BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Robert Rankin

 
 
Justin Brief
15:35 / 29.08.02
I'm halfway through The Book of Ultimate Truths. Not intellectually taxing, I know, and perhaps a bit Terry Pratchett without the goblins. But I'm enjoying it. It's funny. It reminds me of Douglas Adams on a good day.

Never heard of the fellow before, nor seen his other books. Any thoughts, disclaimers, lurid biographical gossip?
 
 
Eloi Tsabaoth
15:38 / 29.08.02
I love Robert Rankin. Just because he floods his work with toilet gags and has scant regard for characterisation, plot or verisimilitude doesn't mean he's not a fine wordsmith. I will defend his honour to the hilt, and if anyone says otherwise I'll call them a cunt and storm off the board in a childish tantrum.
And no, none of this is sarcasm.
 
 
Jack Fear
15:38 / 29.08.02
Paging Rizla...
 
 
Our Lady of The Two Towers
18:39 / 29.08.02
He's basically got one plot which he uses time and again, and everything always builds to a climax before the meter runs out or something, but he's amusing enough. It took me a little while to get used to his style, but when I realised he wasn't telling stories but tales it all made sense. He's not the 'funniest writer in Britain today!' but then i think he'd be the first to say that and has never claimed he was. But I think he has to be read sparingly. I once read his first three Brentford books back to back and by the end was ready to kill.
 
 
rizla mission
10:20 / 30.08.02
Well when I was in school I read every single one of his books back to back and, um, strangely lost the urge to kill..

I'll try not to do the whole Rankin evangelist thing again, but I really think that at his best, as well as all the pop culture pillaging cheap gag fun, he's a genuinely great absurdist comic writer in the vein of Flann O'Brien or Ishmael Reed.. you shouldn't be ashamed to read him, and if anyone gives you shit for it, you should argue that the likes of A Dog Called Demolition and The Book of Ultimate Truths are fine, fine books!

However, I really think it's a shame that these days he seems content to play down to expectations (and play up the Pratchett comparisons) by knocking out a book every six months, all of which have pretty much the same plot and are largely written on autopilot (though they're still hugely enjoyable nonetheless).. he seems to be gradually losing the freewheeling "Goon Show written by Philip K Dick" madness that made his best work so great, and just churning out increasingly uninspired books about how evil technology is, with lots of dick jokes and the devil turning up at the end.. makes me want to weep, it really does..

Though having said that, all it takes is one more appearance of Lazlo Woodbine or Hugo Rune and he's won me back as a loyal fan for a few more months..

As he's now written over 20 books, here, for the records, is a list of all the ones I reckon are the best:

The Antipope
The Brentford Triangle
East of Ealing
The Book of Ultimate Truths
Armageddon the Musical
They Came And Ate Us
A Dog Called Demolition
Nostradamus Ate My Hamster
The Garden of Unearthly Delights
Sprout Mask Replica
Acocalypso
 
 
Justin Brief
12:24 / 30.08.02
Thanks. The Book of Ultimate Truths really is a lot of fun, and, as you say, has a great deal more depth to it than the 'New Pratchett' spin would suggest. Very much a kind of Flann O'Brien with a point.

20 books, you say? I'm amazed I've never heard of him before now. Will definitely seek out more (as a Beefheart fan, Sprout Mask Replica has a certain allure).

Ultimate Truths pays for the admission price with the following lines alone:

“And then he went on to tell me that a Second World War had been arranged. Something to do with solving unemployment and getting full use from allotments...... It was supposed to start in 1936. By 1939 Hitler said he couldn’t wait any longer for the BBC and he was going to start without them.”
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
15:00 / 30.08.02
Very much a kind of Flann O'Brien with a point.

Much as Babylon 5 is the Ring of the Nibelung but with spaceships.

Rankin, for all his many mildly amusing moments, has from my limited understanding essentially jumped the Pratchettian shark where he realises that his fans will buy any old crap as long as it says something funny about either pubs, sprouts or both. Product rather than writing.

Flann O'Brien is something rather other entirely.
 
 
Justin Brief
15:51 / 30.08.02
No doubt because he's published by Flamingo Modern Classics, and attended University College, Dublin. The Third Policeman is a gag-heavy less referential Ulysses without the wit, and is to blame for introducing the lengthy footnote to modern 'humorous' writing.
 
 
Justin Brief
15:52 / 30.08.02
Eastenders is certainly a modern-day Dickens. But without the silly names.
 
 
DaveBCooper
16:09 / 30.08.02
Haven’t read any of Rankin’s stuff, but isn’t there one where the characters realise they’re in a book and start peeking ahead to see what’s going to happen them or something ? This struck me as an interesting idea, so if there is one like this, and it can be read without having to read loads of others, I’d be grateful if someone could let me know the title… thanks.

DBC
 
 
rizla mission
17:31 / 30.08.02
Um, well, absurd amounts of 4th wall demolishing go on throughout many of these books .. though 'They Came And Ate Us' is notable as the one which begins with a great big biro looming in the sky and ends with Elvis threatening the author at gunpoint..
 
 
rizla mission
18:22 / 30.08.02
Product rather than writing.

While I take your point to some extent, I gotta take issue with this bit - the reason Rankin can get away with writing so many books which are essentially about nothing at all is that he's an extremely talented writer who, even at his worst, produces effortlessly fine prose. If he put his mind to it he could compete with the best of 'em. Problem is, he's content (as is his bank manager, no doubt) with just going over the same ground again and again..
 
 
The Falcon
00:24 / 31.08.02
He's rubbish, though. I read that one about the Anti-pope when I were young, and back then, e'en, it was rubbish.

Steve Aylett's funnier and weirder, I think.
 
  
Add Your Reply