BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Clear Channel Bans Songs

 
 
YNH
00:53 / 20.09.01
Okay, from what I've gathered so far Clear Channel Communications, owner of over 1000 US radio stations issued a ban on more than 200 songs in the wake of the attacks... including stuff like "Walk Like an Egyptian," "Love is a Battlefield," and "all Rage against the Machine songs."

Clear Channel is now denying the existence of said list: link

Original report: link

Some of the stuff in the original is misspelled, so it may be, indeed, a load of soiled pants.
 
 
Mystery Gypt
01:14 / 20.09.01
there was a mainstream news story about this. the songs were not banned. they were put on a list by a music director who said the songs might be offensive. many clear channel dj's continue to play the songs, which included Stairway ot Heaven and Leaving on a Jet Plane. assbrained or not, it wasnt really a 1st ammendment attack.
here's the link
 
 
Molly Shortcake
02:04 / 20.09.01
It's totally absurd. Every single video game, TV show and movie with a fucking big ass sky scraper in it, is either being revised or delayed. What difference does it make???
 
 
Ofermod
02:34 / 20.09.01
When I first saw this today, Banned or "suggested" aside, I understand how some of these songs could be considered "insensitive" at this time, but some of these choices are laughable. "Blowin' in the Wind?" "St. Elmo's Fire?" And Neil Diamond's "America" in which "they" is now a paranoid term for the enemy..'cause "they're coming to America"
And would anyone remotely think of the WTC when listening to "Jump" it wasn't on the list?
So anything relating to dying, fire, falling, flying, Tuesday (Boy, the Bangles are lucky it wasn't on a Monday), September and NYC should be avoided for the next several month so as not to offend anyone.
I understand why Hollywood has delayed terrorist/bombing themed movies and shows. Some of it might have to do with sensitivity, but also money. I mean, release a movie about terrorists last weekend? Who would have gone to see it? But to say a song which has the word "fall" or "crash" is insensitive is absurd.
That being said, I would promote "New York, New York" as this seems more inspirational than a song which would lead to mourning.
And as a last note. If you're going to pick a Billy Joel song to be "insensitive," it would be a song about trying to get under a Catholic girl's skirt...I'd go with "Miami 2017" "..they sent the carriers up from Norfolk..."
But that's just my opinion.
 
 
Mister Snee
02:40 / 20.09.01
Some of the songs were chosen not because of offensive lyrics but just because they're TOO happy or inspirational to be "appropriate" right now... "New York, New York" was probably one of them.
 
 
rizla mission
08:35 / 20.09.01
It could be a lot worse. When Diana died, BBC music stations stopped completely and just played funerial muzak for about 3 days.
 
 
The Return Of Rothkoid
08:35 / 20.09.01
Don't let me hear you knockin' Fauré, Riz. That way lies pain.
 
 
Verbal Kint
08:35 / 20.09.01
That's just goofy.

Having said that there is a guy on public radio here who has a morning show where he basically plays anything he wants and Monday played five versions (I am assuming it was just five - thats when I changed channels) of Autumn in New York back to back. Aside from the fact it was incredibly irritating to hear the same song in five really crappy versions, it was a little creepy and started to approach tasteless after about the third version.

[ 20-09-2001: Message edited by: Verbal Kint ]
 
 
Happy Hensu
11:34 / 20.09.01
I would have thought that there was never a more appropriate time than now for songs like Lennon's Imagine: if ever we needed to turn our thoughts from hatred to love and peace it's now.
 
 
Happy Hensu
14:16 / 20.09.01
As a result of the enormous amount of criticism it has recieved the US radio chain has denied banning songs from its affiliated stations: http://news.bbc.co.uk/hi/english/entertainment/music/newsid_1554000/1554355.stm
 
 
Yagg
15:40 / 20.09.01
Lemme set the record straight here. The radio station where I work was bought by CC last year...They're not really the evil empire everyone else in the biz likes to pretend they are. Well, not anymore than any other giant corporation is, anyway.

This list came along and it LOOKED like it was official, except that damn near everything on it was spelled wrong. Also, the choice of songs seemed UTTERLY RIDICULOUS. "Peace Train," "Sunday Bloody Sunday," and "Imagine" being a few that made no sense. How the FUCK do you get offended by "Imagine?" Most of us were pretty disgusted with it. Our boss decided it was so much BS and we would ignore it. Then it came out that it wasn't a directive anyway, it was just some hogwash thrown together by some program director somewhere and sent out on email company-wide. It LOOKED official at first, so everybody freaked. Whoever started the whole thing is probably being handed his own ass right about now.
 
 
000
16:27 / 20.09.01
quote:by YaggHow the FUCK do you get offended by "Imagine?"

For the same reason they got offended by all who had the power to make the people believe that there could be a better world without any violence and prejudice, were we all can live as one.

”Imagine a world were we could all live as one” John Lennon
“I have dream were we all live as one” Martin Luther King
“We are one” Ghandi

Collect some quotes from those who had the same dream and See what they all have in common beside this vision.

quote: Then it came out that it wasn't a directive anyway, it was just some hogwash thrown together by some program director somewhere

Some program director? Somewhere?
 
 
Yagg
16:51 / 20.09.01
Oh, man, now I'm sorry I said anything...
 
 
Genie
18:09 / 20.09.01
During the Gulf War, John Lennon's "Give Peace a Chance" was banned from airplay lists, and Massive Attack and Bomb The Bass both had to change their names, amongst other instances of state-censorship. But then Lulu had her opus "Boom Bang-a-Bang" cut too, so it can't all be bad.

Oh, and to keep it contemporary, Radio 1's editorial policymaker Alex Jones-Donnelly says:
quote: "It's business as normal now," says Jones-Donelly. "But if events change we'll take appropriate action again. We're well prepared to do that."

(From The Guardian 20.09.01)

So better listen to that Lennon while you still can......
says
 
 
Cherry Bomb
18:18 / 20.09.01
I still... what is offensive about "Imagine" is beyond me. The fact that "Peace Train" is on the "questionable" list I can't get over either - is it because Cat Stevens is now Yousef Islam, or because it's about Peace?

I wonder how much more of the Lennon back catalogue will land on the list. I just keep thinking about the doubtless "questionability" of one of my favorite Christmas songs "Happy Christmas (War is Over)."
 
 
Not Here Still
18:38 / 20.09.01
There is also a discussion of this over in the Music forum.

See here.

I'm presumin people get offended by Imagine's opening lines 'Imagine there's no heaven' as much as anything else. Certain people don't want to hear that at the moment, when they are in mourning.

[PEDANT ALERT] Martin Luther King:

I have a dream that one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed: "We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men are created equal."

but Laila's meaning remains the same.
 
 
Cherry Bomb
19:18 / 20.09.01
They even banned "Stairway to Heaven," which I'm thinking were they thinking of the WTC stairwells as stairways to heaven? Or crashing a plane into a highrise building as a stairway to heaven? I'm not sure. All I know is I'm offended any Zep would be banned ever!!

And really, why not ban "Kashmir" and "Night Flight" if we're going to take this ALL THE WAY?? Or "The Battle of Evermore?"
 
 
Yagg
02:45 / 21.09.01
Ok, again, they didn't ban anything. It was a total case of the usual corporate miscommunication. Which is really funny, considering it's a communications business.

<sigh> You know, when I got into radio, I thought it was a great way to NOT work for a giant corporation. I managed to stay out from under the Giant Corporate Heel for almost ten years, but there's almost no way out now, one giant conglomerate or another has bought up EVERYTHING...I'm working on my escape, though...

BTW...Where was "Give Peace A Chance" banned? As I recall, Sean Lennon recorded a new version of it with various musicians...I used to hear it pretty frequently during the Gulf War.
 
 
Chuckling Duck
12:48 / 21.09.01
quote:Originally posted by Yagg:
Ok, again, they didn't ban anything. It was a total case of the usual corporate miscommunication.



No, but maybe "Killing an Arab" should be left out of rotation for a while. Sorry, Camus fans.
 
 
Mister Snee
13:14 / 21.09.01
"Never be rude to an Arab;
An Israeli, or Saudi, or Jew...
Never make fun of an Irishman, no matter what you do..."

Damn that's a good song.
 
  
Add Your Reply