Quentin's intense stares at Sophie?) and would this be why they tried to kill him? Their altercation with Ms. Frost etc. Plus as stated above I'll be non-plussed if the killer turns out to be anyone other than a telepath.
 
 
Quireboy
09:43 / 05.05.03
Consider one of the sources Grant is drawing on for the Stepford Cuckoos - the Midwych Cuckoos. If I remember rightly the women of Midwych all suddenly and mysteriously became pregnant. Are the Stepford Cuckoos borrowing Angel's reproductive system to replenish their ranks? Did they plan to leave yet have another batch of Cuckoos take their place at the start of the next term? So they decided to kill Emma because they realise Angel is on the verge of telling her about the pregancy. I guess we'll find out if those pupae hatch next issue and contain blonde-haired telepaths instead of bug-birds.
 
 
Quireboy
20:27 / 05.05.03
IF the larvae in the wood cabin are the source of kick - and mutant amniotic fluid sounds as good a source as any for a mutant-power-enhancing drug - then that means they have been there since before the riot.

So either they're not Angel's, or she lied to Beak, so he'd help her deal with them. Of course the women of Mydwich fell pregant without having sex. So, if we accept the above theory, the Cuckoos would be using Angel, who's now using Beak.

It's suitably soap opera-ish anyway!
 
  

Page: 12(3)45

 
  
Add Your Reply