|
|
Marillion doing Lavender's Green on TOTP, with Fish trying to do Bob Dylan and being defeated by an A3 pad-- laughable, or strangely endearing?
Very endearing (and it's Lavender, not Lavender's Green...). Bearing in mind that Fish was trying to avoid miming, not even bothering to pretend to sing and just trying to show the lyrics rather than mime to the song on Top Of The Pops, at a time when EVERYONE was miming to their Top 20 single. Lavender got to number 6/7 in the UK charts. Trouble was, he was very likely fucked off his tree, hence the trouble with the pad...
(For those who haven't been lucky enough to see it, he tries to do Dylan's 'Subterranean Homesick Blues' with their second single off Misplaced Childhood and fucks it up when he can't keep up with the song being played over the PA)
...but Fish wanted to be an iconoclast, at a time when every critic was trying to portray him and his band as Everything Punk Was Trying To Kill. While I'm much more a fan of Steve Hogarth's Marillion, Fish wrote some absolutely beautiful songs with them.
Thing to bear in mind is that Marillion have never been fashionable. Ever. However, I have never met anyone who hasn't found at least one of their songs to be a) surprisingly good or b) powerfully uplifting. Ever. That includes 'dance' fans (an entire remix album of This Strange Engine, which Paul Oakenfold was very into), goths ('Splintering Heart', 'Out Of This World', 'A Collection', most of Brave), indie kids ('Afraid Of Sunrise' - very Belle & Sebastian), angst rockers ('The Hollow Man', 'The Answering Machine', etc), jazz fans ('Icon', 'If My Heart Was A Ball It Would Roll Uphill', etc), metal kidz ('Cathedral Wall', 'King', etc), britpoppers ('Beautiful', 'Separated Out', etc), prog fans (nothing since 1984's Fugazi, except 'This Strange Engine' - the title track of the album), old school British 80's epic pop rock fans a la Waterboys/Duran Duran/Police('Easter', 'Estonia', 'Between You And Me', 'Cover My Eyes', 'Man Of A Thousand Faces', 'An Accidental Man', etc), and gorgeous love songs a la The Righteous Brothers ('Beyond You', 'Waiting To Happen', etc) and U2 ('Holidays In Eden', 'Dry Land', etc). Then there's 'Cannibal Surf Babe', which I defy anyone not to have a sneaking lust for... Todd Rundgren/Brian Wilson/Chilli Peppers describes it best. 'Beyond You', by the way, IS the best unrequited love/break up song EVER WRITTEN. Massive mono Phil Spector-esque production. I defy any Jeff Buckley fan not to well up.
Not everyone is going to love them wholesale like I do... but individual songs show exactly how diverse their appeal is. All I've ever asked is that people give them more of a chance than the lazy mainstream music media give them. So there you go. Stall set out once again! |
|
|