BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


When Teen Romance attacks! Scary passages for a nation;s youth.

 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
10:01 / 20.06.02
Knowign my predilections, a friend recently gave me book 10 of the popular and gorgeously 80s "Seniors" series, "Presenting Superhunk", a "My Fair Lady" tale in which hapless nerd Bruce is made over into a love god by the group of friends whose triumphs and tragedies have seen them through the previous nine books.

So far so good, until I came across a paragraph relating to formerly-chubby-and-now-rigorously-dieting Gayle:

Gayle had hoped things would have changed after she lost all that weight, but to her dismay they hadn't. Her mother had remarked how pleased she was and told Gayle she'd treat her to a new wardrobe - a promise that was not yet fulfilled. But her father, Gayle noted sadly, hadn't seemed to notice at all.

Don't you like my....new body....daddy?

So, have you encountered any other tales for the edification of our nation's youth (well, the US in this case, but principle's good) which contain THE WORST MESSAGES EVER FOR GROWING MINDS? Share share share...
 
 
Kit-Cat Club
11:44 / 20.06.02
Weell - not teen fiction per se, but there is the notorious part in The Last Battle in which Susan doesn't get to the garden because she's more interested in boys, make-up and nylons than Aslan. Oh, and the description of Eustace Clarence Scrubbs' parents in which their vegetarianism and teetotallism is held up to scorn...
but both those seem the opposite to the example you gave.

Not a devotee of eighties teen fiction, but I can think of numerous things from school stories etc - spots indicate a flawed character, smoking indicates bad morals (until you hit eighteen, when it is perfectly all right), it's fine to be clever and to take on responsibilities at school, but all real Chalet School girls marry doctors and have huge families (in the Abbey books they marry the peer who lives in the castle next door, but in both cases it is essential to have lots of twins). Naturally they can afford servants to look after same, leaving them free to deal with avalanches, rabid dogs, stroppy new girls. Oh, and being too bookish is another sign of being unhealthy and morbid (see especially Eustacia goes to the Chalet School).

(Incidentally - has anyone else seen the Mary-Kate and Ashley books? I had a look at one the other day, and in the picure on the cover the girls have the complexions and under-eye shadows of thirty-year-olds - something very wrong there)
 
 
Cherry Bomb
15:43 / 21.06.02
Haus: before I got to "Don't you like my new body..... Daddy" comment I was thinking the reason this girl felt upset is because she had worked so hard to "improve" herself and was feeling bad because her dad hadn't noticed. It never even occurred to me that it might be because she wanted her dad to comment on her newly hot bod.

Kit Kat: even scarier have you ever seen any of their television programs? They are like creepy alien 13-year-olds who like they are 30. But then, perhaps that's what the rigours of running a multi-million dollar empire does to you...
 
 
ONLY NICE THINGS
15:51 / 21.06.02
Cherry: Oh, I think it's shit on both levels. Gayle does achieve some measure of happiness with herself when she rejects the advances of Fast Derek in the Disco, and Lori (her best friend) points out that she would never have been so self-willed and ready to reject male attention when she was fat. So she has achieved a sort of self-confidence....as long as she keeps dieting for the rest of her life.
 
 
Tuna Ghost: Pratt knot hero
02:49 / 22.06.02
So, have you encountered any other tales for the edification of our nation's youth (well, the US in this case, but principle's good) which contain THE WORST MESSAGES EVER FOR GROWING MINDS? Share share share...

Any and all Sweet Valley High books. "You're not real if you don't engage in melodrama so gooey that it would give Luciano Pavarotti a heart attack just reading it!"
 
  
Add Your Reply