BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Krzysztof Kieslowski

 
 
Margin Walker
03:54 / 18.07.02
With the exception of White (Blanc), I haven't seen a film that Krzysztof Kieslowski directed that hasn't bored me to tears. Especially "The Double Life of Veronique". Goddamn, I hated that film. Anyways, does anyone here actually like his films? I've not seen The Decalogue yet--is it worth watching? Even though I hate his other films?
 
 
odd jest on horn
04:28 / 18.07.02
Thou shalt not kill is good, very powerful emotionally. The only one of his ten commandments things I ever saw. (Is that the same as the Decalogue?). I have heard good things about Red.
 
 
The Natural Way
07:49 / 18.07.02
Maybe, but I have an artist friend who obsessed about the trilogy to the extent that, whenever I popped over to see him, I'd find myself interrupting a 3 colours fest. I enjoy the films, and, it seems, if yr willing to pay attention, Kieslowski's attention to detail is breathtaking - they're more like paintings than films.
 
 
Jack Fear
13:49 / 18.07.02
Oh, I looooooove Kieslowski.

Runce is right: it's all about attention, about putting yourself in the right frame of mind and lketting the film explain itself to you, to lay out its own rules for understanding it.

White is perhaps his most accesible film—it's almost a caper movie, ennit? albeit imbued with that dour Eastern European sensibility.

Blue was devastating, on so many levels—its theme, liberty, taking the form of Camus' axiom: "the terrible burden of knowing all men are free." The build-up of Red was intriguing, but I felt a tad let down by the deus ex machina ending: I mean, I know what he was trying to do, and that the contrived nature of it was part of the point, but I didn't feel it in my guts.

Double Life, for me, is one of the sexiest movies ever made. Nuff said.

Much of The Decalogue falls into soap opera territory, IMHO. There are some harrowing moments—though oddly enough I thought "A Short Film About Killing" (episode 5) was actually one of the weaker spots. It did a fine job of bringing us inside the mind of the killer as he slips deeper into psychosis, but I thought its politics were bit too obvious. "A Short Film About Love," (episode 6) however, is a stone fucking classic—the way the struggle of love and attraction shifts back and forth between a teenage voyeur and his promiscuous neighbor.

The Decalogue films are only an hour each, so they're an economical investment of your time.

Kieslowski was one of those filmmakers whose stuff just unfolded in a time of its own—like Werner Herzog, Wim Wenders, or Andrei Tarkovsky. It's a Euro thang: it's the antithesis of Hollywood's "give 'em what they want and beat 'em over the head with it" approach. It's more like I'm going to tell you a story, but I'll be telling it in a language you do not speak: but with proper attention, you can learn the language even as I tell you my story.
 
 
yawn - thing's buddy
17:33 / 18.07.02
I looooooove Kieslowski too.

One of the best artists in any medium during the last 50 odd years.

without doubt.

If you didn't rate it first time, it's doubtful you'll ever like it.

red and double are incredible - so is irene jacob.

blue is very blue.

if you've an attraction to synchronicites,coincidence, texture and montage there really is no better filmmaker to slaver over.
 
 
yawn - thing's buddy
17:35 / 18.07.02
yeah, what fear says bout decalogue - it is soapy.

but the best soap I've ever seen.

Score the dvd of all ten for quite cheap moneys me reckon.
 
 
Baz Auckland
12:55 / 20.07.02
I've only ever seen "Double Life", but I love it. It helps that my best friend told me how great it was for years beforehand, but. Preisner's music is incredible too.
 
 
Knight's Move
20:39 / 20.07.02
The college film society I was president for showed the three colours trilogy one per term and they were the biggest sellers all year. It helped that we hit the modern languages faculty, but even so, there is some sort of backing for them.

The films are emotionally overwrought in a really understated way. It is obviously sentimental but on such a grand scale that you cannot fully comprehend them so instead of being to over the top the very scale reduces the emotional intensity as you cannot compute all that is being said with words.

GOd that sounded pretentious.

I loved Double Life, like the trilogy it's very slow (save White) and is all about subtle manipulation of character and repeated parallelism that runs throughout, a theme he seems very interested in.

I don't know how much of that made sense. Ultimately, I loved the ones I've seen depsite the fact that they are slow, art-house, achingly shot, poigniant, nothing really happens over again films. I'm not sure why. Possibly the shots like the opening shot of red with the trip down the phone line, or the really obvious way each film is drenched in the appropriate colour with out any pretence of hiding the device. If he had tried to do it subtley it would have looked obvious and shit but by being blatant it changed the nature of the film from film-making, story-telling telling to theme extraction and examination.

Sorry, I've smoked way to much pot and studied way to much English to be allowed to talk about French films at this moment.
 
 
Margin Walker
03:13 / 26.08.02
I don't know if this is worth starting a new thread but here it goes (for now at least). Kieslowski co-wrote the script for the "new" Tom Tykwer film "Heaven" starring Cate Blanchett & Giovanni Ribisi. The word new is in quotes because it isn't new--it should have came out on Sept 14th, 2001 but was pushed back because of what happened three days earlier. Over in this AICN review of it (http://www.aintitcool.com/display.cgi?id=13084), the reviewer likened it to "Badlands". Um, riiiight.
 
  
Add Your Reply