BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Jeff Smith's BONE

 
 
Margin Walker
02:41 / 22.10.02
I know there was a thread in an earlier incarnation of the board, but I can't seem to find it. Anyways, the 8th trade paperback of "Bone" (titled "Treasure Hunters") just came out recently and I thought this was as good a time as any to start a thread.

Here's my take on Bone: fantasy comics suck--except for Bone. It's well-written with some interesting new-agey aspects to the plotline, drawn beautifully by Smith himself and published independantly by Smith's own company Cartoon Books (w/ the official Bone website here: Boneville.com). Any takers?
 
 
Solitaire Rose as Tom Servo
03:08 / 22.10.02
I liked the comic before the break, bt since Smith came back, the pace of the book has slowed to a crawl, and the joy seems to be gone. I remember the Great Cow Race and how there were three or four plots running together all at once, all ending in one big climatic scene...now I think if he tried to do something like that, it would take 12 or 18 issues instead of 4 or 5...

It's one of the downsides of the trade paperback boom...it's great for the people who just buy it as books, but as individual issues, BONE isn't really worth reading anymore.
 
 
lentil
09:49 / 23.10.02
I still buy Bone, although of late that has been more for the art than the story. I deeply dig smith's linework, use of black areas and those slightly untidy but somehow right textures he puts on stone, cloth, etc. It's become something I study as much as enjoy, a lesson in economy that reminds me not to get caught up in flashy superfluosity in my own work. But what really really gets me hot is the pure cartooning aspects of his work (ie not the plot or individual details of the artwork - crappy distinction to make, I know); the flow of movement from panel to panel, the malleability of the Bone cousin's physiques, facial contortions, pacing of jokes etc. The sequence where Fone Bone is being chased by two rat creatures just before colliding with, yes, the great cow race, has some of the best (in terms of readability and pure grace) panels I've seen. The weight of the bodies, direction of movement just gives you so much information; you can see where Fone has been running from, the change of direction he is about to take, from one simple drawing, and then in the next panel follow the pursuing rat creatures through that initial line of motion into the perfectly slapstick tree stump. His past in animation is v apparent. Smith has described Bone as "one long chase scene", and I think that's when he's at his best.

The story has picked up with the last issue, although I agree that pacing had been... verrry... slooowww recently. I guess it could be explained in part by attributing it to "build-up", moving the pieces around in preparation for the finale. Or it could be that now Smith has a sizeable (? I guess this must be the case as the book continues to be published but have no real information) and loyal readership he doesn't need to throw out as many comedy/ action "hooks" as in the first few volumes. aaah, i don't know, more likely he's become so attached to his epic and characters that he's eking the whole thing out in an attempt to a) stave off the inevitable mid-life crisis that will follow the completion of his magnum opus and b) allow the characters "breathing room" so that everyone will realise what wondrous and DEEP creations they are.

It's probably worth picking up again - I have to say that the final panel of the last issue with Gran'ma gazing at the approaching rat hordes saying "we're not ready.." has me glistening with anticipation in much the same way that the attack of the superguardians in the "Imperial" NXM storyline did. Just hope the ensuing battle isn't as much of a damp squib.

(Nice abstract, btw)
 
 
adamswish
13:59 / 25.10.02
I love Bone, but I hate shopping for it. The last few issues have been a complete nightmare to hunt down and the gaps in between issues really ruin the story for me as by the time I find a new issue I worry that I've missed one, thus ruining the story for me.

I think you're right Rose, the issues have slowed down a lot since they arrived at the city and there's stuff out there we need to know, or at times feel Jeff isn't telling us.

But if I'm truefull I miss the red dragon, he was my favourite.
 
 
Hieronymus
14:10 / 25.10.02
I think I read somewhere that Jeff Smith, in attempting to get BONE made into an animated movie, wanted Tom Waits to voice the Red Dragon.
 
 
adamswish
14:59 / 25.10.02
seem to remember that Disney were sniffing around Jeff and his creations a few years back, but as far as I'm aware it all came to nothing.
 
 
Hallo, Paper Spaceboy
20:48 / 16.07.08
I picked up the latest Scholastic-reissued colourized Bone trade today (The Treasure Hunters, being weirdly the original trade to kick off this thread six years ago!), and I just wanted to reiterate that I really, really love Bone. I couldn't get into RASL, but the character work is so intricate yet simple. I like that Smith plays pretty fast and dirty with the world-building rules (you know, before I started this volume, I had no idea there were any dwarves around -- but there they are, just hangin' out, being dwarves), nothing feels nailed down even while the history and backstory fill out to tell you about the epic struggle going on.

The books are pretty cheap, too -- but I, as someone who works with them in a library system, the binding's shit and I'm always having to mend them over and over again because they're staggeringly popular with kids and the publishing quality's a little suspect.
 
  
Add Your Reply