BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


I insist Dave Grohl is incomparable on drums because...

 
 
Cliff and Ferry Street
22:06 / 03.11.02
...I keep listening to that damn Songs for the Deaf or what ever it is by Queens of the Stone Age. His drumming on that thing doesn't taste like chicken at all, but is excellent.

Who is your drum God, and what has ze done for you lately?

If you don't care about drums then I don't know what to ask you. Fantastic pianists? Actually, I wouldn't mind you telling me something about contemporary pianists, because I feel all unedumacated in that respect and want to expand my mind. And if pianists don't matter to you either... Any instrument will do, really.

All I'm saying is everybody knows talking (with words) about musical preferences is meaningless, so let's. Explanations that aren't reasonable but are all impressionistic-like would be lovely, for instance. Or offer up your opinions in whatever way comes natural to you. Anybody willing?
 
 
The Return Of Rothkoid
22:12 / 03.11.02
Mitsuko Uchida plays Schubert like nobody else. Fanfffuckingtastic.

I agree with the Grohl reference. Particularly the drum solo in "Song For The Dead". BIG! FUCKING! STICKS!
 
 
Matthew Fluxington
22:46 / 03.11.02
Can a moderator please send this over to the Music Forum?
 
 
Linus Dunce
23:32 / 03.11.02
While it's still here ...

True jazz fans will probably disagree, but I always like Art Blakey as a drummer. The man could squeeze in a roll where a lot of people would put in a single beat. Just because, I think, he fuckin' could.
 
 
Solitaire Rose as Tom Servo
23:37 / 03.11.02
Neal Peart is the only person whose drum solos I can not only tolerate, but enjoy. Rush is known as a geek band, but I have yet to hear any drummer say a bad thing abotu him.
 
 
RadJose
05:58 / 04.11.02
i was always down w/ Mr Buddy Rich in the drummin' department
 
 
Seth
07:39 / 04.11.02
I'm a big fan of Manu Katche, or however you spell it. I've not heard a lot of his drumming, but I remember being amazed at what he did on Peter Gabriel's Secret World tour, specifically Come Talk to Me, in which he plays probably the two greatest solos/extended breaks I've ever heard. They weren't huge on technique, but the feel was incomparable.

I've wanted to get hold of some Mark Mondesir for quite some time - I've heard he's joined some kind of drum orchestra (six kit players), so I might try to lay hold of that. I've only heard him on a couple of songs he did with his brother a few years back, and his playing was extraordinary, the man's got an alien brain. Shifting the backbeat an offbeat down the bar with each successive verse is inspired (an one I'll use myself at some point), but playing in 33/32 is just ridiculous. And it grooved, didn't sound calculated at all.

Anyone who's a fan of drumming should listen to the later Bordoms work. Vision Creation Newsun is a three kit psychedelic epiphany: louder and faster and louder and faster and louder and faster....

Besides that, I mainly prefer listening to drum programmers these days, as I don't have to wade through jazz-wank to get to decent ideas. My favourites are Tim Simenon, Photek, and Aphex Twin (shadow would have made the list if it weren't for his last album).

If any one wants to give me a list of great jazz drummers and their finest hours, I'll take back what I said about jazz-wank and take my card unto the library.
 
 
Brigade du jour
20:40 / 10.04.04
Oh don't make me choose one!

Stewart Copeland because he's flash, although he is a bit too flash.

Alex van Halen because apparently he loves his drums so much he licks them.

John Bonham because he was versatile and knew when to use silence and let the listener put the beat in for themselves.

Sheila E because she can do anything. Anything. Um, with a drum kit.
 
 
m
06:22 / 11.04.04
Martin Atkins in the early eighties. His drumming on PIL's Flowers of Romance record is where it's at.
 
 
m
06:25 / 11.04.04
Oh, and as far as "jazz wank" goes, you should check out anything that Ed Blackwell has played on.
 
 
The Falcon
14:30 / 11.04.04
The Octopus from Don Caballero. Appropriately named.

Also, Steven Adler, formerly of G'n'F'n'R.
 
 
frownland
07:02 / 12.04.04
Dull answer maybe, but I personally believe no-one surpasses Mr Bonham.
 
 
rizla mission
09:46 / 12.04.04
Billy Cobham!

"He is to the drums what Hendrix was to the guitar" say the liner notes of a Maravishnu Orchestra CD, and who am I to disagree? It might be dodgy 70s fusion stuff, but he absolutely kicks it..
 
 
Benny the Ball
10:13 / 12.04.04
Mitch Mitchell.
 
 
---
18:16 / 17.04.04
Dave Grohl here too!

He was amazing on the QOTSA album. His drumming and the quality of the songs and i was addicted for weeks, i love that album.
 
 
Miyakochann
05:37 / 18.04.04
Chopin.. brilliant, amazing.
 
 
Pan Paniscus
10:16 / 19.04.04
I always liked the chap out of Therapy?, Fyfe Ewing, I think it was. Apparently he was so good because he spent all his time listening to drum n bass, and ignoring the fat lad with the beard. His drumming on 'Screamager' rocks the bells. Specifically cowbells, I think. Not sure what he's done for me lately, though. Probably one for the 'where are they now?' file.
 
 
at the scarwash
17:54 / 20.04.04
Billy Higgins (late '50s-early '60s Ornette Coleman) is one of my very favorites. The delicate sizzle of the ride into "A Lonely Woman," the breakneck directional changes in "Congeniality;" yikes, man. He was aware of color and texture in a way that most drummers never consider even today.

Ringo Starr is fantastic too. Perhaps not all that much technically (although not bad), but he did after all come up with a lot of the cliches that are currently inescapeable in popular music. I think his drum work on "Something" is a fantastic bit of pop-drama, meshing perfectly with one of Paul's shining moments as a bassist.

I saw Dave Lombardo with Fantomas a couple of weeks ago, and was quite impressed. Slayer is not my thing, and I can generally do without Mike Patton if he's not in Faith No More, but Lombardo is an amazing technical drummer. What really impressed me was his awareness of the mics on his drums.
 
 
Locust No longer
20:13 / 20.04.04
I'm a huge Han Bennink fan. He's absolutely insane. He can play normal jazz to out there skronk fests with ease. Probably the most entertaining drummer I've ever seen, as well. He makes helicopter noises with a wet rag while doing a drum roll with one hand, all with a combat booted foot cranking out massive bass drum hits. One of the few drummers I can take a solo album by.

Hamid Drake is a also an amazing drummer. Plays with almost every free jazz master out there and ususually steals their thunder. I've never heard more interesting rythms come from anyone.

Dave Wiite from Discordance Axis has got to get some props, as well. Cuz he bashes the shit out his drums like no other grind drummer before him. He's amazingly tight and very loud. Everything metal should be.

Other favorites that I don't have time to write about:
Sunny Murray
Elvin Jones
The guy from Hella
Weasel Walter
Sven jak Johhanson


Now who likes bass players?
 
 
phrankphutta
03:35 / 21.04.04
Danny Carey of TOOL, hands down.
 
 
Char Aina
04:04 / 23.04.04
i'll vote for grohl, as long as we can glue his ass to the drum stool.

i'm not sick, he can have a stool with a hole in it for his.. well, stool. i just hate it when he sings and plays his silly guitar.

BEHIND the kit, MONKEY-BOY!
 
 
SteppersFan
11:42 / 06.05.04
Drums?

It's all about programming. So we're talking Dem 2, above and beyond all others, in Garage, as the ultimate freakfunk drum programmers. Nobody else comes close for sheer transcendental groove.

I still have a big soft spot for MAW, and of course the junglist house beats of da Jaxx. Listen to the /swing/.

In jungle itself you have to bow down to Congo Natty's punk minimalism (but what a GROOVE!) -- in fact I literally bowed down before Rebel MC when he was on the telly last night. Plus of course millions of semi-unknown 94 ragga-jungle programmers -- The Greatest Music Ever Made.

And from way back -- Keith LeBlanc.

'Course he was a "real" drummer too. Surprised nobody here mentioned Clyde Stubblefield (if you did, sorry if I missed ya) cos he is quite transparently both superior to and far more important than 99% of the turgid rock bores cited here.

Tool? You can't dance to Tool. So the drummer's no good. That's axiomatic. This is why Nile Rogers will always be better than Joe @snigger@ Satriani. You want rock, go for Bonham -- cos he's not really rock. He's funky as fuck.

In jazz, maybe Jack DeJohnette. In reggae you're spoilt for choice -- it is the ultimate music after all -- so I'll just go for any of the house drummers at Studio One, to whom no white boy rock drummer can compare. Period.
 
 
The Falcon
13:24 / 06.05.04
Codeine/June of '44's drummer Doug Scharin is probably my real #1 in drumming terms.
 
 
Michelle Gale
15:31 / 06.05.04
That drummer in Hella he's super, uber complicated beat a diddle!!
 
 
Char Aina
17:38 / 08.05.04
You can't dance to Tool. So the drummer's no good.

its a bad workman blames tool, mate. maybe you cant dance.
 
  
Add Your Reply