BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Iain Banks- "Dead Air"

 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
11:48 / 04.09.02
Just finished this, and I have to say, the boy's well back on form. Despite having the September 11th aftermath as a backdrop, it's frequently hilarious, but still has a real core of righteous anger. The main character sees himself as the angriest of liberals- kind of like Bill Hicks, if he was a shock-jock, which the narrator here is. Oh, there's also a really neat Banks thriller running through the middle as well, as well as plenty of opportunity for ranting (a two-page argument with his ex-wife on the Middle East situation is particularly well-done).

I liked "The Business", but it didn't really connect with me in the way most of his stuff tends to. This time he's sorted that out, making this one of his best in ages.

Anyone else read it? What did you think? Should he even be writing a fairly humorous (though dark humour, it must be said) in relation to the WTC? Is his timing immaculate or in poor taste? Would it even have been relevant if he'd waited longer to publish?
 
 
Tryphena Absent
12:46 / 04.09.02
Banks is signing this on Thursday at Waterstones in Piccadilly. I haven't read it yet but I'm buying a copy for someone and going along.
 
 
rizla mission
13:24 / 04.09.02
I'm finding the process of reading new Iain banks books kind of frustrating of recent .. Whit, the Business and Look To windward have all bored me shitless, whilst Song of Stone was just "I really don't know where you're going with this one, but I wish you weren't.." .. but I've got to keep reading because you never know when he's going to produce another fine book like Inversions or The Crow Road.. where do you think this one stands on the scale of previous Banks goodness?
 
 
STOATIE LIEKS CHOCOLATE MILK
14:28 / 04.09.02
I'd put it on a kind of "Complicity" level...
 
 
invisible_al
16:35 / 04.09.02
Whoah! Thats some big shoes to fill their, but I'm hopeful. Haven't read The Business but Look to Windward was good, but not his best ala Excession or The Crow Road.
Looks like I'm buying that tommrrow.
 
 
The Strobe
19:48 / 04.09.02
OK: as an aside: help me with Iain Banks!

I tried to read the Wasp Factory, and really didn't like it very much; little sticking power. I was given Song of Stone by a friend, duly plowed through it, and thought it was shite.

The only other Banks book I've read was Whit. I liked this very much. The thing is: am I a lost cause? Or is there Banks I might like? I'm less fussed about the SF, but it could of course be excellent. I'm just not sure if this is a road I should be treading, given several Banks-fan-friends hated Whit. Can't see why; thought it was lovely.
 
 
invisible_al
21:03 / 04.09.02
Right the best Iain Banks books to read are The Crow Road, which is a lovely book and Complicity, which is a lot nastier but still brilliant.

As far as Iain M Banks, start off with Consider Phleabas and then go onto The Player of Games and Use of Weapons. The first one isn't quite as good as the other two but it was his first Culture book and will blow you away before you read the other two.
 
 
ghadis
22:17 / 04.09.02
Yea...if you liked Whit but not Wasp Factory go for Crow Road and Complicity as Al said and also Espadair Street which is similer in tone and prettydamm good...

Me i'm pretty much a 'nasty' Banks fan with Wasp Factory and Walking on Glass rating pretty highly up my list but i'd have to go for The Bridge as my all time favourite ...Also quite liked Stone Road when i first read it but while i can re-read Bridge over and over again i got pretty bored on the second reading of it...

(Actually makes me think about why i re-read books...I often do this when i'm bored of a book i'm reading and can't get into anything else...someone like Banks, who i got obsessivly into in my mid teens along with Vonnegut does this for me...kind of a waste really when there's so much to get through elsewhere...)

Anyway...Just bought the new one today hopefully it's better that The Business......
 
 
rizla mission
08:40 / 06.09.02
I think the two Banks holy trilogies are;

Wasp Factory
Walking on Glass
The Bridge

and

Consider Phlebas
Player of Games
Use of Weapons

Every one of those books has to count as one of my all-time favourites.. I just find the quality of everything he's done since has been .. pretty variable..
 
 
Mina Cool
09:17 / 07.09.02
Wasp Factory is a trilogy ?!?!


happy days...
 
  
Add Your Reply