BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


A local book for local people

 
 
Kit-Cat Club
18:01 / 27.10.02
Books on the state of the nation - readers asked to choose the book which best sums up their region... the shortlists are quite interesting, though I'm not exactly sure that Aberystwyth Mon Amour is a very flattering choice for Wales...

I think I'd go for Captive State for England, but that's probably because I read Private Eye too much.

Interesting to look at it from a more local level too - is there a book which sums up your particular area for you? I was trying to think of the book which summed up Oxford for me, adn went through the usual suspects - Gaudy Night, Zuleika Dobson, Brideshead Revisisted - before I remembered reading a book called The Noonday Devil by Alan Judd, which is the perfect choice. It's about a couple of students (actually at this very college, there are a number of pointers in the text for those in the know) in their final term and it captures the terrible sense of wasted time that you often get here - the sense of time spent doing something other than that which you should be doing, if you see what I mean, which characterised a great deal of my time here. It's also pretty accurate about the city itself... a shame that Judd's other stuff is, by all accounts, dire, and moreover he once wrote the motoring column for the Spectator...

Your choice?
 
 
bjacques
21:51 / 27.10.02
Puppet On A Chain (Amsterdam) - Alistair MacLean. Lots of drugs moving through town, only it's E, not H. Groovy early '70s disco and flares are in.
 
 
Sax
08:58 / 28.10.02
No-one writes books about Wigan any more since George Orwell ruined it for everybody.

Re: Gauda Secunda (thanks Deva) I'd probably go for any of Joolz Denby's psycho-crime stuff.
 
 
William Sack
10:39 / 28.10.02
As a Brummie, I think that Jonathan Coe does a good job on Birmingham in the 70s in "Rotters' Club."
 
 
Baz Auckland
17:11 / 30.10.02
The best summing up of Toronto that I've seen was done by Catherine Bush (Minus Time and The Rules of Engagement). Just two books set mostly in Toronto that capture bits of it really well.
 
 
Catjerome
15:20 / 31.10.02
I liked Zodiac by Neal Stephenson - he did a good job with Boston as a setting, making reference to lots of realistic local landmarks, cultural stuff, etc. rather than the usual "generic city except with the Red Sox or some fella saying 'pahk your cah in hahvuhd yahd'" treatment.
 
 
at the scarwash
16:01 / 31.10.02
cat, just wondering, how well does Infinite Jest do Boston?
 
 
gergsnickle
14:44 / 01.11.02
Ah, it would have to be The Ice Storm (Rick Moody)... I live a few miles from New Canaan, where the book takes place, and the locations, streets and landmarks (such as Silver Hill, the mental hospital) are all there as described. Beyond that, the depiction of the New Canaan residents as irritatingly neurotic, um, rich people is definitely accurate, as is also the case with their more charmingly screwed up children. The movie was also good and was filmed nearby. It was uncanny to see on the screen the autumn scenery around here. All in all the book and movie remind me of middle school back in the early 80s.
 
 
Catjerome
03:38 / 02.11.02
testpattern: Infinite Jest ... erm, haven't read it. What's it about? Worth reading?
 
 
gergsnickle
14:42 / 02.11.02
Well, I'm not testpattern obviously, but I do reccommend Infinite Jest. For a llong while it was my favorite book, I've read it 5 times trying to get everything straight (coming to the conclusion that one should keep in mind that it IS called Infinite Jest for a reason. Laugh)...

Taking place in Boston (I have a friend who mentioned she shops at the Bread and Circus in Cambridge which Gately visits, but I doubt there's an tennis academy in Enfield), IJ is, briefly a huge book about tennis, addiction & recovery and films. Set in the near future it focuses on a DVD called Infinite Jest which is so addictive that anyone who sees eeven an instant of it is rendered a vegetable with no desire but to watch more... Certain Canadian terrorist cells wish to use it to destroy the USA.

All in all, very interesting (if somewhat long and confusing at times), funny and informative (the parts about recovery and addiction will stay with me for quite a while). Anyone else?
 
 
Loomis
16:39 / 05.11.02
Am I the only one bothered by the fact that there are two books by Bill Bryson there? Surely a list of books summing up one's country need not include second-rate travel writing? Let's just hope the kiddies aren't spending their £1 voucher on him ...
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
21:21 / 05.11.02
London, I'd have to say "Lights Out For The Territory" by Iain Sinclair.
 
 
Fist Fun
09:35 / 16.11.02
Anything that bases itself purely on national considerations will always be suspect for me. At the same time you need a community and support for cultures that otherwise might not get it.

The problem here is that the cultural side becomes automatically locked into the political side. Witness the inclusion of "Why Scots Should Rule Scotland, Alasdair Gray". That isn't a state of the nation book. That is a state of the politics of nationalism book.

I've read very few of the books on the Scottish list, so I can't really make much comment on them. To be fair, I noted down some of the names then had a look in the Edinburgh Princes Street Waterstones, which has a large Scottish Fiction section depressingly isolated from other Fiction for some reason, and none of them were on sale.

I know it is lame to say it but I really loved Trainspotting at the time. I'd never read a book about Neds before and that is pretty much the default culture of working class Scotland. That would get my vote, but it isn't a state of the nation book it is a state of a particular culture in a particular region book.
 
 
at the scarwash
21:46 / 18.11.02
Houston, Texas is pretty dry as far as site-specific literature is concerned. I'd have to go for one of Donald Barthelme's short-stories, I suppose, either "I bought a little town" or "Porcupines at the University," but more because he's from here than because they say anything about here.
 
  
Add Your Reply