BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


P2P Legislation- hidden agendas, cowardice, or just dumb law?

 
 
Naked Flame
00:36 / 27.07.02
From Wired-

...Rep. Howard Berman (D-California) introduced his much anticipated peer-to-peer legislation in the House of Representatives on Thursday. The proposal would give copyright owners, from Hollywood studios down to independent musicians, the legal go-ahead to employ a variety of technological measures that would stop computers hooked up to decentralized networks from trading...

Along with making it open season on individual users, open-source programs and decentralized networks, the bill also gives a free pass to chat applications run by the very media companies that would most benefit from open-source networks being shuttered.... AOL Instant Messenger (AIM), MSN Messenger and Yahoo Messenger -- which each have specific file-trading options built into their systems that enable millions of users to trade their share without fear of electronic attack -- will continue to flourish. The recording industry and movie studios have largely ignored those three chat applications, which have financial ties to the major record studios and movie studios, in their litigation and anti-piracy activities.

At its height, the Napster network handled just under three billions files a month, where AIM has
one billion files a day zipping across its system.

So: what's the point of this legislation? If they close down the independent networks, but leave IM software as is, isn't everyone going to share over IM instead?
 
 
w1rebaby
12:28 / 27.07.02
Good point, although I can see the major networks introducing some sort of copyright filters in the clients, and trying to crack down on 3rd-party clients? Still, that wouldn't really stop IRC...

I remember there was a p2p file-sharing system based around AIM called Aimster. Don't know what happened to that.

The convenience factor of file-sharing networks is not to be underestimated, though. Not as many people are going to have the persistence to track someone down with the song they want, as opposed to just typing in the name in Audiogalaxy. The 1 billion files a day on AIM weren't all music - the 3 billion a month files on Napster were.
 
  
Add Your Reply