BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Anarchists and Revolutionaries in Fiction and Reality

 
 
Saveloy
10:11 / 18.10.02
I posted the following in the 'Random Q and A' thread, but thought it might be worth a thread of its own. To make it more relevant to the books forum, I'll add here and now an additional request for further examples of anarchists/revolutionaries in fiction (not just from the period mentioned below), and invite comments about how they are portrayed; you know the sort of thing. Here's the original post:

A question about history:-
You know how all the stuff that you stick in your head - books, films, education etc - tends to clump together in lumps of significance, which you use to build mental models of various periods in the past? And how, as you're adding a new bit of information to your collection it will often cause previously stored nuggets, covering similar themes, to light up and go "remember us?" Well, I've just finished reading "The Secret Agent" by Joseph Conrad (first published in 1907), and all the time I was reading it I'd find myself thinking: "hmmm, late 19th/early 20th Century: G K Chesterton's 'The Man Who Was Thursday', Oliver Reed and Diana Rig in 'The Assassination Bureau', anarchists, decadents, bombs (round ones with fizzing wicks), revolutionists, ferment, jumpers for goal posts..." and it occured to me that I've clocked plenty of references to 'anarchy at the end of the 19th Century' in fiction and popular culture, but bugger all from any non-fiction sources. So, my question is: what went on back then to inspire Conrad, Chesterton et al? I'm interested in anything relating to the subject, really - links to info would be nice, book recommendations etc, as would brain dumps of Everything You Know About It. How seriously was anarchy and terrorism taken as a threat by the authorities, the media etc? Were there any dominant factions, leaders, beliefs etc. ? That sort of stuff.

In an author's note to the book (included in the Penguin Popular Classics edition), Conrad says that the plot to "The Secret Agent" was partly inspired by a brief conversation with a friend about an actual attempt to blow up the Greenwich observatory, and he mentions the "dynamite outrages in London, away back in the eighties." A bit of info on those particular events would be particularly lovely, ta.
 
 
Pepsi Max
10:54 / 18.10.02
I haven't had time to examine this in any depth but it looks like a good start.

I'm sure this has cropped up a few times b4.
 
 
rizla mission
11:14 / 18.10.02
I Have fuck all to base this on, but I get the idea that the whole 19th Anarchist scare thingy was based on next to nothing in terms of actual fact..kind of the natural bogeyman of the Victorian Patriot mindset, possibly aroused by the first stirrings of Marxist/Socialist goings on in Europe .. or something..

I think that's partly what Chesterton was satirising in '..Thursday' (the first half anyway) - all the policemen running around chasing their own tails, effectively creating anarchy without the help of the largely imaginary anarchists..

(I do love that whole 'shady characters meeting for an informal breakfast and casually discussing blowing up the King of Denmark' vibe though..)
 
 
grant
14:10 / 18.10.02
If you read the second year of the comic book "House of Secrets" you'll know what kinds of things they're referring to.
Basically, yes, the anarchist was a bogeyman, but bear in mind - there were congresses between the anarchists and the communists in Russia (the Red and the Black), and an anarchist assassinated President McKinley.
I'll do a websearch on that and post more in the Q/A thread.

Here's a bit of history:

Although the Army had conducted counterintelligence work during the Philippine insurrection, not since the Civil War had it contended with the problems of espionage, sabotage, or subversion in the continental United States. However, when the United States joined the war against Germany in 1917, it appeared that the country confronted a substantial threat from within. The America that entered World War I was still a nation of immigrants, many newly arrived. German Americans were particularly suspect, but the War Department was also concerned about the loyalties of Irish Americans, Scandinavian Americans, and African Americans. In addition to the problems that might be posed by unassimilated ethnics, there was a substantial antiwar movement. Finally, opinion-makers at the outbreak of war had exaggerated ideas about the scope and power of the German espionage and sabotage organization within the country.

In 1917 the United States seemed almost defenseless against these perceived enemies from within. The Treasury Department had a Secret Service, but it was confined by law to narrowly circumscribed duties. The Department of justice maintained the Bureau of Investigation, but the bureau's duties before the outbreak of war had largely consisted of investigating cases of fraud against the government. A few major cities had organized police "bomb squads" to deal with the anarchist threat of the period. The almost total lack of civilian resources in the field spurred the Army to launch its own major and widesweeping counterintelligence program.


And here's another bit:

Alexander Berkman is known in American history as having perpetrated the first anarchist "attentat" in this country as an act of propaganda of the deed. In 1892, at the time of the Homestead Steel Strike, he attempted to kill Henry Clay Frick, the manager of the Carnegie Steel Company. He failed and was sentenced to 22 years of prison. After his release, he edited Emma Goldman's Mother Earth, contributed in organizing the Ferrer School in New York, then published his own magazine, The Blast, on the West Coast. His efforts certainly played a great role in preventing the execution of Thomas Mooney, falsely accused of throwing a bomb into the July 22, 1916 preparedness parade. When World War I broke out, he set up a number of antiwar demonstrations. His remarkable activism made the headlines of the San Francisco Chronicle. With Emma Goldman, his former lover, and a number of other radicals, he was deported to the Soviet Union in 1919.

In Russia, he confronted Lenin and Trotsky, unsuccessfully tried to mediate in the Kronstadt uprising, and finally left the country deeply disillusioned.


So they weren't altogether imaginary.
 
 
grant
14:34 / 18.10.02
Here's an excerpt taken from the CrimeLibrary.com site.

A series of killings took place during this era that was attributed to the violent anarchists. In 1881, Czar Alexander II of Russia and 21 bystanders were killed by an anarchist’s bomb. In Chicago in 1886, during the Haymarket Square Riot, a demonstrator tossed a bomb into the crowd and killed seven police officers. An anarchist stabbed French President Marie Francois Sadi Carnot to death in 1894. And in 1901, an Italian-American anarchist from New Jersey assassinated Humbert I, the King of Italy in 1901. These terrorist acts helped the public see the anarchist cause as an attempt to subvert existing authority by violence.

And


Eventually, Czolgosz had no other friends except anarchists. “During the last five years, I’ve had as friends anarchists in Chicago, Cleveland, Detroit and other western cities,” he said. He lived for the cause and for years knew nothing else except political rallies and meetings. It was later reported that Leon belonged to an anarchist group known as “Sila” which was based in Cleveland. But during the late 19th and early 20th century, there were many such groups in large cities. “It is estimated there are over a thousand anarchists in the city of Cleveland. They have in the last few years adopted the plan of meeting in small coteries or clubs at the homes of members,” reported the N. Y. Times .


The assassination itself was also rather dramatic:

Immediately, a wall of people fell upon the assassin. He was knocked to the ground and pummeled by the crowd and the security detail. The people screamed: “Lynch him!” and “Hang the bastard!” As the furious crowd nearly beat the assailant to death, McKinley, his hands clutching his bloody chest, said, “Boys, don’t let them hurt him!”


Even without similar attacks taking place around the world, this is the stuff legends are made of.
 
 
Jack Fear
14:49 / 18.10.02
Just a sidebar/correction, here: the factions in Russia (Bolsheviks and Mensheviks) were the Reds and the Whites.

The Red and the Black was a novel by Stendahl, wherein the title colors represented the only two paths of upward mobility for the working class--the red of the military, and the black of the clergy.
 
 
Saveloy
14:57 / 18.10.02
This is all cracking stuff, many thanks everyone. Pepsi Max, that web site is enormously interesting and useful, and grant, you are God. I'll be printing loads of stuff off and reading over the weekend.

More of everything, please.
 
 
grant
15:13 / 18.10.02
Yeah, Jack, I knew that first bit - I just appropriate the Stendahl title for the more interesting leftist confluence around the same time cuz I never read it (and to be honest, only got it from the Blue Oyster Cult song of the same name).
When trying to suss out a punk rocker/political radical's politics, I like to color code: red flag bad, black flag good = Ramones-style libertarian.

Maybe we need more colors.

Oh, and as a sidebar, the surrealists also went to a few of the conferences in Russia (I think Louis Aragon was sent as a delegate), but the communists didn't know what to make of them, so they weren't really dealt in with the revolution.
 
 
Jack Fear
15:28 / 18.10.02
Well, some were, some weren't--leading to the great split in the group, with Breton officially leaving for the Communist party...

Sorry. Carry on with your thread.
 
 
Baz Auckland
22:48 / 18.10.02
I wonder how many of these people were self-professed anarchists though, and how many were "Daily Mirror Headline Anarchists".

Then: 'They're Italian Immigrants! They must be anarchists! Aah!'
Now: 'They're protesting the WTO! They must be anarchists!' Aah!'
 
 
The resistable rise of Reidcourchie
14:24 / 20.10.02
Once again more half remembered ramblings from myslef.

First of all wasn't Shelley and his crew, through Mary Shelley's parents somehow connected to anarchists?

Also in the erlier part of the 20th century I seem to recall in London (I think) there was a seige which was to do with anarchists, the army was called in, a pre prime ministirial Winston Churchill, turned up, all the best people where there. A film was made about it and everything, so it must be true.

Also weren't there a lot of anarchist groups involved in the student uprisings of the late 60's on the continent? And the sunsequent terrorism of the 70's? Although I realise this probably isn't the time period you're discussing.
 
 
tSuibhne
17:36 / 20.10.02
I haven't had a chance to read it yet, but I have a book called, "Facing The Enemy, A History of Anarchist Organization from Proudhon to May 1968," that might fit your bill. For that and a whole slew of other sources on the subject of anarchy, check out AK Press. Or, it's UK sister group

I'm currently reading a book called, "Sister Of The Road." Which is written as the autobiography of a female hobo at the begining of the 20th Century. There are a lot of references in there to anarchists, and might give you more of a "day to day" reality of the situation. I picked that up from AK Press as well, though it's put out by the same people who released Jack Black's "You Can't Win" or whatever it was called.
 
 
bjacques
00:06 / 21.10.02
Barbara Tuchman's "The Proud Tower," which fictionalizes the
events leading up to WWI, gives a pretty good treatment of the four
famous anarchist assassinations mentioned above. She points out
that the choices of targets left something to be desired. The Tsar was
a reformer, and his successor (Paul?), already a reactionary responded
with repression.

One source of the red/black colors is the CNT/FAI, the Spanish
consolidated labor union that formed the backbone of anarchist
Barcelona during the Spanish Civil War


An anrchist well worth getting to know is Nestor Makhno, the Ukrainian
peasant leader. He did time in Butyrki prison for anarchist activities and
became a rebel leader during WWI. When Lenin
got Russia out of the war, he gave Austria-Hungary the Ukraine. Makhno
threw out their puppet. Then he threw out the Cossacks, who fought
for the Whites. He threw out Petliura, a rival nationalist and an
anti-Semite (Ukrainians are distressingly anti-Semitic to this day, alas).
Makhno also fought the Reds to a draw. From 1917 to 1920 he took
on all comers. His home town of Hulyai Polye changed hands over ten times.

Makhno invented mobile infantry, loading his troops into horse-drawn
wagons in order to deploy them quickly. He also commandeered a
train to use as his mobile headquarters. Unfortunately, he never
succeeded in linking up with urban workers, so his revolution was a
rural one. Finally the Reds called a parley and gunned down Makhno's
lieutenants. He escaped, fighting his way through Romania and
eventually reached Paris. The tuberculosis he caught in Butyrki
(apparently still a hell-hole), along with strong drink, finished him
of in 1934.

History of the Makhnovist Movement ("Makhnovshchina") by Peter
Arshinov, who was there, provides an excellent account of the
struggle. I used to have another book that borrowed heavily from it,
but I stupidly lent it. Michael Moorcock gave Makhno a happier destiny
in The English Assassin and My Experiences During the Third
World War.

I've got a page of anarchy links. Most of them are still active:

http://www.vermilion-sands.com/anarchy/anarchy.html
 
 
_pin
13:13 / 21.10.02
JACK FEAR-

The Whites were the aristocrats, conservatives, nationalists and foreign soldiers sent in to try and overthrow the Bolsheviks and get Russia back into WWI. The GREENS, were the Menshviks, SR's, Populists and traditional anarchists who fought after the Whites had been defeated.

There still weren't any Blacks tho.
 
 
Saveloy
15:48 / 21.10.02
More good stuff, hoorah! Big tips of the hat to tSuibhne and bjacques. That "Sister of the Road" book sounds especially interesting, I'll have a look out for that.
 
  
Add Your Reply