BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Crunchy Conservatives

 
 
Ethan Hawke
14:00 / 10.10.02
We are as suspicious of big business as we are of big government. We rarely watch TV, disdain modern architecture and suburban sprawl, avoid shopping malls, and spend our money on good food we prepare at home. My wife even makes her own granola....generally speaking, Small and Local and Particular and Old are better.

Where did this quote come from? The Green Party Platform? Hardly. It comes from an article from the National Review Online (a Bush-boosting publication) that details the confessions of a Granola G.O.P.er.

Writer Paul Johnson and his wife belong to a food Co-op. They don't watch TV, they're for the protection of the environment, against hormones etc. added to cattle, and generally live a lifestyle that would be called, if practiced by a peasant dress-wearing 60s refugee, earthy. But Johnson labels himself and his lifestyle deeply conservative, if out of step with the mainstream Republican version of that ideology.

Is he fooling himself? Can he really attribute the accessability of suburban "good chain bookstores, whole-food co-ops, specialty shops
that cater to eclectic tastes" which make his lifestyle practical to the invisible hand of the free market? How can someone praise the free market and then despise the sprawl and shopping malls the voices of dollars create? Is the only reason millions of Americans describe themselves as conservative their religion (which seems to be the case here)?
 
 
grant
14:40 / 10.10.02
There's a very conservative strain to that sort of Thoreau lifestyle - rural, DIY, isolationist, entrepreneurial & community oriented.
I think mainstream Republicans might view it as pleasantly nostalgic (what we're fighting for! right? right?). The down-home conservative heart - anti-modern in almost every respect.
 
 
8===>Q: alyn
16:02 / 10.10.02
How can someone praise the free market and then despise the sprawl and shopping malls the voices of dollars create?

He's a nitwit.
 
 
MJ-12
17:13 / 10.10.02
Or simlply, he may believe that while people may make choices about where their money goes that he does not agree with, it is better for them to have those choices.
 
 
w1rebaby
17:26 / 10.10.02
I don't think the guy's ideas are necessarily inconsistent (though they may be a bit naive, if he thinks that supporting the Republican party is going to lead to the lifestyle that he holds dear being preserved). What's inconsistent about being a conservative socially and environmentally? The group described don't seem like rabid free marketeers at all.

While they reject the anti-scientific utopianism of hysterical mainstream environmentalism, crunchy cons are skeptical that the Republican party can be trusted as stewards of the natural world.

If they can't see the connection between market pressures, environmental destruction and social degradation then they're nitwits, but I get the sense that some of them might just like right-wing social conservatism but not like some of the stuff that goes with it.

Nice balanced editorial line, though:

Leftists tend to absolutize their tastes and convictions, look upon people who don't share them as morally deficient, and seek to impose them on an unwilling community.

Those darned liberals. Eat tofu, scum!
 
  
Add Your Reply