BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Osteopaths/ chiropractors

 
 
Ariadne
11:35 / 27.09.02
My friend wants to see an osteopath or chiropractor about his back. I wondered if anyone can recommend one in London or suggest where to look? He'll get it paid for by work, so it doesn't have to be too cheap.

Also, what's the difference between the two?
 
 
grant
14:36 / 27.09.02
In the US, osteopaths are recognized as medical doctors, and chiropractors are more viewed as... therapists, or maybe alternative healers (but, you know, not flaky, like herbalists).
If I'm getting it right, osteopaths can make prescriptions, while chiropractors can't (and nor would they want to).
They're both concerned with the skeletal system and the way bone positioning affects health, but osteopaths are generally better versed/educated in Western medicine, while chiropractory bears a loose relationship to the energy-based systems of Eastern medicine.

On the other hand, this helpful article points out that osteopaths in America are not the same as osteopaths in the rest of the world.
 
 
grant
14:49 / 27.09.02
This article also discusses the differences in a more useful way.
 
 
Ariadne
15:01 / 27.09.02
Ah. That explains why, when he called a chiropractor in Ealing 'the answerphone message sounded all hippy and American, so I just hung up'. I will try to encourage him to be more openminded!
 
 
angel
15:07 / 27.09.02
Grant, it's really interesting that you find that, as my experience is completely the opposite. (Although I know nothing about the prescriptions part of it)

I would always go see an osteopath over a chiropractor as the osteopaths I have been to see in the past have always had a much more wholistic approach than any Chiropractor I have ever been to.

But hey it could just be the way of the world.
 
 
grant
16:35 / 27.09.02
Yeah, apparently in the UK, osteopaths do to the whole skeleton what the chiropractor just does to the spine. In the US, an osteopath is basically an MD with some chiropractic/bodywork training - an altogether different beast traveling under the same name.
 
 
captain piss
12:39 / 28.09.02
I found the chiropractor I went to a complete closed-minded arse, with much more of a only-conventional-medicine-around-here-please approach. Gave up on it in the end. Have found Alexander technique more useful for me own problem- in fact, it's cured my dodgy back/legs/arms problems (heheh- don't ask) almost completely - yet no doctor or chiropractor ever thought to recommend it. You have to do a lot of detective work on your own with these problems.
 
  
Add Your Reply