BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Schticks + Gimmicks

 
 
Margin Walker
04:24 / 22.07.02
When it comes right down to it, most bands have a schtick. There's obvious ones: Los Straitjackets wear Mexican wrestling masks onstage, Clinic wears surgical masks, The Knack wore white shirts & black ties, The Hives wear black shirts and white ties, Tribe 8 severs strap-ons, Nashville Pussy's old bassist blew fire onstage, The White Stripes wear red & white duds onstage and GG Allin did whatever anyone paid him $5 to do. But what about acts that are quasi-fronts for solo artists? Would Bob Pollard, Trent Reznor or Rivers Cuomo have less credibility if they weren't Guided By Voices, Nine Inch Nails or Weezer, respectively? And what about stage names? Would Bob Dylan, Iggy Pop or Prince be as big as they are if they would've stuck with their birth names?

Anyways, there's no denying the power of creating an image. In that light, I reckon one could make the argument that schticks or gimmicks are a way for bands to create their own image rather than have one foisted upon them. And I'm certain that there's a way to create a public image without any sort of hyperbole. But in these fast-paced times, is it possible to make you music heard without some angle to make you stand out from the crowd? What's your spin on schticks?
 
 
Cop Killer
05:48 / 22.07.02
Really, schticks do fuck all if the band doesn't have the songwriting ability to back it up. If I don't like the albums that a band puts out I could really care less about their schtick. I mean, look at the New York Dolls and the Tubes, two bands that both relied on schtick, but people are still, to this day, being heavily influenced by the New York Dolls music, while I think the only people that were all that influenced by the Tubes are in Gwar.
 
 
bio k9
06:07 / 22.07.02
Bob Pollard records under various names (Airport 5, Lexo and the Lepers, Robert Pollard, not to mention the dozens on names he used on the Suitcase box set tracks). His fans don't really seem to care what he calls himself.

Is Trent Reznor still alive? Does it matter? I have a feeling his next album will be distributed by the same company that distributed Machina II for the Smashing Pumpkins.
 
 
Our Lady of The Two Towers
09:00 / 22.07.02
schtick sounds a bit disparriging don't it? If you like them, it's a style and if you don't it's schtick. I don't think Iggy Pop choosing to be Iggy Pop is really a schtick, everyone's got to be called something. But I agree with the fact that there has to be content first. The Pet Shop Boys are an example of a British band that have always managed to maintain an image and a style and a schtick if you will, but if those songs had been crap they wouldn't have lasted.
 
 
grant
20:30 / 22.07.02
I love a good live shtick - every band in the Man or Astro-Man? diaspora has one (crashed aliens, killer robots of Servotron, the we-are-not-a-cult cult of Causey Way).
To a certain degree, I think a shtick is really just a miniature manifesto, a way of making the music seem like part of something bigger and more politically/narratively potent. Devo was a good example - shtick plus. So were the Sex Pistols (and most other early punk, before it got totally formalized).
 
  
Add Your Reply